Originally Posted by
edmundronald
Why not just disable MCAS, leave the pilots to trim as usual, and retrain them a bit to deal with the feel of the plane at a high AoA?
Zero software to write, and no new bugs introduced.
Because as they say in the industry, new features always means new bugs.
Edmund
It is pretty basic. An aircraft has to fly like an aircraft. If you pull the nose up, and then release back pressure, the nose must return to somewhere near the original attitude and speed. If you disable MCAS, the B737 MAX will not meet the FAA stability requirements of Sec. 25.173 (Static longitudinal stability)
I suspect that without MCAS there would need to be a major aerodynamic redesign to meet the stability requirements.