Originally Posted by
derjodel
Lion air's FDR show that the trim was moved to full of the available 7 notches (it's not clear how those translate to degrees). They would certainly still be alive if there as a limit. They kept it in air at ~ 3 notches. If max needs more to get out of stall, perhaps it does need a larger hstab/eleveator instead of a hacked together software?
Or perhaps the key really is the reset. Does mcas reset with each trim input and takes the current position as the new neutral? If AoA vane is sending wrong data it's easy to see how this would result in a runaway trim.
This
image shows the difference between a 737-800 (yellow) and MAX (magenta). Notice the bigger nacelles and same hstab size.
I thought 0.6 was a hard limit... e.g, we move this much and then it's up to the pilot. If it was 0.6 every 5 seconds it's still bad, but at least easier to manage.
What strikes me in the image is the tiny elevator? It would have been very interesting to see the same picture of the A320 tail/elevator.