PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Mid-air collision between EMS helicopter and light fixed wing in southern Germany
Old 29th Jan 2018, 08:40
  #51 (permalink)  
TorqueOfTheDevil
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Among these dark Satanic mills
Posts: 1,197
Received 1 Like on 1 Post
Originally Posted by Hot and Hi
In our neck of the woods, in uncontrolled airspace we heavily rely on pilots making regular radio calls (position and intention reports). This has proven to work relatively well, at least outside the pattern. Away from the airfield, pilots tend to avoid reported traffic by a wide margin, and/or making arrangement with conflicting traffic to the same effect.

In the pattern the perceived restrictions in going higher or lower, or left or right, make people become more stubbornly stick to their planned trajectory. And then the lack of precision in reporting the exact position, combined with the lacking ability of most or all humans to create a perfect dynamic mental picture sometimes catches us out.

Thanks, Evalu8ter, and also echoed by many others here and in other threats. And who wants to disagree.

But it can also be the other way around. I just came back from a 1 hr flight in a busy weekend GA airspace. During the course of this flight, I made half a dozen of arrangements with other airspace users going to the same aerodrome that I intended flying over, or flying in opposite direction, to achieve or maintain 500 FT vertical separation, or similar. All based on blind radio calls, and thereafter both parties' mental determination that this might constitute "conflicting traffic".

To my total shame I must admit that despite my best endeavours I did not visually acquire a single of those other aircraft that I 'negotiated' with. We could as well all have been in a cloud, with the same satisfactory outcome. (Before somebody asks, I hold a recent Class 1 medical, and my - corrected - eye sight is well above 100%).

So how good would have been my chances to visually acquire traffic that I wasn't even aware of and expecting?
All entirely valid (and no shame at all IMHO). I have also been amazed how hard it can be to acquire visually an aircraft which I know is there based on TAS or R/T. But this is not quite the same situation as the accident under discussion, where (we are told) the aircraft were aware of each other yet the aeroplane still managed to plough into the helicopter. On the occasions when I am struggling to see another aircraft which I know is close, I make sure I am pointing at a piece of sky which is definitely empty. So far, this has always worked...
TorqueOfTheDevil is offline