PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   USA (https://www.pprune.org/usa-43/)
-   -   USA passing level requirement (https://www.pprune.org/usa/662899-usa-passing-level-requirement.html)

jettropo 5th December 2024 14:17

USA passing level requirement
 
Is anyone able to point me to the reference in AIM or anywhere else for this:

Leaving LAX on initial contact with the departure frequency, we report passing level etc. This is standard for all airports.

On first contact with LA centre, they said they want the passing level reported as well as cleared level. They said everyone should state this (passing level once again).
My question is where is this requirement written?

340drvr 5th December 2024 18:04

Try AIM 5-3-1 (b) ATC Frequency Change Procedures.
Several examples of comms, including altitude passing (climb or descent) and altitude assigned.
It's been my understanding that procedures in the AIM are considered advisory rather than regulatory. (However, if neglect or misuse of advisory procedures resulted in an incident or worse, I suppose the FAR 91.13 "careless/wreckless" clause could be used.)

Amadis of Gaul 5th December 2024 19:31


Originally Posted by jettropo (Post 11781387)
Is anyone able to point me to the reference in AIM or anywhere else for this:

Leaving LAX on initial contact with the departure frequency, we report passing level etc. This is standard for all airports.

On first contact with LA centre, they said they want the passing level reported as well as cleared level. They said everyone should state this (passing level once again).
My question is where is this requirement written?

Is this such a burden that you need something written to make you do it?

Capn Bloggs 6th December 2024 03:14


Originally Posted by Amadis of gaul
Is this such a burden that you need something written to make you do it?

Yes. Say only what is required. Or do you suggest we just waffle on with whatever we think is a fair thing/would be nice to know?

There have been R/T procedures here that have been rewritten/clarified in the regs because pilots have used only the published phrases and not what some ATCO has got into the habit of demanding.

Amadis of Gaul 6th December 2024 16:39


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 11781704)
Yes. Say only what is required.

Yes, sir!

B-757 7th December 2024 03:48


Originally Posted by jettropo (Post 11781387)
Is anyone able to point me to the reference in AIM or anywhere else for this:

Leaving LAX on initial contact with the departure frequency, we report passing level etc. This is standard for all airports.

On first contact with LA centre, they said they want the passing level reported as well as cleared level. They said everyone should state this (passing level once again).
My question is where is this requirement written?

..ICAO Doc4444..(4.11.3)..

Fly safe,
B-757



Capn Bloggs 7th December 2024 04:37


Originally Posted by B-757
..ICAO Doc4444..(4.11.3)..

Not quite (from my 2007 version :{​​​​​​​):

Originally Posted by ICAO 4444
4.11.3 Radiotelephony procedures for air-ground voice communication channel changeoverWhen so prescribed by the appropriate ATS authority

My bolding.

B-757 7th December 2024 05:26


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 11782355)
Not quite (from my 2007 version :{):

My bolding.

..Mine is 28 NOV 2024..I really hope you are not flying with a 17yr old manual..

​​​​​​​B-757

Capn Bloggs 7th December 2024 06:30


Originally Posted by B-757
..Mine is 28 NOV 2024..I really hope you are not flying with a 17yr old manual..

Obviously not. We have our own regulator's regulations to comply with. We don't fly to 4444. We do what our AIP says.

So, what does the current ICAO 4444 say at 4.11.3 and if it says similar to my copy, what does your regulator say?

shared reality 8th December 2024 09:26


Originally Posted by jettropo (Post 11781387)
Is anyone able to point me to the reference in AIM or anywhere else for this:

Leaving LAX on initial contact with the departure frequency, we report passing level etc. This is standard for all airports.

On first contact with LA centre, they said they want the passing level reported as well as cleared level. They said everyone should state this (passing level once again).
My question is where is this requirement written?


Your location seems to be the UK. ICAO generic states to always, on initial contact with an ATC unit, state passing level+ cleared level (ATC is supposed to check your reported lvl vs their readout on their screen...)

However, if I am not mistaken, the UK has an exception to this requirement, hence your question? By the way, this is also why UK SIDīs have a note stating that on initial contact with dep.ctrl to state passing altitude+ cleared altitude (again as this is normally not done in the UK).

Rgds,

jettropo 8th December 2025 12:40


Originally Posted by shared reality (Post 11782938)
Your location seems to be the UK. ICAO generic states to always, on initial contact with an ATC unit, state passing level+ cleared level (ATC is supposed to check your reported lvl vs their readout on their screen...)

However, if I am not mistaken, the UK has an exception to this requirement, hence your question? By the way, this is also why UK SIDīs have a note stating that on initial contact with dep.ctrl to state passing altitude+ cleared altitude (again as this is normally not done in the UK).

Rgds,

That’s true. We have that exemption which is why I wanted to make sure I was doing it correctly in the US. I got told off climbing out of a US airfield on my third handover for not stating the passing level. Looks as if I should be doing it all the way up to cruising altitude in the US.

Thanks everyone for the info.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:50.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.