PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   Swiss Airbus wing lights always on? (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/625476-swiss-airbus-wing-lights-always.html)

rekop 13th Sep 2019 10:19

Swiss Airbus wing lights always on?
 
Does anyone know why Swiss always has the wing lights on on their Airbuses?

Capt Fathom 13th Sep 2019 11:23

Something to do with the switch position? :E

jmmoric 13th Sep 2019 11:24


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 10569063)
Something to do with the switch position? :E

They forget to swiss them off?

rekop 13th Sep 2019 12:00


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 10569063)
Something to do with the switch position? :E

Because the switch is called “wing on/off” and they don’t dare to put it in wing off?! 🤪

DaveReidUK 13th Sep 2019 12:06


Originally Posted by rekop (Post 10568994)
Does anyone know why Swiss always has the wing lights on on their Airbuses?

I don't know, but I've always though that having the logo light on the tail was a big plus.

Fly Aiprt 13th Sep 2019 12:46

In Switzerland, even cars must have their lights always on.

widmimabi 13th Sep 2019 12:52

To be better seen from other aircraft in fog or in the air as the logo light is by design switch off by gear up or slats in.
some pilots use that as a reminder for " clear to push"
Or to always see if the wings are still there 😀😀

lomapaseo 13th Sep 2019 13:21


Originally Posted by rekop (Post 10568994)
Does anyone know why Swiss always has the wing lights on on their Airbuses?

Some believe that birds know what the lights mean

pattern_is_full 13th Sep 2019 23:16

At most commercial operations I'm familiar with, the policy was - nav lights (red and green wing) ON when the aircraft was "alive." Crew on board, or electrical power flowing.

Which includes most turnarounds, and even overnight if the aircraft is (electrically, probably with ground connection) powered up for ground personnel (cleaners, mechanics and such).

With a full cold shutdown, the nav lights are the last thing turned off before the Master power switches.

Check Airman 14th Sep 2019 00:20

Nav light switch on my fleet is covered with dust...

rekop 14th Sep 2019 07:02

These are all very good guesses :-) Does anybody actually know why Swiss has it in their SOP. Not many companies use the wing lights for anything else than what they are designed for - to check for ice on the wing leading edge in flight. Nav and logo lights are the same switch and they are enough to keep the aircraft visible.

easymxp 14th Sep 2019 09:02

Some captains I used to fly a part from icing conditions etc wanted to have them on on some “little lighted - dark” airports during evening/night turnaround. But this was an exception rather than the usual.

ACMS 14th Sep 2019 10:33

Qantas use their Wing Lights all the time for taxi takeoff and landings on all fleets.

I can’t see any problem with doing it.
I sometimes switch them on in busy disorganized airspace such as Delhi or Jakarta and when crossing busy runways in places like Seoul and Beijing at night, can’t hurt to light up the Jet a little more.

I still remember a Us Air 737 landing on top of a Metro at LAX a number of years ago simply because the 737 crew didn’t see them.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_...unway_disaster

An an old saying referring to Driving in Victoria years ago is relevant to Aviation:—

“Be seen, be safe”

If you wish to talk about stupid use of lights then complain about the idiots that love aiming their nose at you lining up with all their lights blazing in your face......now that is bad airmanship.











meleagertoo 14th Sep 2019 15:36


Originally Posted by rekop (Post 10568994)
Does anyone know why Swiss always has the wing lights on on their Airbuses?


Er...many Hans make light work...?

Ahem! I'll get my coat!

csd 14th Sep 2019 17:21


Originally Posted by ACMS (Post 10569769)
If you wish to talk about stupid use of lights then complain about the idiots that love aiming their nose at you lining up with all their lights blazing in your face......now that is bad airmanship.

I've never found that a problem. Admittedly, turning onto the runway with traffic waiting at the reciprocal hold point, I normally do turn the lights off as a courtesy. However, if crews leave them on whilst pointing at me, I just don't look down the centre of the beam. Never been an issue for me.

Look up the incident involving a 737 at FAHS in 2011. A good reminder that perhaps those lights are useful after all.

WhatShortage 14th Sep 2019 22:33


Originally Posted by widmimabi (Post 10569129)
To be better seen from other aircraft in fog or in the air as the logo light is by design switch off by gear up or slats in.
some pilots use that as a reminder for " clear to push"
Or to always see if the wings are still there 😀😀

Do you know that sensation of knowing something or having read something, then mixing everything up and obviously give an erroneous explanation? That was your reply since the beginning.

Lights on fog = even less visibility than having them off
"" "" Clear to push"" "" = beacon on

ACMS 15th Sep 2019 10:27


Originally Posted by csd (Post 10569959)
I've never found that a problem. Admittedly, turning onto the runway with traffic waiting at the reciprocal hold point, I normally do turn the lights off as a courtesy. However, if crews leave them on whilst pointing at me, I just don't look down the centre of the beam. Never been an issue for me.

It happens a lot at places like HK with holding points on opposite sides of the runway, very annoying and inconsiderate to blast your landing lights straight into another crews face 100’ away.........


Anyway thread drift.....

Smythe 15th Sep 2019 21:47

With your lights on, AC thinks the taxiway is a runway...be careful1

AerocatS2A 15th Sep 2019 21:59


Originally Posted by Smythe (Post 10570831)
With your lights on, AC thinks the taxiway is a runway...be careful1

No, those jets all had their lights OFF. One of the crews turning them ON was one of the things that made AC go around.

fdr 16th Sep 2019 07:53

1. Because they are wise beyond their years?
2. the bullet that gets you is the one you don't see?
3. Why would you not?

pineteam 16th Sep 2019 08:23

Airbus FCOM says: When crossing a runway: Strobe sw.... ON and Runway turn off lights..... ON. Period. No TCAS, it's forbidden due to potential interference and no other lights. I don't understand why some airlines like to supersede Airbus SOP. If you don't see an aircraft with his strobe ON, something is terribly wrong. By the way the wing light is annoying for other traffic taxiing nearby. xD

jmmoric 16th Sep 2019 10:35

I'm not sure about the SoP for all carriers, but one thing hinting us as ATC, is that some airlines turn on landing lights when being given an take off clearance.

ACMS 16th Sep 2019 12:47


Originally Posted by jmmoric (Post 10571185)
I'm not sure about the SoP for all carriers, but one thing hinting us as ATC, is that some airlines turn on landing lights when being given an take off clearance.

yes correct....Airbus SOP...

pineteam 16th Sep 2019 12:55


Originally Posted by jmmoric (Post 10571185)
I'm not sure about the SoP for all carriers, but one thing hinting us as ATC, is that some airlines turn on landing lights when being given an take off clearance.

This is standard procedure on Airbus. They are called landing lights but they are used for take off and landing and anytimes flying below 10 000 feet Above Aerodrome Level.

EDIT: Oups, ACMS, you beat me on that one. xD

FlightDetent 16th Sep 2019 17:30

The LAND = ON upon receipt of TKOF clearance in the Cookbook was a change about 7 years ago, to align the generic manufacturer's guidance to the industry best practice from the FAA land. Before, a more grass-root level concept prevailed: as little actions on the runway as possible (to be done when entering the runway).

For me using TCAS = ON for crossing a runway is the smart choice, similar to displaying LS=ON briefly during line-up in LVP. May not be up to date on the latest print. The technical reasons for disallowing TCAS on the ground are not in conflict with its use for crossing the active.

2 side remarks done

fdr 16th Sep 2019 20:47


Originally Posted by pineteam (Post 10571081)
... I don't understand why some airlines like to supersede Airbus SOP. If you don't see an aircraft with his strobe ON, something is terribly wrong. By the way the wing light is annoying for other traffic taxiing nearby. xD

You may be surprised how strobes can be missed, as they were on 24L at LAX to the detriment of the Metro and 737.

zondaracer 18th Sep 2019 13:36


Originally Posted by fdr (Post 10571590)
You may be surprised how strobes can be missed, as they were on 24L at LAX to the detriment of the Metro and 737.

At that time, SkyWest SOPs were to have strobes off until cleared for takeoff. After that accident, they changed the SOPs to have strobes on anytime they are on or crossing an active runway.


All times are GMT. The time now is 22:22.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.