PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   B737 Takeoff with VNAV and LNAV disarmed (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/625420-b737-takeoff-vnav-lnav-disarmed.html)

tae9141 11th Sep 2019 07:06

B737 Takeoff with VNAV and LNAV disarmed
 
Hellow everyone, I am currently undergoing B737 and I got question to ask.

Let us say you were instructed to takeoff and fly runway heading soon after departure,
when you hit TOGA, does HDG SEL automatically selected and shows up on FMA or is it after departure ?

James



gegemi 11th Sep 2019 08:01

yes. At least on the NG.

FlyingStone 11th Sep 2019 08:12

It depends on the aircraft, as this is customer option.

It is either HDG SEL for takeoff, which means that as soon as you hit TOGA, you will get HDG SEL on the FMA, or it is wings level in which case the roll FMA will be blank.

Banana Joe 11th Sep 2019 10:36

Customer options. Ours engage HDG SEL, but there is an airframe or two in the fleet that don't.

Bergerie1 11th Sep 2019 10:42

As a very old fossil, why don't you just fly the aeroplane?

733driver 11th Sep 2019 10:59


Originally Posted by Bergerie1 (Post 10567251)
As a very old fossil, why don't you just fly the aeroplane?

One can do that and at the same time want to understand how the automation behaves i.e. what to expect from it.

ImbracableCrunk 12th Sep 2019 03:59


Originally Posted by Small cog (Post 10567265)
If one is doing a course on the 737, why not ask your instructor?

1. Why have this forum if not to ask questions?
2. There are also instructors here.

Aoyb 15th Sep 2019 05:22

As mentioned it depends. Certainly on the classics and on some NGs the HDG SEL will become active on the FMA at 400’

Until then the roll mode will be blank and FD bars will command wings level

Jumbo744 21st Sep 2019 17:04


Originally Posted by Bergerie1 (Post 10567251)
As a very old fossil, why don't you just fly the aeroplane?

Take it easy hero. It has nothing to do with flying the plane. The guy is asking a question about how the automation works on takeoff.

Derfred 24th Sep 2019 12:16


Originally Posted by Bergerie1 (Post 10567251)
As a very old fossil, why don't you just fly the aeroplane?

I have a lot of respect for a pilot who is capable of “just flying the aeroplane” when required.

But I have no respect for a pilot who chooses to “just fly the aeroplane” because he actually doesn’t know or understand his aeroplane.

Chuck Yeager apparently would never fly an aircraft until he knew the flight manual by heart and could find every switch blindfolded.

We’d all be wise to fully understand our aircraft systems before we get airborne and be forced to exercise our superior handling skills in an attempt to cover for our lack of study and knowledge.

Sig229 24th Sep 2019 22:26

At my company all aircraft will stay in TOGA until a lateral/vertical mode is selected. For vector departures we set the heading and call for Heading Select at 400AGL or the charted turn altitude if higher.

Tomaski 25th Sep 2019 02:44

Wait.... what?? You can actually takeoff with the LNAV and VNAV disarmed?!

Next thing you'll be telling me is that we can fly this thing without Flight Directors!

;););)

Centaurus 25th Sep 2019 12:37

Flight Director addiction, like tobacco addiction, is a real health hazard.

I say that, having operated with one simulator instructor who screams at his students to "follow the bloody flight director" even though the aircraft is in a gross unusual attitude 30 degrees nose down in a spiral dive.

anson harris 26th Sep 2019 09:12


Originally Posted by Bergerie1 (Post 10567251)
As a very old fossil, why don't you just fly the aeroplane?

Bingo! What do I win?

jmmoric 26th Sep 2019 14:01


Originally Posted by Bergerie1 (Post 10567251)
As a very old fossil, why don't you just fly the aeroplane?

Old fossils are overrepresented in stall or spin during departure/landings :)

I've read e few reports where they don't use the ASI, but go by their "instincts" getting older.

misd-agin 26th Sep 2019 15:37


Originally Posted by ImbracableCrunk (Post 10567941)


1. Why have this forum if not to ask questions?
2. There are also instructors here.

The instructors at his company will know what options their fleet has. As others have stated "it depends upon which options your company has for their aircraft."

misd-agin 26th Sep 2019 16:35


Originally Posted by Derfred (Post 10578220)


I have a lot of respect for a pilot who is capable of “just flying the aeroplane” when required.

But I have no respect for a pilot who chooses to “just fly the aeroplane” because he actually doesn’t know or understand his aeroplane.

Chuck Yeager apparently would never fly an aircraft until he knew the flight manual by heart and could find every switch blindfolded.

We’d all be wise to fully understand our aircraft systems before we get airborne and be forced to exercise our superior handling skills in an attempt to cover for our lack of study and knowledge.

He'd never get airborne in a modern airliner. The manuals are much longer than the manuals of earlier eras. The P-51 flight manual was 78 pages. Switches? In a modern airliner? He can't reach about 1/4 of them.

Tomaski 27th Sep 2019 12:24


Originally Posted by jmmoric (Post 10580121)
Old fossils are overrepresented in stall or spin during departure/landings :)

I've read e few reports where they don't use the ASI, but go by their "instincts" getting older.

Speaking as an old fossil, relying on the airspeed indicator without reference to the attitude and power settings is simply asking for trouble. I can think of quite a few accidents that resulted from chasing airspeed as opposed to setting appropriate pitch and power.

In my "old school" instrument training parlance, attitude and power are "control" instruments. Airspeed, altitude, heading, etc are "performance" instrument. You set the "control" instruments to the desired positions and then cross-check the "performance" instruments to see if you are getting the desired response. If something is out of whack, then you would first cross-check your attitude and power indicators and, if deemed reliable, continue to fly them and then determine if something is wrong with one of your performance indicators. This is a lesson that is easily forgotten in the age of modern airliners. Sadly, there are many pilots who don't get much beyond following the flight director commands, a method that probably works 98% of the time. It's that other 2% that will get you in trouble.......

Centaurus 28th Sep 2019 02:40


The P-51 flight manual was 78 pages.
You were spoilt. The Pilots Notes Mustang RAAF Publication Mo. 780 dated September 1950 issued to this scribe, only had 50 pages. RAF Dakota Pilots Notes only had 45 pages, while RAF Pilots Notes for the Lincoln (four Rolls Royce Merlins) in 1950 had 54 pages

reverserunlocked 28th Sep 2019 11:23

My understanding is the RYR don’t use VNAV for departure, cleaning up they flaps first before selecting it.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:58.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.