PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   Changing auto brake setting during roll out (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/614604-changing-auto-brake-setting-during-roll-out.html)

stilton 21st Oct 2018 22:47

Changing auto brake setting during roll out
 
I’ve not seen any specific guidance against this or done it personally


If I’m not getting the required deceleration
i’ll disconnect the AB and manually brake


But I’ve seen it done and curious as to
thoughts on this technique

BluSdUp 21st Oct 2018 23:01

Madness...

Tee Emm 21st Oct 2018 23:15

Technically possible but what's the point? It's a gimmick and lacks class

InSoMnIaC 22nd Oct 2018 00:05

It seems like a good/acceptable idea until you accidentally hit MAX

N1EPR 22nd Oct 2018 00:37

I often changed the auto brake settings on the B757. It was a smooth operation. I never used the technique to increase braking.

pineteam 22nd Oct 2018 04:31


Originally Posted by InSoMnIaC (Post 10288971)
It seems like a good/acceptable idea until you accidentally hit MAX

Exactly my thought too. I often use Autobrake low and disconnect it if I need more or less braking. I always try to brake as smooth as possible and take the last high speed exit for the sake of confort and brakes life. If a pilot relies so much on automation on the ground, I would be concerned.

FlyingStone 22nd Oct 2018 04:32

Seen it being done, never really understood the point, especially when people would change it mutiple times during rollout (i.e. 3 to 2, then 2 to 1).

Isn’t it much easier just to press the pedals to disconnect the autobrake and brake manually?

AmarokGTI 22nd Oct 2018 04:47

If you are not getting the required deceleration changing the setting might not work if the reason is a fault with the system. Once you work that out you have even less time for the manual option.

172_driver 22nd Oct 2018 06:44


I often changed the auto brake settings on the B757. It was a smooth operation. I never used the technique to increase braking.
Same here.

It's in the 737 FCOM that autobrakes can be selected and changed during landing roll out. No warning or caution.

73qanda 22nd Oct 2018 10:08


It seems like a good/acceptable idea until you accidentally hit MAX

Exactly my thought too.
I can’t imagine anyone ever ‘accidentally ‘ selecting MAX. Would you accidentally lift the knob up and over ? It’s not that easy to do.
I don’t use the above technique and prefer to select a slightly lower setting than required and override to disengage.

CaptainProp 22nd Oct 2018 10:14


Originally Posted by InSoMnIaC (Post 10288971)
It seems like a good/acceptable idea until you accidentally hit MAX

Exactly THAT! What a load of BS! Taking your eyes of the runway on rollout to “locate” switches and stuff is simply unprofessional. As far as I’m concerned you touch nothing until clear of runway and spoilers are being disarmed.

CP

InSoMnIaC 22nd Oct 2018 10:19

Not all aircraft use knobs to set autobrake.

ACMS 22nd Oct 2018 11:58

Ummmmmm..........:8

Skyjob 22nd Oct 2018 12:41


Originally Posted by AmarokGTI (Post 10289071)
If you are not getting the required deceleration changing the setting might not work if the reason is a fault with the system. Once you work that out you have even less time for the manual option.

I'd only use it the other way around:

Say you've prepared performance rollout data for a WET runway but during landing its damp at best if anything.
Having checked DRY and WET performance prior to landing, you know that a lower AB setting would make the desired exit in DRY conditions.
Lowering the AB eating to the desired lower one is good airmanship in this case, alternatively, manual braking to disconnect the higher auto brake selected the other option.

FlightDetent 22nd Oct 2018 14:05

Skyjob: AB usually provides a controlled deceleration rate.

The Boeing RTO OFF-1-2-3-MAX is far superior to AB's LO-MED MAX in the interface, given the task suggested above.

AB: no, unless you really want to do the inevitable.
B: to reduce decel rate? Worked nicely, I seem to remember (steel brakes at the time).

vilas 22nd Oct 2018 17:14

Routinely in normal conditions doesn't make any sense. But in rain and crosswind etc. if one wants to increase braking effect not a bad idea to change to medium from low. You are assured of even braking.

FullWings 22nd Oct 2018 18:52

It’s the poor man’s Brake To Vacate...!

Tee Emm 23rd Oct 2018 01:55


Lowering the AB eating to the desired lower one is good airmanship in this case, alternatively, manual braking to disconnect the higher auto brake selected the other option.
All very complicated and unnecessary fiddling about. If you land with autobrake MEL'd u/s, should you declare Mayday or simply PAN? Or just land and use normal manual braking like ordinary pilots have done so in the past 50 years. Much ado about nothing, IMHO

stilton 23rd Oct 2018 02:10

Not necessarily against it, particularly in
adverse conditions with gusty winds and
a wet / short runway


But If you do, I think it should be the PNF
that adjusts the setting, it’s an awkward reach to where the selector is usually
located and an unnecessary distraction to the PF



I was in the jump seat of a 747 Classic a
few years ago however that had the AB selector mounted on the left side of the overhead panel in easy reach of the CA

Old Fella 23rd Oct 2018 02:37

Changing Auto Brake Selection after touchdown.
 

Originally Posted by InSoMnIaC (Post 10289281)
Not all aircraft use knobs to set autobrake.

No, but some other knobs might change the setting during roll out.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:55.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.