PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   Sense of Propellor rotation (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/375356-sense-propellor-rotation.html)

b377 26th May 2009 20:28

Sense of Propellor rotation
 
Other than in engines with counter rotating propellors, is there a technical or historical reason for choosing an anticlockwise propellor rotation?
(when regarded from the front) I presume this is universal in western piston and turboprop designs.

barit1 26th May 2009 21:48

While clockwise (viewed from rear) is predominant, there are still plenty of exceptions even today. There's no hard technical reason, but since a prop needs to be fitted, it's an advantage to make the engine turn the same direction as available props.

captjns 26th May 2009 22:21

With non-geared engines, subject to the engine manufacturer. Us built engines rotate clockwise where UK built engines rotate counterclockwise… even the jet engines GE and Pratts rotate clockwise whilst the RR counterclockwise.

Jumbo Driver 26th May 2009 22:31


Originally Posted by b377 (Post 4955582)
... I presume this is universal in western piston and turboprop designs.

Not so ... Clockwise (from the rear) is only "normal" for American engines, whereas British piston engines rotate in the counter-clockwise (from the rear) direction.

That, of course, begs another question ...


JD
;)


sorry, captjns, I inadvertently duplicated your post ...

Shackman 27th May 2009 08:03

The answer:

Contra-rotating!

captjns 27th May 2009 09:23

Hey what happens if you are south of the equator!?!?!:eek::}

brakedwell 27th May 2009 09:31


Hey what happens if you are south of the equator!?!?!
You disappear straight down the plughole hanging on to a bootful of left rudder! :eek: :eek:

barit1 27th May 2009 13:02


The answer:

Contra-rotating!
At least one new engine, the GEnx, is contrarotating. Core turns cw, fan ccw (anti-clockwise in the UK). :ok:

captjns 27th May 2009 13:31

Oops... forgot about the Piper (PA-34) Senca. It has continental counter rotating engines. and the PA-31-325, the Piper Navajo CR has Lycoming counter rotating engines.

dutch crosswind 27th May 2009 13:57

Of course England is counter rotating. Same on the road and with the money.

eckhard 27th May 2009 14:23

I believe that low-power British engines (gipsy major, etc) traditionally rotate anti-clockwise (when viewed from behind) to make them easier for a right-handed chap (or chapess) to swing them.

When standing in front, ones right arm naturally swings clockwise.

:)Eck

Landroger 27th May 2009 21:30

Prop swinging.
 

When standing in front, ones right arm naturally swings clockwise.
I'm sure someone who has done it will correct me, but if you swing clockwise right handed, is there not a danger that your body naturally leans toward the prop? I'm sure I've seen props swung 'on the backhand', so to speak, so you naturally walk away from the disk with the 'swinging hand' behind you. :confused:

Roger.

Landroger 27th May 2009 21:36

Jet engine rotation.
 

With non-geared engines, subject to the engine manufacturer. Us built engines rotate clockwise where UK built engines rotate counterclockwise… even the jet engines GE and Pratts rotate clockwise whilst the RR counterclockwise.
Do they? That is an interesting and intriguing fact, to be sure, which prompts me to ask; There is quite a lot of rotating mass inside a high bypass fan jet so, would a GE powered aeroplane - say a 757 - turn slightly differently from an R-R powered 757?

Roger.

barit1 27th May 2009 22:15

US vs UK
 
In theory, yes, due to gyroscopic loads the rotors place on the engine structure and thus into the mountings.

But the gyro loads are quite insignificant compared to the control forces the pilot employs during normal maneuvers, and I doubt anyone ever notices.

PS - the engines available for the 757 are R-R and P&W, not GE.

eckhard 28th May 2009 20:51

Landroger,

Back in the '70s I did start Chipmunks, Stampes and Tigers a few times by prop-swinging. I found the position that the prop stopped in (2 o'clock) made it easy to use my right arm, but I see what you mean about the 'backhanded swing'. I must say I was always very careful (and a little scared). There was a horror story doing the rounds then about a poor guy who walked towards the entry door of an Aero Commander with the engines running and got minced by the prop. They found one of his hands on the hangar roof.:(

The trickiest part was taking a passenger for a flight and having to brief them on the operation of the cockpit controls. Always made sure we had chocks installed and brakes on for that exercise!

gas path 28th May 2009 23:12

Of course just to complicate matters the Rolls Royce Trent 900 and 1000 has spools that contra rotate!:8

NutLoose 28th May 2009 23:14

Griffon rotates the opposite way to the Merlin.

As to the man walking into the prop of the Aero Commander, on the C152 the wing strut would tend to prevent that a bit, but the new 162 sadly has the strut behind the door, which in my eyes is an accident in the making.

AS for some of the Gas Turbs, well a lot of them go both ways, as in the HP/ LP compressor rotations to counteract the rotational forces.

Damn u beat me to it as I typed !!

barit1 29th May 2009 02:00

Before all the modern c/r ships -

The fighter pilot's lament:

"Don't give me a P-38
with propellers that counter-rotate;
she loop and she'l spin
and she'll soon auger in -
Don't give me a P-38!"

dixi188 29th May 2009 06:44

The Rolls Royce (Bristol) Pegasus engine in the Harrier uses counter rotating shafts to reduce the gyroscopic effect on the low speed handling of the aircraft.

Landroger 29th May 2009 17:40

Thanks for the information guys - fascinating stuff. As for contra rotating spools in modern engines, you can sort of see why from the gas flow/reaction point of view, but any bearing between two spools will naturally have elements running at twice the speed of a fixed outer/moving inner arrangement and several times that of spools rotating in the same orientation. In that case I imagine one spool would be running at a percentage of the other and thus the relative speeds are quite small.

Roger.


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:10.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.