PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   trouble 't mill? (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/280368-trouble-t-mill.html)

Thirty Eight South 17th Jun 2007 12:54

trouble 't mill?
 
4 weeks and counting, can't remember where the pictures come from, but they show 787 barrel sections 41/5-19 mis-match, a recognized problem with this manufacturing method borrowed from the MV-22 fuselage manufacture method
BusinessWeek has learned that Boeing's engineers are wrestling with several significant technical and production problems that could threaten the scheduled 2008 delivery of the jetliner
At a time when Boeing has left itself with little margin for error, the wide-ranging series of glitches could create a domino effect if they aren't resolved quickly. The worst news: The fuselage section -- the big multi-part cylindrical barrel that encompasses the passenger seating area -- has failed in company testing. That's forcing Boeing to make more sections than planned, and to reexamine quality and safety concerns.

http://www.businessweek.com/magazine...5/b3989049.htm

+ Systems not installed.
+ Workmanship issues with the horizontal stabilizer.
+ Temporary fasteners that will have to be replaced.


Those are only some of what 787 workers at The Boeing Co.'s Everett plant face as the mad dash begins to get the first Dreamliner assembled and out the factory door by July 8.



http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/a...h_photo/B1.jpg

http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/a...h_photo/B2.jpg

http://i200.photobucket.com/albums/a...h_photo/B3.jpg

Dan Winterland 17th Jun 2007 14:37

I suspect there aren't too many people in Seattle laiughing about Airbus' misfortunes with the A380 right now.

lomapaseo 17th Jun 2007 14:52

Typical pre-production problems and probably far easier addressed (with a large hammer) than rerouting a gazzillion miles of wires.

Sallyann1234 17th Jun 2007 15:14

Are Boeing still designing a new airplane in the 21st century in INCHES?

A Very Civil Pilot 17th Jun 2007 19:21

What's wrong with inches?
What about the (albeit 20th century space shuttle being in measures of roman chariots?
(Link to well-worn internet story!) http://www.seiyaku.com/reference/shuttle.html

Sallyann1234 17th Jun 2007 20:49

Yes that's an interesting quote, but doesn't really justify the design of a new aircraft in an obsolete measurement system (if that really is the case?).
Try this link instead:
http://mars.jpl.nasa.gov/msp98/news/mco990930.html

skiingman 17th Jun 2007 21:03


Originally Posted by A Very Civil Pilot
What's wrong with inches?

You must be that bald curmudgeon engineering prof who slapped me around with customary units I'd never heard of before but apparently are awful important to bald old people. Rankine what?

Spodman 17th Jun 2007 21:03


...doesn't really justify the design of a new aircraft in an obsolete measurement system...
Look a bit more closely, you'll see the ruler is metric, metric inches that is...

Marvo 17th Jun 2007 21:47

They should have used Withworth.... I have several withworth spanners in my loft going spare..

Max Angle 17th Jun 2007 22:10


far easier addressed (with a large hammer)
Rather hard to address anything made in carbon fibre with a hammer I would have thought

wobble2plank 18th Jun 2007 07:39

Can't they just heat it up with the missus's hairdryer and smudge it into shape with an engineers thumb :confused:

Thats what my lad does with his (late) airfix models ;)

Sheesh, all those engineering degrees outthought by a six year old :p

james ozzie 18th Jun 2007 09:48

We should remember the Gimley Glider was partly caused by a SNAFU with non SI units

Sallyann1234 18th Jun 2007 11:01

Isn't it time that aviation finally bit the bullet and standardised on SI units? How can such a safety-conscious industry continue to live with so many superfluous calculations and so many proven causes of error?
Sorry, I realise this is serious topic drift.

john_tullamarine 18th Jun 2007 11:17

Isn't it time that aviation finally bit the bullet and standardised on SI units?

Some of us might even opine that the sorry mess could best be corrected by going back to slugs and poundals ..... real units with some meat to them ...

forget 18th Jun 2007 11:26

With you 100% there JT. See what Bony had to say about 'metrication'. :ok:

http://i21.photobucket.com/albums/b270/cumpas/nap.jpg

hetfield 18th Jun 2007 11:35

Yeah, let's have the rest of the world pennies and pounds, lefthand driving, fish and chips and a queen.....

forget 18th Jun 2007 11:45

Location Sydney? You've already got three out of four.:)

hetfield 18th Jun 2007 11:58

Yeah, the $ must be an accident:O, don't know 'cause not very good in history:*

Sallyann1234 18th Jun 2007 12:12

Some of us might even opine that the sorry mess could best be corrected by going back to slugs and poundals ..... real units with some meat to them ...

It's relatively unimportant which standard is used. The key thing is that everyone uses the same one.
Since almost every country has adopted SI units, and the great majority of the world's population are taught in them, surely it is time that a great international industry fell into line. Not for the sake of appearance, but because of the undoubted benefits of efficiency and safety that will follow.
My original question is still unanswered - is the 787 really being designed in inches?

Mad (Flt) Scientist 18th Jun 2007 13:18

If it is, its probably safer that way.
There's no especial risk in any given system of units; it's mixing systems that causes issues. Which would be riskier - sticking to inches and 'thou' on the Seattle production line, or having a switchover to millimetres - likely on just one programme at that.
"Gee, what's the standard tolerance, 10 (thou) mil?". NASA's inadvertent collision with Mars wasn't because of using metric or imperial - it was using BOTH that caused it. Sticking to what you know is often a good idea.


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:32.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.