Low speed buffet quick rule of thumb
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
From: Here and there
Low speed buffet quick rule of thumb
I'm flying an EFIS 737 wo speed tape. How does one calculate the low speed buffet onset speed Up at altitude? (Assuming calm conditions)
I have heard some pilots use the vref40 speed plus a fudge factor... Is that a safe estimate? and if so, what should that fudge factor be?
Thanks in advance.
I have heard some pilots use the vref40 speed plus a fudge factor... Is that a safe estimate? and if so, what should that fudge factor be?
Thanks in advance.
Last edited by Trash8mofo; 20th July 2015 at 07:34.
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
From: Here and there
Because the flap manuvering speed is only applicable to 20,000 ft. What I would like to know is my coffin corner margin without the benefit of a speed tape. I haven't seen a buffet boundary charts in the AFM and I'm thinking some of the old hands here might have some advice.
Joined: Sep 1999
Posts: 122
Likes: 0
From: USA
"What I would like to know is my coffin corner margin without the benefit of a speed tape."
If I may make a rash assumption that you do not intend to fly at an altitude greater than the FMC predicted 'Max', then you will be NOWHERE near CC and do not need any 'rule of thumb'.
Of course, if you seek to soar with the angels near 'coffin corner', then you need to consider high speed buffet as well.
If I may make a rash assumption that you do not intend to fly at an altitude greater than the FMC predicted 'Max', then you will be NOWHERE near CC and do not need any 'rule of thumb'.
Of course, if you seek to soar with the angels near 'coffin corner', then you need to consider high speed buffet as well.
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 193
Likes: 0
From: In thin air
The variation of the buffet boundary with altitude is caused by compressibility effects, expressed by the Mach number. Those effects are too complex to fit any 'rule of thumb'. What you really need is the buffet boundary determined in the manufacturer's flight tests, and that should be in the AFM. If you can't find it in the AFM, why don't you ask Boeing's Operations Support?
Joined: Jun 2002
Aviation Qualifications: PPL
Posts: 5,106
Likes: 323
From: east ESSEX
Why not give the pax the flight/fright of their life and just go and horse around a bit,see how it feels at `x+` degrees of bank/v Mach; then you`ll know...
or perhaps it might be worthwile doing it in the Sim first.,...
or perhaps it might be worthwile doing it in the Sim first.,...
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 223
Likes: 0
From: SSE of smoki
I can't answer you question directly regarding low speed buffet at altitude so apologies for that.
If you have an FMC with the hold page function then you could use that to give you a sensible minimum speed to fly in the cruise at high altitude. Select PPOS but don't execute. Note the speed it generates and don't fly below that, thus remaining on the correct side of the drag curve.
If you don't have an FMC then use the FCOM tables for holding. They will tell you amongst other things a speed to fly based on weight and altitude. Again a safe and sensible minimum speed.
Good luck and let us know if you get anything firm.
If you have an FMC with the hold page function then you could use that to give you a sensible minimum speed to fly in the cruise at high altitude. Select PPOS but don't execute. Note the speed it generates and don't fly below that, thus remaining on the correct side of the drag curve.
If you don't have an FMC then use the FCOM tables for holding. They will tell you amongst other things a speed to fly based on weight and altitude. Again a safe and sensible minimum speed.
Good luck and let us know if you get anything firm.
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
From: Hong Kong
Buffet is min speed but...
It is nice to know your low speed buffet for a particular weight and altitude, however I personally don't think that it is not too smart to be flying below drift down speed one eng inop.
I fly the 767 and we use as a ball park Ref30 + 100. (It is actual somewhere between +98 and +95, close enough). It would be easy enough to extract the figures for the 737 from the books.
If you know your min speed at sea level, you can simply add 1 knot for every 1000' above 20 000'. That equates the allowance for compressibility. This is important because aircraft stall relative to equivalent airspeed and not CAS.
Remember also that high speed buffet is in relation to Mach number but low speed buffet although it may be expressed as a Mach number actually happens at a EAS.
Good luck with the books!
I fly the 767 and we use as a ball park Ref30 + 100. (It is actual somewhere between +98 and +95, close enough). It would be easy enough to extract the figures for the 737 from the books.
If you know your min speed at sea level, you can simply add 1 knot for every 1000' above 20 000'. That equates the allowance for compressibility. This is important because aircraft stall relative to equivalent airspeed and not CAS.
Remember also that high speed buffet is in relation to Mach number but low speed buffet although it may be expressed as a Mach number actually happens at a EAS.
Good luck with the books!
Last edited by Colin Oskopi; 26th July 2015 at 06:00.
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 193
Likes: 0
From: In thin air
00'. That equates the allowance for compressibility. This is important because aircraft stall relative to equivalent airspeed and not CAS.
Remember also that high speed buffet is in relation to Mach number but low speed buffet although it may be expressed as a Mach number actually happens at a EAS.
Remember also that high speed buffet is in relation to Mach number but low speed buffet although it may be expressed as a Mach number actually happens at a EAS.
Therefore the low-speed buffet boundary at altitude is not constant EAS.
Last edited by Gysbreght; 25th July 2015 at 17:42.
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
From: Hong Kong
Min speed and drift down VS Mach no.
That may be so, however what we are discussing here is min speed at altitude. The figures are readily available in the book and they are quoted in CAS, as are drift-down speeds. Both are derived from stall speed adjusted for compressibility.
Here is how they derive it on the A330-300.
Min clean = 191kts at 140,000kg below 20,000'
Add 6 kts per 10,000kg above 140,000kg
Add 1 kt per 1000' above 20,000'.
Say 200,000 kg flying at 35,000' min clean would be 191+36+15=242kts
Interestingly, that is how the Airbus FMS also calculates it, and this speed is also the drift down speed one engine out. You will notice that at no time is Mach number considered.
Here is how they derive it on the A330-300.
Min clean = 191kts at 140,000kg below 20,000'
Add 6 kts per 10,000kg above 140,000kg
Add 1 kt per 1000' above 20,000'.
Say 200,000 kg flying at 35,000' min clean would be 191+36+15=242kts
Interestingly, that is how the Airbus FMS also calculates it, and this speed is also the drift down speed one engine out. You will notice that at no time is Mach number considered.
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 193
Likes: 0
From: In thin air
Colin Oskopi,
I believe the subject of the thread is "low speed buffet". Have you looked at the buffet boundary and the stall speed on pages 4 and 7, respectively, of the A330 FCOM 3.01.20?
I believe the subject of the thread is "low speed buffet". Have you looked at the buffet boundary and the stall speed on pages 4 and 7, respectively, of the A330 FCOM 3.01.20?
Last edited by Gysbreght; 26th July 2015 at 09:12.
Thread Starter
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 37
Likes: 0
From: Here and there
Thanks for the input, but wouldn't the plane have a lower AOA during drift down and therefore is afforded more stall protection? Therefore min speed in level flight in altitude would need a higher speed than drift down?
Joined: Oct 2007
Posts: 24
Likes: 0
From: Hong Kong
Min speed clarification.
The reason I don't fly below drift down speed is, 1. It gives adequate margin over the stall, and 2. Drift down speed is your initial target speed or min speed if you like should an engine failure occur. If you fly below drift down speed, and you do lose an engine you will have to descend immediately, and part of the procedure regarding RVSM is to minimise your altitude loss until 10 nm off track. Remember you will be turning as well. Do you want to be doing this at low speed?
The point is not so much what speed you chose as your minimum, but being able to justify why you chose that speed.
Back to the 767, Min speed at sea level is Ref30+80.
At 37000' +17 kts, min speed is Ref30+97, which is within a couple of knots of the book figures for drift down speed. There is method to their madness.
At no time does the book figures or the FMS give a Mach number.
The point is not so much what speed you chose as your minimum, but being able to justify why you chose that speed.
Back to the 767, Min speed at sea level is Ref30+80.
At 37000' +17 kts, min speed is Ref30+97, which is within a couple of knots of the book figures for drift down speed. There is method to their madness.
At no time does the book figures or the FMS give a Mach number.
