Avro RJ 85
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
From: Madrid
Avro RJ 85
Hello,
Is it the APU starting that we hear a few minutes after take-off, around the acceleration altitude? I've always wondered what the noise was, it does sound like the crew is starting the 4th engine or something. Thanks for your enlightment
Is it the APU starting that we hear a few minutes after take-off, around the acceleration altitude? I've always wondered what the noise was, it does sound like the crew is starting the 4th engine or something. Thanks for your enlightment
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 945
Likes: 445
From: Austria
While I have not flown this type, I do remember a highly distinctive wailing sound the flaps emit when travelling through a certain setting from my flights as pax. As You have heard this during acceleration, this might be the cause. In fact, one of the many nicknames the 146 bore was "Hound of Hatfield" due to this noise...
EDIT:
Starting from 0:39 in
, You can hear the sound I was referring to.
EDIT:
Starting from 0:39 in
Last edited by Tu.114; 27th February 2013 at 08:39.
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 2,296
Likes: 305
From: All at sea
It is indeed airflow as a result of the flaps running through a certain position. The airline I worked for had the cabin crew include a short spiel about this in their pre takeoff passenger brief.
The BAC 1-11 made a similar racket, though the engines were so noisy on takeoff that the flap howl was only audible on approach at idle thrust.
The BAC 1-11 made a similar racket, though the engines were so noisy on takeoff that the flap howl was only audible on approach at idle thrust.
Last edited by Mach E Avelli; 28th February 2013 at 02:07.
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 366
Likes: 14
From: California
The Phantom (F-4) had wonderful noises when on final for landing, due to the various engine intake door(s) scheduling I think.
I lived for a while on the approach to a US ANG (Air National Guard) base and couldn't resist rushing outside whenever a flight pair made their approaches.
Great stuff !!
I lived for a while on the approach to a US ANG (Air National Guard) base and couldn't resist rushing outside whenever a flight pair made their approaches.
Great stuff !!
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 121
Likes: 0
From: EGPH
It is the flaps moving from flap18 to flap0. It makes the same noise going from flap0 to flap18.
It won't be APU starting. You wouldn't start the APU after take off. Normally you took off with it off. It is was running on take off you would switch it off after flap0. On approach you would switch the APU on at about 5000'.
It won't be APU starting. You wouldn't start the APU after take off. Normally you took off with it off. It is was running on take off you would switch it off after flap0. On approach you would switch the APU on at about 5000'.
Thread Starter
Joined: Dec 2006
Posts: 88
Likes: 0
From: Madrid
Haha I don't get it then: Has the Avro got too much power or not enough 
And thanks for your replies. Indeed I was not convinced myself that this noise was due to an APU (or even engine!) starting
And thanks for your replies. Indeed I was not convinced myself that this noise was due to an APU (or even engine!) starting
Last edited by dudubrdx; 28th February 2013 at 13:54.
Joined: Nov 1999
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 3,150
Likes: 744
From: UK
Yep, it is flap howl. Caused by the airflow resonating when the flap gap is a certain size, and changing in pitch as the gap size changes when the flaps are running in or out. A similar process to organ pipes, where air is blown across a gap to produce a note.
When I flew the 146, I was told that the Queen's Flight, (which used 146 or variants) had a modification to reduce the noise, but I can't imagine what that would be, or even if it was true.
When I flew the 146, I was told that the Queen's Flight, (which used 146 or variants) had a modification to reduce the noise, but I can't imagine what that would be, or even if it was true.
Joined: Oct 2002
Aviation Qualifications: PPL
Posts: 8,208
Likes: 352
From: London UK
One of the most regular questions about the 146/Avro type. The flap howl is is an aerodynamic harmonic between the inner flap edge and the fuselage side at certain settings, it makes the ascending tone as the flaps come in on departure, and the opposite descending tone as they are deployed on approach. It was apparently a surprise on first flight, the wind tunnel tests hadn't identified it. BAe did indeed develop a modification to overcome it but it weighed 100 kg, two pax, and I always thought nobody took it until reading above that the RAF VIP ones put it on.
I've heard cabin crew say the descending tone is the cue to them to give cabin secure. On departure from London City on 28 and turning right, the flaps normally come in overhead Stratford and the Olympic stadium at 3,000 feet. The howl from this is quite audible when standing out on the train station platform at Stratford as the aircraft passes overhead. I was wondering if the commentators were going to pick up on it in the Olympics !
I've heard cabin crew say the descending tone is the cue to them to give cabin secure. On departure from London City on 28 and turning right, the flaps normally come in overhead Stratford and the Olympic stadium at 3,000 feet. The howl from this is quite audible when standing out on the train station platform at Stratford as the aircraft passes overhead. I was wondering if the commentators were going to pick up on it in the Olympics !
