Weather Radar interpretation
Thread Starter
Weather Radar interpretation
How do you determine if a heavy/red radar return is :
- heavy stratus rain (meaning it safe to fly through)
or
- thunderstorm / CB cloud (not wise to fly through)
Sometimes the return will be solid red but you know it is only heavy rain so you continue to fly through it.
Other times it might be a CB
How did you tell the difference.
- heavy stratus rain (meaning it safe to fly through)
or
- thunderstorm / CB cloud (not wise to fly through)
Sometimes the return will be solid red but you know it is only heavy rain so you continue to fly through it.
Other times it might be a CB
How did you tell the difference.
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 1,414
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Try reducing the manual Gain control (if fitted) to minimum setting (as against Auto/Cal/ or max). If the picture is still strongly red then avoid like a plague. This technique was usually successful when operating into Pacific islands where very heavy rain associated with towering Cu would cover the radar screen with red returns. By experiementing with the Gain control you could eliminate most of the heavy returns and the last one left was the one to avoid as it may be a CB rather than a towering Cu.
Same principle for high altitude cruise with certain types of radar. In this case set the Gain out of the automatic position into the MAX gain and the tops of CB normally invisible in AUTO gain, would show up as a very small echo. But enough to arouse suspicion that something big is in front. Tops of big CB up to 50,000 ft are usually dry and thus no reflection but with MAX gain often something shows up as a tiny return.
Get a copy of the radar manufacturer's Pilot Information Manual. Always good information in it.
Same principle for high altitude cruise with certain types of radar. In this case set the Gain out of the automatic position into the MAX gain and the tops of CB normally invisible in AUTO gain, would show up as a very small echo. But enough to arouse suspicion that something big is in front. Tops of big CB up to 50,000 ft are usually dry and thus no reflection but with MAX gain often something shows up as a tiny return.
Get a copy of the radar manufacturer's Pilot Information Manual. Always good information in it.
PPRuNe supporter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Planet Earth
Posts: 1,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How do you determine if a heavy/red radar return is :
Cheers, D.L.
Guest
Posts: n/a
Right.
By experimenting i.e reducing the gain, you may find yourself in the middle of the 5hit very easy.
If you were "experimenting" i.e. moving your radar beam up and down, as necessary, using Tilt, you would be in a much better situation.
By experiementing with the Gain control you could eliminate most of the heavy returns and the last one left was the one to avoid as it may be a CB rather than a towering Cu.
If you were "experimenting" i.e. moving your radar beam up and down, as necessary, using Tilt, you would be in a much better situation.
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: fort sheridan, il
Posts: 1,656
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
john citizen
invest in an archie trammel radar course or video...great stuff. play around with tilt and gain ALOT!
some radars have a magenta tone in the red and that can be really bad.
I've learned that it is the boundry between colors that can really smack you upside the head.
invest in an archie trammel radar course or video...great stuff. play around with tilt and gain ALOT!
some radars have a magenta tone in the red and that can be really bad.
I've learned that it is the boundry between colors that can really smack you upside the head.
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: USA
Posts: 451
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
John Citizen
Unfortunately, much of what you read here on PPrune is utter nonsense. I strongly suggest you have a look at the Airbus documents....two in particular....one is Getting to Grips with Aircraft Surveilance, the other is Optimum Use of the Weather RADAR.
This is a start......
Next, discuss this issue with someone in your training department.
Asking the opinion of an experienced captain may be f benefit, as well.
Fly safe,
PantLoad
This is a start......
Next, discuss this issue with someone in your training department.
Asking the opinion of an experienced captain may be f benefit, as well.
Fly safe,
PantLoad
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: fort sheridan, il
Posts: 1,656
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
john citizen
my airline issued us the archie trammel course and everyone loved it.
certainly read what your airline gives you. but you have just heard it from an experienced airline captain...
come on pantload
my airline issued us the archie trammel course and everyone loved it.
certainly read what your airline gives you. but you have just heard it from an experienced airline captain...
come on pantload
How do you determine if a heavy/red radar return is :
- heavy stratus rain (meaning it safe to fly through)
or
- thunderstorm / CB cloud (not wise to fly through)
- heavy stratus rain (meaning it safe to fly through)
or
- thunderstorm / CB cloud (not wise to fly through)
There are plenty of threads here on it (including Archie Trammel's info):
http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/48016...tml#post440714
http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/37673...her-radar.html
http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/23512...adar-tilt.html
http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/40341...-question.html
etc etc
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Australia
Posts: 1,414
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Asking the opinion of an experienced captain may be f benefit, as well.
Thread Starter
what is "heavy stratus rain", JC
1. Heavy
2. Stratus
3. Rain
You can find many references to "Stratus Rain" in this Honeywell document if you still can't work it out
Airborne Weather Radar Interpretation
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: US
Posts: 2,205
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
JC - as A37575 stated, decrease sensitivity at low altitude, increase sensitivity(gain) at high altitude. Newer aircraft can reduce gain below the old 'auto/calibrated/normal' setting.
Tilt is inverse to altitude. Low alt = tilt up, high alt = tilt down.
Rapid increase in intensity is not good.
Practice(gain/tilt) with storms you can see as you manuever past them. Use that knowledge(experience) at night or when you're in clouds (IMC) and can't see the storms.
Not a fan of the official guidance in the AFM's re: radar use. Air France President spoke about another flight (AF?) hitting turbulence at altitude along the same route as AF447. Said the Captain switched to a more sensitive setting (that is not AFM guidance..) and changed his route of flight based on the new radar depiction.
After all this there is no guarantee about weather you're penetrating. Sometimes it's better, and sometime it's worse, than you'd expect.
Tilt is inverse to altitude. Low alt = tilt up, high alt = tilt down.
Rapid increase in intensity is not good.
Practice(gain/tilt) with storms you can see as you manuever past them. Use that knowledge(experience) at night or when you're in clouds (IMC) and can't see the storms.
Not a fan of the official guidance in the AFM's re: radar use. Air France President spoke about another flight (AF?) hitting turbulence at altitude along the same route as AF447. Said the Captain switched to a more sensitive setting (that is not AFM guidance..) and changed his route of flight based on the new radar depiction.
After all this there is no guarantee about weather you're penetrating. Sometimes it's better, and sometime it's worse, than you'd expect.
Per Ardua ad Astraeus
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 18,579
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
JC - I'm sure that is a fantastic book you have linked, but here is the definition of 'Stratus' cloud/rain for you. You do not get 'heavy rain' from Stratus cloud as you can see, hence my query
"Stratus clouds are more known for drizzle than for precipitation, however. When heavier rain falls from them, their title is changed to nimbostratus clouds
Nimbostratus clouds form at or below 6,000 feet. They are dark, low level clouds that bring light to moderately heavy prolonged precipitation, such as snow or rain.
Altostratus clouds are incapable of producing heavy precipitation, but they are often the cause of a light drizzle. Following altostratus clouds are nimbostratus clouds, which are the source of heavier precipitation."
I believe '"Nimbus" is 'Rain cloud' in Latin. Hope this helps!
"Stratus clouds are more known for drizzle than for precipitation, however. When heavier rain falls from them, their title is changed to nimbostratus clouds
Nimbostratus clouds form at or below 6,000 feet. They are dark, low level clouds that bring light to moderately heavy prolonged precipitation, such as snow or rain.
Altostratus clouds are incapable of producing heavy precipitation, but they are often the cause of a light drizzle. Following altostratus clouds are nimbostratus clouds, which are the source of heavier precipitation."
I believe '"Nimbus" is 'Rain cloud' in Latin. Hope this helps!
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: engineer at large
Posts: 1,409
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
jeezus JC...
If you have questions about "heavy/red radar return", do you expect everyone to know which system you are using?
Aside from that.....
You would ask the question on a forum ( and F with the people that respond) rather than your chain of command?
Yet ..YOU..as an intelligent person, can find no avenue for an operational response other than the anonymous internet...
Liability...your respective operations SOP, or an anonymous internet forum?
If you have questions about "heavy/red radar return", do you expect everyone to know which system you are using?
Aside from that.....
You would ask the question on a forum ( and F with the people that respond) rather than your chain of command?
It should not be too hard for an intelligent person to work out what it is if you know the meaning of each of the individual words :
Liability...your respective operations SOP, or an anonymous internet forum?
Guest
Posts: n/a
Remember just this one thing:
If you get banjoed by lightning, word your ASR defensively.
I wish I had.
Turning the gain down is useful as wx radar nowadays paints too much stuff red.
Think about turning away if its on your FAT. That 10 mins that you lose manoevering will be easy compared to one hour of form filling!
If you get banjoed by lightning, word your ASR defensively.
I wish I had.
Turning the gain down is useful as wx radar nowadays paints too much stuff red.
Think about turning away if its on your FAT. That 10 mins that you lose manoevering will be easy compared to one hour of form filling!
Originally Posted by OBN
You would ask the question on a forum ( and F with the people that respond) rather than your chain of command?
Why not tap into the global knowledge available on Tech Log? If nothing else, some good links have popped up.
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: fort sheridan, il
Posts: 1,656
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
global knowledge...good idea
and no one has said always make sure to be painting something, even if distant ground clutter.
While out flying near Baltimore, Maryland, USA, I heard some American Airlines pilot complaining that her wx radar wasn't working and asked ATC to point her at some weather to make sure it was working right.
yikes.
and no one has said always make sure to be painting something, even if distant ground clutter.
While out flying near Baltimore, Maryland, USA, I heard some American Airlines pilot complaining that her wx radar wasn't working and asked ATC to point her at some weather to make sure it was working right.
yikes.
Psychophysiological entity
A bit of light relief here.
British Eagle (second biggest local carrier after BEA/BA) had a fleet of Viscounts. When a 12" dish was developed, they opted for those. The trouble was they had been the only ones to own the old jig for building a pressurized bulkhead for a raydome. They'd sold it for something like 14k quid. When they got Marshalls ???? to do the work, they cost about that each to do the job. They kind of worked.
When we got the first (all green) digitals, we thought we were in the modern world. Little blocks of square pixels used to flash if the return was too great.
Into the flightdeck comes the head opps bloke. Look at that! I'd say. That little flashing rectangle is Buckingham palace. This one, Westminster. When they flash, it means the Queen's in residence.
British Eagle (second biggest local carrier after BEA/BA) had a fleet of Viscounts. When a 12" dish was developed, they opted for those. The trouble was they had been the only ones to own the old jig for building a pressurized bulkhead for a raydome. They'd sold it for something like 14k quid. When they got Marshalls ???? to do the work, they cost about that each to do the job. They kind of worked.
When we got the first (all green) digitals, we thought we were in the modern world. Little blocks of square pixels used to flash if the return was too great.
Into the flightdeck comes the head opps bloke. Look at that! I'd say. That little flashing rectangle is Buckingham palace. This one, Westminster. When they flash, it means the Queen's in residence.
Per Ardua ad Astraeus
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 18,579
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hopefully maintaining LR's efforts.......
Time to tell again the story of the grumpy Captain who's F/O (un-noticed) wound the scanner angle right down and immediate avoiding action was taken on the island of Jersey
Time to tell again the story of the grumpy Captain who's F/O (un-noticed) wound the scanner angle right down and immediate avoiding action was taken on the island of Jersey