Airbus A320 roll control.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: uk
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Airbus A320 roll control.
New to the Airbus A320 having been on Boeing Jets for years to date! The 'bus' seems like a great a/c in many ways but I am 'interested' in how the experienced A320 drivers out there handle succesfully gusty and strong cross wind approaches and landings!
So far, I have noted that it actually runs out of roll control at times!... ie: even having given the FBW 'zero roll rate' a chance to sort things out and then applying side-stick up to 'full', it still on occasion keeps rolling against these inputs the wrong way!
Not very confidence inspiring near the ground when one is trying to land the beast (scarebus!!??)...
Comments and suggestions please
Thanks muchly!
So far, I have noted that it actually runs out of roll control at times!... ie: even having given the FBW 'zero roll rate' a chance to sort things out and then applying side-stick up to 'full', it still on occasion keeps rolling against these inputs the wrong way!
Not very confidence inspiring near the ground when one is trying to land the beast (scarebus!!??)...
Comments and suggestions please
Thanks muchly!
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Both Emispheres
Posts: 226
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hi,
before others can contribute with "real deal" type of advice, I can indicate you the "official" answer:
http://www.airbus.com/store/mm_repos...LAND-SEQ05.pdf
Sorry if you have this doc already.
before others can contribute with "real deal" type of advice, I can indicate you the "official" answer:
http://www.airbus.com/store/mm_repos...LAND-SEQ05.pdf
Sorry if you have this doc already.
Hi chillpill,
We had a rather long discussion re this subject on PPRuNe earlier this year, on a thread "LH A320 Rough Landing @ Hamburg". You could have a look at it if you're not short of time! Here's a link to one of my own contributions, for what it's worth:
http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/31609...ml#post3979423
We had a rather long discussion re this subject on PPRuNe earlier this year, on a thread "LH A320 Rough Landing @ Hamburg". You could have a look at it if you're not short of time! Here's a link to one of my own contributions, for what it's worth:
http://www.pprune.org/tech-log/31609...ml#post3979423
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Europe
Posts: 99
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Chris Scott,
Chillpill,
Welcome to the bus!!! You`ll love it! I also flew the 737 several years before flying the A320! Just forget the 737! Both airplanes are very good and a joy to fly! But they fly different! Some prefer the boeing way, some the Bus way (like me!)... The A320 is a magnificent plane!
Learn it well and take advantage of it! The table, the quiet cockpit, the simple procedures, the automation, the sidestick, etc...
Read Chris Scott post, it says it all!
I don`t remember of ever reaching the sidestick stop! Remember, if you reach it, you`re not flying it as you should!
Use the force of your fingers to fly the plane, not the force of your arm, or even your wrist, as many people wrongly do!
When you`re moving the sidestick from one side to the other, just let it go for 2 senconds and then start flying it again making only small inputs!
Cheers!
Chillpill,
Welcome to the bus!!! You`ll love it! I also flew the 737 several years before flying the A320! Just forget the 737! Both airplanes are very good and a joy to fly! But they fly different! Some prefer the boeing way, some the Bus way (like me!)... The A320 is a magnificent plane!
Learn it well and take advantage of it! The table, the quiet cockpit, the simple procedures, the automation, the sidestick, etc...
Read Chris Scott post, it says it all!
I don`t remember of ever reaching the sidestick stop! Remember, if you reach it, you`re not flying it as you should!
Use the force of your fingers to fly the plane, not the force of your arm, or even your wrist, as many people wrongly do!
When you`re moving the sidestick from one side to the other, just let it go for 2 senconds and then start flying it again making only small inputs!
Cheers!
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Tropics
Posts: 360
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
PPRuNe supporter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Planet Earth
Posts: 1,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So far, I have noted that it actually runs out of roll control at times!
D.L.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: uk
Posts: 18
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Many thx guys for the links and info. Good reading.
Read all pages of the Hamburg incident... there seems to indeed be a degree of mis-understanding about how the Flight Control Logic works!
I have no probs with the 'nudging the stick' principle... It indeed works a treat. The question arose on a gusty cross wind day, but within a/c limits! after watching the a/c roll left and continue to do so with no apparant correction. So, give it a bit of a nudge, still rolls left, so a bit more and more smooth right sidestick, but STILL rolling left. Finally end up on the stop, with it still rolling left! Finally begins to roll right and then no probs!
I just never experienced this lack of roll control authority on the Boeing, even in much stronger cross winds! I dont think I ever got to full control column deflection... yet there it was on the A320!
So, it does seem that de-crab in the flare is the way to go, instead of at 100 ish feet then wing down. It is just what to do on the way down that has me writing this after the above experience... And again it was not THAT bad a day!!!
Looking fwd to more 'practice'!!!
Read all pages of the Hamburg incident... there seems to indeed be a degree of mis-understanding about how the Flight Control Logic works!
I have no probs with the 'nudging the stick' principle... It indeed works a treat. The question arose on a gusty cross wind day, but within a/c limits! after watching the a/c roll left and continue to do so with no apparant correction. So, give it a bit of a nudge, still rolls left, so a bit more and more smooth right sidestick, but STILL rolling left. Finally end up on the stop, with it still rolling left! Finally begins to roll right and then no probs!
I just never experienced this lack of roll control authority on the Boeing, even in much stronger cross winds! I dont think I ever got to full control column deflection... yet there it was on the A320!
So, it does seem that de-crab in the flare is the way to go, instead of at 100 ish feet then wing down. It is just what to do on the way down that has me writing this after the above experience... And again it was not THAT bad a day!!!
Looking fwd to more 'practice'!!!
Dog Tired
TO MEMO,
"I don`t remember of ever reaching the sidestick stop! Remember, if you reach it, you`re not flying it as you should!"
Rubbish.
Wait until you have sixteen years on the magnificent Airbus.
You CAN run out of lateral authority in extreme conditions and it has nothing to do with your flying technique.
I look forward to reading your apology after your first fright.
"I don`t remember of ever reaching the sidestick stop! Remember, if you reach it, you`re not flying it as you should!"
Rubbish.
Wait until you have sixteen years on the magnificent Airbus.
You CAN run out of lateral authority in extreme conditions and it has nothing to do with your flying technique.
I look forward to reading your apology after your first fright.
PPRuNe supporter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Planet Earth
Posts: 1,677
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Wait until you have sixteen years on the magnificent Airbus.
You CAN run out of lateral authority in extreme conditions and it has nothing to do with your flying technique.
You CAN run out of lateral authority in extreme conditions and it has nothing to do with your flying technique.
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: on the golf course (Covid permitting)
Posts: 2,131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So, it does seem that de-crab in the flare is the way to go, instead of at 100 ish feet then wing down.
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Europe
Posts: 99
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
fantom,
I do respect your opinion... after all 16 years is a lot! I`ll be honest with you, I`m flying the bus for 3 years.
With this I ment that we pilots, should keep this quote in our mental debriefing after each landing. I didn`t mean that pilot flying technique was the fault. If you understood it like that, I do apologize!
I do have fewer hours than you, but with litle over 2000 hours on the 320, I have come to conclusion that 1/3 of stick displacement gave me the same result as full stick, with half the turbulence (ended up realizing that I was creating that turbulence). The 737 was flown quite more agressivelly than the A320. That`s one of the things I love on the plane, I fly it more relaxed than the 37.
But that`s me... 3 years on the plane, not 16... so who nows...
Cheers
I do respect your opinion... after all 16 years is a lot! I`ll be honest with you, I`m flying the bus for 3 years.
You CAN run out of lateral authority in extreme conditions and it has nothing to do with your flying technique.
I look forward to reading your apology after your first fright.
I look forward to reading your apology after your first fright.
I don`t remember of ever reaching the sidestick stop! Remember, if you reach it, you`re not flying it as you should!
I do have fewer hours than you, but with litle over 2000 hours on the 320, I have come to conclusion that 1/3 of stick displacement gave me the same result as full stick, with half the turbulence (ended up realizing that I was creating that turbulence). The 737 was flown quite more agressivelly than the A320. That`s one of the things I love on the plane, I fly it more relaxed than the 37.
But that`s me... 3 years on the plane, not 16... so who nows...
Cheers
Dog Tired
Sorry, that was a bit rude of me.
The normal law (as you know) filters inputs and presents a 'soft' reaction.
In adverse conditions this law can be a little slower to react than you might expect, hence running out of authority. If we always approached in direct law, we would not notice the effect.
Be aware: one day you will get my message and I hope to have forewarned you.
Best wishes,
f.
The normal law (as you know) filters inputs and presents a 'soft' reaction.
In adverse conditions this law can be a little slower to react than you might expect, hence running out of authority. If we always approached in direct law, we would not notice the effect.
Be aware: one day you will get my message and I hope to have forewarned you.
Best wishes,
f.
I'm absolutely puzzled.
A320 is slow to pick up a dropped wing by itself, but with full stick deflection in normal law, it will try to give you 15 deg/sec roll and it will do it without hesitation and with as much aileron and spoiler deflection as needed. So if you have gradually fed stick up to full, with all ELACs, SECs, control surfaces and hyd operative, then your "scarebus" was rolling against full deflection of ailerons and all four roll spoilers in conditions that were not
Spoooooky!
Oh and sideslip is easy to do on A320, as long as you remember to let the stick go. But it's useless above 15kt because you run out of bank, and decrab is a piece of cake, so who needs the sideslip, anyway?
A320 is slow to pick up a dropped wing by itself, but with full stick deflection in normal law, it will try to give you 15 deg/sec roll and it will do it without hesitation and with as much aileron and spoiler deflection as needed. So if you have gradually fed stick up to full, with all ELACs, SECs, control surfaces and hyd operative, then your "scarebus" was rolling against full deflection of ailerons and all four roll spoilers in conditions that were not
THAT bad.
Oh and sideslip is easy to do on A320, as long as you remember to let the stick go. But it's useless above 15kt because you run out of bank, and decrab is a piece of cake, so who needs the sideslip, anyway?
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Both Emispheres
Posts: 226
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Isn't this type of problem worth a detailed entry and a through inspection, including looking at FDR ?
After all, if it an a/c doesn't do what is commanded to, there must be a reason,
Perhaps just new software needed in a/c
These questions obviously come from an enthusiast that appreciates very much this forum competence, kindness and sporadic nostalgia.
EDIT: after some thinking I got the feeling the most likely is that when the airbus does like that all what one has to do is the" right action" as trained by the ones who know and keep flying happily.
You can happily ignore my naive questions !
After all, if it an a/c doesn't do what is commanded to, there must be a reason,
Perhaps just new software needed in a/c
These questions obviously come from an enthusiast that appreciates very much this forum competence, kindness and sporadic nostalgia.
EDIT: after some thinking I got the feeling the most likely is that when the airbus does like that all what one has to do is the" right action" as trained by the ones who know and keep flying happily.
You can happily ignore my naive questions !