VC 10 Pilots, please.
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: wiltshire uk
Age: 62
Posts: 84
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Quite.
And let us not forget that Vickers BAC tried desperately to upgrade the VC10 but met a BOAC brick wall. The SVC10 Super 200 was ready to go- seating 212 pax, with tip and leading edge root fillet tanks added, bigger cabin doors and true LHR - LAX capability.
Then BOAC asked for it to be made smalelr, and it was a 200s eater, adn then smaller still - all for one airline's (BOAC) needs- thus losing any hope of selling to world wide. Which is also what BEA did to the Trident by insisting it was made smaller with weaker engines - thus handing the world market to the 727.
The Super Super VC10 212 had massive commerical appeal adn I have seen the paper work that rpvies that Pan Am adn toerhs looked at it. It had massive payload/range capacity and could have competed/ exceeded the stretched DC-8s and later 707s - except of course for the Conway's thirst.
And Vickers also came up with not just teh swing nose cargo VC!0 proposal, but also a nose -loading VC10 cargo freighter with a raised cockpit upper lobe fuselage- a picture of which is in the book, 'VC10' by Cole- published by The Crowood Press adn with a B Trubshaw forward.
As Trubshaw says, we Brits faield to develope teh VC10.
Most people blame BOAC - whatever the paradox of that airline's superb VC10 marketing campaign..
Ex RAF VC10 reg'd as G-ALXR flew around with an RB211 on tis port side for months as trial -to test the RB 211. Suitably re-engined with x 2 RB 211s, the VC10 could have been the first big twin!
And the thing was as Chris says, over engineered - but that is why it never suffered an airframe related crash -unlike the 707s - remember the Dan- Air cargo 707 and a failed tailplane spar crack...to cite one example.
The VC10 is also the only T tailed airliner never to have suffered a deep stall and subsequent loss. This is becasue the very large, very powerful
tailplane is high and swept back -placed well aft from the wing wake and thus less subject to the T tail dipping into the stalled main wing wake as it is on the Trident or 1-11 for example.
Such was the excellence of Vickers design work - which Fokker copied for the F28/F100 - which has also never deep stalled into a loss.
All this lack of development was such a waste- as with the hovercraft, the Whittle work, the Rover car company, and so much else we failed to develop or market. All at a time when the French were selling Caravelles by teh bucket load to the Americans...
Oh and on the original thread, Trubshaw did the RAF VC10 tanker conversions test flying using XV 141 I think, and once accidently allegedly exceeded the velocity /height envelope -not his fault -. The VC10 went fast- smoothy and serenely you understand.
And let us not forget that Vickers BAC tried desperately to upgrade the VC10 but met a BOAC brick wall. The SVC10 Super 200 was ready to go- seating 212 pax, with tip and leading edge root fillet tanks added, bigger cabin doors and true LHR - LAX capability.
Then BOAC asked for it to be made smalelr, and it was a 200s eater, adn then smaller still - all for one airline's (BOAC) needs- thus losing any hope of selling to world wide. Which is also what BEA did to the Trident by insisting it was made smaller with weaker engines - thus handing the world market to the 727.
The Super Super VC10 212 had massive commerical appeal adn I have seen the paper work that rpvies that Pan Am adn toerhs looked at it. It had massive payload/range capacity and could have competed/ exceeded the stretched DC-8s and later 707s - except of course for the Conway's thirst.
And Vickers also came up with not just teh swing nose cargo VC!0 proposal, but also a nose -loading VC10 cargo freighter with a raised cockpit upper lobe fuselage- a picture of which is in the book, 'VC10' by Cole- published by The Crowood Press adn with a B Trubshaw forward.
As Trubshaw says, we Brits faield to develope teh VC10.
Most people blame BOAC - whatever the paradox of that airline's superb VC10 marketing campaign..
Ex RAF VC10 reg'd as G-ALXR flew around with an RB211 on tis port side for months as trial -to test the RB 211. Suitably re-engined with x 2 RB 211s, the VC10 could have been the first big twin!
And the thing was as Chris says, over engineered - but that is why it never suffered an airframe related crash -unlike the 707s - remember the Dan- Air cargo 707 and a failed tailplane spar crack...to cite one example.
The VC10 is also the only T tailed airliner never to have suffered a deep stall and subsequent loss. This is becasue the very large, very powerful
tailplane is high and swept back -placed well aft from the wing wake and thus less subject to the T tail dipping into the stalled main wing wake as it is on the Trident or 1-11 for example.
Such was the excellence of Vickers design work - which Fokker copied for the F28/F100 - which has also never deep stalled into a loss.
All this lack of development was such a waste- as with the hovercraft, the Whittle work, the Rover car company, and so much else we failed to develop or market. All at a time when the French were selling Caravelles by teh bucket load to the Americans...
Oh and on the original thread, Trubshaw did the RAF VC10 tanker conversions test flying using XV 141 I think, and once accidently allegedly exceeded the velocity /height envelope -not his fault -. The VC10 went fast- smoothy and serenely you understand.
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Location: Location:
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The longest VC10 flight in my logbook is 9h 55m. LHR to Barbados in January 1971.
Aircraft was GASGO ( how's that for a classic reg! ) a super.
Headwind too strong for direct flight so planned tech stop in Bermuda.
Fastest track to BDA was via o/h Gander (and within sight of Greenland enroute).
Made fuel so recleared to Antigua with Barbados as alternate then climbed to 410, made more fuel and recleared again to Barbados with Port-o-Spain.
Not a lot left in the tanks on arrival!
Can anyone beat that ( without in flight splash'n'dash ) ?
Aircraft was GASGO ( how's that for a classic reg! ) a super.
Headwind too strong for direct flight so planned tech stop in Bermuda.
Fastest track to BDA was via o/h Gander (and within sight of Greenland enroute).
Made fuel so recleared to Antigua with Barbados as alternate then climbed to 410, made more fuel and recleared again to Barbados with Port-o-Spain.
Not a lot left in the tanks on arrival!
Can anyone beat that ( without in flight splash'n'dash ) ?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: UK
Posts: 32
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks again
Thanks again to all respondents for their input to my original question in this post. And to all who apologised for 'going off at a tangent' - please don't apologise! That's half the fun, and there were some fascinating insights, information and history from those of you who are really in the know.
Brilliant stuff!
Brilliant stuff!
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: LGW
Posts: 45
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
0100, up early in the morning but had to read all this thread, it's really great general a/c chat, thank you all!
Few trips in RAF pax and tkr VC10s and a few trips "jousting" the basket behind them.
On the ground and in the air it always looked great. The best colour scheme must be the BOAC one though as at Duxford. As a child of the 60/70s I had the airfix model in this colour scheme and it epitomised the romantic era of aviation to me.
Few trips in RAF pax and tkr VC10s and a few trips "jousting" the basket behind them.
On the ground and in the air it always looked great. The best colour scheme must be the BOAC one though as at Duxford. As a child of the 60/70s I had the airfix model in this colour scheme and it epitomised the romantic era of aviation to me.
Warning Toxic!
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hampshire, UK
Posts: 4,011
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It was pretty violently destroyed along with a Swissair Convair and a TWA 707. I very much doubt if there was much salvageable, if anything. Unlike the VC10 destroyed at Amsterdam where the tailplane was recovered and allowed a rotation around the fleet for repairs as cracks were affecting the tailplane screwjacks.
Now someone will say that was totally wrong.
I flew with the Captain of the Jordan one, an absolute gentleman of the old school called Cyril Goulbourn. He described the sheer violence of the hijack and the crew and passengers subsequent travails in the middle of a civil war in Jordan. Fascinating and sobering saga that went on for about 10 days.
So, we lost 2 BOAC VC10s to hijacking. One at Kano, one at Addis. One quite badly bent over the Andes....... I was not involved!
You've got me going now! I was lying in bed on standby one Sunday morning when I was called out for a 'test flight'. So off we went over Anglia in a VC10 just off maintenance. There followed 4 hours of sheer terror. Maximum speed extension of everything, but what really got my goat was stalls....to stick push. Bearing in mind the superstall incidents with BAC 1-11 and Trident were not that far in the past, watching an angle of attack gauge creep up to 15 degrees, then start twitching, then jump to 17 degrees (I gather if it jumped over 17 degrees, you were living dead) with speed below 95 kts on a 4 engine jet, accompanied by stick push and horns and panoramic view of Anglia was not my idea of an enjoyable Sunday morning which was lying in bed with the Mrs (awful woman, she preferred Boeing pilots), the Sunday Times and mug of tea. I was absolutely bloody petrified, and resolved never to continue my short, and very unpopular 'test flying' career. The horror still comes back after over 30 years. In fact I was complaining bitterly afterwards that this was no occupation for a new father who fancied watching his children grow up and under no circumstances was I ever doing that again! Respect to test pilots, but not for me! I'm a coward through and through- which makes me a superb pilot (well Mum thought so anyway).
Now someone will say that was totally wrong.
I flew with the Captain of the Jordan one, an absolute gentleman of the old school called Cyril Goulbourn. He described the sheer violence of the hijack and the crew and passengers subsequent travails in the middle of a civil war in Jordan. Fascinating and sobering saga that went on for about 10 days.
So, we lost 2 BOAC VC10s to hijacking. One at Kano, one at Addis. One quite badly bent over the Andes....... I was not involved!
You've got me going now! I was lying in bed on standby one Sunday morning when I was called out for a 'test flight'. So off we went over Anglia in a VC10 just off maintenance. There followed 4 hours of sheer terror. Maximum speed extension of everything, but what really got my goat was stalls....to stick push. Bearing in mind the superstall incidents with BAC 1-11 and Trident were not that far in the past, watching an angle of attack gauge creep up to 15 degrees, then start twitching, then jump to 17 degrees (I gather if it jumped over 17 degrees, you were living dead) with speed below 95 kts on a 4 engine jet, accompanied by stick push and horns and panoramic view of Anglia was not my idea of an enjoyable Sunday morning which was lying in bed with the Mrs (awful woman, she preferred Boeing pilots), the Sunday Times and mug of tea. I was absolutely bloody petrified, and resolved never to continue my short, and very unpopular 'test flying' career. The horror still comes back after over 30 years. In fact I was complaining bitterly afterwards that this was no occupation for a new father who fancied watching his children grow up and under no circumstances was I ever doing that again! Respect to test pilots, but not for me! I'm a coward through and through- which makes me a superb pilot (well Mum thought so anyway).
Last edited by Rainboe; 7th Sep 2008 at 11:59.
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: 58-33N. 00-18W. Peterborough UK
Posts: 3,040
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dawson's Field.
Memory tells me all four engines were recovered. They were virtually untouched being 'gently' lowered to the ground as the fuselage broke up.
[IMG]
[/IMG]
I very much doubt if there was much salvageable, if anything.
[IMG]
[/IMG]
Warning Toxic!
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hampshire, UK
Posts: 4,011
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Those tail colours cause a stirring in the heart! To think they went to that garish red white and blue 'ice cream van' colour scheme from that lovely gold Speedbird/blue background. Shocking. But that's what the marketing companies charge a fortune for. And do you remember the 'BEA' logo that nobody could read?
[/IMG]
Warning Toxic!
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hampshire, UK
Posts: 4,011
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Remember the 2 feel unit motors in the preflight check and the loud whirring noise they used to make in an otherwise silent flight deck? I could do a fantastic imitation of the loud hum they made after a couple of really deep breaths. It used to cause consternation when the switches were observed off, or when the tone changed as I ran out of puff.
And one of the first things you did when you walked on the flight deck was put the 10 switches (the 'top ten') inside the door on the left hand side on. What were they?
And one of the first things you did when you walked on the flight deck was put the 10 switches (the 'top ten') inside the door on the left hand side on. What were they?
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: 58-33N. 00-18W. Peterborough UK
Posts: 3,040
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
...10 switches (the 'top ten') inside the door on the left hand side on. What were they?
- and BEA at that. Anyway, here's a Boys' Own VC-10 story for after Sunday lunch.http://www.vc10.net/Memories/funandgames.html
PS. One more. I was aboard this one. The only time that Transport Command came close to writing me off - that I know of.
HERE.
Last edited by forget; 7th Sep 2008 at 13:12.
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: North Wiltshire, UK
Age: 78
Posts: 155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Marketing ????
During 1967-8 I distinctly remember BOAC ( or their advertising copywriting minions ) coming up with the phrase "Try a little VC-10 derness" - this when the Viet Nam war was in full swing ....... it must have struck quite a note with our transatlantic cousins.
Warning Toxic!
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hampshire, UK
Posts: 4,011
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
At the height of the Vietnam war in the early 70s, we used to use a route to HKG that took us due east over head Da Nang or Qui Nonh in the centre of the country in the middle of the night. At 37,000', there were no missiles that could get up to us. It seemed remarkable flying with passengers over a Vietnam in full war mode in the dark and seeing it lit up with white flashes from horizon to horizon, and the ring of lights around Da Nang, the giant airbase. Now we fly over all parts of Afghanistan.
Rainboe - I remember those days as well, but then I was a Boeing pilot. Other airlines flew a longer route around Sth. Vietnam if I recall ? but then we used to shove a Union Flag out of the sextant hole - they wouldn't shoot a Brit. - would they ? Ignorance was bliss ! 
Warning Toxic!
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Disgusted of Tunbridge
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Hampshire, UK
Posts: 4,011
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The traditional method on which the British Empire was built was to stick a Union Flag (carefully the right way up) out of the window, if they put you in a cooking pot, then a large number of redcoat would follow some time later and make a new swathe of the world pink on the map. Seemed to work well, but failed a bit in the US for some reason, but I think that was because George III went a bit loopy. Perhaps we'll try again one day when Northern Rock is fixed. God knows we've got enough youf itching to stick it to somebody...usually us.
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 683
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Back Every Afternoon ...
or
Bu**er Everybody About ...
aka Hounslow Flying Club ...
JD
Last edited by Jumbo Driver; 7th Sep 2008 at 22:16.
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Essex
Posts: 579
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"Jo90" mentioned the longest VC10 flight in his logbook. What would be the shortest? Didn't BOAC use VC10s between Aldergrove and Prestwick before dedicating a Viscount to the operation? (Does anyone have a photo of that Viscount in BOAC colours?) Weren't there Birmingham-Manchester flights, too? Was the VC10 ever used for those short hops in the Gulf (Abu Dhabi-Doha or similar)?
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 683
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One particular flight does come to mind here -an unplanned SHJ-DXB (Sharjah-Dubai) sector, which followed an inadvertent landing at SHJ at the end of a very long duty period from LHR to DXB. This had already included a significant delay at (I think) Kuwait, awaiting a weather clearance at their destination further down the Gulf in DXB. If my memory serves me correctly, the skipper was a newly promoted (but not inexperienced) Les Hawkes and I think it may even have been his first trip in command but I'm not sure. I seem to remember they were carrying out a procedural let-down into DXB when they were asked by ATC to extend their outbound leg; when they eventually turned back in, the picture was misleading as both airfields had runways aligned 30 and they mistook SHJ runway for DXB, and landed. However, they soon realised their mistake and, clearly pretty tired by then, adopted the very practical solution of taking off again and flying the short hop across to DXB, just a few miles away.
It seems that Les took the attitude of "least said, soonest mended" and simply annotated the Voyage Report "1 extra landing SHJ", or similar and, after slipping in DXB, continued with his crew on his planned trip. Normally, this type of event would have required self-suspension of himself and his crew pending approval (or otherwise) from London to continue. Instead, it seems the news only came to light when a bill for the landing fee at SHJ was presented back at Base some time after the event. By then, it was far too late to suspend the offenders and I don't think any disciplinary action ensued. Those were the days when a practical attitude often prevailed, especially if "initiative" had been used.
JD
Just another number
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: UK
Age: 76
Posts: 1,077
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I believe that the shortest scheduled service was Bahrain to Dhahran. The two airfields were 25 miles apart with the runways more or less in line. The shortest flight in my logbook is 22 minutes chock to chock with 8 minutes airborne (we just managed to get the flaps up) (19/08/71, G-ARVK).
Dave
Dave