When do we do Improved Climb!!
Guest
Posts: n/a
Hi Mutt
I follow you now, as a Boeing driver (and not a perf engineer) I am not used to calculating speeds from tables like that. Our company 737 data has either normal speeds or the full blown max capability improved climb, with the associated huge increase in runway speeds - even if you only need an extra ton. A sledgehammer for a walnut maybe, but very easy to use. Your Airbus tables seem like a nightmare at first glance, but at least you only have to increase your runway speeds by the amount needed to meet your actual TOW, which must be safer.
John_t
I know Hudson well and have great respect for his experience, but I am sure that flap 25 is definitely for landing only. It may have been finger trouble or maybe he knows something else I don’t know ;-)
S & L
I follow you now, as a Boeing driver (and not a perf engineer) I am not used to calculating speeds from tables like that. Our company 737 data has either normal speeds or the full blown max capability improved climb, with the associated huge increase in runway speeds - even if you only need an extra ton. A sledgehammer for a walnut maybe, but very easy to use. Your Airbus tables seem like a nightmare at first glance, but at least you only have to increase your runway speeds by the amount needed to meet your actual TOW, which must be safer.
John_t
I know Hudson well and have great respect for his experience, but I am sure that flap 25 is definitely for landing only. It may have been finger trouble or maybe he knows something else I don’t know ;-)
S & L
Fleet Manager

Joined: Apr 2001
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 7,447
Likes: 310
From: various places .....
CaptainSandL,
Then we probably know each other as well - Hudson and I go back nearly 30 years.
Using the -200 as Hudson quoted,
takeoff 1/2/5/10/15/25
landing 15/30/40
Then we probably know each other as well - Hudson and I go back nearly 30 years.
Using the -200 as Hudson quoted,
takeoff 1/2/5/10/15/25
landing 15/30/40
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 22
Likes: 0
From: Some Chilly Location
Figaretto,
I believe your idea of using the normal Vr and climbing out at the improved V2 doesn't hold up:
1. Imagine an engine failure at Vr - no room to accelerate here to achieve your 1 ENG INOP best angle speed (v2). You've just defeated the purpose of your augmented speeds.
2. I believe FAR 25 specifies V2 as equal or less than 1.2 Vr. Correct me please if I'm wrong. Don't have my perf books in front of me now.
Cheers,
AO
I believe your idea of using the normal Vr and climbing out at the improved V2 doesn't hold up:
1. Imagine an engine failure at Vr - no room to accelerate here to achieve your 1 ENG INOP best angle speed (v2). You've just defeated the purpose of your augmented speeds.
2. I believe FAR 25 specifies V2 as equal or less than 1.2 Vr. Correct me please if I'm wrong. Don't have my perf books in front of me now.
Cheers,
AO




