Something or nothing. ?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2023
Location: Lancashire
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Something or nothing. ?
frequent flier and occasional pprune visitor - please move if I haven’t posted in the right place
Flew HER to MAN yesterday with Jet2 - LS3906
Myself and fellow pax noticed something unusual on take off yesterday
tried to post screenshot from my Flightradar24
at 1,775 ft we reached -3,200 fpm
just wondering if this was ‘normal’ ?
Flew HER to MAN yesterday with Jet2 - LS3906
Myself and fellow pax noticed something unusual on take off yesterday
tried to post screenshot from my Flightradar24
at 1,775 ft we reached -3,200 fpm
just wondering if this was ‘normal’ ?
frequent flier and occasional pprune visitor - please move if I haven’t posted in the right place
Flew HER to MAN yesterday with Jet2 - LS3906
Myself and fellow pax noticed something unusual on take off yesterday
tried to post screenshot from my Flightradar24
at 1,775 ft we reached -3,200 fpm
just wondering if this was ‘normal’ ?
Flew HER to MAN yesterday with Jet2 - LS3906
Myself and fellow pax noticed something unusual on take off yesterday
tried to post screenshot from my Flightradar24
at 1,775 ft we reached -3,200 fpm
just wondering if this was ‘normal’ ?
Apparently the aircraft reached 1,775' and then descended at a rate of 3,200 fpm, for about 30seconds.
My maths says that would be uncomfortably low. As the airport is only at about 100' elevation, that really would be too close for comfort.
My maths says that would be uncomfortably low. As the airport is only at about 100' elevation, that really would be too close for comfort.
There is a series of plots that appear to show the climb interrupted by a descent from 2075' to 1600' (both uncorrected for QNH) over 15 seconds, before a positive ROC was re-established.
Within that, there are two consecutive points, 3 seconds apart, showing a drop in height of 150', which is presumably where the calculated 3000 fpm comes from, until one remembers that the height readouts are all ± 25' and the timestamps ± ½ sec.
Certainly something happened, but I'd be surprised if brown trousers resulted on this occasion.
With the caveat of this being uncorroborated altitude data, something like this could be a TCAS RA, (unlikely, so close to take-off) or dipping under birds. I have done the latter twice on take-off, although, I didn't descend, I just levelled out to fly under the crossing birds, and resumed climb once they had passed.
I did have to increase descent rate to stay clear of a banner towing aircraft that had no transponder and ATC did not know about, that I saw crossing our path on initial approach to Alicante once.
I did have to increase descent rate to stay clear of a banner towing aircraft that had no transponder and ATC did not know about, that I saw crossing our path on initial approach to Alicante once.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2023
Location: Lancashire
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thank you for the replies
I had my headphones on as I always do on take off. But was aware of vibrations/descending so took them off immediately.
my partner described being aware of loosing height and hearing something mechanical with a slight dip to the right.
it was when we landed I corroborated with FR24
I had my headphones on as I always do on take off. But was aware of vibrations/descending so took them off immediately.
my partner described being aware of loosing height and hearing something mechanical with a slight dip to the right.
it was when we landed I corroborated with FR24
Why do you have your headphones on during take off?
Are we not supposed to have all electrinic devices turned off for take off and landing.
If there's an emergency you are supposed to be able to hear any announcements by the crew.
Sorry, minor rant.
Are we not supposed to have all electrinic devices turned off for take off and landing.
If there's an emergency you are supposed to be able to hear any announcements by the crew.
Sorry, minor rant.
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Brentwood, Essex
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Seems to be the younger folks!
Sorry for the thread drift.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2023
Location: Lancashire
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
FYI of course I watched the safety briefing.
I put them in when it finishes because I’m scared of take off, I’m still very aware and alert. Hence noticing what happened
don’t tarnish people with the same brush. My flight were majority oap’s and many of them weren’t paying attention to the safety briefing.
I put them in when it finishes because I’m scared of take off, I’m still very aware and alert. Hence noticing what happened
don’t tarnish people with the same brush. My flight were majority oap’s and many of them weren’t paying attention to the safety briefing.
