Using scanner at US airports
Thread Starter
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 87
Likes: 0
From: Liverpool
Using scanner at US airports
Hello
I am going to New York (JFK) in October but I have been a bit concerned about taking my scanner there in the light of the current security climate (I fear-and my parents fear that I could have my equipment confiscated!). I am just asking what the tolarence is like to airband listeners at JFK and other US airports in general as I would like to here what ATC comms are like in New York as it is a very busy aviation hub but on the other hand I would not like to face legal and other consequences. Anyone any advice on what I should do?
Luke
I am going to New York (JFK) in October but I have been a bit concerned about taking my scanner there in the light of the current security climate (I fear-and my parents fear that I could have my equipment confiscated!). I am just asking what the tolarence is like to airband listeners at JFK and other US airports in general as I would like to here what ATC comms are like in New York as it is a very busy aviation hub but on the other hand I would not like to face legal and other consequences. Anyone any advice on what I should do?
Luke
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 2,335
Likes: 0
From: Wet Coast
Use of scanners in the US is governed by Federal, individual State and in some cases City ordinances. New York State has one of the most restrictive laws (section 397) which, although intended to prevent listening to police frequencies, effectively makes it an offence to simply posess a scanner.
The airports and environs are under the jurisdiction of the Port Authority Police (not NYPD) who are not well-disposed to spotters. Confiscation is probably the least of your concerns, being detained for some considerable time or even in jail is not entirely far-fetched.
Leave the scanner at home, you probably wouldn't understand the controllers' accents anyway
The airports and environs are under the jurisdiction of the Port Authority Police (not NYPD) who are not well-disposed to spotters. Confiscation is probably the least of your concerns, being detained for some considerable time or even in jail is not entirely far-fetched.
Leave the scanner at home, you probably wouldn't understand the controllers' accents anyway
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
From: The Sand
Gatvol
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 4,197
Likes: 1
From: KLAS/TIST/FAJS/KFAI
On the other hand as a Pilot I always carry my scanner and transeiver with me along with any other equipment I dont want to show up at the flea market or some baggage handlers house. I have yet to have a problem. You can go to the website www.tsa.gov and search for prohibited items.
I would agree that walking around a terminal with one in hand will no doubt draw attention. Its only because of the paranoia that exists after the U.S has so terribly failed on keeping the wrong folks out of the country.
Possesion of a scanner as far as I know is not illegal. New York is a place to avoid anyway. If NYPD will not allow you to listen to their frequencies its probably because they dont want you to hear what they are not doing. Too many employees costing too much money. Dont think your safer because of them.
If you think you will have a problem, put it in your checked baggage or better yet leave it home..
I would agree that walking around a terminal with one in hand will no doubt draw attention. Its only because of the paranoia that exists after the U.S has so terribly failed on keeping the wrong folks out of the country.
Possesion of a scanner as far as I know is not illegal. New York is a place to avoid anyway. If NYPD will not allow you to listen to their frequencies its probably because they dont want you to hear what they are not doing. Too many employees costing too much money. Dont think your safer because of them.
If you think you will have a problem, put it in your checked baggage or better yet leave it home..
Joined: Feb 2000
Aviation Qualifications: SLF
Posts: 2,222
Likes: 60
From: Anderlecht
My advise would be not to use it openly in public view because, as mentioned above, of public paranoia. You can use it discreetly inside your (hire)car and in your hotel. Listening to ATC and pilots in the USA is something almost completely alien to what we are acustomed to over here, but great fun I find.
Gatvol
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 4,197
Likes: 1
From: KLAS/TIST/FAJS/KFAI
"Listening to ATC and pilots in the USA is something almost completely alien to what we are acustomed to over here, but great fun I find."
Im not going to dispute Paper Tiger, but I cannot believe that listening to Police Frequencies is illegal. The only reason I question this is because New York is such a weird place and nothing there would surprise me. Guns are illegal in new York city so you know who the only people there who have them. Scanning is done everywhere in the states and one can purchase a scanner at any Radio Shack store for a few dollars. I do know that transmitting on certain frequencies is illegal without the proper FCC license. I thnk that information can be obtained via www.fcc.gov
I hope Paper Tiger will come back with a website to prove the point, again anything in NY is possible.
Im not going to dispute Paper Tiger, but I cannot believe that listening to Police Frequencies is illegal. The only reason I question this is because New York is such a weird place and nothing there would surprise me. Guns are illegal in new York city so you know who the only people there who have them. Scanning is done everywhere in the states and one can purchase a scanner at any Radio Shack store for a few dollars. I do know that transmitting on certain frequencies is illegal without the proper FCC license. I thnk that information can be obtained via www.fcc.gov
I hope Paper Tiger will come back with a website to prove the point, again anything in NY is possible.
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 2,335
Likes: 0
From: Wet Coast
Gatvol
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 4,197
Likes: 1
From: KLAS/TIST/FAJS/KFAI
Thanks PT, As I said Nothing surprises me in New York and I certainly dont feel any safer with them "Serving and Protecting"
Based on my past experiences they only serve and protect themselves.
I preface that with 27 years of Law Enforcement work.
Based on my past experiences they only serve and protect themselves.
I preface that with 27 years of Law Enforcement work.
Joined: Aug 2005
Aviation Qualifications: PPL
Posts: 220
Likes: 8
From: Toronto
Scanners in the USA
http://www.ncsl.org/programs/transportation/radar.htm
Has a write-up of these laws. As a licenced radio amateur from Canada, I am asked if the radios I have in the car are scanners every time I go through customs into New York State. A couple of years ago I was asked this getting off the ferry in Bar Harbor, ME.
It really is illegal under some state laws, and cops sometimes try to confiscate equipment from amateur radio operators, who are exempt from the state laws because the Federal laws under which they are licenced supercede them.
Best advice is leave the scanner at home.
Has a write-up of these laws. As a licenced radio amateur from Canada, I am asked if the radios I have in the car are scanners every time I go through customs into New York State. A couple of years ago I was asked this getting off the ferry in Bar Harbor, ME.
It really is illegal under some state laws, and cops sometimes try to confiscate equipment from amateur radio operators, who are exempt from the state laws because the Federal laws under which they are licenced supercede them.
Best advice is leave the scanner at home.
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 8,571
Likes: 3
From: Arizona USA
It is not illegal to monitor any public service frequency anywhere in the USA because the US FEDERAL government says so, in codified federal regulations.
You CANNOT however disclose the contents of same, nor can you rebroadcast to others.
Some states do indeed try to confiscate scanners and/or amateur radio equipment installed in automobiles, however, in each and every one of these cases, where contested in Federal court, the Federal regulations have prevailed, and the equipment needed to be returned to the owner.
Excepted are cases where illegal activity of a criminal nature occured.
So, if you have the bucks required, you indeed can win and retain your equipment, and possibly litigate for just compensation.
OTOH, if you want to avoid problems altogether, just keep it out of sight.
You CANNOT however disclose the contents of same, nor can you rebroadcast to others.
Some states do indeed try to confiscate scanners and/or amateur radio equipment installed in automobiles, however, in each and every one of these cases, where contested in Federal court, the Federal regulations have prevailed, and the equipment needed to be returned to the owner.
Excepted are cases where illegal activity of a criminal nature occured.
So, if you have the bucks required, you indeed can win and retain your equipment, and possibly litigate for just compensation.
OTOH, if you want to avoid problems altogether, just keep it out of sight.
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
From: About 1 mile from WOD ndb
I travel to the US a great deal and always have an amateur transceiver with me (particularly in California where it's considered polite to be equipped for emergency communications).
After being questioned once, I now carry a copy of my UK Amateur Radio licence which is valid in the US under the CEPT T/R 61-01 reciprocal agreement.
After being questioned once, I now carry a copy of my UK Amateur Radio licence which is valid in the US under the CEPT T/R 61-01 reciprocal agreement.
The Cooler King
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,717
Likes: 30
From: Europe
I bring my scanner into the US all the time. It always travels in my flight bag which I take on board with me.
I have had my bag searched a couple of times but the David Clarks and the flight computer usually get more attention than the scanner.
I use an earpiece with the scanner if I have a long wait at the gate. I love listening to RT in the US - the relaxed atmosphere might grate on some pilots but I love some of the comments that get thrown back and forth.
One poor F/O's mother got slated in KORD one afternoon!
I have had my bag searched a couple of times but the David Clarks and the flight computer usually get more attention than the scanner.
I use an earpiece with the scanner if I have a long wait at the gate. I love listening to RT in the US - the relaxed atmosphere might grate on some pilots but I love some of the comments that get thrown back and forth.
One poor F/O's mother got slated in KORD one afternoon!
