PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Space Flight and Operations (https://www.pprune.org/space-flight-operations-58/)
-   -   SpaceX flight testing in South Texas (https://www.pprune.org/space-flight-operations/637604-spacex-flight-testing-south-texas.html)

tdracer 15th Sep 2023 17:36

I can't help but wonder how long it would have taken to develop the Atlas back in the late 1950's-early 1960's if the FAA had been in charge. Those things blew up on a regular basis, yet they continued to launch them as part of the development process to sort out all the issues.
Even when the Atlas was 'man-rated' for Mercury-Atlas orbital flights, it's failure rate was close to 1/3rd...

ORAC 16th Sep 2023 05:58

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....6141601e5.jpeg

HOVIS 19th Sep 2023 15:30

Could be a long delay. January next year perhaps.

https://wccftech.com/spacexs-starshi...case-scenario/

ORAC 21st Sep 2023 07:53

Musk getting pissed off. Not sure what NASA thinks…

US Fish and Wildlife officials have yet to begin a formal review of SpaceX’s upgrades following Starship’s first launch in April. This could push back the next launch window by months, which I know none of us want to hear.

The agency still needs to review SpaceX’s plans to operate a water deluge system during the next launch of its Starship rocket — this process could take anywhere from 30 to 135 days, the FWS said in an email to Bloomberg News on Monday.

However, that review process has yet to formally begin, the FWS said, which could further delay SpaceX’s plans to launch Starship on its second test flight from South Texas.

The US Federal Aviation Administration cannot give SpaceX a new launch license until the consultation with the FWS is complete, the FWS added….

Elon Musk:

That is unacceptable.

It is absurd that SpaceX can build a giant rocket faster than they can shuffle paperwork!
​​​​​​​

robocoder 21st Sep 2023 11:06

Pretty sure calling their work useless paperwork will speed up things.

tdracer 22nd Sep 2023 18:19

The scariest words in the English language:
"I'm from the government and I'm here to help you".

ORAC 26th Sep 2023 08:28

https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....f36be3308.jpeg

https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....9046f6a08.jpeg


ORAC 18th Oct 2023 14:38

In a remarkably frank discussion this week, several senior SpaceX officials spoke with Ars Technica on background about how working with the Federal Aviation Administration has slowed down the company's progress.

https://arstechnica.com/space/2023/1...censing-staff/

Citing slow Starship reviews, SpaceX urges FAA to double licensing staff

ORAC 18th Oct 2023 14:46

As the consultation with FAA and US Fish and Wildlife over the Starship mishap will likely push into November, further delaying a second launch attempt, SpaceX is calling on Congress to push FAA to issue launch licenses faster - The Washington Post

​​​​​​​

tdracer 18th Oct 2023 19:28


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11523360)
In a remarkably frank discussion this week, several senior SpaceX officials spoke with Ars Technica on background about how working with the Federal Aviation Administration has slowed down the company's progress.

https://arstechnica.com/space/2023/1...censing-staff/

Citing slow Starship reviews, SpaceX urges FAA to double licensing staff

If the FAA had been overseeing NASA in the 1960's, we wouldn't have landed on the moon for another 20 years...

Less Hair 18th Oct 2023 19:31

Let the FAA do its job. No industry fast track for billionaires please.

IFMU 19th Oct 2023 03:54


Originally Posted by Less Hair (Post 11523474)
Let the FAA do its job. No industry fast track for billionaires please.

But is it only for a billionaire? I have hopes to see progress in space travel, so limiting bureaucracy is a benefit to me. I suspect I'm not the only one.

The FAA didn't help us get to the moon in '69.

what next 19th Oct 2023 13:18


Originally Posted by IFMU (Post 11523619)
I have hopes to see progress in space travel, so limiting bureaucracy is a benefit to me.

We are not going to see any space travel soon if a major accident happens during testing of these rockets. A fueled Superheavy/Starship rocket has the destructive power of a small nuclear bomb. On the first launch attempt, the rocket was completely out of control, staging didn't work and the safety systems not as expected. I wouldn't want to live any closer than 1000 miles from Boca Chica when they try it again, unless the FAA and the other supervising authorities work as good as they can. If it takes a little longer, then be it so. An accident will cause much bigger delays or even an end of the entire program.

ORAC 19th Oct 2023 22:09

SpaceX is cleaning up the concrete debris from the inaugural Starship launch! Personnel from the Fish & Wildlife Service and Texas Parks have been spotted onsite, likely overseeing the process.


tdracer 20th Oct 2023 19:09


Originally Posted by Less Hair (Post 11523474)
Let the FAA do its job. No industry fast track for billionaires please.

SpaceX has advanced the start of the art in the launching payloads into space more in the last 10 years than NASA has in the last 50 years. And that did that with precious little government funding.
They didn't do that because they had the FAA looking over their shoulder and second guessing everything they did.
Sometimes you need to turn the innovators loose to do their thing.

ORAC 21st Oct 2023 15:25

​​​​​​​Single engine static fire demonstrating flight-like startup for a Starship deorbit burn

HOVIS 21st Oct 2023 16:33


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11524104)
SpaceX is cleaning up the concrete debris from the inaugural Starship launch! Personnel from the Fish & Wildlife Service and Texas Parks have been spotted onsite, likely overseeing the process.

About time. This is the real reason for the delay. SpaceX were allowed to build a launch complex in the middle of a wildlife sanctuary, they made a right mess of that when the launch pad got blasted to bits and threw debris for literally miles! It's been months and there has been no attempt to clear it up. None! Did NASA ever create a similar mess at The Cape in the 60s?
Blaming the FAA is a straw man, SpaceX has only itself to blame.

tdracer 21st Oct 2023 22:40


Originally Posted by HOVIS (Post 11525340)
About time. This is the real reason for the delay. SpaceX were allowed to build a launch complex in the middle of a wildlife sanctuary, they made a right mess of that when the launch pad got blasted to bits and threw debris for literally miles! It's been months and there has been no attempt to clear it up. None! Did NASA ever create a similar mess at The Cape in the 60s?
Blaming the FAA is a straw man, SpaceX has only itself to blame.

Are you sure?
I wonder how long it took SpaceX to get Parks and Wildlife approval for their cleanup plan, and to arrange for the government required observers of their process?
Because I'd bet big money that it wasn't a quick or easy process to do that, and SpaceX doesn't have a reputation for procrastination.

ORAC 22nd Oct 2023 17:35

Starship: Catch & release - Though not planned for the first few launches, with the help of @LunarCaveman, I have put together this infographic explaining how SpaceX plans to catch the biggest operational rocket in history on future missions.

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....1b3cf90e6.jpeg
​​​​​​​

ORAC 22nd Oct 2023 22:52

​​​​​​​The Flame Deflector test from earlier today was pretty intense compared to past tests. Such a massive amount of water being ejected in less than a 60 seconds.

This change is result of an additional 82,000 gallons of capacity that was added recently. Along with this, the high pressure gas system now has nearly double the capacity since the last time this system was tested.

Can't wait for launch day, when ever that is!

ORAC 26th Oct 2023 06:24

A marine notice has been posted for November 6th for rocket launching operations near Boca Chica Beach!

This does NOT mean a launch license has been granted but is a good sign one could be granted very soon!

(I think we could get a launch license announcement today or tomorrow, just my opinion though)

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....e68b5fd5a.jpeg

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....ad3f888ffe.png
​​​​​​​

Tango and Cash 26th Oct 2023 12:58


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11525801)
Starship: Catch & release - Though not planned for the first few launches, with the help of @LunarCaveman, I have put together this infographic explaining how SpaceX plans to catch the biggest operational rocket in history on future missions.


ORAC, quite an interesting graphic and complex sequence of events. I know Musk and SpaceX are fans of 'try it, see what happens, and learn from the wreckage' but this seems like many opportunities for things to end in tears. Eventually it may all seem routine just like bringing Falcon 9 boosters back. The first few attempts, though, were rather spectacular failures. Not a big deal to lose a booster and scorch a landing pad. It seems that a failure to catch a Starship booster could result in a much bigger spectactular failure and take out not just the booster, but also the launch/landing structure. That would be a rather big setback for future missions...

I trust that SpaceX has smart people who know what they're doing...
​​​​​​​

ORAC 1st Nov 2023 06:56

​​​​​​​The FAA has completed the safety review portion of Starship-Super Heavy today.

Main outstanding item is now the consultation with FWS, and the environmental section of the review.

tdracer 2nd Nov 2023 02:08

FAA completes safety review for next Starship launch - SpaceNews

The FAA is continuing to work on an environmental review, including consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) regarding any environmental effects of a new water deluge system installed on the Starship launch pad at Boca Chica, Texas.

FWS, in an Oct. 26 statement, said it had formally reinitiated an Endangered Species Act consultation with the FAA about modifications to the pad on Oct. 19. “We have up to 135 days to issue an amended biological opinion but do not expect to take the full amount of time,” FWS stated, but did not offer a more precise estimate of the time needed to complete the review.

“When it comes to projects of national interest, such as the Artemis program, Congress should establish a regulatory regime consistent with the national program’s objectives and schedules,” he said. Agencies supporting the FAA licensing process, “like those with environmental responsibilities, should also be required to complete their work consistent with the national program schedules.”
135 days - if calendar days that's 4 1/2 months - if it's "work" days, it's over six months. :ugh:

ORAC 3rd Nov 2023 20:01

The second flight test of a fully integrated Starship could launch as soon as mid-November, pending regulatory approval →

https://www.spacex.com/launches/miss...rship-flight-2
​​​​​​​

ORAC 6th Nov 2023 20:39

Closures for November 13th through the 15th have just been posted. This is likely for the 2nd Starship Integrated Flight Test!

Time to get excited!

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....60b856dd6f.png
​​​​​​​

ORAC 7th Nov 2023 19:28

This weekend is bringing a front of bad weather extending into next week. If the government isn't causing delays mother nature will always pick up the slack.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d05a6efc76.png
​​​​​​​

ORAC 8th Nov 2023 13:17

A NOTAM has been posted for Mexican airspace for the next launch of SpaceX's Starship rocket. The notice is valid from November 13th to 18th with daily windows running from 7AM CST to 9:39AM CST (13:00-15:39 UTC).

And now a Navigational Hazard Warning has been posted as well for the Gulf of Mexico. Same daily windows from November 13th to November 18th running from 7AM CST to 9:39AM CST.

And hold up, another one just came in also for the Starship reentry over the Pacific Ocean near Hawaii. So that's the launch and reentry of Starship now covered.



https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....6a4670fb6a.png
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....3f1c63ccdf.png

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....96be97a26.jpeg

ORAC 9th Nov 2023 06:35

Weather related - wind and rain expected to last until 16th.

NOTAM now indicating NET November 15 for IFT2 launch, of course, pending approval. As if it's not already....


ORAC 9th Nov 2023 21:56

One of the last actions performed before flight….


Videos…

Booster 9 Flight Termination System (FTS) install - the explosives that will destroy the vehicle in case of anomaly.

An improved system from Booster 7 after its FTS trigger resulted in a "It's just a flesh wound!" reaction during the first test flight.

HOVIS 9th Nov 2023 23:32

Ah, now then. The FTS is only good for a finite period so they must be confident.
I also spotted something the other day that indicated a 3rd launch on 1st of December.
Assuming the environmental cleanup and regulatory approval gets done quickly.
Fingers crossed.

ORAC 10th Nov 2023 14:26

Ahead of Flight 2, Jack Beyer (@thejackbeyer) has a detailed guide to Starship's pre-fueling activities, the pre-launch sequence, and the propellant load nuances. Plus, an overview of the trajectory timelines for Booster 9 and Ship 25.

​​​​​​​

IFMU 11th Nov 2023 02:09


ORAC 11th Nov 2023 05:33

The second flight test of a fully integrated Starship could launch as soon as early as Friday, November 17, pending final regulatory approval.

A live webcast of the flight test will begin about 30 minutes before liftoff, which you can watch here and on X @SpaceX. As is the case with all developmental testing, the schedule is dynamic and likely to change, so be sure to stay tuned to our X account for updates.

ORAC 14th Nov 2023 06:01

Elon Musk:

​​​​​​​Was just informed that approval to launch should happen in time for a Friday launch.

ORAC 15th Nov 2023 21:48

Targeting Friday, November 17 for Starship’s second flight test. A two-hour launch window opens at 7:00 a.m. CT → http://spacex.com/launches

[1300 UTC ]

​​​​​US Fish and Wildlife Service gave the go for launch. FAA license approval still pending but likely.

tdracer 15th Nov 2023 23:41


Originally Posted by ORAC (Post 11540052)
FAA license approval still pending but likely.

FAA approval reportedly granted,

HOVIS 16th Nov 2023 01:06

We are GO for launch.
Consider me excited by the way.

ETOPS 16th Nov 2023 12:41

Launch window is from 13.00 GMT for 2 hours. Friday 17th Nov

ORAC 16th Nov 2023 14:29

https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....768fe324cd.png


All times are GMT. The time now is 08:44.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.