PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Air Uganda, crew forgot to set flaps? (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/494098-air-uganda-crew-forgot-set-flaps.html)

Skypilot 29th August 2012 08:13

Slightly off-topic, but this seems as good a time and place as any to ask a question that I've wondered about for a while. On take off in an MD-8x series aircraft, there seems to be a point after the engines have spooled up when the engine note suddenly changes - it's audible 42s into this video. What is it that's going on that causes this to happen?

framer 29th August 2012 10:08

I pretty much agree with you fox niner but I can imagine some countries ( I'm thinking Asia and Africa ) where the actual culture of the country would mean that pilot didn't even know they were in a rubbish airline. They get good grades at school or more likely have the right surname, and then get into a national carrier that is corrupt and recurrent simulator sessions are a complete sham. But I agree in most cases, there is no excuse for not setting flap. especially if you are the Captain and therefore managing the tempo and priorities of the flight.

blind pew 29th August 2012 10:12

Sky pilot
If I remember correctly the air con switches off and doesn't come back on to above 500ft?
Take off performance up to and including 2nd segment in the event of an engine failure.

de facto 29th August 2012 10:32


I pretty much agree with you fox niner but I can imagine some countries ( I'm thinking Asia and Africa ) where the actual culture of the country would mean that pilot didn't even know they were in a rubbish airline.
How condescendent towards other countries pilots..do you listen to yourself when you say such junk?:yuk:

DX Wombat 29th August 2012 10:53


The SLF just care about cheap tix
Hetfield, I find that a most offensive remark. I am much more concerned with safety than the cost of my ticket which is why I prefer to save up, pay a little more and fly only with reputable airlines with a good safety record not those with a dodgy reputation but tickets which cost a mere handful of beans. Your attitude towards the people who effectively keep you employed is disgraceful and whether or not you intended it to do so, reflects badly on the airline which employs you. :*

hamil 29th August 2012 11:00


... a 727, Delta, in DFW, that didn't lower flaps on takeoff ...
At least 2 DC-9/MD-80 series crashed because of it ... NWA in Detroit and Spanair in Madrid ... by the way, in both cases the TO warning system didn't work.

framer 29th August 2012 12:04

Defecto , I don't think it's junk, that's why I say it :)
I'm not sure why you or anyone would be offended by it, it's just life, some countries ( and therefore some airlines) have major problems with corruption and safety is one of the first casualties. I mentioned Asia and Africa because I have lived in both those places while flying. Why does it upset you that I mentioned it? Anyway, don't get too worried, it was just an opinion, have a fun day , Framer

hetfield 29th August 2012 12:35

@DX WOMBAT

Offensive? Maybe....

Couple years ago there was one of these candid camera shows on tv. They had a 737 (GERMANIA) with no seats (maintenance event, btw) instead on the ceiling a pair of handrails was installed, like in a bus.

They offered a refund of 25 Euros to do the two hour trip. Out of about 100 pax only 5 denied.

Lonewolf_50 29th August 2012 13:06


At least 2 DC-9/MD-80 series crashed because of it ... NWA in Detroit and Spanair in Madrid ... by the way, in both cases the TO warning system didn't work.
hamil:

Whilst I appreciate why that system is in place, I find it hard to excuse professional pilots not properly performing checklists in multi crew aircraft. I am glad to see that whatever alerted the crew in the case under discussion go them to lower the flaps, but the part that gets me is: did these gents actually complete the take off checklist before beginning take off roll?

If not, there is an issue that needs to be addressed here.

Cockpit discipline.

KingChango 29th August 2012 13:15

that tone chance around 42 seconds heard in this video is when the autothrottle switch is engaged.

in this video you can break down the throttle sequence in pieces.
from when the video starts, the throttle position is in IDLE.

then at the first chance of pitch, the pf moves the throttles from IDLE to Flight idle to get the initial spool up.

there after he slowly starts to increase throttle position to get to EPR 40% (where you stabelize engines and turn on autothrottle), but here in this range he received the Takeoff warning stating: FLAPS. letting you know that your flaps/slats are not in the correct position. they quickly put the flaps, noticing the CAWS (Central Aural Warning System) went silent; takeoff config is good, and then proceeded with autothrottle to takeoff power.

from what i see in this video, that the crew that day did miss several boeing recommendations. on taxi out, they were supposed to set flaps. in the taxi out checklist they should confirm flaps by doing a takeoff config test, and the before take off checklist as well with a visual gauge check.
they probably didn't do ANY checklist on this particular flight.
Atleast not an "post-spanair crash md80 checklist".:ugh:

c46r 29th August 2012 13:38

A normal flaps 5 t/o from Embakasi

PhilW1981 29th August 2012 17:22


At least 2 DC-9/MD-80 series crashed because of it ... NWA in Detroit and Spanair in Madrid ... by the way, in both cases the TO warning system didn't work
If I recall, in the case of NWA at Detroit the TO config warning did sound, but this still didn't trigger the crew to the non deployment of F&S.

Sunnyjohn 29th August 2012 21:16

This is incorrect.
From Wiki:


The NTSB probable cause statement is as follows: "The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of the accident was the flightcrew's failure to use the taxi checklist to ensure the flaps and slats were extended for takeoff. Contributing to the accident was the absence of electrical power to the airplane takeoff warning system which thus did not warn the flightcrew that the airplane was not configured properly for takeoff. The reason for the absence of electrical power could not be determined."

Mr.Bloggs 29th August 2012 21:58

BS
 
Nice ones, framer and Hetfield. Two truthful statements attracting impassioned politically-correct nonsense responses. The world has many people who cannot bear to hear the truth if it is remotely uncomfortable to them. (My airline management contains such individuals, who live in a fantasy world exemplified by the Emperor's New Clothes.

hamil 30th August 2012 13:45


If I recall, in the case of NWA at Detroit the TO config warning did sound, but this still didn't trigger the crew to the non deployment of F&S.
Sorry, Phil, but the final report says that the CAWS - takeoff configuration warning mode was inop and, therefore, it did not inform the crew that the airplane was not properly configured for departure.

However, I suppose in NBO it saved the day ... fortunately.

SeenItAll 30th August 2012 16:16

Flaps overrated?
 
Not relevant to current passenger jets, but if you read the book "Thirty Seconds over Tokyo" by Ted Lawson (who was a pilot on the Doolittle raid of WWII) he forgot to set the flaps of his B-25 while taking off from the Hornet. Only realized it when he put his hand down after takeoff to raise the flaps.

Pretty amazing that you had a medium bomber that was both very heavily loaded and never designed to take off from a carrier (no catapults in those days), that was still able to get into the air without flaps.

Pugilistic Animus 31st August 2012 00:11

SeenItAll That was a good flying story they were lucky for the prop slipstream that's for sure...:\:\:\

while I don't think they should be sacked retrained definitely...but this is such fundemental airmanship that I feel it's like being trained on when to tie your shoes....and if it was company culture, training or SOPS then retraining may be futile...the captain should definitely switch seats---at the very least

Schnowzer 31st August 2012 03:07


What's that light spot thingy on the ground that moves from the piano keys towards the trailing edge between 12-17 seconds on the film?
The Mysterons?;)

framer 31st August 2012 03:10


and if it was company culture, training or SOPS then retraining may be futile...the captain should definitely switch seats---at the very least
I agree the Captain should switch seats.If it was culture and training then itīs the leadership that is lacking and the CEO or CP should switch seats as well. It would take an external investigation to come up with that recomendation though....not very likely.

Hotel Tango 31st August 2012 07:36

DX wombat, I don't know why you're getting so hot under the colar. I too am not led by price and I too am very selective about who I fly with. Nevertheless, I think it's a fair statement to suggest that most (not all) passengers flying LCC and or cowboy outfits are only looking for the cheapest deals.


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:31.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.