PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Speed tape, much? (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/646358-speed-tape-much.html)

slfool 23rd Apr 2022 22:28

Speed tape, much?
 
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....d398d37996.jpg
Picture via Reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinfur...to_saudi_from/

hans brinker 24th Apr 2022 02:28

I think at some point it might be more efficient to paint the airplane.

Tom Sawyer 24th Apr 2022 06:33

B787? There is a known issue with paint adhesion on the wing top surface - https://www.faa.gov/other_visit/avia.../SAFO20006.pdf

Haven't seen one that bad before though. Slightly ironic having a QR aircraft in the background.....or is it a QR 787? :E

Less Hair 24th Apr 2022 07:09

The made-for-metal-wings-paint is unable to follow the increased bending of the "softer" CFRP-wing and peels of? How about FOD including by all that tape coming off one day?

alf5071h 24th Apr 2022 07:43

How might the wrinkles affect the drag profile. Or lift characteristics, stalling speed, Mach trim ?

Are the wrinkles proportional to wing flexing;- effect of mass, manoeuvre, thence control effectiveness.
Could be some interesting test flying in these areas !

Krystal n chips 24th Apr 2022 08:52


Originally Posted by alf5071h (Post 11220172)
How might the wrinkles affect the drag profile. Or lift characteristics, stalling speed, Mach trim ?

Are the wrinkles proportional to wing flexing;- effect of mass, manoeuvre, thence control effectiveness.
Could be some interesting test flying in these areas !

Speed tape is an invaluable "quick fix" and I used it, as do most engineers, many times over the years.

The only reason for those wrinkles, and they are excessive, is poor application technique. Once the patch is cut to size, and in place, you simply ensure even pressure is applied and lo and behold, a smooth surface results. It's not a complex technique. And if you do get a wrinkle, you simply remove the patch....and start again.

wiggy 24th Apr 2022 09:04


Originally Posted by alf5071h (Post 11220172)
How might the wrinkles affect the drag profile. Or lift characteristics, stalling speed, Mach trim ?

Are the wrinkles proportional to wing flexing;- effect of mass, manoeuvre, thence control effectiveness.
Could be some interesting test flying in these areas !

Didn't there used to be something in the books about surfaces being "clean" in the context of all weather ops and contamination?

I know use of speedtape as/is fairly widespread for small dinks (as per K'n'Cs comment) but wonder if there is any guidance on it being used to cover significant areas of aerodynamically important surfaces?



172_driver 24th Apr 2022 09:14

And I can't help but wonder what the passengers think... doesn't really instill confidence. Even if it works.

Less Hair 24th Apr 2022 09:21

Takeoff performance and icing might be affected?

SRM 24th Apr 2022 10:46

Without having reference to the 787 Structural Repair Manual.

I would say there’s an excessive amount of tape on this wing!

meleagertoo 24th Apr 2022 12:15

More to the point, surely, is the simple "why"?
I can't think of any reason to use that much, nor anything like it.
I'd love to read the associated Tech Log entry.

albatross 24th Apr 2022 14:01

Was a weight and balance amendment completed after the tape installation?
Otherwise safety could be compromised!
Hat, coat, door.

Busbert 24th Apr 2022 15:20

The tape is to protect the CFRP from UV damage where the paint has flaked off. Think of it as sun cream.

nivsy 24th Apr 2022 15:31


Originally Posted by 172_driver (Post 11220198)
And I can't help but wonder what the passengers think... doesn't really instill confidence. Even if it works.

Absolutely..as a pax if on that aircraft I would be quite alarmed looking out at that wing. Infact I would suggest most people would...

Airbus_a321 24th Apr 2022 15:56

:D
:D
no further comment. Welcome to „banana“ airlines. I would disembark this flight with this a/c on the spot

DType 24th Apr 2022 16:11

I remember being somewhat concerned when I noticed a smallish hole in the upper surface of a wing prior to take off.
But when we climbed above the cloud it became obvious that it was just some locallly exposed black CFRP that had looked awfully like a hole in the dull light at ground level.
Doh!

zerograv 24th Apr 2022 16:15


Originally Posted by Tom Sawyer (Post 11220148)

Haven't seen one that bad before though. Slightly ironic having a QR aircraft in the background.....or is it a QR 787? :E

The machine in the background is not a 787. It is triple 7 ...

Cat Techie 24th Apr 2022 18:18

I hope there is the ADD's raised for these temporary repairs and wonder if they have been applied in accordance with the Boeing instructions for doing so. I suspect not by the shoddy application. Embraer do allow such alloy tape repairs to surface exposed composites and some liberal permanent repair times. However they tend to be under the requirement of an Embraer Technical Directive and with SRM directives of weekly inspections of said repairs as part of the concession to operate. Suspect Boeing as OEM would have a hissy fit if they saw that picture.

Cat Techie 24th Apr 2022 18:27


Originally Posted by Krystal n chips (Post 11220186)
Speed tape is an invaluable "quick fix" and I used it, as do most engineers, many times over the years.

The only reason for those wrinkles, and they are excessive, is poor application technique. Once the patch is cut to size, and in place, you simply ensure even pressure is applied and lo and behold, a smooth surface results. It's not a complex technique. And if you do get a wrinkle, you simply remove the patch....and start again.

And use a pair of scissors to cut it.

Speed tape is used in conjunction with the SRM or AMM procedures to be legally used. Protection of curing aerodynamic sealant, damaged surfaces for environmental protection and other call ups when the manuals require it to solve a line issue. When used with such, it is not a bodge. Does need to be recorded mind as a deferred defect in virtually all cases.

teej013 24th Apr 2022 19:22

When applying Speed Tape, I used to go over it with the back of a spoon to smooth it out and feather in the edges. With a bit of application you could get quite a good polished finish.


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:01.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.