PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Challenger 600 series down in Mexico (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/621253-challenger-600-series-down-mexico.html)

seafury45 7th May 2019 05:05

Challenger 600 series down in Mexico
 
Our Nine news, via CNN, is reporting a Challenger private jet with 13 aboard down in Mexico. I do not know how to post a link, so if someone can help out.
Aircraft looks like it was burnt out on the ground rather than an impact event. No visible debris trail, tracks, or crater.
Fate of passengers and crew unknown at this time.

seafury45 7th May 2019 05:08

just noticed - already reported in Biz jets forum.

Airbubba 7th May 2019 05:09


Originally Posted by seafury45 (Post 10465078)
Fate of passengers and crew unknown at this time.

Sadly, the fate of the passengers and crew is known: https://www.pprune.org/biz-jets-ag-f...ng-mexico.html


Thaihawk 7th May 2019 05:37

CL-601 N601VH en route LAS-MTY.

RIP all on board her.

Raffles S.A. 7th May 2019 05:54

Looks like it pancaked. According to Flight Aware they were passing around some weather at FL410 and the data ends at this altitude. Lightning strike followed but an AF447 scenario?

armchairpilot94116 7th May 2019 06:04

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombar...ger_600_series
Is there something wrong with the Challenger jets or are they in the news more simply because there are more of them around?

DaveReidUK 7th May 2019 06:24

Thirty-year-old CL-600-2B16 (i.e. Challenger 601-3A) operated by Gama Aviation, returning to its Monterrey base with a boxing charter group after the Alvarez/Jacobs fight in Las Vegas.

atr-drivr 7th May 2019 12:47


Originally Posted by Raffles S.A. (Post 10465098)
Looks like it pancaked. According to Flight Aware they were passing around some weather at FL410 and the data ends at this altitude. Lightning strike followed but an AF447 scenario?

Exactly what I was thinking looking at the wreckage...no forward speed at all.....🤔

Lonewolf_50 7th May 2019 12:59

The Biz Jets forum discussion on this loss is here.
:{

pattern_is_full 7th May 2019 14:26


Originally Posted by armchairpilot94116 (Post 10465101)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombar...ger_600_series
Is there something wrong with the Challenger jets or are they in the news more simply because there are more of them around?

19 hull losses out of 1066 built = 1.9%. Over 41 years.

No consistent cause - everything from failure to de-ice to W&B error to upset by an A380 wake to bounced landing to test flights.

It does use a supercritical wing, which has - unusual - stall characteristics, and may be a factor in this particular accident. Might (emphasize might) have been a contributing factor in the Dick Ebersol failure-to-de-ice accident in Colorado.

It's also the basis for the CRJ 100-200 designs, and again, accident causes with those seem to be all over the map, not due to any particular problem.

lomapaseo 8th May 2019 01:57


Originally Posted by Raffles S.A. (Post 10465098)
Looks like it pancaked. According to Flight Aware they were passing around some weather at FL410 and the data ends at this altitude. Lightning strike followed but an AF447 scenario?


Does lightning go up towards clear air or down towards the ground or another cloud?

Sailvi767 8th May 2019 02:26

It can do any of the above.

armchairpilot94116 9th May 2019 02:18

Disconcerting this one and the Turkish owned jet both went down very fast during cruise

We don’t know the cause of each case yet do we ?

Airbubba 9th May 2019 03:25


Originally Posted by armchairpilot94116 (Post 10466769)
Disconcerting this one and the Turkish owned jet both went down very fast during cruise

We don’t know the cause of each case yet do we ?

The cause of the 2018 crash of TC-TRB in Iran is known. They had unreliable airspeed and the captain thought they were overspeeding and pulled the power back into a stall.

See: https://aviation-safety.net/database...?id=20180311-0

The preliminary accident report is here:

https://www.cao.ir/web/english/inves...FmY1hnPT0=.pdf

armchairpilot94116 9th May 2019 15:03


Originally Posted by Airbubba (Post 10466786)
The cause of the 2018 crash of TC-TRB in Iran is known. They had unreliable airspeed and the captain thought they were overspeeding and pulled the power back into a stall.

See: https://aviation-safety.net/database...?id=20180311-0

The preliminary accident report is here:

https://www.cao.ir/web/english/inves...FmY1hnPT0=.pdf

thanks for that. Interesting the captains dna was not found but everyone else’s was. Flameout due to weather and engines at low power perhaps?




rak64 9th May 2019 22:36


Originally Posted by armchairpilot94116 (Post 10467300)

thanks for that. Interesting the captains dna was not found but everyone else’s was. Flameout due to weather and engines at low power perhaps?



He said the so-called captain-lady did the wrong reaction of the crew for airspeed disagree. Fighting the symptoms, erased overspeed warnings by reducing the power, which leads to a stall. That turned out not as a clever move.
It was her first job as captain after a role as Copilot with TK. The Lady-Copilot was continuing after a couple of years as a university teacher. The owner was proud to have a 100% female crew for his daughter but now he lost them all.
Insalah





hans brinker 10th May 2019 15:27


Originally Posted by rak64 (Post 10467631)
He said the so-called captain-lady did the wrong reaction of the crew for airspeed disagree. Fighting the symptoms, erased overspeed warnings by reducing the power, which leads to a stall. That turned out not as a clever move.
It was her first job as captain after a role as Copilot with TK. The Lady-Copilot was continuing after a couple of years as a university teacher. The owner was proud to have a 100% female crew for his daughter but now he lost them all.
Insalah




Can we please avoid the “lady-pilot”? If the gender is relevant, as it could be here, as apparently the father specifically wanted women to fly his daughter, a better way would be “female pilot”. Nobody would think of using “gentlemen-pilot” for a male pilot.

Yes, the female captain did a horrible job, the female co-pilot did her best to correct, but should have taken control.



AndoniP 10th May 2019 15:40


Originally Posted by hans brinker (Post 10468258)


Can we please avoid the “lady-pilot”? If the gender is relevant, as it could be here, as apparently the father specifically wanted women to fly his daughter, a better way would be “female pilot”. Nobody would think of using “gentlemen-pilot” for a male pilot.

Yes, the female captain did a horrible job, the female co-pilot did her best to correct, but should have taken control.



you can tell english isn't his native language, cut him some slack.

armchairpilot94116 10th May 2019 17:35

I am interested in how both engines flamed out and if that was recognized and any actions taken to restart them. Seems not. On the Turkish flight.

rak64 11th May 2019 07:47


Originally Posted by hans brinker (Post 10468258)


Can we please avoid the “lady-pilot”? If the gender is relevant, as it could be here, as apparently the father specifically wanted women to fly his daughter, a better way would be “female pilot”. Nobody would think of using “gentlemen-pilot” for a male pilot.

Yes, the female captain did a horrible job, the female co-pilot did her best to correct, but should have taken control.


I used it for a good purpose because these ladies were selected because they are female, despite her questionable qualification. Another captain, as well female, left the job because of working conditions...
Hope you understand.

hans brinker 11th May 2019 14:34


Originally Posted by rak64 (Post 10468722)
I used it for a good purpose because these ladies were selected because they are female, despite her questionable qualification. Another captain, as well female, left the job because of working conditions...
Hope you understand.


Originally Posted by rak64 (Post 10467631)
He said the so-called captain-lady did the wrong reaction of the crew for airspeed disagree. Fighting the symptoms, erased overspeed warnings by reducing the power, which leads to a stall. That turned out not as a clever move.
It was her first job as captain after a role as Copilot with TK. The Lady-Copilot was continuing after a couple of years as a university teacher. The owner was proud to have a 100% female crew for his daughter but now he lost them all.
Insalah

Why were the captains qualifications questionable? She had almost 5000hrs, 1600 on type and passed her check rides at CAE in the Netherlands, that all sounds reasonably qualified (and yes, she undeniably messed up big time on the last flight). I would not be surprised if they were selected based on gender, but that alone does not make them unqualified. Having to defend a female pilot is hard when the accident is clearly a result of her errors, but I have yet to see a study that shows female pilots are more accident prone then their male counterparts. Using terms like lady-pilots is not helpful in anyway, so no, I don't understand.
And correct me if I am wrong, but your ending of your first post suggests to me you might not be totally okay with equal rights.

hans brinker 11th May 2019 14:40


Originally Posted by armchairpilot94116 (Post 10468349)
I am interested in how both engines flamed out and if that was recognized and any actions taken to restart them. Seems not. On the Turkish flight.

I think the engines flamed out because of high AOA

His dudeness 11th May 2019 15:29


Originally Posted by hans brinker (Post 10469009)
And correct me if I am wrong, but your ending of your first post suggests to me you might not be totally okay with equal rights.

IF someone is employed because of his/her gender, then one could hardly call this equal rights. Even if the leftwingers and/or feminists say so, its not.

hans brinker 11th May 2019 18:18


Originally Posted by His dudeness (Post 10469054)
IF someone is employed because of his/her gender, then one could hardly call this equal rights. Even if the leftwingers and/or feminists say so, its not.

You are absolutely right, and the whole preferential hiring thing is a can of worms that is hard to solve. As a left-winger/ feminist myself I have no problem with hiring QUALIFIED "minorities" to rectify the obvious discrimination they have endured in the past, but I can see it offends the sensibilities of the WASP (White Anglo Saxon Pilots) population to the point they get their panties in a twist.

https://www.newsweek.com/pilot-ignor...-1421996?amp=1

His dudeness 11th May 2019 18:21


Originally Posted by hans brinker (Post 10469140)
You are absolutely right, and the whole preferential hiring thing is a can of worms that is hard to solve. As a left-winger/ feminist myself I have no problem with hiring QUALIFIED "minorities" to rectify the obvious discrimination they have endured in the past, but I can see it offends the sensibilities of the WASP (White Anglo Saxon Pilots) population to the point they get their panties in a twist.

https://www.newsweek.com/pilot-ignor...-1421996?amp=1


So your example for WASP pilots having twisted panties is:


A senior Air India Express pilot ignored the recommendations of his junior female co-pilot while landing in bad weather
who had "history" and clearly some other issues than being a WASP:


In 2016, the senior pilot in question was found to be alcohol-positive twice and had his flight license suspended for three months.
Particularly 'nice' is :


As a left-winger/ feminist myself I have no problem with hiring QUALIFIED "minorities" to rectify the obvious discrimination they have endured in the past
So if I´m, say, 22, male and just had my license finished and I compete with a 22 year old female with an equally fresh license and she gets hired because OTHER males in the PAST have treated OTHER females bad / wrongly (exchange female with any minority if you wish) then you are fine with that ?

Are you one of these individuals who think racism and prejudice is only possible to origin from white persons, particularly white men ?

hans brinker 11th May 2019 19:20


Originally Posted by His dudeness (Post 10469145)
So your example for WASP pilots having twisted panties is:



who had "history" and clearly some other issues than being a WASP:



Particularly 'nice' is :



So if I´m, say, <A> 22, male and just had my license finished and I compete with a 22 year old female with an equally fresh license and she gets hired because OTHER males in the PAST have treated OTHER females bad / wrongly (exchange female with any minority if you wish) then you are fine with that ?

<B>Are you one of these individuals who think racism and prejudice is only possible to origin from white persons, particularly white men ?

<A> Yes, I have no problem provided equally qualified.

<B> Nope, as a white guy who has lived and experienced discrimination by non-white in both Asia and Africa I can confirm most people are capable of racism. The issue at hand is however the historical discrimination against non-white-male-pilots.

punkalouver 12th May 2019 03:02

[QUOTE=hans brinker;10469140]You are absolutely right, and the whole preferential hiring thing is a can of worms that is hard to solve. As a left-winger/ feminist myself I have no problem with hiring QUALIFIED "minorities" to rectify the obvious discrimination they have endured in the past, but I can see it offends the sensibilities of the WASP (White Anglo Saxon Pilots) population to the point they get their panties in a twist[QUOTE]
Kind of ironic what happened.

His dudeness 12th May 2019 06:57


<A> Yes, I have no problem provided equally qualified.
May I suggest that you google "Sippenhaft" and why normal, somewhat healthy societies have abandoned it ?

His dudeness 12th May 2019 08:30


Originally Posted by evansb (Post 10469435)
I believe fight beyond the service ceiling of the aircraft due to the captain's storm avoidance may have contributed to this tragic crash.

The gender of the captain and flight crew is irrelevant.

Plus 1. Some of us (including me) were sort of off topic. Apologies.


pattern_is_full 12th May 2019 14:33

Equality will come when we start remarking on the gender of every male crew that turn their aircraft into a hole in the ground/water. There have been a lot more of them. :ugh:

AF447 - "The FO-gentleman held the stick in a stall for 30000 feet....."

JT904 - "The testosterone-laced male crew continued the approach even after losing visual contact with the runway, and ended up in the ocean....."

Squawk7777 12th May 2019 19:06

Is this story related to this crash?

Borderland Beat: Pilot of plane that crashed in Coahuila, involved in money laundering and transfer of drugs

hans brinker 13th May 2019 00:42


Originally Posted by His dudeness (Post 10469441)
Plus 1. Some of us (including me) were sort of off topic. Apologies.

Add me, apologies


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:39.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.