Better tell the FAA quick - they are betting the ranch on ADS-B as a cornerstone of their NextGen ATM strategy. Perhaps it's something that Donald can fix as one of his first tasks ...
Then imagine how this would look if sombody tried to use this data to analyze an accident. |
|
Read carefully again... Like the post says.... The thread has been closed
|
Not unreasonable to ask why.
|
BTW, there are more interesting pictures from FR24 to share:
https://cdn.aviaforum.ru/images/2017...fa3a59c0d2.png x - distance, m Green - flight 13/01 Red - glidepath Blue - crash flight 16/01 https://cdn.aviaforum.ru/images/2017...9bf5b0e5cd.png x - distance, km |
Not so much censorship as a limit to the discussion based on the information available from local press reports and hobby reception of flight radar data. Some valid theories have been advanced as to the cause, but pointless speculating further until an official accident report appears. Seems reasonable to me.
|
From IAC site:
January 20, 2017 January 19, 2017 flight recorders from the Boeing 747-412 TC-MCL airline «myCARGO» (Turkey), crashed at the airport in Bishkek, January 16, 2016 was delivered to the Interstate Aviation Committee. Received recorders have significant mechanical damage and traces of the extremely high temperatures. Conditions prevent it from reading information conventional way. Specialists of the Interstate Aviation Committee, together with Turkish experts, the United States and the Kyrgyz Republic performed inspection, opened recorders and removed memory modules from protected storage. The deciphering of the Flight Data data parametric recorder completed. Information read. Preliminary analysis showed that information about the accident is available. The reconstruction of the data from voice recorder continues. The Commission continues to work on the site of the accident. In the work of the Commission participate authorized representatives of the National Committee for Transportation Safety (the NTSB) and the United States Committee on Accident Investigation (KAIK) Turkey, as well as advisors - NTSB experts, FAA, Boeing, KAIK and airlines «myCARGO». http://mak-iac.org/upload/iblock/bb4...-01-2017_1.jpg http://mak-iac.org/upload/iblock/688...-01-2017_2.jpg |
Originally Posted by G0ULI
(Post 9649770)
Some valid theories have been advanced as to the cause, but pointless speculating further until an official accident report appears. Seems reasonable to me.
Clearly that has nothing to do with why this one was closed. |
MyCargo/ACT has had 2 major widebody accidents.
The B747-400f at Bishkek and an A300 in Bagram Afghanistan 2010. This is a very poor record. |
Mea Culpa
I think it was an easy mistake for the media to make who wouldn't know that another airline can operate under a Turkish Airlines flight number. I should have changed the name of the thread to reflect the true position.
|
IIRC some governments oblige the marketing carrier to assume liability for loss and damage under international treaties (Warsaw etc./Montreal 99). Although they might try and distance themselves from the operating carrier, they likely remain liable in law for any shipments under their flight code.
|
A very simple judgement,
No real news for several days. Working pilots have abandoned the thread It is totally overwhelmed by armchair and desk bound accident fiends All discussion became endless posturing over nonsensical and simply wrong ADSB data points The wrong data is assigned greater importance than the actual crash tracks and visuals because our accident boffins find data more convincing while these boffinistas tunnel in on patently wrong numbers. Zero legal threats and zero contact from the ostensible "owners." Therefore thread killed until there is real news from the initial formal report and the data recorders and the pilots can step in again Rob |
Manas 747 MAC-IAC update
The Interstate Aviation Committee informs that the Commission on investigation of aviation incident with the aircraft Boeing 747-412F TC-MCL completed the work on the accident site. During the field phase of the investigation, scheme the accident site was drafted with the use of unmanned aircraft. The Commission, including representatives of the National Committee for transport safety (NTSB) of the USA and the Committee on investigation (CAC) of Turkey, reviewed the elements of the aircraft, found on the site, and analyzed their damage to selected parts for future research.
Parts of the aircraft was removed from the scene and stored at the territory of airport Manas (Bishkek). Commission completed analysis of meteorological information. Together with the specialists from the Kyrgyzstan Republic, the NTSB CAK of the US and Turkey scheduled program of flight-checking landing systems installed at the airport Manas. The Commission continues data analysis of parametric (FDR) and voice (CVR) recorders, radar data review, tower negotiations. ... http://mak-iac.org/upload/iblock/16e/001.jpg http://mak-iac.org/upload/iblock/3ad/002.jpg |
Photos appear to have been taken looking west (top) and east (bottom) along the debris trail.
|
|
Paraphrasing from the report, in line with most of the ADS-B data:
According to preliminary information, while conducting a CAT II approach at Manas, the Boeing 747-412F TC-MCL reached the end of runway 26 at an altitude much higher than estimated. Continuing descent, the plane flew over the entire runway and touched down 900m from the far end of the runway 26 (at the end of runway 08) at sunset. After touch down, the aircraft collided with a concrete fence and rolled into a village, located 1000m away from the runway, substantially on the runway's extended centerline. |
After touch down, the aircraft collided with a concrete fence and rolled into a village, located 1000m away from the runway, substantially on the runway's extended centerline. That's hard to reconcile with Kulverstukas' second photo, which shows the houses nearest to the runway still intact. |
Rather like the Blackbushe biz jet crash last year but on a much bigger scale , too high, too fast on final resulting in touch down way to far down the runway , momentarily airborne at far end of runway but instantly crashed -in that case into cars. In there an earth bank or anything at the end of runway that could punch plane into air momentarily or perhaps a frantic haul back on stick which just got the 747 airborne to skip the boundary fence but with no energy/ momentum /speed to maintain flight and crashing again almost instantaneously
Very sad those pictures, houses remains intact and untouched on one side but the other side of the narrow street houses demolished almost completely and assume occupants killed. Can you see the untouched car somehow escaping devastation that reaches within a few feet of it. |
Originally Posted by peekay4
(Post 9663519)
Paraphrasing from the report, in line with most of the ADS-B data:
|
It just looks like a classic false g/s all the way down to me or am I over simplifying ?
|
All times are GMT. The time now is 20:05. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.