PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   A330 AIR BERLIN INCIDENT IN HKT (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/503408-a330-air-berlin-incident-hkt.html)

greenspinner 21st Dec 2012 04:14

A330 AIR BERLIN INCIDENT IN HKT
 
At HKT Airport on 20-Dec-12, ~2130LT, Air Berlin A330 Departure from HKT, then request air turn back for Emergency landing cause Engine 1 fire!.

A/C made a hard landing and 3 of main wheels burst. AOT declare Runway closure due to unable to move a/c off the runway.

JammedStab 21st Dec 2012 04:55

I wonder if they did an overweight landing. I was told that on my craft, the autopilot is not approved for overweight landings. Is this pretty much standard among airliners.

Bearcat 21st Dec 2012 05:00

Refer to QRH- airbus mention from memory non certified but you can do an o/weight Ldg upto 227t?

gtseraf 21st Dec 2012 05:01

I'm not sure what the autopilot approval has to do with this.

last I checked pilots were trained to manually fly aircraft, or have the standards dropped so low that the a/p has to be used for everything.

alidad 21st Dec 2012 06:06

Bit difficult to do an autoland RWY 27 when the localiser is offset by about 2 degrees from the runway course :\

PA-28-180 21st Dec 2012 06:22

" Last I checked pilots were trained to manually fly aircraft, or have the standards dropped so low that the a/p has to be used for everything. "

Unfortunately, Gtseraf, seems they have in many cases. Check the thread on the temorary loss of control because the captain didn't have an operable FD.....:eek::ugh:

DouglasFlyer 21st Dec 2012 06:24


Bit difficult to do an autoland RWY 27 when the localiser is offset by about 2 degrees from the runway course
...and is CAT I only...

Coastrider26 21st Dec 2012 06:25

You can do an overweight landing on the autopilot but one of the items mentioned in the QRH is that the rate of descend on touch down can not exceed 360 ft/min.

DouglasFlyer 21st Dec 2012 07:22

Our QRH A-333 says in the chapter "overweight landing":

"An overweight landing is authorized up to MTOW.
Automatic landing is certified up to Maximum Landing Weight (MLW). Autoland flight tests have, however, been successful up to 229 tons.
Depending on the situation (e.g. emergency or other) and provided that the runway is approved for automatic landing, the flight crew can decide to perform a autoland up to 229 tons."

In my opinion you have to have a good reason to conduct a AL with overweight - i think it wouldn't be good airmanship to try it on a CAT I ILS with an offset LOC...

joe two 21st Dec 2012 07:38

there is no reason at all to do an autoland anyway

DouglasFlyer 21st Dec 2012 07:48

...fog... ?

MANTHRUST 21st Dec 2012 08:38

Was it foggy?
Did they do an auto land?
We're they overweight?
Have I missed something?

BOAC 21st Dec 2012 08:43

How CAN we have a thread without the 'METAR Poster'?:ugh:

Dg800 21st Dec 2012 08:50

Can I run for the position of 'AvHerald poster' instead? :E

Incident: Air Berlin A332 at Phuket on Dec 20th 2012, engine fire

BOAC 21st Dec 2012 08:54

You got it:ok: T&C are crap.mind you, but STILL no actual:{

Shot Nancy 21st Dec 2012 10:58

HKT 09 has RNAV, VOR or visual approach. 27 has RNAV, offset ILS, VOR or visual approach. Ergo auto land not possible.
Please, no more mention of auto land.

4468 21st Dec 2012 11:48

Tyres normally burst due to excess energy (heat) being applied to the brakes during deceleration after landing. Not purely by any overweight issues. A wind report (available to the investigation team) will assist in explaining any decelaration 'issues'. It may also give an indication as to why the crew took off from 27, and landed on 09. As the pax did not evacuate on the runway (but are reported to have used mobile stairs) an unextinguishable fire, requiring immediate landing, looks unlikely?

JW411 21st Dec 2012 16:36

Dear God; why would anyone in their right mind even attempt to do an autoland in these circumstances?

Hotel Tango 21st Dec 2012 18:24


Dear God; why would anyone in their right mind even attempt to do an autoland in these circumstances?
They didn't, so it's irrelevant!

Squawk7777 21st Dec 2012 22:25


Dear God; why would anyone in their right mind even attempt to do an autoland in these circumstances?

They didn't, so it's irrelevant!
Is it really irrelevant, or does it show the lack of common sense these days?

root 21st Dec 2012 22:31

Is the A330 AP certified for AL on 1 engine?

Zorin_75 21st Dec 2012 22:44


how can we have a thread without the 'metar poster'?:ugh:
vtsp 201430z vrb02kt 8000 few020 sct120 bkn300 26/24 q1009 a2982 nosig
:E

galant1 21st Dec 2012 23:06

if the majority here advocate an auto land an aircraft overweight because it has one of the two engines on fire, please leave the industry. Of course we are talking about airbus pilots. What do you guys do in training, sit and read the womans journal.

chaz88z 21st Dec 2012 23:52


Quite amazing how many of the above post so knowledgeably and completely ignore the fact that they don't even know if it was foggy and that they can't auto land at HKT anyway..
Fog in Phuket, Thailand ? Does that ever happen ?

el caballero rojo 22nd Dec 2012 00:09

I quote a reaction made on the Aviation Herald

By Denti on Friday, Dec 21st 2012 23:13Z

Well, uncontained engine failure, two hydraulic systems gone, crew flying on direct law and of course no anti skid on landing, all that well above landing weight. Air Berlin is quite lucky to still have a few experienced flight crews that know how to handle a multiple malfunction situation without any injured passengers or crew.

Gentleman,
This comment more or less describes what happened and not the assumptions that were made here prior.
If you are a 330 driver, you really understand that this a severe emergency that Airbus considers as " very unlikely".
Well done to the well experienced "Air Berlin" pilots
To the Green poster who started the Topic: a bit off to conclude that the tire burst was due to a hard landing after an overweight landing with dual hydraulic failure and 1 eng out. To the Autoland fraction: you have a third Auto Pilot in the A330 I didn't know off who suddenly works with a Dual Hydr leaving you in Alternate law until you lower the landing gear?? We are talking about hand flying in a FBW aircraft that is missing some of its flight controls :eek: on one engine.
Forget the Autoland stuff; you can't do one in Direct law and for sure not on a RNAV09 ( not to mention the offset 27) in the middle of the night.
As always. Please stop the false assumptions.
Well done to those pilots and the cabin crew. Experience does matter no matter what they say.

rubik101 22nd Dec 2012 05:26

Fog?
 
In Phuket? No such thing.

ZimmerFly 22nd Dec 2012 07:37


Very mild cool season or weather at Phuket Starts mid of October ends at mid of March. Celsius is like 25c-32c.The hint of starting cool weather at phuket,when moisture weather winds at phuket crash with cool winds arrives from china. This wind meeting create fog in Phuket for around for 2 days, on that time if you go to any mountains like Big Buddha mountain, feels like you are in some of the other places.
http://www.ephuket.net/wp-content/up...her-phuket.jpg

Weather Phuket | Travel Phuket

:E

BN2A 22nd Dec 2012 08:04

Phuket and Krabi, both can be susceptible to fog...

:)

giblets 24th Dec 2012 14:11

If anyone is interested, Air Berlin have the Pratt P4168A option on their A330s.

safelife 25th Dec 2012 10:21

This will make record as the biggest bull**** ever.

bracebrace! 25th Dec 2012 11:06


After an engine failure,it automatically changes from normal to alternate law/direct law..in which many systems are unavailable including antiskid..
Really? I don't know what sort of Airbus you fly but I suggest taking it back to to Toulouse and asking for another as it sounds like it's completely b*ggered. :ugh:

DouglasFlyer 25th Dec 2012 11:10


RAJITHRAJAN320 "...in which many systems are unavailable including antiskid..."
According to my knowledge, the following systems are inop after a engine shutdown in a A330-200:

Engine 1 (2) Shutdown (ENG 2 shutdown in paranthesis)

BLUE HYD (if ENG 1 shutdown)
(YELLOW HYD) (if ENG 2 shutdown)
PART SPLRS
REV 1 (2)
CAT 3 DUAL
ENG 1 (2) BLEED
PACK 1 (2)
G ENG 1 (2) PUMP
B ENG 1 PUMP
(Y ENG 2 PUMP)
GEN 1 (2)
ALTN BRK (if ENG 1 shutdown)
PART GALLEY (electric)
(YAW DAMPER 2) (if ENG 2 shutdown)

affected:

SLATS SLOW (if ENG 1 shutdown)
FLAPS SLOW (if ENG 2 shutdown)
CAT 3 SINGLE ONLY
if one ENG FIRE p/B has been pressed A/THR may be inop - then degraded to CAT 2 ONLY

In my opinion the antiskid is available - but I flew the A-330-200 for only seven years...

CABUS 25th Dec 2012 11:17

[QUOTE]Is the A330 AP certified for AL on 1 engine?/QUOTE]

Yes, Cat 3 A.

Good on them, an engine fire out of HKT could not have been easy especially with negotiating with local ATC. ATC can be very good but as soon as things go wrong and nonstandard phrases start to slip in things can get very busy very quickly.

A few well deserved Chang's will be enjoyed by the crew I hope.

el caballero rojo 25th Dec 2012 19:25

Eng1 fail with additional green Hydr failure.
In other words: green and blue system gone and on one engine.
Overweight landing
These are facts.
So if you loose 2 Hydr systems you go in alternate law with reduced protections.
Once you lower the gear, you are in direct law.
All the discussions about Autoland are not relevant.
The assumption that once you loose an engine you are in alternate law is not correct.
On all the Airbus 330 and 320 (on which I am rated and current on) series you can still make an Autoland with one engine out. Correctly stated CAT 3 A or single as mentioned in Airbus Aircraft. Things change when you loose more then "just" an engine.

Stuck_in_an_ATR 25th Dec 2012 19:44

Q for 330 guys - does a "vanilla" engine failure in the '330 result in 1 Hyd system loss? :confused:

illusion 25th Dec 2012 19:50

With no Green Hyd Sys. There is the small detail of not being able retract the landing gear. On one engine, not a good place to be.....

DouglasFlyer 25th Dec 2012 20:21

On an engine failure you loose either blue or yellow hydraulics...

Stuck_in_an_ATR 25th Dec 2012 20:26

Thx for info! :ok:

BN2A 25th Dec 2012 20:47

Think I'd be losing brown hydraulics!!!!

:\

loc22550 25th Dec 2012 20:56

Caballero,

Unlike the A-320, 0n the A-330 you don't go to direct law once you put the landing gear down in alternate law .


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:02.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.