PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rumours & News (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news-13/)
-   -   Adam Air B737 Heavy Landing (https://www.pprune.org/rumours-news/265099-adam-air-b737-heavy-landing.html)

PK-KAR 21st Feb 2007 09:04

Adam Air B737 Heavy Landing
 
Another accident/incident today involving Adam Air, reported hard/baulked landing at Surabaya.
Runway was blocked, airport closed, several injuries including pax trapped in the aircraft. Conflicting reports as to the extent of the damage.
Aircraft has been towed to Merpati Maintenance Center.

No matter how many accidents/incidents/writeoffs/loss of life, if they don't change, this will continue unfortunately. I guess they'll have to lower their lowest fares again now!

PK-KAR

PK-KAR 21st Feb 2007 10:16

OK, airframe bent behind emergency exit, by about >3 degrees by the looks of it.

Windshear suspected.

FlexibleResponse 21st Feb 2007 13:09

Fuselage bent?

bnt 21st Feb 2007 13:40

That's what the news reports say e.g. Reuters and the Herald Tribune. Very bent, due to a hard landing. :{

gengis 21st Feb 2007 13:42

2g landing? Arghhhhhh........................ airplane abuse? I beg your pardon!

Well i s'pose, they'd be able to hire some guys to fly the airplane for 2,000,000 rupiahs (US$200). Good luck, guys

:ugh:

bnt 21st Feb 2007 13:43

Picture
 
Reuters has a picture, here. Any Boeing employees should exercise caution when viewing this image. :eek:

PK-KAR 21st Feb 2007 14:51

Tis bent indeed my friend... my friends in Surabaya are already placing their bets on the price of aluminium saucepans for next month! :rolleyes:
http://www.liputan6.com/files/daerah...07cadamair.jpg
Bent? Hell yea!
PK-KAR

gengis 21st Feb 2007 14:55

What bout slipped discs among the passengers????????? Or whiplash????

macam2ada 21st Feb 2007 14:58

I am surprised that they are still operating. Why do people still want to fly with them?

readywhenreaching 21st Feb 2007 15:08

for a closer look:

http://www.indoflyer.net/indoforum/t...9&mpage=4&key=

maxalt 21st Feb 2007 16:18

Bit late on the round-out Hoskins......

G-UNIT 21st Feb 2007 16:26

http://www.alertnet.org/thefacts/ima...ticleimage.jpg

tightcircuit 21st Feb 2007 18:17

Better pictures here, sorry its so long! http://foto.detik.com/index.php/home...kanal/157/id/1

BTDT 21st Feb 2007 18:47

Natalia Budihardjo, a regional spokeswoman for PT Adam Skyconnections Airlines, said "The sudden stop of the plane was the best decision by the pilot for the safety of the 130 passengers,"

:ugh:

Slats One 21st Feb 2007 18:48

faintly amusing
 
You have all been duped my friends.

That is the new aerodynamic test bed for the Dreamliner Constellation series of Boeing- with banana shaped substitutes for drag reducing fairings once called Whitcombe bodies- a la Convair C990.

See how the excess heat of Indonesia has bent the locally cured carbon fried fibre?

Sour buyer it happende at you say - you better Adam Air and believe it...

You want bendy boeing mister- cheap cheap....

Beaver diver 21st Feb 2007 18:48

Jesus Christ, how long can a family owned company run for???

Non acceptable standards at all, but they keep on doing it...maybe they have some big shot in the government, who knows, sounds like it otherwise they'd be out of business long time ago...

Their logo should be; "Adam air, everytime you fly us you are closer to heaven"

Hehehehe....

hikoushi 21st Feb 2007 20:04

Or rather closer to hell, since they seem more adept at attempting to drive their airplanes down INTO the earth than keeping them above it.:ugh:

act700 22nd Feb 2007 00:05

A better business plan for Adam Air:

Why not chose or let passengers fly the trips, sort of like a car rental? They could save the ridiculous high pilot wages they pay!!!

This could also make a new reality TV show-like Airline.

barit1 22nd Feb 2007 02:30

maxalt quotes Roger Bacon -

Bit late on the round-out Hoskins......
ROFL!

Hey, it looks ferriable to me...

jet_noseover 22nd Feb 2007 03:18


Hey, it looks ferriable to me...
Watch ebay closely. :rolleyes:

Sad, really.

Freehills 22nd Feb 2007 03:26

Heh, just outside Juanda airport are large Maspion factories. Maspion is Indonesia's largest maker of aluminium items (pots/ pans etc.)

Now I know why they are there - inexhaustable supply of cheap scrap metal!

jet_noseover 22nd Feb 2007 03:41

Grounded
 
Seems the Adamair's B737-300 (all 7 of them) have been grounded.

PK-KAR,


Adam Air officials explained that Wednesday's accident occurred after the aircraft encountered poor weather conditions - heavy rains and strong wind.
'A few minutes before landing, it was reported that the plane received wind pressure from above, or what we call a downdraft,' Hartono, Adam Air's safety and security director, was quoted as saying by The Jakarta Post.
Television footage showed the Boeing 737-300 stranded on the airport runway with its rear section bent downwards and apparently a vertical split in the fuselage.
Seems the weather knocked this 'chine out.



The incident caused the body of the plane cracking, creating an angle of some 35 decrees, according to the television. But there is no report of serious wound and casualty from the incident.
http://www.thejakartapost.com/detail...1183226&irec=6


http://news.monstersandcritics.com/a...r_hard_landing


http://www.cnn.com/2007/WORLD/asiapc...eut/index.html

Rush2112 22nd Feb 2007 04:36

Having lived in Indonesia (and having an Indonesian wife) I can assure you that people will continue to fly with these clowns, until (if) they are closed down - which given their connections is unlikely.

Why? 1. They are cheap. 2. Indonesians generally have no concept of "what would happen if..." - look at how they cram 5 people on a moped and set off across Jakarta to visit the inlaws.

twenty eight 22nd Feb 2007 09:21

They did not waste any time painting the whole aircraft white.
picture

discostu 22nd Feb 2007 09:21

Nah....this is just the test bed for the drooping tail option, copied from the kneeling bus. Saves the need for airstairs....

Say again s l o w l y 22nd Feb 2007 09:27

With their reputation, I'm not surprised they were prepared to get the a/c painted as fast as they did. They unfortunately seem to get plenty of practise.

abeb 22nd Feb 2007 10:14

:D
Some official comments on 'painted white incident', rough translation.

Angkasa Pura (Juanda Airport) Head of PR, Edmundus Priyono :
"It's just temporary, no problemo, it's their plane anyway"
"It's their plane, they own the plane, it is their rigth to do so"

Chairman Subcommittee of KNKT (National Transportation Safety Committee),
Indonesian Agency responsible for investigating transportation accident, Fran Wenas :
"Team is already in Juanda, color alteration does not interfere with investigation process."
"Maybe they (Adam Air) did not want their airplane to be so obvious"

Both are not consulted first by Adam Air before repainting the aircraft white. Those comments disregard Indonesian Law and ICAO adopted as a Legal Framework for KNKT regarding evidence. Clearly Adam Air has tempered with the evidence.

Dude~ 22nd Feb 2007 10:55

it is quite common for airline liveries to be covered after incidents. Air France were quick to blank the tail of that Fokker that got bent last month, and Brittania did the same with the 757 that broke up after leaving the runway a few years back. No idea whether or not its interference with evidence though.

xetroV 22nd Feb 2007 11:27

I believe it's due to ownership reasons: an airplane that's written-off in an accident becomes property of the insurance company. Hence the removal of markings and registrations. (Or something like that.) However, painting a wreck this thoroughly seems pretty remarkable to me.

Raggyman 22nd Feb 2007 11:36

Very much a missed marketing opportunity really... why white? Would have thought bright banana yellow would have been more appropriate.

Ouch, when that hit the ground that woud have definitely hurt a little.. hope the poor passengers were ok.

SOPS 22nd Feb 2007 12:13

mmmmm.....must have been a very very hard hit:confused:

Ben_S 22nd Feb 2007 12:35

Ouch.

Hard to beleive people will still fly with clowns like this given that the wreckage of their last crash still hasn't been found.

Is stuff like this covered up over there so people don't know about it or are people really stupid enough to keep using them?

abeb 22nd Feb 2007 12:51

They did it in less than 24 hours after the incident, before any formal investigation took place. For me that's kindda odd. :bored:

And now the owner + management is denying the cracking body of the airplane, said it's fine and sitting in the Merpati Hangar in front of reporters and jurnalist, saw that in Metro TV (Indonesian CNN-like). What do they expect us to believe, that the airplane is in for a tire change? Their denials is out of this world. Everybody in Indonesia knows it's bullsh*t, every people I've talked to said it was cracked and bented like a hump whale. They KNOW!

Adamair ticked box employee was interviewed by Metro reporter and was asked why Adamair canceled/delayed other fligths and were there any customer returning tickets, demanding refunds. His response was business is as usual. "The one you see in the information board (cancelled) has already departed an hour ago, full sitting". Yeah ..right. And that there were no ticket cancelation by customer. After that interview, Metro runned a footage of qeuing tickets holder returning them and wanting refunds. Gotcha, again.

Apparantly denials is their game now. Nice company damage control startegy.:ok:

Ndicho Moja 22nd Feb 2007 13:03

Last year Indonesia had an aviation incident or accident, on average, every ten days. This info compliments of the Idonesia aviation authorities.
Jakarta and Juanda airspace, on a good day is chaotic and on a bad day just down right dangerous.

CargoOne 22nd Feb 2007 13:04

For me is a bit strange that landing gear didn't collapsed first...

barit1 22nd Feb 2007 13:10


Having lived in Indonesia (and having an Indonesian wife) I can assure you that people will continue to fly with these clowns, until (if) they are closed down - which given their connections is unlikely.

Why? 1. They are cheap. 2. Indonesians generally have no concept of "what would happen if..." - look at how they cram 5 people on a moped and set off across Jakarta to visit the inlaws.
Why is it I am reminded of -

"There are three kinds of people:
Those who learn from their own mistakes,
those who learn from others' mistakes, and
those who never learn." :(

OldChinaHand 22nd Feb 2007 13:39

I suppose we have all heard of Official white washes in the past......But this paint job takes the biscuit !!!!!.

PK-KAR 22nd Feb 2007 14:21

(Self-EDITed: erroneous info)

PK-KAR

The AvgasDinosaur 22nd Feb 2007 14:42

Learned contributors,
Will the FDR be able to give details such as rate of decent and G loadings?
Be lucky
David

G-CPTN 22nd Feb 2007 16:09


They did not waste any time painting the whole aircraft white.
Maybe there was more than one . . . ?

For me is a bit strange that landing gear didn't collapsed first...
Maybe the load-distribution (and total) were 'unusual'?

look at how they cram 5 people on a moped and set off across Jakarta to visit the inlaws.


All times are GMT. The time now is 05:53.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.