AF passengers asked to pay fuel bill in cash
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: LSZA & EGWU
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
au nombre desquels figuraient des personnalités libanaises hostiles au régime de Bachar al-Assad
But then, almost half the world is currently hostile to the Assad regime.
Last edited by Victor Inox; 27th Aug 2012 at 16:35.
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Germany
Age: 67
Posts: 1,777
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
But then, almost half the world is currently hostile to the Assad regime.
But you probably know that sheep avoid at all costs to get to the lair of the wolf
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Germany
Age: 67
Posts: 1,777
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Paris-Damas: le droutant priple du vol AF 562 - L'EXPRESS
How Air France refused to ask one of its aircraft with 174 passengers on Beirut airport, destination ... to make land at Damascus, while the civil war torn Syria. Synopsis of this incredible journey that could end badly.
Google*Traduction
How Air France refused to ask one of its aircraft with 174 passengers on Beirut airport, destination ... to make land at Damascus, while the civil war torn Syria. Synopsis of this incredible journey that could end badly.
Google*Traduction
A surprisingly well written, factual article that clarifies the decision process and answers my previous question.
In summary for those lacking the time to read through:
- The filed alternate was LCA
- 5 mins after takeoff a cockpit window heat failed. Ops authorised continuation of flight, with repair to be done in BEY before next flight.
- When the BEY events unfolded, AMM was chosen to divert because of the availabiity of tech support (to fix the window heat) and also to take care of pax (CAI was also considered, but was beyond range)
- The flight did not have Syrian overflight permits, while the matter was negotiated fuel was used up and there was no option left but to land in DAM
- Subsequently the a/c performed two more legs (DAM-LCA and LCA-BEY) with the fault.
Seems to be a case of a well intended but ill informed and not quite thought through decision leading to an unexpected and potentially disasterous outcome. AF ops should have been aware that crossing Syrian airspace requires flight specific permits.
In summary for those lacking the time to read through:
- The filed alternate was LCA
- 5 mins after takeoff a cockpit window heat failed. Ops authorised continuation of flight, with repair to be done in BEY before next flight.
- When the BEY events unfolded, AMM was chosen to divert because of the availabiity of tech support (to fix the window heat) and also to take care of pax (CAI was also considered, but was beyond range)
- The flight did not have Syrian overflight permits, while the matter was negotiated fuel was used up and there was no option left but to land in DAM
- Subsequently the a/c performed two more legs (DAM-LCA and LCA-BEY) with the fault.
Seems to be a case of a well intended but ill informed and not quite thought through decision leading to an unexpected and potentially disasterous outcome. AF ops should have been aware that crossing Syrian airspace requires flight specific permits.
Last edited by andrasz; 29th Aug 2012 at 16:18.
So essentially 5mins after take off, the single planned alternate, LCA, was no longer practicable...
However I think I would have made the same decision, if the MEL says the flight may be continued to the next landing and the destination has suitable maintenance facilities. At the time everyone involved could safely assume that the flight will continue to Beirut.
The fundamental mistake was the decision to divert to AMM without making sure that all the necessary paperwork was in order. Anyone operating in that part of the world should know better than to simply redespatch in mid-air (...at least they did not consider TLV, they did have some vague ideas after all...). Clearly it would have been a better choice to bite the bulet and go for LCA and either organise the maintenance support, or get a one-off waiver for the next flight from the DGAC (it seems they eventually did for the LCA-BEY leg - I don't think the issue was ever raised leaving DAM).
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: FR
Posts: 477
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Respectfully, in GCD you're correct. However should you care to make the effort, I suggest you have a look at the published mandatory entry points and routes over Syria, and you will find that the shortest distance you may do BEY-AMM along the published airways is a good 50% more (~320 Km) than the distance BEY-LCA (~210 Km).
Thanks for pointing that out
jcjeant, thanks for the L'EXPRESS link.
I can add this one from Le Point, less "new" facts, but I understand that the alternates were Amman, Cairo & Larnaca (not only Larnaca, as stated by L'EXPRESS, even if it may have been the 1st alternate on the FP)
Apart from this detail, I fully agree with the analysis of andrasz
With hindsight, a bad decision, but I'm at last reassured to learn that there don't seem to be any kind of strict "minimum fuel policy" at AF.
Pegase Driver
On the comments part of the "L'Express" article posted here ( below the article itself) is this interesting sentence :
Or " Correction, the Windshield failure was known before departure from CDG because mentioned to the crew during the Cabin Crew briefing "
If this is correct ,and if the guy who posted that is genuine, ( 2 "if" ) = a different story.
Si je peux me permettre un petit rectificatif à votre article, la panne du pare-brise était connue au départ de CDG puisque notifiée à l'équipage au cours du briefing PNC.
If this is correct ,and if the guy who posted that is genuine, ( 2 "if" ) = a different story.
Pegase Driver
I understand that the alternates were Amman, Cairo & Larnaca .
Because to fly BEY-AMM you normally need overfly diplomatic clearance(s) unless you declare emergency and call mayday (from the start)
Join Date: Aug 2009
Location: Germany
Age: 67
Posts: 1,777
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Or " Correction, the Windshield failure was known before departure from CDG because mentioned to the crew during the Cabin Crew briefing "
Google*Traduction