737 rudder issues resurface despite redesign
Thread Starter
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 86
Likes: 0
From: CA
737 rudder issues resurface despite redesign
I found this on Flight Global a week ago, and have been patiently waiting, expecting that it would turn up here. I'm surprised it hasn't so, what does this mean?
Not a concern?
Nobody noticed?
Hush-hush?
http://www.flightglobal.com/articles...-redesign.html
Not a concern?
Nobody noticed?
Hush-hush?
http://www.flightglobal.com/articles...-redesign.html
Per Ardua ad Astraeus
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 18,575
Likes: 4
From: UK
Well, its really 'just another AD', although indicative of fairly poor manufacturing errors, and the percentage of affected frames is high (681/880). However, I would not necessarily expect it to 'hit the headlines'...............unless of course it caused an accident.
The AD will require inspection/replacement within a certain time so I do not think there is a drama - yet
The AD will require inspection/replacement within a certain time so I do not think there is a drama - yet
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 934
Likes: 0
From: Balmullo,Scotland
Joined: Apr 2005
Posts: 801
Likes: 1
From: Southeast USA
Well, it looks to me like the article itself has already reported the determination and the conclusion .
Someone, someplace is convinced that the continued operation of aircraft with the "enhanced" rudder system that was delivered with the "suspect rods," is not something that must be immediately stopped for safety considerations. I would imagine that's a difficult seat to sit in - it's a good call if nothing happens; but if one breaks and causes another hard-over rudder with resulting injuries or death - that guy would become the goat of the month!
Although Boeing identified the problem in 2006 and initiated a retrofit programme, the FAA AD and acceleration of the replacement effort was made inevitable by "the subsequent discovery of a second broken rod in December".
Boeing says 880 aircraft have been fitted with the "enhanced" rudder system, of which 681 were discovered to have been delivered with "suspect rods".
Boeing says 880 aircraft have been fitted with the "enhanced" rudder system, of which 681 were discovered to have been delivered with "suspect rods".
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 8,571
Likes: 3
From: Arizona USA
B737 rudder hard-overs seem to be a slight problem.
Now, never having flown the B737....I wonder if it is the same general rudder power system used on the 707.
With that aircraft, an AA 707 in 1960, a rudder hardover resulted in the loss of the airplane, and all aboard, at IDL, now JFK.
Now, on the 707 there is a rudder power switch, right over the Captains head.
Is there a similar switch on the 737?
This rudder hardover scenario was a regular training exercise in the 707 sim.
Seems to me that Boeing should have solved these 737 rudder problems a long time ago.
Now, never having flown the B737....I wonder if it is the same general rudder power system used on the 707.
With that aircraft, an AA 707 in 1960, a rudder hardover resulted in the loss of the airplane, and all aboard, at IDL, now JFK.
Now, on the 707 there is a rudder power switch, right over the Captains head.
Is there a similar switch on the 737?
This rudder hardover scenario was a regular training exercise in the 707 sim.
Seems to me that Boeing should have solved these 737 rudder problems a long time ago.
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 1,693
Likes: 0
From: fairly close to the colonial capitol
Now, on the 707 there is a rudder power switch, right over the Captains head.
Is there a similar switch on the 737?
Is there a similar switch on the 737?
I wonder if it is the same general rudder power system used on the 707.
Boeing says 880 aircraft have been fitted with the "enhanced" rudder system, of which 681 were discovered to have been delivered with "suspect rods".
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 8,571
Likes: 3
From: Arizona USA
Many thanks, vapilot2004, for the information.
Yes, as you mention, the B707 was a single PCU.
There really can't be any valid reason why Boeing hasn't fixed the rudder issues on the 737.
NOT a good scenario.
Yes, as you mention, the B707 was a single PCU.
There really can't be any valid reason why Boeing hasn't fixed the rudder issues on the 737.
NOT a good scenario.
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 416
Likes: 0
From: No one's home...
The rudder hard-over in the 737 was NOT a slight problem but the odd thing was how random it seemed to happen.
The big thing was unloading the airplane and trying to get enough speed so you were above crossover.. where you had enough aileron authority to exceed the roll being created by the rudder hardover. Pulling back increased G, increased crossover speed and decreased your chances of recovery.
It tended to be a very exciting training maneuver even in the simulator. One left with the distinct impression that while you would be able to handle it in cruise, it was not going to be a fun day and you really didn't want to have to deal with it at low pattern altitude.
The big thing was unloading the airplane and trying to get enough speed so you were above crossover.. where you had enough aileron authority to exceed the roll being created by the rudder hardover. Pulling back increased G, increased crossover speed and decreased your chances of recovery.
It tended to be a very exciting training maneuver even in the simulator. One left with the distinct impression that while you would be able to handle it in cruise, it was not going to be a fun day and you really didn't want to have to deal with it at low pattern altitude.
