PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   R44 crashed Alps (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/636375-r44-crashed-alps.html)

[email protected] 3rd Nov 2020 19:59

A summary would be - LTE doesn't really exist and most encounters were caused by pilots being reluctant to put in sufficient pedal to stop the rotation. There are yaw disturbances caused by the interaction of the MR downwash and other turbulent flows.

There, saved you hours of excruciating reading.....


Well (as with SWP) what the FAA taught me about LTE has kept me alive for almost twenty years.
perhaps because the type of flying you are doing isn't very demanding.......

[email protected] 3rd Nov 2020 20:29

As a check of understanding Robbiee - imagine you are operating at MAUM at high density altitude into a landing site where you can't approach into wind, only crosswind - which way do you take the crosswind, from the left or the right?

Robbiee 3rd Nov 2020 21:59


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10918180)
As a check of understanding Robbiee - imagine you are operating at MAUM at high density altitude into a landing site where you can't approach into wind, only crosswind - which way do you take the crosswind, from the left or the right?

Well, I don't know who MAUM is, but having done crosswind approaches from both sides, I guess I'd just pick the side that has the best view of the chicks on the beach.

Robbiee 3rd Nov 2020 22:01


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10918165)
A summary would be - LTE doesn't really exist and most encounters were caused by pilots being reluctant to put in sufficient pedal to stop the rotation. There are yaw disturbances caused by the interaction of the MR downwash and other turbulent flows.

There, saved you hours of excruciating reading.....

perhaps because the type of flying you are doing isn't very demanding.......


Hmm, so again, no new information, just a desire to no longer call it LTE. Yep, that sounds like its worth fifteen pages.

aa777888 4th Nov 2020 02:41

Hate to say it, Robbiee, you and I are usually on the side of goodness and light, but in this case I'm in total agreement with crab!

Open your mind, read the damn article, and get with the program. You have already passed your oral exam, no need to parrot the FAA textbooks. And do a damn Google search for "MAUM" as it relates to flying. Certainly those on the wrong side of the pond ;) have some differences in jargon, but you are an intelligent guy (seriously, you are, you can't fool us), you really don't need to be spoon-fed this stuff, come on!


[email protected] 4th Nov 2020 05:35

Robbiee - Maximum All Up Mass FFS...perhaps you prefer MTOW?

The flippancy of your answer leads me to believe you really don't understand the importance of the question in regard to TR performance and yaw control.

aa777888 - :ok:

Robbiee 4th Nov 2020 12:48


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10918371)
Robbiee - Maximum All Up Mass FFS...perhaps you prefer MTOW?

The flippancy of your answer leads me to believe you really don't understand the importance of the question in regard to TR performance and yaw control.

aa777888 - :ok:

I suppose not. Guess I'm just doomed to spin endlessly. :(

[email protected] 4th Nov 2020 16:58


I suppose not. Guess I'm just doomed to spin endlessly. https://www.pprune.org/images/smilies/sowee.gif
and if you bothered to read the paper, you would know that doesn't happen either.

It would be quite nice once in a while if the seasoned professional pilots (of which there are a large number on here) were actually listened to by the less experienced when knowledge is being imparted. It's for your good not ours as we have 'mostly' learned from our mistakes and close calls.

Robbiee 4th Nov 2020 19:10


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10918757)
and if you bothered to read the paper, you would know that doesn't happen either.

It would be quite nice once in a while if the seasoned professional pilots (of which there are a large number on here) were actually listened to by the less experienced when knowledge is being imparted. It's for your good not ours as we have 'mostly' learned from our mistakes and close calls.

Sorry, oh wise one, your great secret will just have to remain hidden amongst those fifteen sacred pages.

Bell_ringer 4th Nov 2020 19:24


Originally Posted by Robbiee (Post 10918825)
Sorry, oh wise one, your great secret will just have to remain hidden amongst those fifteen sacred pages.

Hopefully you are less flippant with the owners of those 22's you have to haggle down to hire. At least there is only 1 other seat if ego runs out.

Robbiee 4th Nov 2020 19:53


Originally Posted by Bell_ringer (Post 10918835)
Hopefully you are less flippant with the owners of those 22's you have to haggle down to hire. At least there is only 1 other seat if ego runs out.

Well, those 22 owners never tried to convince me that the textbook was wrong while keeping their great truth buried in a book so dull that it makes my VCR owners manual seem like a Penthouse Forum.

,...but please, more melodramatic responses, I really need the distraction from the insanity that is playing out in my neck of the woods these days. :bored:

ApolloHeli 4th Nov 2020 21:48


Originally Posted by Robbiee (Post 10918856)
...but please, more melodramatic responses, I really need the distraction from the insanity that is playing out in my neck of the woods these days. :bored:

Perhaps that paper could be a timely distraction. You don't have to agree with or believe in the findings, but at least the exposure to the perspective that the paper takes on the 'phenomenon' of LTE will broaden your knowledge and approach to flying challenges in the future. It won't do you any harm, but there's a good chance some thought-provoking will entertain the aviator in you.

nomorehelosforme 5th Nov 2020 00:23

Robbie,

You have dug yourself a rather large hole and worse than that have fallen head first in it. Maybe it’s time to get off your high horse and actually take on board some of the proven advice that has been offered to you in recent posts... as a pilot show some form of responsibility!

Robbiee 5th Nov 2020 01:08


Originally Posted by nomorehelosforme (Post 10918980)
Robbie,

You have dug yourself a rather large hole and worse than that have fallen head first in it. Maybe it’s time to get off your high horse and actually take on board some of the proven advice that has been offered to you in recent posts... as a pilot show some form of responsibility!

"Proven advice"? What?,...you mean, "read our awesome fifteen page dissertation on the great LTE secret",...?

Nah, I think I'll just stay on my high horse,...I can check out a lot of cleavage from up here! :ok:

[email protected] 5th Nov 2020 05:43

Nice attitude, perhaps you should consider another forum since there is nothing professional about your approach to flying it seems.

Robbiee 5th Nov 2020 14:41


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10919061)
Nice attitude, perhaps you should consider another forum since there is nothing professional about your approach to flying it seems.

Such melodrama and smugness,...you must be a delight at the pub. :rolleyes:

[email protected] 5th Nov 2020 17:18


Such melodrama and smugness,...you must be a delight at the pub.
but my smugness and melodrama has kept me alive and flying safely for 38 years where as your gash attitude is far more likely to lead you into problems:)

I'm sure they love you at the flying club.................

Robbiee 5th Nov 2020 17:36


Originally Posted by [email protected] (Post 10919574)
but my smugness and melodrama has kept me alive and flying safely for 38 years where as your gash attitude is far more likely to lead you into problems:)

I'm sure they love you at the flying club.................

Hmm, preferring knowledge I gained from a textbook (knowledge which has kept me from crashing for almost twenty years) over some great secret hidden in some abstract paper I found on the internet, is considered "gash",...?

Know what?,...next beer is on me. :}

Torquetalk 5th Nov 2020 19:51


Originally Posted by aa777888 (Post 10916510)
There is plenty of tail rotor authority in the 22

What were the conditions when you had your "LTE" experience?

Great reference paper aa77788.

I think my LTE/unanticipated yaw experience can firmly be placed in the poor aircraft management category as opposed to lack of inherent tail rotor authority. In strong laminar wind I made a lazy clearing turn with right pedal turn and presented the tail rotor directly into wind, with entirely predictable results. Whether there would have been enough authority to reverse the problem is moot, as the first 90 degrees were through so fast, it was clear that a continued turn back into wind was the easiest solution.

The moral of the story was be aware of aircraft limitations and don’t fly daft. I say aircraft limitations because many larger aircraft would have tolerated the same winds without the sudden snap. TR authority is, necessarily related to the aircraft‘s mass and the R22 is a light helicopter.

Torquetalk 5th Nov 2020 20:26

There is a very good video of an R44 down under that gets into all sorts of trouble due to poor management which was attributed to LTE, but isn't really. From a dozy lack of awareness that the aircraft was running out of power, to pretty much losing control took less than 10 seconds. And under stress, the pilot fought the aircraft almost into the sea, before it flew itself out of what had become vortex ring state. The one thing the pilot didn't do was lower the collective, roll on and get airspeed. Lucky. Very, very lucky.

I can't upload my versions of it. But maybe someone has another format (I have non-accepted MPEG & FLV).


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:55.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.