PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Encoding Altimeter rip-off for the Agusta A109E (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/612917-encoding-altimeter-rip-off-agusta-a109e.html)

Dick Smith 3rd Sep 2018 00:51

Encoding Altimeter rip-off for the Agusta A109E
 
It appears my encoding altimeter is faulty and the aircraft manufacturer requires USD $31,000 (AUD $43,152) plus GST to replace the unit. I understand I can get the unit serviced by the instrument manufacturer for AUD $22,584.96 plus GST, plus the cost of return freight to Europe.

All of these amounts are crazy. If I had Garmin equipment fitted I think it is about a $3,000 maximum rate to get a unit fixed.

Does anyone on this thread have any ideas of where I might be able to buy an exchange unit or get the unit serviced at a reasonable price?

I already have the copilot’s attitude indicator blanked off because Rogerson Kratos wanted over $70,000 for a repair – which could have been for a ten cent resistor – and I would rather sell my aircraft and just keep my beautiful LongRanger rather than being ripped off.

What do others think?

Ascend Charlie 3rd Sep 2018 01:25

If you sell it with those items blanked off, will you lose more than the cost of getting them fixed?

The prices for avionics are ridiculous, always have been. It was cheaper to put glass screens into the B206 fleet to make them IFR than to fit steam gauges and overhaul them on a regular basis.

Dick Smith 3rd Sep 2018 01:30

Then surely there must be a lot secondhand steam instruments available at rock bottom prices?

I can can easily afford the repairs by donating less to important causes but I would prefer not to kowtow to these rip off merchants.


9Aplus 3rd Sep 2018 06:44

Do not know about your local avionic paperwork needed, but recently we done facelift of one old fix wing airframe with:
G5+G5+GNS750+GMU11+GAD29B+TT31
Now altitude encoding goes
-over RS232 from G5 to TT31 with full ADSB out
-over CANBus to GAD and than via Airinc 429 to GNS750
Total cost level of $30 k USD

arketip 3rd Sep 2018 07:09


Originally Posted by Dick Smith (Post 10239877)
I can can easily afford the repairs by donating less to important causes but I would prefer not to kowtow to these rip off merchants.

Or you could sell your aeroplanes and helicopter and donate even more.

Ascend Charlie 3rd Sep 2018 07:22

Arketip, what was the point of that comment?

Dick wants to enjoy aviation. He is also a philanthropist of the highest order. To pay for the mods, he would be giving less to charities. So he is looking for a cheaper alternative.

Senior Pilot 3rd Sep 2018 07:23


Originally Posted by arketip (Post 10239980)
Or you could sell your aeroplanes and helicopter and donate even more.

That’s an unworthy comment given Dick’s well known philanthropy :=

https://www.pprune.org/pacific-gener...ght=Dick+smith

Dick Smith 3rd Sep 2018 08:13

Arketip. My concern about the ripp off cost is not for me personally.

I am concerned for the very viability of our industry throughout the world.

I want to see the world helicopter industry thrive. It won’t with these service costs!

Evil Twin 3rd Sep 2018 08:32


Originally Posted by arketip (Post 10239980)
Or you could sell your aeroplanes and helicopter and donate even more.

Ooohhhh, written like a true labour voter

gulliBell 3rd Sep 2018 11:45

Dick, something like this?

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/www.gmf...7f3ec5a343.png

SASless 3rd Sep 2018 15:08


If you sell it with those items blanked off, will you lose more than the cost of getting them fixed?
Perhaps....but the thieving bastards are prevented from having their evil way with you!

At the prices being quoted for the items needing repair....it would seem a full panel re-do with current state of the art kit would be worth considering.

Sometimes you just have to kick in a bit more money but have a far better outcome.

noooby 3rd Sep 2018 16:02

I looked at STC'ing (is that a word?) a complete flight deck for the 109E/S complete with digital autopilot, in partnership with a major avionics installer with EASA/FAA/TCCA certification.

He warned me it wouldn't be cheap. The parts came out at just under CAD$200k.

Plus SPIFR certification. For a market of less than 1000 helicopters. How many of you would be prepared to pay that much for better kit, fully certified? And yes we looked at Garmin too. G1000H at that time was not available to aftermarket, only OEM and Garmin didn't have anything else that was IFR capable for helicopters. Even the new G500H touch screen is 24k per screen and that is just for the screen, not for any of the adapters or other boxes to let it talk to anything else on your machine.

They know how small the market is. And it just isn't worth the hassle for them sometimes.

They also aren't as cheap as you would hope. I have personal experience with replacing the data card for the G1000H after the file was corrupted. The data card is needed for any software updates. Garmin were only too happy to supply a new USB stick with the file on it. For US$34,000.00. For a file. That they don't have to write specially. Just an off the shelf file.

And yet Garmin are eons ahead of Kratos for Customer Service!!!!

I'm still pushing for an STC with an avionic OEM (Astronautics) for the 109E/S to replace the Kratos screens. They're in final testing but it likely won't be certified till Q4/18 or Q1/19.
I feel your pain Dick and we've spoken many times about options. OEM's like Agusta/Bell/Airbus are contractually bound to purchase their avionics from the OEM. They can't shop around. But you can.

To a point. If you install an altimeter that is not listed on the Type Cert, you lose your IFR capability. Unless you submit a mod.

So gullibell, that is a nice altimeter there but you can't install it into a 109. Is it even the right size? 109 instruments are not 3 1/8 inch, they're 2 1/4 inch which makes them even MORE expensive.

The best advice I can give Dick, is let your fingers do the walking. Try these guys. They have feeds from many different sources.

https://www.avspares.com/parts/search?parts=3A432220F05

Good luck!

Dick Smith 4th Sep 2018 09:36

Thanks Nooby Most likely sell and use my Long Ranger which I have now fitted with a really good autopilot!

roscoe1 4th Sep 2018 21:56

Based on my personal experience in getting A109 Kratos instruments repaired, I would avoid buying any model aircraft that relied on them. Total nightmare for a variety of unexplainable reasons.

noooby 4th Sep 2018 23:36

Yep, that was why late model 109E's went to the Astronautics screens. But even they are expensive. US$90k each for a new one!

Dick Smith 5th Sep 2018 00:07

Thanks everyone for your assistance. The part number I am looking for is 3A67.32.20F.05.1.KR manufactured by Thommen Aircraft Equipment.

malabo 5th Sep 2018 07:16

Any word on if/when the G5 will be blanket STC’d for helicopters same as it is for fixed wing? Would like to put one in a 206, can I do that without an STC if it doesn’t replace anything?

9Aplus 5th Sep 2018 12:56

Regarding G5
https://static.garmin.com/pumac/AML-SA01818WI_1710.pdf
https://static.garmin.com/pumac/EASA_10060846_01.pdf
Certification basis is FAR 23
therefore not, at the moment.
One limitation may be the fact that is not possible to adjust zero angle of artificial horizon during the fly,
with non certified G5 that is possible

wrench1 5th Sep 2018 13:31


Originally Posted by Dick Smith (Post 10241530)
Thanks everyone for your assistance. The part number I am looking for is 3A67.32.20F.05.1.KR manufactured by Thommen Aircraft Equipment.

Don't know if this route would be cost-effective to you, but this group has provided good service in the past:
3A67.32.20F.05.1.KR - Precision Aviation Group

Evil Twin 6th Mar 2019 00:09

Just saw this on the vertical site Dick and wondered if it may be of use https://www.verticalmag.com/press-re...ests-on-a-109/


All times are GMT. The time now is 23:31.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.