PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   Identify this helo: Bin Laden compound (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/450511-identify-helo-bin-laden-compound.html)

SansAnhedral 3rd May 2011 15:32

Identify this helo: Bin Laden compound
 
http://img856.imageshack.us/img856/1...90be1e4ac0.jpg

http://img855.imageshack.us/img855/2...90be1e40f0.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/...84_470x423.jpg

saw these in the comments section of AvWeek blogs....supposedly this was the crashed MH60K from the UBL raid.

A 5 bladed TR on a hawk derivative would seem an awfully substantial modification.

Flap 5 3rd May 2011 16:09

How about a Commanche?

RAH-66 Comanche - Reconnaissance/Attack Helicopter - Army Technology

hoodie 3rd May 2011 16:13

That's no fan-in-fin.

Exbat 3rd May 2011 16:21

Have to agree - not a fenestron style hub. Also the tail setion looks strange for an MH60.
Notice the horizontal stab seems to have an angled plan form.
Not got a clue!!! :confused:

eivissa 3rd May 2011 16:27

Another view
 
http://www.spiegel.de/images/image-2...eryV9-nldh.jpg


Update: a little wider angle
http://i54.tinypic.com/hs13tf.jpg

Exbat 3rd May 2011 16:46

Is it just me or do these two photos look different?
Eivissa's appear to have no tail rotor on the top of the fin unlike the one from Sans with the shrouded 5 blader.

SansAnhedral 3rd May 2011 17:10

Stealth Helos Used In Osama Raid

Aser 3rd May 2011 20:48

I would bet for a modified blackhawk or other TRANSPORT helicopter (not comanche), you wouldn't be hovering above the house in a combat helicopter.

Anyway... Amazing!

Regards
Aser

LowObservable 3rd May 2011 21:01

Well, that's easy - it's an...

excuse me, there's someone outside the window with a g

gfsn,zxsdkjng.xdfkhjgn

Senior Pilot 3rd May 2011 22:31

http://www.spiegel.de/images/image-2...eryV9-nldh.jpg

And what's left on the other side of the wall:confused:

:E

Aser 3rd May 2011 23:35

SP,
The picture from the other side...
http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/...04_964x684.jpg
:E

SASless 4th May 2011 00:00

So what is new about "stealth" helicopters being used by the US Armed forces and CIA? There's been a long discussion about this Hughes 500 project that was used in the Vietnam War. Why would the CIA/US Military not continue in those secret efforts.

Air America's Black Helicopter

Dimitris 4th May 2011 00:32

guys I'm not a pilot, but show in some 'forums' that it might have been a decoy to convince Pakistani people that their government really didn't know. Sounds far fetched to be but I'm not flying those things...

birrddog 4th May 2011 01:13

This was NAVY Seal Team 6...

Clearly that is the lower drive unit of one of their rubber duckies outboards....

:8

Mungo5 4th May 2011 02:03

Rotate some of the photo's.. you'll see there seems to be a large fairing or housing round the TRGB, and certainly the 'dinnerplate' is echod on the vertical stab too.

Peter-RB 4th May 2011 05:48

Could be some commanche mated with the 500, to become a super stealth, so steathy that they diddnt hear the other till they mated just above GL, and the result is toasted stealth....??

to quote.. "the answer is out there" didnt this also happen in the Desert of Iran a few Decades ago.?

Peter R-B

mac oz 4th May 2011 06:34

a modify balck-sea hawk

whodictus 4th May 2011 07:05

Has anyone thought of a modifided CH 53 with that size tail boom and 5 bladed TR cann't see it being a Blackhawk.

forget 4th May 2011 08:46


I smell a rat
Can't disagree there. So where are the 'indestructable' bits?

Cows getting bigger 4th May 2011 09:53

Whatever Chuck was driving I'm guessing he needs a little practice on his confined areas. :)

Andy Brandt 4th May 2011 10:08

The plot thickens!
I'm sure the research from the RAH-66 Project didn't go to waste!

311kph 4th May 2011 10:34

Maybe not, but that pile of crap doesn't look like it was once a real aircraft.
Too neat...
This is what it looks like when something stealthy crashes:

http://img231.imageshack.us/img231/5094/f117serbia.jpg
F117 in Serbia, 1999

So, why not use the opportunity and get the competition thinking ...
:yuk:

SASless 4th May 2011 11:08


a modify balck-sea hawk
What....now the Roosians are involved?:eek:

forget 4th May 2011 11:13

851Pilot has nailed it. (But where are the other bits:confused: )

http://www.pprune.org/military-aircr...ml#post6428762

John Eacott 4th May 2011 11:27

311kph,

I read that the wreck was destroyed, most likely thermite grenades or similar. I doubt the F-117 driver in Serbia was in a position to have much to do with his wreckage after he ejected!

FlyHiGuy 4th May 2011 11:33

Something seems fishy !
 
Hello fellow rotor heads. I don't doubt that its possible that some sort of quieting TR has been developed for the H-60 but something seems fishy about these two sets of pics. The one with the mystery 5-bladed hub is taken of an assembly of some sort that is sort of depicted to show it strewn over a wall. This wall is completely different than the wall in the other photos. In addition, the assembly itself seems to be not genuine aviation construction - it almost looks like a welded seam going up what would/could/should be the vertical tail structure. Anyway - the photos that are all over the press show the brick constructed wall and that is clearly an S-70/H-60 tail. It does indeed look like it could be an MH-60K because it has the Naval Hawk's foldable rectangular stabilators in lieu of the more rounded standard Black Hawk stabilator. Just as with the Marine/HMX-1 Presidential VH-60N hybrids, the "Special K's" were made to be shipboard compatible. ANyway - back to the main issue: that odd mystery structure just somehow doesn't seem genuine to me based on the wall - not on the viability of the tail design...Any other POV's welcome though - this is just my first reaction.

Freewheel 4th May 2011 12:15

Whatever it is, I'll bet Lyn Tilton is pissed she missed out on the contract to build it.......:E

Frenchrotorhead 4th May 2011 12:30

The last picture of that "Fenestron" looking thing shows that it is absolutely huge, take a look at the guy to the left and compare...
Also, something strange about the hub, it looks a bit fake.

The line looking like a weld on what we'll call the tail boom seems more like damage to composite structure after a crash than a weld to me.

rabidcat 4th May 2011 13:56

It seems the press agrees that this tail section is 'odd'

Top Secret Stealth Helicopters used in Bin Laden Raid


I am a fledgling pilot with minimal experience and the first time I saw this tail it didn't sit right with me.

Brilliant Stuff 4th May 2011 15:23

Maybe it's a Glider a la World War 2? ;)

trackdirect 4th May 2011 18:03

try this one for size!

Link to dummy image created to troll!

Shawn Coyle 4th May 2011 18:03

Since this is a rumour network, I'd heard a rumour from a very well placed source that the US Army special ops folks had some stealth Blackhawks since - are you ready for this? - the mid '80s....
Nice to see they were able to keep 'em quiet for that long.
I can only wonder what wonderous sights those boys have seen.

hotzenplotz 4th May 2011 19:46

It's hard to believe that these super-duper-specops guys forget to clean up their mess properly.

birrddog 4th May 2011 19:57

Trac, since when did Eurocopter make Blackhawks? ;)

Maybe the pilot kicked in left instead of right pedal :-)

(assuming the rotors as shown in that drawing turn "the wrong way")

hotzenplotz 4th May 2011 20:18

http://www.abload.de/img/dybhqkx08.jpg

http://www.abload.de/img/rxvqmnbuh.jpg

Aser 4th May 2011 20:39

another interesting link
Active Sensors | NASA SELECTS ACTIVE SENSORS RVDT?S FOR LATEST BLACKHAWK STEALTH PROJECT

Regards
Aser

rabidcat 4th May 2011 21:27

So, now that we established they are likely stealthy blackhawks... The next question is, was this a 'mechanical failure' or did that thing get blown on to the wire topped fence when they destroyed the thing? Kinda hints at a tail strike...
Anyone? Mr. Coyle?

SansAnhedral 4th May 2011 21:51

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/...-assau-005.jpg

You can clearly see a standard S70/UH60 series pitch horn in this picture, just slightly left of center.

http://www.aircraftresourcecenter.co...Spenard/12.jpg

AdamFrisch 4th May 2011 22:23

Images are legit and come from numerous news agencies. So I guess it must be true.

rabidcat 4th May 2011 22:25

Just wanted to add, and yes it's totally off topic, but his million dollar mansion looks like a hovel. The construction is shoddy and there is a real lack of landscaping or any kind of flair to that place. Too much living in caves I guess... And for all of the trouble of big walls and privacy fencing, there sure seems a lack of security or true fortification to this place. After all, we did land at least one blackhawk in it. It will be interesting to see what else is revealed about this hovel of a compound. Makes me really wonder how much he relied on Paki intel for his early warning system. Just glad he's dead, God Bless America and the troops :ok:


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:54.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.