PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Rotorheads (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads-23/)
-   -   German Police MD 902 Crash (https://www.pprune.org/rotorheads/401826-german-police-md-902-crash.html)

skadi 12th Jan 2010 16:49

German Police MD 902 Crash
 
Another MD 902 of the Police of Lower Saxony, Germany was destroyed while on a training mission. The crash happened in the Hannover area near Elze. The crew of three were lucky again, only minor injuries.

Pics: Polizeihubschrauber verunglückt in der Wedemark Mediathek / HAZ - Hannoversche Allgemeine

skadi

Shawn Coyle 12th Jan 2010 18:07

And not a MD900 / 902 simulator in sight anywhere...

ab33t 12th Jan 2010 18:19

whats happening here, another one?

SilsoeSid 12th Jan 2010 18:54

Please can you add 'Germany' to the thread title.
:ok:

http://www.haz.de/var/storage/images...imagelarge.jpg

http://www.haz.de/var/storage/images...imagelarge.jpg

Fortyodd2 12th Jan 2010 19:06

Good to see the cockpit and cabin intact :ok: - the rest will polish out!!

RVDT 12th Jan 2010 19:26


And not a MD900 / 902 simulator in sight anywhere...
For about 50 helicopters and not much prospect of any more??

S76Heavy 12th Jan 2010 19:39

Certainly getting fewer and fewer this way..:}

Ian Corrigible 12th Jan 2010 20:14

Glad the crew are okay. I guess Rotorcraft Pro will have to revisit its 'interesting' claim from last January that "...the Explorer’s safety record [is] hands down the best in the industry..." :E

I/C

borjaracing 12th Jan 2010 20:44

Murphy's laws up your ****
 
I´m really glad they walked away. However something is starting to bother me a lot. Looks like this year is starting with way too many accidents, don't you think?.

I just hope that the :mad: holes of the :mad: cheese are not trying to line up and play us a bad joke :uhoh:. I don't know whether is plain bud luck, complacency, pressure factors because of the crisis :ugh: or all added up, but something smells really bad.

You stay safe up there for God's sake.

P.S. Sorry for the language, I'm in a bad mood today

peterprobe 12th Jan 2010 21:32

Chuffed they all got out OK!! A good indicator of the machines toughness. Before it all starts..... those exploders are good machines and safe, well as safe as any thing that flies. Please don't let us turn this into a ewwwwwwww MD are not safe issue/rumour. I only know of two ( in germany as it happens, probably by bad luck nothing more) and no one has been killed, so that to me means BINGO well made whirly thing.:ok:

DeltaNg 12th Jan 2010 21:40

There are more than two that have gone down.

peterprobe 12th Jan 2010 22:04

Are there? when were they then ? I honestly do not know of others

Shawn Coyle 12th Jan 2010 22:06

If memory serves me right, in the FW world of larger aircraft, there's one simulator for about every 30 airplanes...
Why are we so far behind?

DeltaNg 12th Jan 2010 22:27

peterprobe: B2116 is the most serious of note, a Chinese marine pilot transfer operation, which I believe crashed with 3 fatalities. following an anti-torque malfunction.

Griffin-helicopters have an excellent accident database, have a look, there are a few 900/902 incidents.

Griffin Helicopters | Accident Database

MightyGem 12th Jan 2010 22:35

Glad they got out OK. Tricky things, snowlandings.

mfriskel 13th Jan 2010 01:19

Interesting the the rotor head is laying next to the machine, relatively intact with all blades attached albiet broken.
It looks like the static mast was pulled right out (or broken) of the mast support. I have only heard of that 3 times, once in an IAF Apache, once in a special ops MH-6 and now possibly this machine.
Does anyone know what type of training maneuver they were attempting?
Mark

Downupside 13th Jan 2010 06:09

Another one in 2004 in Japan.
See http://www.mlit.go.jp/jtsb/eng-air_report/JA6757.pdf
Pretty interesting as well
Kami

wallsend 13th Jan 2010 10:04

A quick look at the Griffin Helicopters accident database suggested above shows five 902 accidents with no fatalities. The same database shows 17 EC135 accidents including 7 involving fatalities. I don't know how comprehensive this database is, but it puts this latest accident in perspective before we start making assumptions about the 902's safety record.

hueyracer 13th Jan 2010 10:30

All companies are reducing flight hours-especially all governmental helo operators are near at the absolute minimum...

Rumours are spreading, that they got into white out conditions prior crashing...
Other rumours say that the pilot had just a few hundert hours-and had been involved in another crash just a few years ago...
(I think that they maybe swap something...maybe the P(F) had only a few hours-and maybe the other P(NF) (IP?) had been involved in an accident....)?


We will have to wait for more (proofed) details....

DeltaNg 13th Jan 2010 10:57

wallsend: It must have been a quick look at the database as the chinese aircraft involved 3 fatalities.

If you are going to start your own EC135 comparison, you should calculate your statistic in percentages as the numbers of 135 vs 902 in the world are very different with a ratio of at least 5:1.

An aircraft has crashed and all survived - nobody has made any comparisons between this and any other aircraft, the thread has merely opened up (understandably - and always happens regardless of type) a look at the aircrafts incident history. Nobody has suggested the aircraft is unsafe or otherwise.


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:35.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.