Sporty autos
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Ecton
Age: 71
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One of the problems seems to be that teaching pilots to fly safely is seen as boring and it does not feed the egotistical needs of some. The UK has an exceptional level of safe helicopter pilot training, which is the result of sound knowledge, good instructional technique combined with a strong ethos of flight safety, what is being exported is in my opinion down right irresponsible. This is pure "look at me" flying which is paramount to teaching pilots to fly the helicopter outside of the procedures within the POH, as mentioned by topedtorque; what insures think of this type of training would be interesting. This does nothing other than increase the accident rates and increase your insurance costs.
I have been conducting training in Russia for many years and hear constantly how Russian pilots are being encouraged to ignore the HV diagram by a UK pilot.
Keep your RPM in the green
D
I have been conducting training in Russia for many years and hear constantly how Russian pilots are being encouraged to ignore the HV diagram by a UK pilot.
Keep your RPM in the green
D
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Ross-on-Wye
Posts: 282
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
EOL Handling
Dear Dick,
You know I have the utmost respect for your professional words and the superb safety training and information you bring to our industry and for what my judgement is worth, in recent years, the Robinson record has been vastly improved in no small way due to your personal involvement.
BUT ... and there's always a but! It has to be the way of humans to want to investigate and explore any difficult area of human handling. Hence we have F1 racing, the Everest climbers, the Chuck Yeagers of the world who made the first supersonic flights and made Concorde possible, or the 'Round the World' fliers, the top class Rally Drivers ... and I can go on and on as we all can. You will know I taught the skills of flying to my 18-year old son but who was later lost in a helicopter that broke up in flight. Ours is an unforgiving industry. His mother never forgave me.
I don't want to overly mention display flying, especially in view of my own record ... but that discipline (either fixed wing or rotary) is a challenging and rewarding area of aviation and adds an upward notch to pilot skill levels and as we all know, such flying is hugely enjoyable for the general public and an area of flying I enjoy absolutely.
So bearing in mind, the most important aspect in flying and the other similar disciplines, is safety ... should we seek to ban such sports. Dick, I don't have the answer. In fact I've just completed an article for FLYER that seeks to invite discussion on this very subject. Would you say F1 racing or Rally Driving is responsible in any way for the number of accidents and loss of life on our roads?
All I can say is that in my 40 years of display flying, covering over 1300 displays, I've received nothing but supportive comments from the public and also from much of the aviation industry. Having said that, I have discussed the matter with many highly professional individuals such as yourself and there are more than a few highly qualified FIs/FEs who echo your thoughts. Indeed, one FE has suggested, such display flying brings a 'Cavalier' attitude to the discipline we need to teach in flying training ... something I don't really want to hear, but I would be interested to hear the views of other experienced pilots from across the pond.
Dick, the only conclusion I have come to is ... If my Salt Lake City episode should be followed by an unreasonable number of copycat accidents in our industry, then yes, perhaps the time has come to call a halt to rotary display flying. But then, are we saying we should similarly ban a highly skilled pilot whose skill levels allow him to complete a safe reverse autorotation with a 180 degree yaw pedal turn in the final flare for a rearward touch down. Nothing in that sequence violates the PFM. I can't do that manoeuvre, but I couldn't support those who would seek to stop him doing so.
I go back to the 1972 days when that wonderful pilot KD at Fairoaks Aerodrome first demonstrated a standard Bell 47 autorotation to the ground, after which he had enough rotor inertia and handling skill to lift off again for a 360 degree turn and final skids-on touch down. I can't do that one either! But, and another but ... should we ban that manoeuvre for our future pilots?
Do novice climbers rush off to Nepal to make an ascent to the summit of Everest just because the professional can do it. Aren't we talking about a better perception of the skill levels being handed down by our flying instructors? I don't have the answer Dick, but will listen avidly to the further comments from other top professionals who inhabit this site.
Safe flying to all. Dennis K.
PS. It's a 40 knot day and I'm grounded so forgive the rambling!
You know I have the utmost respect for your professional words and the superb safety training and information you bring to our industry and for what my judgement is worth, in recent years, the Robinson record has been vastly improved in no small way due to your personal involvement.
BUT ... and there's always a but! It has to be the way of humans to want to investigate and explore any difficult area of human handling. Hence we have F1 racing, the Everest climbers, the Chuck Yeagers of the world who made the first supersonic flights and made Concorde possible, or the 'Round the World' fliers, the top class Rally Drivers ... and I can go on and on as we all can. You will know I taught the skills of flying to my 18-year old son but who was later lost in a helicopter that broke up in flight. Ours is an unforgiving industry. His mother never forgave me.
I don't want to overly mention display flying, especially in view of my own record ... but that discipline (either fixed wing or rotary) is a challenging and rewarding area of aviation and adds an upward notch to pilot skill levels and as we all know, such flying is hugely enjoyable for the general public and an area of flying I enjoy absolutely.
So bearing in mind, the most important aspect in flying and the other similar disciplines, is safety ... should we seek to ban such sports. Dick, I don't have the answer. In fact I've just completed an article for FLYER that seeks to invite discussion on this very subject. Would you say F1 racing or Rally Driving is responsible in any way for the number of accidents and loss of life on our roads?
All I can say is that in my 40 years of display flying, covering over 1300 displays, I've received nothing but supportive comments from the public and also from much of the aviation industry. Having said that, I have discussed the matter with many highly professional individuals such as yourself and there are more than a few highly qualified FIs/FEs who echo your thoughts. Indeed, one FE has suggested, such display flying brings a 'Cavalier' attitude to the discipline we need to teach in flying training ... something I don't really want to hear, but I would be interested to hear the views of other experienced pilots from across the pond.
Dick, the only conclusion I have come to is ... If my Salt Lake City episode should be followed by an unreasonable number of copycat accidents in our industry, then yes, perhaps the time has come to call a halt to rotary display flying. But then, are we saying we should similarly ban a highly skilled pilot whose skill levels allow him to complete a safe reverse autorotation with a 180 degree yaw pedal turn in the final flare for a rearward touch down. Nothing in that sequence violates the PFM. I can't do that manoeuvre, but I couldn't support those who would seek to stop him doing so.
I go back to the 1972 days when that wonderful pilot KD at Fairoaks Aerodrome first demonstrated a standard Bell 47 autorotation to the ground, after which he had enough rotor inertia and handling skill to lift off again for a 360 degree turn and final skids-on touch down. I can't do that one either! But, and another but ... should we ban that manoeuvre for our future pilots?
Do novice climbers rush off to Nepal to make an ascent to the summit of Everest just because the professional can do it. Aren't we talking about a better perception of the skill levels being handed down by our flying instructors? I don't have the answer Dick, but will listen avidly to the further comments from other top professionals who inhabit this site.
Safe flying to all. Dennis K.
PS. It's a 40 knot day and I'm grounded so forgive the rambling!
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Ecton
Age: 71
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dennis. I am sorry to hear that you are twiddling your thumbs due to the inclement weather, BUT, and there is as you say always a 'but' it has afforded you the time to pen a very thought provoking response, thank you.
I am not even going to suggest I can comprehend the impact the loss of your son must have had. I can only say that it directly effected my thoughts on the possibility of my son becoming a helicopter pilot. We (my son and I) talked about it and I was reasonably happy to teach him to fly but I am not sure if I could have got out of the helicopter and sent him solo.
It is late here in Borneo and my glass of red is evaporating so I will just respond with a quick thought.
I agree that display flying has its place in the industry and your displays have done nothing but present the helicopter in the finest traditions of aviation and I applaud you for that. I am sure there are a lot of pilots today that are pilots because they have seen your performances.
But, display is display, what we currently have is far from that.
We have a situation where pilots of unknown skill/experience levels are being taught these manoeuvres without any checks or balances, they are being taught that the HV diagram is a nonsense, where in the POH does it talk about landing the helicopter backwards from an autorotation?
As you know a display pilot has to be checked out and the routine has to be approved and forgive me if I am wrong but the display pilot is not authorised to teach other pilots to conduct the display manoeuvres.
A display pilot requires a greater level of discipline, what is the old saying? "Do not try this at home"
I look forward to reading your article, I will add to this thread tomorrow.
Dennis before I sign off, I would like to thank you personally for your truly outstanding contribution to the helicopter world.
Take care, keep your RPM in the green
D
I am not even going to suggest I can comprehend the impact the loss of your son must have had. I can only say that it directly effected my thoughts on the possibility of my son becoming a helicopter pilot. We (my son and I) talked about it and I was reasonably happy to teach him to fly but I am not sure if I could have got out of the helicopter and sent him solo.
It is late here in Borneo and my glass of red is evaporating so I will just respond with a quick thought.
I agree that display flying has its place in the industry and your displays have done nothing but present the helicopter in the finest traditions of aviation and I applaud you for that. I am sure there are a lot of pilots today that are pilots because they have seen your performances.
But, display is display, what we currently have is far from that.
We have a situation where pilots of unknown skill/experience levels are being taught these manoeuvres without any checks or balances, they are being taught that the HV diagram is a nonsense, where in the POH does it talk about landing the helicopter backwards from an autorotation?
As you know a display pilot has to be checked out and the routine has to be approved and forgive me if I am wrong but the display pilot is not authorised to teach other pilots to conduct the display manoeuvres.
A display pilot requires a greater level of discipline, what is the old saying? "Do not try this at home"
I look forward to reading your article, I will add to this thread tomorrow.
Dennis before I sign off, I would like to thank you personally for your truly outstanding contribution to the helicopter world.
Take care, keep your RPM in the green
D
Dick
A lot of us spend a lot of time in the HV curve( dead man's curve when I first started) when long lining. Virtually all utility flying operates in the HV curve, our American cousins call it the money curve. While I don't disagree with you that teaching the HV curve is nonsense too much emphasis maybe put on it, as you are the first to tell us that R22 engines for example are very reliable, I am sure I have seen that 90% of crashes are pilot error. With that in mind is the HV curve a kick back to when engines failed on a regular basis ???
A lot of us spend a lot of time in the HV curve( dead man's curve when I first started) when long lining. Virtually all utility flying operates in the HV curve, our American cousins call it the money curve. While I don't disagree with you that teaching the HV curve is nonsense too much emphasis maybe put on it, as you are the first to tell us that R22 engines for example are very reliable, I am sure I have seen that 90% of crashes are pilot error. With that in mind is the HV curve a kick back to when engines failed on a regular basis ???
Helicopters auto fine backwards
Don't drop the soap.
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Ecton
Age: 71
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Correct, I do not 'do' long line and helicopters auto backwards just fine.
My error, i did not explain my point on the avoid curve very well.
The point I was making was the fact that the Russian pilots are being taught throttle chops in the avoid area and the result of this is that they are lead to assume that it is not an area with an increase in risk, which is wrong.
Helicopters autorotate backwards very well and I use to demonstrate the fact often, however, landing the thing requires the pilot to be facing the direction of travel and the curvy bits are at the front for a reason.
Hillberg, I stopped having a bath for that reason, I now have a shower and use shower gel.
Keep your RPM in the green
D
My error, i did not explain my point on the avoid curve very well.
The point I was making was the fact that the Russian pilots are being taught throttle chops in the avoid area and the result of this is that they are lead to assume that it is not an area with an increase in risk, which is wrong.
Helicopters autorotate backwards very well and I use to demonstrate the fact often, however, landing the thing requires the pilot to be facing the direction of travel and the curvy bits are at the front for a reason.
Hillberg, I stopped having a bath for that reason, I now have a shower and use shower gel.
Keep your RPM in the green
D
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: q.l.d
Posts: 56
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Dennis all I can say is holy **** , i wasn't going to post ,I have been sitting on my own replaying your story in my head and feel I have to say you have paid more than anyone I know .
As for the Russians , go hard it looks awesome regardless of a practical requirement or the you shouldn't do that approach , I take my hat off and bow .
Once again Dennis your story will remain with me always.
Just a lonely mustering pilot ,
Nathan
As for the Russians , go hard it looks awesome regardless of a practical requirement or the you shouldn't do that approach , I take my hat off and bow .
Once again Dennis your story will remain with me always.
Just a lonely mustering pilot ,
Nathan
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: hayling island
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Both Dennis and Dick are Leg ends, its great to here the story from both sides.
Let's hope everyone else learns something from this!
We are in and industry that is constantly in the spotlight lets keep it safe, but we still got to have fun, because I and many others have always said if your not enjoying yourself whats the point.
Let's hope everyone else learns something from this!
We are in and industry that is constantly in the spotlight lets keep it safe, but we still got to have fun, because I and many others have always said if your not enjoying yourself whats the point.
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Ross-on-Wye
Posts: 282
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For Nathan
Many, many thanks for your warm words Nathan ... so very much appreciated ... and to take on a more serious note.
As some pruners will know, and as I prepare to retire from helicopter aviation, I like to put my thoughts into words and see other pilots and rotary aviation people become involved in the more contentious aspects of rotary handling. But coping with the loss of my son and later his mum, became the most difficult thing I've had to tackle in my lifetime and in forty years working in this sometimes mad industry. At the time I received so much support from the guys and a few gals out there I've known and often flown with. I'm not even sure I ever formally thanked you all ... something I want to do now. In the nicest way ... I love you all.
But with glass in our hand, let's get back to the main thread ... who's for a jaunty autorotation or two? DRK.
As some pruners will know, and as I prepare to retire from helicopter aviation, I like to put my thoughts into words and see other pilots and rotary aviation people become involved in the more contentious aspects of rotary handling. But coping with the loss of my son and later his mum, became the most difficult thing I've had to tackle in my lifetime and in forty years working in this sometimes mad industry. At the time I received so much support from the guys and a few gals out there I've known and often flown with. I'm not even sure I ever formally thanked you all ... something I want to do now. In the nicest way ... I love you all.
But with glass in our hand, let's get back to the main thread ... who's for a jaunty autorotation or two? DRK.
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: hayling island
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Did it once Dennis by mistake, lucky to get away with it.
My student and I were completing low level engine off's in a Hughes 269 and for some reason on the last one of the day he suddenly put in full left pedal instead of right, before I knew it we were flying low level backwards and just about to touch the ground so kept the flare and just pulled up the collective.
The tail rotor was not very effective in the early 269's and I consider it a lucky escape as we did slide along a little bit on the turned up part of the skid.
I remember the student getting all excited and wanting to do another auto, but I said that was enough for me, never did find out why he just put in the wrong pedal on that auto.
So I feel been there got the T shirt, its not for me, now a days if there was an incident even if minor, dont think you would have a leg to stand on any how.
The FAA has the right idea, they do auto's to the hover and they have far fewer incidents than we do in Europe, ie a perfectly serviceable helicopter written off in an EOL practice.
My student and I were completing low level engine off's in a Hughes 269 and for some reason on the last one of the day he suddenly put in full left pedal instead of right, before I knew it we were flying low level backwards and just about to touch the ground so kept the flare and just pulled up the collective.
The tail rotor was not very effective in the early 269's and I consider it a lucky escape as we did slide along a little bit on the turned up part of the skid.
I remember the student getting all excited and wanting to do another auto, but I said that was enough for me, never did find out why he just put in the wrong pedal on that auto.
So I feel been there got the T shirt, its not for me, now a days if there was an incident even if minor, dont think you would have a leg to stand on any how.
The FAA has the right idea, they do auto's to the hover and they have far fewer incidents than we do in Europe, ie a perfectly serviceable helicopter written off in an EOL practice.
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Ross-on-Wye
Posts: 282
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
EOLs
Yes Tim ... I certainly understand the FAA stance on 'skid-on' practice autos.
I suppose you've got to say that any accident that occurs as a result of practicing the emergency, has to absolutely unforgiveable. In my Royal Air Force days, we had the same problem with the Canberra B2 which was notoriously difficult on a single engine 'go-around.' Called overshoot in those days! The Squadrons were losing more aircraft during practice than following actual engine failures. I think something similar was happening with the Gloster Meteor. Best wishes to all. DRK
I suppose you've got to say that any accident that occurs as a result of practicing the emergency, has to absolutely unforgiveable. In my Royal Air Force days, we had the same problem with the Canberra B2 which was notoriously difficult on a single engine 'go-around.' Called overshoot in those days! The Squadrons were losing more aircraft during practice than following actual engine failures. I think something similar was happening with the Gloster Meteor. Best wishes to all. DRK
