RNZAF Helicopter Crash near Wellington, April 2010 - 3 Killed
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Beside the seaside
Posts: 670
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is a time and a place for a 'can do' attitude and pre-positioning for a ANZAC day fly-past is neither. A bit more of the 'no can do' attitude that day might have saved them.
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Florida/Sandbox/UK
Posts: 324
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I beg to differ.
"Can do", and "No can do", are frames of mind that determine how every job is approached. The flypast was obviously a big deal, and they wanted it to happen. The "Can do" approach got them in the air in the middle of the night to try to make that important day a little more special.
I have no doubt that the weather risks were assessed and perceived as acceptable by the formation leader, all crews in the formation and the authorising officer.
Yes, your 20/20 hindsight provides you with wisdom that was not available that morning. I don't think that is a reason to change the attitude of an Air Force to one that says "No can do".
Tam
"Can do", and "No can do", are frames of mind that determine how every job is approached. The flypast was obviously a big deal, and they wanted it to happen. The "Can do" approach got them in the air in the middle of the night to try to make that important day a little more special.
I have no doubt that the weather risks were assessed and perceived as acceptable by the formation leader, all crews in the formation and the authorising officer.
Yes, your 20/20 hindsight provides you with wisdom that was not available that morning. I don't think that is a reason to change the attitude of an Air Force to one that says "No can do".
Tam
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Beside the seaside
Posts: 670
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I beg to differ.
The problem that I see with the 'can do' attitude is that once committed it doesn't leave much option for retreat. This formation does not appear to have given much thought to that or how to recover safely from IIMC.
I also somehow doubt that the families of the crew were very happy to read the following which could also be described as a 'can do' attitude.
The Defence Force's court of inquiry, released today, into the accident found sub-standard protocols and a culture of "rule breaking" among 3 Squadron was partly to blame.
In the US Army....IIMC recovery was part of our formation flight SOP's as far back as 1968....and I am sure every military aviation organization that flies formation has an SOP, that while not necessarily briefed prior to each formation flight, remains in the individual Aviator's Kitbag of Knowledge.
It does make one question why the positioning flight was not made the day before in the daylight...or in better weather...if the fly by was that important.
It does make one question why the positioning flight was not made the day before in the daylight...or in better weather...if the fly by was that important.
Join Date: May 2010
Location: New Zealand
Age: 52
Posts: 395
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sas and epiphany, I tend to agree, for a couple of reasons. I also agree that the can do attitude is what makes us New Zealanders, and as long as it doesn't kill us, we either get the job done or learn a great lesson.
It's one of the reasons Sir Ed Hillary conquered Everest!
Unfortunately when it does kill us then we can only hope that others learn from our mistakes. As my instructor said, learn from others mistakes, you won't live long enough to make them all yourself...
Having said that, April 25 doesn't sneak up on us any year, we know that we have dawn parades, we know that the military do fly pasts. I can also tell you that when we, being helicopter pilots, in New Zealand heard that a machine was missing in the fog, we all remembered the weather forecasts from the night before, or infact the few days before, and said of course someone has gone missing, the weather had been marginal for at least a couple of days and the forecast was crap. The military have a base in Wellington, why not go there, I guess that's the question that will always be asked. I hope that they use those options in the future.
It's one of the reasons Sir Ed Hillary conquered Everest!
Unfortunately when it does kill us then we can only hope that others learn from our mistakes. As my instructor said, learn from others mistakes, you won't live long enough to make them all yourself...
Having said that, April 25 doesn't sneak up on us any year, we know that we have dawn parades, we know that the military do fly pasts. I can also tell you that when we, being helicopter pilots, in New Zealand heard that a machine was missing in the fog, we all remembered the weather forecasts from the night before, or infact the few days before, and said of course someone has gone missing, the weather had been marginal for at least a couple of days and the forecast was crap. The military have a base in Wellington, why not go there, I guess that's the question that will always be asked. I hope that they use those options in the future.
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: England
Posts: 576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
An update from the New Zealand Herald;
Officer charged over Anzac Day chopper crash - National - NZ Herald News
Officer charged over Anzac Day chopper crash - National - NZ Herald News
I see it in PNG all the time, Kiwi pilots doing stuff that others wouldn't. Which I guess is part of the reason why Kiwi pilots are so much in favor with the PNG employers (i.e. not many Aussies left in PNG any more).
SuperF,
Best one yet!
Sad but true.
Best one yet!
Sad but true.
Last edited by RVDT; 5th Mar 2013 at 06:43.
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Sale, Australia
Age: 80
Posts: 3,832
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Kiwi pilots doing stuff that others wouldn't.
