Ok here we go light blue touch paper.........
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: uk
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok here we go light blue touch paper.........
Once again post pub night with ex mil mates another debate especially as it is POETS day and even I cant slide off this early.... with the boss still in!!!!.
One oil rig driver (capt) one HEMS driver (capt obviously) me a **** all driver but desk at the mo, a few pints and the debate starts. Why the HUGE difference in pay. Oil equals money clearly but when they actually got talking (on edge of fistymacuffs haha) about the ins and outs of daily jobs I was tending to lean with the HEMS mate.
Round one, no IR yes but single pilot sometimes in **** weather with loads of pressure to get job done, must be able to do limited IR in case of inadvertant IMC etc. Off shore mate fights back with crap weather, limited options over sea, company pressure for revenue flights etc ding ding.
Round two, Hems mate comes out fighting with no idea where your going to go on every job, managing banging round some parts of very clustered busy airspace etc etc, Rigs fights back with night pitching deck and 19 smelly oil rig workers who need to be somewhere or company getting big hit. HEMS comes back with small jab that some companies do HEMS at night with Police (not his). Ding ding.
Round three was mine but I am cheap and the bar was about to shut so we left.
I await your debate gents.......................
One oil rig driver (capt) one HEMS driver (capt obviously) me a **** all driver but desk at the mo, a few pints and the debate starts. Why the HUGE difference in pay. Oil equals money clearly but when they actually got talking (on edge of fistymacuffs haha) about the ins and outs of daily jobs I was tending to lean with the HEMS mate.
Round one, no IR yes but single pilot sometimes in **** weather with loads of pressure to get job done, must be able to do limited IR in case of inadvertant IMC etc. Off shore mate fights back with crap weather, limited options over sea, company pressure for revenue flights etc ding ding.
Round two, Hems mate comes out fighting with no idea where your going to go on every job, managing banging round some parts of very clustered busy airspace etc etc, Rigs fights back with night pitching deck and 19 smelly oil rig workers who need to be somewhere or company getting big hit. HEMS comes back with small jab that some companies do HEMS at night with Police (not his). Ding ding.
Round three was mine but I am cheap and the bar was about to shut so we left.
I await your debate gents.......................
As one of the
I'd be inclined to go with your HEMS mate too.
Although I might be a little biased, as, for the second time in two weeks our bus drivers took the Cooks Tour and tried to deliver their pax to a location we left seven weeks ago.
smelly oil rig workers
Although I might be a little biased, as, for the second time in two weeks our bus drivers took the Cooks Tour and tried to deliver their pax to a location we left seven weeks ago.
It's a simple matter of of time and money.
In touring offshore, we spend so little of our time actually at work that we need more money to spend in our time off.
HEMS guys are constantly at work or on standby and have no opportunity to spend a large salary, therefore they get less.
Easy when you think about it!
P1
In touring offshore, we spend so little of our time actually at work that we need more money to spend in our time off.
HEMS guys are constantly at work or on standby and have no opportunity to spend a large salary, therefore they get less.
Easy when you think about it!
P1
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 321
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why the HUGE difference in pay.
Tightgit
Can the oil business in the N Sea survive without helicopters?
Can the ambulance business survive without helicopters?
Can the oil business afford lots of money?
Can the charities that pay for air ambulances afford lots of money?
Oops, too slow
Can the ambulance business survive without helicopters?
Can the oil business afford lots of money?
Can the charities that pay for air ambulances afford lots of money?
Oops, too slow
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: uk
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's a simple matter of of time and money.
In touring offshore, we spend so little of our time actually at work that we need more money to spend in our time off.
HEMS guys are constantly at work or on standby and have no opportunity to spend a large salary, therefore they get less.
Easy when you think about it!
In touring offshore, we spend so little of our time actually at work that we need more money to spend in our time off.
HEMS guys are constantly at work or on standby and have no opportunity to spend a large salary, therefore they get less.
Easy when you think about it!
P1
That my friend is a beauty hehe I will steal that and use it next time we meet for a few beers............. then run like **** before HEMS mate launches me over the bar.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Over here
Posts: 1,030
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
All the above. Most companies only pay what they have to, in order to hire qualified workers. As long as pilots are willing to work for low wages, low pay will continue, and I see no trend toward holding out for more money. Indeed, there is an endless supply of low-time pilots willing to work for little or no pay. The oil companies are making so much money that they have to spend a lot of it, and they don't care what the helicopters cost, so there is plenty of money for everyone. A couple of years ago we discovered that one of the major oil companies doesn't even bother to break out helicopter expenses as a separate item in their budget, it's just a miscellaneous expense, paid from petty cash as it were, even though they were paying ~$1 million per month. When your net profit is on the order of $100 billion per year, a few quid per pilot per month is negligible.
Having done both jobs, I have to say there is no other explanation for the difference in pay. Offshore, you have more capable equipment and two pilots. IFR is easier than VFR when the weather is less than perfect. In US EMS, you're doing night approaches to unprepared accident scenes single-pilot, in marginally powered aircraft, but most of your time is spent watching TV or reading PPRuNe, and you only have to do it a couple of hours per week, so I guess it all averages out somehow.
Having done both jobs, I have to say there is no other explanation for the difference in pay. Offshore, you have more capable equipment and two pilots. IFR is easier than VFR when the weather is less than perfect. In US EMS, you're doing night approaches to unprepared accident scenes single-pilot, in marginally powered aircraft, but most of your time is spent watching TV or reading PPRuNe, and you only have to do it a couple of hours per week, so I guess it all averages out somehow.
This is all so....well mercenary....what happened to just flying for the sheer love of it? Any pay is just icing on the cake!
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: UK.
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ok this is for free.....Peterprobe,this is just for YOUR mates.......
If the ex-mil guys with their mil pensions would hold out for more or say they won't accept that sort of pay for Hems, then Hems would have to pay more benefiting everyone who flies EMS......I know it's a charity run thing, but they could afford more....Simple really........
And before we start, No, I do not fly Hems so it is not personal, no I do not want to fly for the military nor wished I had,yes I thank them for going abroad and risking their lives as I wouldn't for this Government (unless someone invaded the UK)!!! Yes, I do know ex-mil guys who accepted the lower wages saying that their pensions topped up their pay...I just feel for the civvie guys who are paid less because of the ex mil who keep the wages lower....
Tell them that and then Duck under the table....................
Cheers............
If the ex-mil guys with their mil pensions would hold out for more or say they won't accept that sort of pay for Hems, then Hems would have to pay more benefiting everyone who flies EMS......I know it's a charity run thing, but they could afford more....Simple really........
And before we start, No, I do not fly Hems so it is not personal, no I do not want to fly for the military nor wished I had,yes I thank them for going abroad and risking their lives as I wouldn't for this Government (unless someone invaded the UK)!!! Yes, I do know ex-mil guys who accepted the lower wages saying that their pensions topped up their pay...I just feel for the civvie guys who are paid less because of the ex mil who keep the wages lower....
Tell them that and then Duck under the table....................
Cheers............
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: uk
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mate chill, I put this on here as a currently serving bloke after listening to mates in a pub!!!
Firstly don't blame the mil and ex mil for having a pension they earned their pension as does anyone inculding yourself I am sure by working for a company/military for the required time to earn that pension. If you did 12/20/22 years with the same company from about age 17 or 18 and decided to do something else so so what? Your pension is yours as a Brucey bonus and the company employing you should not rely on your pension. If they do don't work for the feckers, and if you say they don't pay that much because of all the ex mil people floating about taking these lower paid jobs because the have pension in bag so what!!! They earned it you can hardly blame a company either as the will take on the people with the skill set they require for a wage they are happy with. Think that is called buisness but not my field so not sure. Not that I know
but having just spoken to my HEMS mate it is an industry wide prob not an individual company prob and funny old thing airlines have a different wage scheme hmmmmmmm why is that. My original post was light hearted and supposed to be as I was (in the pub you understand) really trying to understand with the skill sets BOTH pilots bring to the party how the INDUSTRY in general (BALPA and co) look upon it. Bit like saying a Doctor in A and E is worth more than a local GP, skill sets different but same job really. OK enough sorry about bit of a rant.
Firstly don't blame the mil and ex mil for having a pension they earned their pension as does anyone inculding yourself I am sure by working for a company/military for the required time to earn that pension. If you did 12/20/22 years with the same company from about age 17 or 18 and decided to do something else so so what? Your pension is yours as a Brucey bonus and the company employing you should not rely on your pension. If they do don't work for the feckers, and if you say they don't pay that much because of all the ex mil people floating about taking these lower paid jobs because the have pension in bag so what!!! They earned it you can hardly blame a company either as the will take on the people with the skill set they require for a wage they are happy with. Think that is called buisness but not my field so not sure. Not that I know
but having just spoken to my HEMS mate it is an industry wide prob not an individual company prob and funny old thing airlines have a different wage scheme hmmmmmmm why is that. My original post was light hearted and supposed to be as I was (in the pub you understand) really trying to understand with the skill sets BOTH pilots bring to the party how the INDUSTRY in general (BALPA and co) look upon it. Bit like saying a Doctor in A and E is worth more than a local GP, skill sets different but same job really. OK enough sorry about bit of a rant.
PP,
The sad point is retired military pilots have readily accepted lesser wages and were able and happy to do so because of that pension.
The truth is civilian pilot wages have and do suffer from that.
So many of my countrymen did just that as they saw a civilian flying job to be both a way of topping off that pension but also as a way of using up some of the free time they suddenly themselves confronted with.
I never could understand why they were so ready to work for part time wages on a full time job?
The net effect was the young civvie pilot trying to raise a family and save for the future was ham stringed by that practice.
The sad point is retired military pilots have readily accepted lesser wages and were able and happy to do so because of that pension.
The truth is civilian pilot wages have and do suffer from that.
So many of my countrymen did just that as they saw a civilian flying job to be both a way of topping off that pension but also as a way of using up some of the free time they suddenly themselves confronted with.
I never could understand why they were so ready to work for part time wages on a full time job?
The net effect was the young civvie pilot trying to raise a family and save for the future was ham stringed by that practice.
Avoid imitations
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Posts: 14,576
Received 423 Likes
on
223 Posts
SASless,
I think no ex-mil pilot in UK has ever been happy about the low public services pilot salaries. Possibly very different west of the Atlantic. I earned a UK military pension but certainly couldn't afford to live on it. Few pure fliers could when I left the military, nor can they today.
There were very few civvy rotary wing jobs at all in the early 90's. The best qualified merely took what was available. I was lucky enough to go abroad instead. When I returned home nearly five years later the public services salaries had not increased and jobs were still scarce. Should folk like me have refused to work, left the profession entirely, or what?
I eventually left that type of work when, instead of the long promised direct employment (rather than through a contractor), which would have given us a reasonable salary, the pilots on my unit were offered a 15% salary cut and a week less annual leave to stay in post under the employment of a "cheaper" employer who had been awarded the new contract.
I think no ex-mil pilot in UK has ever been happy about the low public services pilot salaries. Possibly very different west of the Atlantic. I earned a UK military pension but certainly couldn't afford to live on it. Few pure fliers could when I left the military, nor can they today.
There were very few civvy rotary wing jobs at all in the early 90's. The best qualified merely took what was available. I was lucky enough to go abroad instead. When I returned home nearly five years later the public services salaries had not increased and jobs were still scarce. Should folk like me have refused to work, left the profession entirely, or what?
I eventually left that type of work when, instead of the long promised direct employment (rather than through a contractor), which would have given us a reasonable salary, the pilots on my unit were offered a 15% salary cut and a week less annual leave to stay in post under the employment of a "cheaper" employer who had been awarded the new contract.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: uk
Posts: 52
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Mate I feel for him. It is of course called work or finding a job or life, Just really don;t like the way all civvies seem to think that mil or ex mil in any country think they are getting the jobs. ( I dont have one either still in mil) Simple really, in our flying world hours/experience/ and qualifications make up your CV. if you don;t have what you need, go get it. If the company you just applied to said bugger off you need this or that... go get it. If your trying to raise a family pay the mortgage etc and fly don't be envious of the people that do.... they in any which way or form have done what they need to do to get where they are. If the industry is paying less than you think is should DO something apart from post on here. Any way back to my two mates debate ...............
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: UK.
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey PP, I am chilled mate, but you asked why the difference in pay, and I gave you an honest answer!!! You are right, ex-mils pension,my pension, whoever, nothing to do with the company that employs you...but, the companies know that ex-mil guys in most cases have pensions so offer lower wages.....99% of police, hems etc employ ex-mil, so there's your answer....
Skills set...Hmmm, just different requirements for different jobs whether it be offshore, SAR, Hems whatever....Single pilot in crap weather, you'll work hard.. Two crew offshore, you'll both work hard!! New co-jo, night & bad weather,he/she will be maxed out and you'll be working bloody hard watching everything!!! Different skills for different jobs.....
Shytorque, not blaming you or others for taking the only jobs available at the time, but lets be honest the reason Hems,Police pay etc is so low because of ex- mil guys taking the lower pay....that's the truth, plain and simple.
PH.
Skills set...Hmmm, just different requirements for different jobs whether it be offshore, SAR, Hems whatever....Single pilot in crap weather, you'll work hard.. Two crew offshore, you'll both work hard!! New co-jo, night & bad weather,he/she will be maxed out and you'll be working bloody hard watching everything!!! Different skills for different jobs.....
Shytorque, not blaming you or others for taking the only jobs available at the time, but lets be honest the reason Hems,Police pay etc is so low because of ex- mil guys taking the lower pay....that's the truth, plain and simple.
PH.
PH, my figures are "guesstimates" but if you accept that a Capt on the North Sea earns 65-75k per annum, then why would/should you expect a company employing HEMS or Police pilots to pay the same? The NS guys work in all crap and quite a lot work away from home, those that don't have to relocate. The other guys live close to where they work and HEMS don't work nights. Would I want to go to the NS..No, am I happy working the routine I do, Yes. Wages could be better but what do we do, Strike? Most guys doing Police and HEMs seem to be fairly happy with their lot. Its horses for courses.
As for taking the lower wages, yes we do, but is it not also the case that the Mil guys are prefered because they have all the right ticks in the boxes?
As for taking the lower wages, yes we do, but is it not also the case that the Mil guys are prefered because they have all the right ticks in the boxes?
Avoid imitations
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Posts: 14,576
Received 423 Likes
on
223 Posts
Pullharder, At the time, many ex-military pilots had the required experience to get the jobs, most civvy trained pilots apparently didn't. That's just market forces in action.
After I and another ex-military pilot left, the new contractor had great difficulty finding another pilot with the required experience and in six months used a whole series of "floater" pilots, more than twelve, according to my ex-colleagues. The unit we were with mandated double the CAA minimum hours. Some of these pilots were not invited back. They later lowered the crossbar with regard to hours flown and now use some wholly civilian trained and experienced pilots.
After I and another ex-military pilot left, the new contractor had great difficulty finding another pilot with the required experience and in six months used a whole series of "floater" pilots, more than twelve, according to my ex-colleagues. The unit we were with mandated double the CAA minimum hours. Some of these pilots were not invited back. They later lowered the crossbar with regard to hours flown and now use some wholly civilian trained and experienced pilots.
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: UK.
Posts: 42
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Timex, I am glad you are happy where you are, but if you didn't have that ex-mil pension,would you have gone to the north sea for better pay, even though it may not be everyone's cup of tea?????? Do you think a lot of people would have gone that way if they didn't have a pension to back them up??
Anyway,
There are also many civvies out there that have the required experience, I for one have lot's of onshore,day/night and other types of flying, achieved in various countries,and although I do enjoy my job in many ways, and have no plans to leave,in the future I wouldn't mind doing Hems for a bit, but I won't ACCEPT the substantially lower pay........Should you be paid the same?? In my honest opinion no, for some of the reasons you stated.....Should Hems/police pay substantially more than they are though?? Absolutely.(N.sea P1 72k-90+)............but they won't while people accept what they are offering. If there was no shortage of pilots to fly hems/police over the last few years, then the requirements wouldn't keep coming down so another reason for the pay to go up (which I know Bond have increased for Hems,but it is way too low still)!!!
PH.
Anyway,
There are also many civvies out there that have the required experience, I for one have lot's of onshore,day/night and other types of flying, achieved in various countries,and although I do enjoy my job in many ways, and have no plans to leave,in the future I wouldn't mind doing Hems for a bit, but I won't ACCEPT the substantially lower pay........Should you be paid the same?? In my honest opinion no, for some of the reasons you stated.....Should Hems/police pay substantially more than they are though?? Absolutely.(N.sea P1 72k-90+)............but they won't while people accept what they are offering. If there was no shortage of pilots to fly hems/police over the last few years, then the requirements wouldn't keep coming down so another reason for the pay to go up (which I know Bond have increased for Hems,but it is way too low still)!!!
PH.