One day you're a hero ...
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: New York City
Posts: 820
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
One day you're a hero ...
Award for cliff rescue team
and then ... news
Helicopter rescuevideo
Will the coastguard will take this off their website now? Tribute
Looks like they lost a good guy.
Guess the rules lovers are happy.
and then ... news
Helicopter rescuevideo
Will the coastguard will take this off their website now? Tribute
Looks like they lost a good guy.
Guess the rules lovers are happy.
Last edited by Bronx; 12th Jan 2008 at 01:40.
Chief Bottle Washer
What's the old saying about rules: "For the obedience of fools, and the guidance of wise men?"
OH & S seems to be more important than common sense these days
OH & S seems to be more important than common sense these days
Join Date: May 2007
Location: in the real world
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Many people on this site slag off journalists and the media. Don't believe all you read in the papers. As for the website, thats an unofficial site produced locally in Fort William by one of the Coast Rescue Team there, not the MCA official site.
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Oman
Posts: 365
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
So Blimp22, what's the real story then? You seem to know things the journalists don't.
Thank god for people like Paul Waugh, prepared to take a risk for the sake of others. And a pox on the Coastguard managers who "ticked him off". Idiots. It reminds me of the incident last year with the pretend coppers who watched a child drown because of "Elf 'n' Safety" precautions.
Disgusting
Thank god for people like Paul Waugh, prepared to take a risk for the sake of others. And a pox on the Coastguard managers who "ticked him off". Idiots. It reminds me of the incident last year with the pretend coppers who watched a child drown because of "Elf 'n' Safety" precautions.
Disgusting
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: New York City
Posts: 820
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
blimp22
Who's slagging off journalists and the media?
Which part shouldn't we believe?
A Maritime and Coastguard Agency spokesman said: "We wish Paul well in his future endeavours and the MCA is very grateful for his past activities and work in the Coastguard Rescue Service. However, the MCA is very mindful of health and safety regulations which are in place for very good reasons. Above all our responsibility is to maintain the health and welfare of those who we sometimes ask to go out in difficult and challenging conditions to effect rescues. The MCA is not looking for dead heroes."
Yeah, a Scottish team give a big tribute on their website to an English coastguard who rescued some climbers who got stranded in snow and ice high up Ben Nevis mountain when he visting Scotland .
Have you got a point or did you just feel like posting?
Who's slagging off journalists and the media?
Which part shouldn't we believe?
A Maritime and Coastguard Agency spokesman said: "We wish Paul well in his future endeavours and the MCA is very grateful for his past activities and work in the Coastguard Rescue Service. However, the MCA is very mindful of health and safety regulations which are in place for very good reasons. Above all our responsibility is to maintain the health and welfare of those who we sometimes ask to go out in difficult and challenging conditions to effect rescues. The MCA is not looking for dead heroes."
Yeah, a Scottish team give a big tribute on their website to an English coastguard who rescued some climbers who got stranded in snow and ice high up Ben Nevis mountain when he visting Scotland .
Have you got a point or did you just feel like posting?
Last edited by Bronx; 12th Jan 2008 at 09:35.
I don´t know if there is a story behind the story. Under normal circumstances...
For me with some hundred mountain rescues it´s normal to debrief a mission. And if a regular trooper climbs 300ft without personal rescue gear i would have some questions to him.
First, how could a rescuer after alarming arrive an accident site without equipment? What a kind of mission preparation?
Second, without equipment he is not able to secure the victim and himself. What was really his help in this case? Was the child really safer than before?
An injured or dead trooper is not able to bring help. Thats allways the same word for all kind of rescue missions including our main business helicopter rescues.
May be in a lucky mission he is the hero for the media, but in case of failing he is only a fool, breaking the rules not insurance covered.
Thats my view, but i understand people without real rescue experiences will have an other. After a lot of waited hours for better weather or needed equipment on rescue missions, some injured collegues, dead victims, i hope you will understand.
For me with some hundred mountain rescues it´s normal to debrief a mission. And if a regular trooper climbs 300ft without personal rescue gear i would have some questions to him.
First, how could a rescuer after alarming arrive an accident site without equipment? What a kind of mission preparation?
Second, without equipment he is not able to secure the victim and himself. What was really his help in this case? Was the child really safer than before?
An injured or dead trooper is not able to bring help. Thats allways the same word for all kind of rescue missions including our main business helicopter rescues.
May be in a lucky mission he is the hero for the media, but in case of failing he is only a fool, breaking the rules not insurance covered.
Thats my view, but i understand people without real rescue experiences will have an other. After a lot of waited hours for better weather or needed equipment on rescue missions, some injured collegues, dead victims, i hope you will understand.
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: England
Age: 56
Posts: 591
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It's a terrible shame that red tape keeps blighting those that are genuineley trying to do good. I accept it's a finely balanced argument:- On the one hand do we want to see the rescuer and victim injured or killed because additional safety precautions were not taken and on the other do we want to see the victim perish because additional time was taken to prepare for a "safe(r)" rescue.
I regret that we are heading to a point that H&S are going to insist on individual risk evaluations, paperwork and other red tape in the future.
Life's a risk and I think a trained rescuer is perfectly capable of conducting his or her own risk assesment before performing his/her moral or professional duty.
Well done that Man!!!
I regret that we are heading to a point that H&S are going to insist on individual risk evaluations, paperwork and other red tape in the future.
Life's a risk and I think a trained rescuer is perfectly capable of conducting his or her own risk assesment before performing his/her moral or professional duty.
Well done that Man!!!
The main question is RISK MANAGEMENT and the second Mission Preparation. Seems to me we do not know enough about this in that special rescue mission.
Some years ago i was alarmed in bad visibility to rescue a group of volunteer mountain troopers and a victim with a broken ankle. Because the volunteers lost their key to the equipment room they decided to go out without rescue equipment. They climbed up to the victim which was generally in good mood but unable to go of course. Lacking ropes, rescue bag or harnesses the volunteers tried to bring the victim down under senseless risk, but at last without success. A high risk helicopter rescue (Long Line) mission was started in bad visibility. I was mad furious!
In the descibed file it was better to wait for a backup key than to go blind with a rescue syndrome.
Some years ago i was alarmed in bad visibility to rescue a group of volunteer mountain troopers and a victim with a broken ankle. Because the volunteers lost their key to the equipment room they decided to go out without rescue equipment. They climbed up to the victim which was generally in good mood but unable to go of course. Lacking ropes, rescue bag or harnesses the volunteers tried to bring the victim down under senseless risk, but at last without success. A high risk helicopter rescue (Long Line) mission was started in bad visibility. I was mad furious!
In the descibed file it was better to wait for a backup key than to go blind with a rescue syndrome.
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: here
Posts: 220
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Copied from a Coastie/RNLI/SAR forum..
Hello Everyone
I would like to thankyou all for your comments.As you know in the job we do be it cg rnli ambulance fire or police no job is the same this job was different as the MRU was stuck in a field on the other side of railway track there was 3 locks on both gates a field and a half away only 3 of us responded to pagers so we had called for back up which arrived after the job. 2 of us ran over the field to assess the job the Polce air support unit had a spot light on the girl which was great it was blowing a gale coming off the sea and she had been thre 45mins she was shaking and had mild hyperthermia when you see a young face looking up at you pleading for help i wasnt going to stand there and do nothing she was planning her own funeral in her head. If i couldnt have got to her then thats different i would have had to run back over the field for equipment but i think she would have fallen before we got back. the ledge she had stood on had collapsed so she was hanging by her arms on the grass so i had to get below her and make my own foot holds up behind her and pin her to the cliff face and we were stood there for another 30mins until Resce 128 came and winched her and the others up and took them staright to hospital.
The RAF lads from Leconfield & The police lads at tees valley airport did a good job too considering the wind it was a good bit of flying.
Since the Rescue i have had nothing but chew of certain members of the coastguard from AOM down the line and some trying to cover their backs by lying . I was trutheful i Broke a rule and admitted it i apologised i have been on many sad and bad jobs and to be treated like a criminal for rescuing someone.
In the 13 yrs ive been in the CG i have done alot of things to promote what we do saftey and generally putting the CG forward like organising fund raising event Pulling Tornado Aircraft at RAF leeming and many other things . I recieved the VOLUNTEER COASTGUARD OF THE YEAR IN 2006 Chief Executive Award for working at the boatshow in 2006 both of which i didnt know we did and for all ive done for the coastguard in the community. Some people dont like to do PR wok but i do but i do and some people have been in along time done nothing and got nothing but dont want anyone else to do anything.But like someone said were on the job you have to assess the situation. I was told once that one day i would work outside the Box and this was the time.
But thank you all for your support and comments Im not a HERO WE ARE ALL HEROS THAT DO EMERGENCY WORK AND ONE TIME YOU MIGHT HAVE TO WORK OUTSIDE THE BOX I HOPE YOU GET THE BACKING YOU NEED
Thanks again
Paul Waugh
HTC
Hello Everyone
I would like to thankyou all for your comments.As you know in the job we do be it cg rnli ambulance fire or police no job is the same this job was different as the MRU was stuck in a field on the other side of railway track there was 3 locks on both gates a field and a half away only 3 of us responded to pagers so we had called for back up which arrived after the job. 2 of us ran over the field to assess the job the Polce air support unit had a spot light on the girl which was great it was blowing a gale coming off the sea and she had been thre 45mins she was shaking and had mild hyperthermia when you see a young face looking up at you pleading for help i wasnt going to stand there and do nothing she was planning her own funeral in her head. If i couldnt have got to her then thats different i would have had to run back over the field for equipment but i think she would have fallen before we got back. the ledge she had stood on had collapsed so she was hanging by her arms on the grass so i had to get below her and make my own foot holds up behind her and pin her to the cliff face and we were stood there for another 30mins until Resce 128 came and winched her and the others up and took them staright to hospital.
The RAF lads from Leconfield & The police lads at tees valley airport did a good job too considering the wind it was a good bit of flying.
Since the Rescue i have had nothing but chew of certain members of the coastguard from AOM down the line and some trying to cover their backs by lying . I was trutheful i Broke a rule and admitted it i apologised i have been on many sad and bad jobs and to be treated like a criminal for rescuing someone.
In the 13 yrs ive been in the CG i have done alot of things to promote what we do saftey and generally putting the CG forward like organising fund raising event Pulling Tornado Aircraft at RAF leeming and many other things . I recieved the VOLUNTEER COASTGUARD OF THE YEAR IN 2006 Chief Executive Award for working at the boatshow in 2006 both of which i didnt know we did and for all ive done for the coastguard in the community. Some people dont like to do PR wok but i do but i do and some people have been in along time done nothing and got nothing but dont want anyone else to do anything.But like someone said were on the job you have to assess the situation. I was told once that one day i would work outside the Box and this was the time.
But thank you all for your support and comments Im not a HERO WE ARE ALL HEROS THAT DO EMERGENCY WORK AND ONE TIME YOU MIGHT HAVE TO WORK OUTSIDE THE BOX I HOPE YOU GET THE BACKING YOU NEED
Thanks again
Paul Waugh
HTC
Join Date: May 2007
Location: in the real world
Posts: 11
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If I listed all the people who slag off journalists on this site I'd be here all day. My point was that just as journos add the "plane in death dive, everyone nearly died but didn't" element, they will also do that to emotive stories such as this.
I may have misunderstood your comment about the tribute on the website. I thought you were asking for it to be removed and was pointing out the fact that it was not the "Coastguard" website (www.mcga.gov.uk) as most people know it.
As pointed out by many in this thread we need people like Paul Waugh, he is an ex colleague and I believe, as do the many that he is a hero in the true sense of the word. I used to do the job and would like to think that I had the balls to do the same thing in the same circumstances.
So in answer to your final question, Yes I do have a point.
I may have misunderstood your comment about the tribute on the website. I thought you were asking for it to be removed and was pointing out the fact that it was not the "Coastguard" website (www.mcga.gov.uk) as most people know it.
As pointed out by many in this thread we need people like Paul Waugh, he is an ex colleague and I believe, as do the many that he is a hero in the true sense of the word. I used to do the job and would like to think that I had the balls to do the same thing in the same circumstances.
So in answer to your final question, Yes I do have a point.
I know the feeling well! After quite a few years Service with the Coastguards enough was enough. Like you the job was great, working with various Helos and crews. When it suited management you were a coastguard rescue officer - over step the mark or use common sense you were a volunteer!
Well done on the Rescue .
Well done on the Rescue .
To much PR is allways suspicious.
Imaginable Mr Waugh looked down the cliff with forgotten gear, got panic, feared for a fall of the girl and questions after this and climbed headless down?
Sorry for my mind, but it was Mr. Waugh searching for publicity before real quitting MCA.
Bronx forgot: "No formal resignation letter had yet been received, he confirmed." (The MCA spokesmen about Mr. Waugh)
At first speaking to the media is never a solution.
"some trying to cover their backs by lying" as reported. Who have a reason to lie and why? I see only the troopers, the girl and the police helicopter above.
Imaginable Mr Waugh looked down the cliff with forgotten gear, got panic, feared for a fall of the girl and questions after this and climbed headless down?
Sorry for my mind, but it was Mr. Waugh searching for publicity before real quitting MCA.
Bronx forgot: "No formal resignation letter had yet been received, he confirmed." (The MCA spokesmen about Mr. Waugh)
At first speaking to the media is never a solution.
"some trying to cover their backs by lying" as reported. Who have a reason to lie and why? I see only the troopers, the girl and the police helicopter above.
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Oman
Posts: 365
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
tecpilot
True, if you choose to take a risk there is the possibility that it can all go wrong. But this is not a perfect world and you cannot always make a "risk assessment" and decide that the risks to yourself overweigh the safety concerns for a victim. There may be occasions (God forbid) where you have to accept a certain amount of risk in order to save others. I am happy for you that this situation has not occurred during your rescues.
Please do not criticise others who have had to make that decision on the spur of the moment.
May be in a lucky mission he is the hero for the media, but in case of failing he is only a fool, breaking the rules not insurance covered.
Please do not criticise others who have had to make that decision on the spur of the moment.
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: England
Posts: 155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well said Helimutt...... Heard the interveiw with him on Radio 4, I could be very wrong but he sounded just an ordinary guy that saved a girls life and for him it wasn't a big deal until everyone else got involved. Think what you like but the UK would be a better place if we had a few more with his attitude.
Risk assesment ,,,,HA,,,,,, intelligent people do mentally thousands of time a day !
Respect,
E.
Risk assesment ,,,,HA,,,,,, intelligent people do mentally thousands of time a day !
Respect,
E.
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: London
Age: 64
Posts: 100
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It seems clear to me that this man made a dynamic risk assessment. He weighed up the various courses of action available to him including the potential for failure and decided that he was in a position to minimise the risk to an acceptable level. The fact that he was able to put those actions into practice and reach a successful resolution of the situation proves that the risk assessment was correct.
Well done.
As an aside to this. Had he not been a member of the coastguard, say for instance a postman out walking his dog, and had done exactly the same thing, would the coastguard have critisised him or would they have congratulated him as others are doing now?
LM
Well done.
As an aside to this. Had he not been a member of the coastguard, say for instance a postman out walking his dog, and had done exactly the same thing, would the coastguard have critisised him or would they have congratulated him as others are doing now?
LM
Unfortunately the UK, and some parts of the world, are becoming a 'Risk assessment', 'HSE' nightmare. As I see it, the only real reason behind it all these days is purely for economic reasons, ie not wanting to get sued in this litigious society we now find ourselves living in.
Well done Paul Waugh for having the balls to do what you felt right at the time. Pity those guys in the management positions, not at the coalface, who seem to lose touch with reality at times.
Well done Paul Waugh for having the balls to do what you felt right at the time. Pity those guys in the management positions, not at the coalface, who seem to lose touch with reality at times.