Twin Turbine, Single engine performance & safety
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: uk
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Twin Turbine, Single engine performance & safety
I am very interested in hearing your opinions on the best or worst performing helicopters in the event of one engine failing.
B206, engine fails and you sure know about it real soon - need to apply rapid appropriate skill;
B212, engine fails in the cruise turns you into a B205 - no special skill required;
B412, engine fails at CDP and good chance you'll fly away (412EP that is) - a bit of skill is very helpful;
B214ST, engine fails anytime and you might notice, or might not - only abinitio pilot skill required;
S76A, engine fails and you know about it - need to apply prompt appropriate skill;
S76C above 23 deg C, same as for the A model;
S76C+, same as for 412 but love that 30 sec OEI power - a bit of skill is helpful;
S76C++, can't wait to give it a try!
B212, engine fails in the cruise turns you into a B205 - no special skill required;
B412, engine fails at CDP and good chance you'll fly away (412EP that is) - a bit of skill is very helpful;
B214ST, engine fails anytime and you might notice, or might not - only abinitio pilot skill required;
S76A, engine fails and you know about it - need to apply prompt appropriate skill;
S76C above 23 deg C, same as for the A model;
S76C+, same as for 412 but love that 30 sec OEI power - a bit of skill is helpful;
S76C++, can't wait to give it a try!
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: UK
Posts: 195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Showing my age but Wessex 5!
Could absorb a maximum of 1550shp through the gearbox and each engine produced 1350shp. So you might notice one stop if it blew up but a rundown didn't show up on CWP and we only had one torque needle anyway.
Queen of the skies.
Could absorb a maximum of 1550shp through the gearbox and each engine produced 1350shp. So you might notice one stop if it blew up but a rundown didn't show up on CWP and we only had one torque needle anyway.
Queen of the skies.
Reminds of a saying from the FW world but may be fits helicopters too "In a twin, when an engine fails, the remaining engine will fly you to the scene of the accident"
Nope...in all the above helicopter types, an engine failure above Vbroc should result in continued flight and a safe landing. And as for that S76B, even at a hefty weight you can probably hover that beast on one engine! Love those PT6 engines.
Nope...in all the above helicopter types, an engine failure above Vbroc should result in continued flight and a safe landing. And as for that S76B, even at a hefty weight you can probably hover that beast on one engine! Love those PT6 engines.
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Suffolk, UK.
Age: 65
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Eurocopter types
The BO 105 would manage about 80 kts single engine and then it was a 30 kt run on landing back at base. Throw out the crew and she would be able to hover taxi back to the hangar.
The EC 135 T2 has bags of power. MAUM at SL to +30 OEI. It still needs a smooth approach, but the FADEC won't allow you to overtorque or overtemp at the bottom, you just get Nr droop. So hover is no bover!
The EC 135 T2 has bags of power. MAUM at SL to +30 OEI. It still needs a smooth approach, but the FADEC won't allow you to overtorque or overtemp at the bottom, you just get Nr droop. So hover is no bover!
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Cornwall
Age: 75
Posts: 1,307
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Bo 105 - was embarassing to teach single engine ops on this otherwise likeable beast. A little bit of turbulence and a demo of OEI (using training lmits of course but not at MOM) could become embarassing. It's a bit demoralising for the stude when his RoC suddenly disappears at the nearest bumpy piece of sky
S76B - beautiful, just beautiful. Talk to RS about his OEI landing back at the rig after fire warning light refused to go out.
AW139 - Now we are back in Wessie 5 territory. ......... Exceptional OEI performance. The difference is that whereas the Gnome might let you down the PT6 is rock-solid.
G
S76B - beautiful, just beautiful. Talk to RS about his OEI landing back at the rig after fire warning light refused to go out.
AW139 - Now we are back in Wessie 5 territory. ......... Exceptional OEI performance. The difference is that whereas the Gnome might let you down the PT6 is rock-solid.
G
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: 18 Degrees North
Posts: 699
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I second Geoffers with the AW139,
no avoid curve at at all below 4000 density Alt.
and we had ours in the go around climbing at 1400 fpm OEI at MAUW.
Its awesome
regards
CF
no avoid curve at at all below 4000 density Alt.
and we had ours in the go around climbing at 1400 fpm OEI at MAUW.
Its awesome
regards
CF
Chinooks on one engine are really a challenge.
Join Date: Feb 2002
Location: N20,W99
Age: 53
Posts: 1,119
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
B206, engine fails and you sure know about it real soon - need to apply rapid appropriate skill;
B212, engine fails in the cruise turns you into a B205 - no special skill required;
B412, engine fails at CDP and good chance you'll fly away (412EP that is) - a bit of skill is very helpful;
B214ST, engine fails anytime and you might notice, or might not - only abinitio pilot skill required;
S76A, engine fails and you know about it - need to apply prompt appropriate skill;
S76C above 23 deg C, same as for the A model;
S76C+, same as for 412 but love that 30 sec OEI power - a bit of skill is helpful;
S76C++, can't wait to give it a try!
B212, engine fails in the cruise turns you into a B205 - no special skill required;
B412, engine fails at CDP and good chance you'll fly away (412EP that is) - a bit of skill is very helpful;
B214ST, engine fails anytime and you might notice, or might not - only abinitio pilot skill required;
S76A, engine fails and you know about it - need to apply prompt appropriate skill;
S76C above 23 deg C, same as for the A model;
S76C+, same as for 412 but love that 30 sec OEI power - a bit of skill is helpful;
S76C++, can't wait to give it a try!
Even the A109E Power has problems around here.
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Saltsjöbaden, Sweden
Age: 65
Posts: 113
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Md900/902
I've only flown it once, but from what I understand an OEI condition is more or less a "continue flight", even at high gross weight... Someone with a rating may be able to fill in the details...
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: West Midlands, UK.
Age: 73
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Twin engine helicopter performance
I have looked but are still baffled with a number of elementary and perhaps naive questions regarding twin engine helicopter performance. May I state them simply?
1. Can such a machine sustain its own weight on one?
2. Can it land and takeoff on one?
3. Can it land and take off one one plus some payload?
4. Can it land and take off on one at MAUW?
My reasoning is that if 1 to 4 are true then the second engine is purely in place for safety and more speed.
Put me right someone.
Thanks
Regards
Cron.
1. Can such a machine sustain its own weight on one?
2. Can it land and takeoff on one?
3. Can it land and take off one one plus some payload?
4. Can it land and take off on one at MAUW?
My reasoning is that if 1 to 4 are true then the second engine is purely in place for safety and more speed.
Put me right someone.
Thanks
Regards
Cron.
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Aus
Posts: 120
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You will find that only a couple of aircraft in production are able to take off on one engine when they are configured for "normal" contractual operations.
The limiting factor for most helicopters is the rating of the transmission. A single engine (of the two) is usually not rated with enough power to operate the helicopter through all phases of flight by itself with MAUW.
The limiting factor for most helicopters is the rating of the transmission. A single engine (of the two) is usually not rated with enough power to operate the helicopter through all phases of flight by itself with MAUW.
Cron, virtually all my helo experience is on singles, but I think I can answer some of your questions satisfactorily:
It may seem illogical, but the power required to fly a helicopter doesn't necessarily increase the faster you go. In fact, if you drew a graph of power required vs. speed, it would look a bit like the curve of a skate ramp - high at the start, low in the middle and high at the end. (This is because of various factors of airflow through the rotor disc and components of drag that we don't need to go into just now).
So, you need a lot of power to hover, a lot to go fast, and somewhat less in between.
If each of your two engines can produce a massive excess of power, then an engine failure at any time should be a doddle, because the good engine will just take up the slack, so to speak.
If the engines aren't up to the task of providing hover power on their own, but need to be working as a pair to do so, you won't be able to sustain the hover if one fails and will have to 'cushion' on to the ground with the other.
However, if you're flying above a certain speed (where power required becomes less), your remaining engine may be powerful enough to keep you flying. What about landing, you ask? Well, in that case, you'd need to do a 'running' landing (either on wheels, or scraping along on skids) so you could keep the speed up right to the ground.
Hope that helps.
It may seem illogical, but the power required to fly a helicopter doesn't necessarily increase the faster you go. In fact, if you drew a graph of power required vs. speed, it would look a bit like the curve of a skate ramp - high at the start, low in the middle and high at the end. (This is because of various factors of airflow through the rotor disc and components of drag that we don't need to go into just now).
So, you need a lot of power to hover, a lot to go fast, and somewhat less in between.
If each of your two engines can produce a massive excess of power, then an engine failure at any time should be a doddle, because the good engine will just take up the slack, so to speak.
If the engines aren't up to the task of providing hover power on their own, but need to be working as a pair to do so, you won't be able to sustain the hover if one fails and will have to 'cushion' on to the ground with the other.
However, if you're flying above a certain speed (where power required becomes less), your remaining engine may be powerful enough to keep you flying. What about landing, you ask? Well, in that case, you'd need to do a 'running' landing (either on wheels, or scraping along on skids) so you could keep the speed up right to the ground.
Hope that helps.
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Near the Mountains
Age: 67
Posts: 345
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Geoff,
In one of our early Power Assurance Checks, we did it at low weight and had to restrict the Single Engine Tq to 90% to keep the thing on the ground. Even at that, it was starting to dance on the mains with the oleos well extended! I didn't try, of course, but it had all the feeling of being able to fly away!
If I recall your demos in the Sim correctly, 70% Tq gave us 140kts at 6400kgs. Bring one engine off-line and the Tq went to 140% on the remaining engine which, happily is the Max Continuous OEI!!! Similarly, 80% Tq gave us 160kts. Engine off-line and Tq went to 160% and so on.....
I do hope it never happens though, much cosier feeling with both of them churning away behind you!!!!
22
In one of our early Power Assurance Checks, we did it at low weight and had to restrict the Single Engine Tq to 90% to keep the thing on the ground. Even at that, it was starting to dance on the mains with the oleos well extended! I didn't try, of course, but it had all the feeling of being able to fly away!
If I recall your demos in the Sim correctly, 70% Tq gave us 140kts at 6400kgs. Bring one engine off-line and the Tq went to 140% on the remaining engine which, happily is the Max Continuous OEI!!! Similarly, 80% Tq gave us 160kts. Engine off-line and Tq went to 160% and so on.....
I do hope it never happens though, much cosier feeling with both of them churning away behind you!!!!
22
There are no limits
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Shrewsbury, England.
Age: 66
Posts: 505
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Cron,
I can see your problem and I will try and keep it simple for all the others
Helicopter performance is affected by weight (mass), altitude and temperature, the WAT limits. Look in the flight manual and depending on manufacturer you could have several charts that give you the maximum weight for a given density altitude (pressure altitude versus temperature).
This weight would normally be the maximum for All Engines Operating (AEO), but there will be other charts for One Engine Inoperative (OEI) performance. This MAUW should give you enough performance to make an safe, comfortable approach and landing. Depending on aircraft this could be a running landing or an approach to a hover.
The second engine comes into its own during the critical phases of flight, take-off and landing. If you are at or below OEI MAUW and you are using the correct techniques, should a power unit fail you should be able to land safely.
For an explanation of proper techniques, Performance Class I, II and III and Category A operations have been done to death before (but is still confusing to those who have not done it, and to those that have!)
The answer to your questions, yes and no, yes and no, yes and no, yes and no. Clear?
I can see your problem and I will try and keep it simple for all the others
Helicopter performance is affected by weight (mass), altitude and temperature, the WAT limits. Look in the flight manual and depending on manufacturer you could have several charts that give you the maximum weight for a given density altitude (pressure altitude versus temperature).
This weight would normally be the maximum for All Engines Operating (AEO), but there will be other charts for One Engine Inoperative (OEI) performance. This MAUW should give you enough performance to make an safe, comfortable approach and landing. Depending on aircraft this could be a running landing or an approach to a hover.
The second engine comes into its own during the critical phases of flight, take-off and landing. If you are at or below OEI MAUW and you are using the correct techniques, should a power unit fail you should be able to land safely.
For an explanation of proper techniques, Performance Class I, II and III and Category A operations have been done to death before (but is still confusing to those who have not done it, and to those that have!)
The answer to your questions, yes and no, yes and no, yes and no, yes and no. Clear?