shall i or shall i not.
Thread Starter
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 373
Likes: 0
From: ON A HILL
shall i or shall i not.
Most of us have seen the video of the chap wrecking his helicopter trying to give it a go without the instructor. What is your opinion about the possibilities of someone actually mastering the basics by this go it alone technique and what machine would you suggest
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 3,009
Likes: 62
From: North Queensland, Australia
Most people would wreck it in a minute, I bet, but who can forget the film of the German test pilot, Hanna Reisch, (spelling and quotes probably wrong), working it out for herself:
"I find the position where the wheel does not roll ... I give gasoline ... in 5 minutes, I had it."
"I find the position where the wheel does not roll ... I give gasoline ... in 5 minutes, I had it."
Joined: Apr 1999
Posts: 202
Likes: 0
From: vocation
http://www.reference.com/browse/wiki/Hanna_Reitsch
....She survived many accidents and was badly injured several times.....
Probably the safest way to go it alone in a helicopter would be in one of those childrens' rides outside Woolworths. I believe a Budgie the Helicopter type is available, and 20p should get you about 5 mins useful hands-on time.
I did have someone come up to me not so long ago after I had landed in a street on an EMS job and ask whether his helicopter experience on Microsoft Flight Sim would enable him to jump in and fly a real one. I was stuck for a polite answer!
....She survived many accidents and was badly injured several times.....
Probably the safest way to go it alone in a helicopter would be in one of those childrens' rides outside Woolworths. I believe a Budgie the Helicopter type is available, and 20p should get you about 5 mins useful hands-on time.
I did have someone come up to me not so long ago after I had landed in a street on an EMS job and ask whether his helicopter experience on Microsoft Flight Sim would enable him to jump in and fly a real one. I was stuck for a polite answer!
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 82
Likes: 0
From: NZ Southern Alps
I once had a Qantas captain turn up at the school in which I was instructing and tell me he would like to experience hovering a helicopter.
I explained to him we normally like to do a bit upstairs first before getting close to the ground. He told me he had spent a lot of time flying model helicopters and understanding the principles and aerodynamics of rotary flight.
So, I yielded. First pedals, then collective, then cyclic then all together. From the point where I first gave him control of the pedals only to the point where he had full control of the machine was probably no more than 15 minutes, and his hover was rock solid. During the second half of the lesson we did some landings and takeoffs, and I was just as impressed with him on these as I was on the hover.
I think some people have a greater ability to get into the hand-eye stuff than others. No doubt, his 36 years and 19,000 hours of airline experience helped him understand my verbal instructions better than others, but other fixed wing folks I've taught were not a patch on this bloke.
Now, could he have got in to a machine, worked it out for himself and not broken something? No chance. There were things he had not pre-empted that still needed explaining, and NOBODY is ready for the sensitivity of the controls that first lesson.
GP
I explained to him we normally like to do a bit upstairs first before getting close to the ground. He told me he had spent a lot of time flying model helicopters and understanding the principles and aerodynamics of rotary flight.
So, I yielded. First pedals, then collective, then cyclic then all together. From the point where I first gave him control of the pedals only to the point where he had full control of the machine was probably no more than 15 minutes, and his hover was rock solid. During the second half of the lesson we did some landings and takeoffs, and I was just as impressed with him on these as I was on the hover.
I think some people have a greater ability to get into the hand-eye stuff than others. No doubt, his 36 years and 19,000 hours of airline experience helped him understand my verbal instructions better than others, but other fixed wing folks I've taught were not a patch on this bloke.
Now, could he have got in to a machine, worked it out for himself and not broken something? No chance. There were things he had not pre-empted that still needed explaining, and NOBODY is ready for the sensitivity of the controls that first lesson.
GP
Joined: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,957
Likes: 0
From: Australia
Hanna
Yes another great fan of the lady right here surely she didn't bend anything? details? must have been mechanical!
a country man of hers once in west OZ about very early 70's i think, had done about two hours ab initio and reckoned he could make good his escape in one (a 47G2 that had been on min-ex if memory is right) after he knocked off the local bank on a weekend.
Hung over gingerbeer turns up to do the old daily trick first thing monday-- where is it?--panic-- looks up-- there is one skid hanging out of the hangar roof-- hmmm-- round the back and there she is all rolled up, no sign of a driver.
Then the local indiginni kids started buying mobs of pushbikes and lollies from from downtown trading post - a small town-- and a story eventually came out of a hitchhiker presented to a hospital several hundred k down the highway who claimed to have been beaten up and robbed, he'd stashed the loot in a road culvert where the kids had found it.
Plods put two and two together and gave instructions to immobilise him, the doc plastered him head to foot, hero woke up he was sprung and pinched a sharp instrument, got out of the cast and the hospital toilet window and never was found.
true story.
a country man of hers once in west OZ about very early 70's i think, had done about two hours ab initio and reckoned he could make good his escape in one (a 47G2 that had been on min-ex if memory is right) after he knocked off the local bank on a weekend.
Hung over gingerbeer turns up to do the old daily trick first thing monday-- where is it?--panic-- looks up-- there is one skid hanging out of the hangar roof-- hmmm-- round the back and there she is all rolled up, no sign of a driver.
Then the local indiginni kids started buying mobs of pushbikes and lollies from from downtown trading post - a small town-- and a story eventually came out of a hitchhiker presented to a hospital several hundred k down the highway who claimed to have been beaten up and robbed, he'd stashed the loot in a road culvert where the kids had found it.
Plods put two and two together and gave instructions to immobilise him, the doc plastered him head to foot, hero woke up he was sprung and pinched a sharp instrument, got out of the cast and the hospital toilet window and never was found.
true story.
Joined: Oct 2002
Posts: 1,796
Likes: 1
From: 1 Dunghill Mansions, Putney
Don't remember the company involved, but there was a free-flight multi-axis helicopter simulator featured on the UK show Tomorrow's World a number of years back that - allegedly - allowed the basics to be taught in a fraction of the usual time.
I/C
I/C
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 1,835
Likes: 3
From: Philadelphia PA
I know a man who taught himself to fly a helicopter - evidently built a popular brand of homebuilt from various parts, added a turbocharger as well. In the piles of bits that he bought to assemble the thing was a book that the manufacturer had put out some time earlier, and failed to find in the recall that was basically - how to teach yourself to fly a helicopter.
Seems you start with the thing tethered down, with some play allowed up/down left/right (about 6" springs to the rapidly failing memory), and allowing the tailboom more lateral movement. When you could pick the thing up, and keep it within the limited freedom, you were allowed to add a bit more freedom, etc.
He said it took him all morning the first time just to get to the point where he was nearly off the ground. Obviously a very cautious type!
When he was comfortable hovering within 18" of slack, he went for a 'trial lesson' on one of the more popular production piston engine machines and astounded the instructor by being able to hover it perfectly.
So it can be done. But definitely not recommended.
Seems you start with the thing tethered down, with some play allowed up/down left/right (about 6" springs to the rapidly failing memory), and allowing the tailboom more lateral movement. When you could pick the thing up, and keep it within the limited freedom, you were allowed to add a bit more freedom, etc.
He said it took him all morning the first time just to get to the point where he was nearly off the ground. Obviously a very cautious type!
When he was comfortable hovering within 18" of slack, he went for a 'trial lesson' on one of the more popular production piston engine machines and astounded the instructor by being able to hover it perfectly.
So it can be done. But definitely not recommended.
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 297
Likes: 0
From: The gulag
Originally Posted by Gas Producer
I once had a Qantas captain turn up at the school in which I was instructing and tell me he would like to experience hovering a helicopter.
I explained to him we normally like to do a bit upstairs first before getting close to the ground. He told me he had spent a lot of time flying model helicopters and understanding the principles and aerodynamics of rotary flight.
So, I yielded. First pedals, then collective, then cyclic then all together. From the point where I first gave him control of the pedals only to the point where he had full control of the machine was probably no more than 15 minutes, and his hover was rock solid.
I explained to him we normally like to do a bit upstairs first before getting close to the ground. He told me he had spent a lot of time flying model helicopters and understanding the principles and aerodynamics of rotary flight.
So, I yielded. First pedals, then collective, then cyclic then all together. From the point where I first gave him control of the pedals only to the point where he had full control of the machine was probably no more than 15 minutes, and his hover was rock solid.
NC43
Joined: Oct 1999
Posts: 1,444
Likes: 21
From: Beyond the black stump!
An acquaintance of mine taught himself to fly helicopters in a Sikorsky S52 that he purchased many, many years ago.
He had a fixed wing licence already and coupled with that experience, taught himself to perform running take-offs and landings. He never felt safe
slowing down to the point the machine would hover, so hired an instructor to teach him that part. After mastering his hovering, he completed the requisite flight hours, passed his commercial check ride and never looked back, immediately picking up a commercial flying position.
According to another good friend, there is never any doubt in your mind that he taught himself to fly helicopters, should you have the misfortune to fly with him!
He had a fixed wing licence already and coupled with that experience, taught himself to perform running take-offs and landings. He never felt safe
slowing down to the point the machine would hover, so hired an instructor to teach him that part. After mastering his hovering, he completed the requisite flight hours, passed his commercial check ride and never looked back, immediately picking up a commercial flying position.According to another good friend, there is never any doubt in your mind that he taught himself to fly helicopters, should you have the misfortune to fly with him!
Avoid imitations
Joined: Nov 2000
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 15,110
Likes: 1,083
From: Wandering the FIR and cyberspace often at highly unsociable times
Originally Posted by bugdevheli
Most of us have seen the video of the chap wrecking his helicopter trying to give it a go without the instructor. What is your opinion about the possibilities of someone actually mastering the basics by this go it alone technique and what machine would you suggest
BTW, please make it somewhere with something nice and solid for us all to hide behind.
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts: 112
Likes: 0
From: North of Eq
BP
I have been flying for many years but the length of time I can keep Microsoft Flight Simulator or a Radio Controlled model helicopter airborne is embarrassing.
Do you think it would work any better the other way around? Would it really help?
HA
I have been flying for many years but the length of time I can keep Microsoft Flight Simulator or a Radio Controlled model helicopter airborne is embarrassing.
Do you think it would work any better the other way around? Would it really help?
HA
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 777
Likes: 0
From: Harwich
1. Experience with MS Flight Sim made a beneficial difference for me, but I had already (many years before) had half an hour in a 206 with SAS (the stability system, not the old bold contributor to this forum).
2. By and large, computer sims are harder than the real thing because of the lack of peripheral vision and the lag - you need almighty computing power to give it true real-time feel in high-gain situations.
2. By and large, computer sims are harder than the real thing because of the lack of peripheral vision and the lag - you need almighty computing power to give it true real-time feel in high-gain situations.
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 39
Likes: 0
From: Australia
Like SC I remember seeing a book on homebuilt helicopters years ago. I think it was talking about a one place machine.
And I think it did recommend learning how to fly by starting with four 6" tethers to the ground and then gradually increasing the length. Maybe it was the same book.
(At one point it said to never let actual helicopter pilots fly the helicopter untethered because they will not be familiar with the type and almost certainly roll it over.)
But as far as flying untethered helicopters from scratch, without automatic control, for someone to actually succeed I think they would need to bypass the hovering stage entirely, both on takeoff and landing.
Would it be possible to start by pulling max takeoff power and jam in left pedal while still on the ground? Then very quickly on the way up try to stop the yaw before you got too disoriented. At that point you are in a climb and could have time to figure out the basics of flying. Then finish off with a fast run-on landing onto a runway. ....It could work...I bet the workload would be high.
And I think it did recommend learning how to fly by starting with four 6" tethers to the ground and then gradually increasing the length. Maybe it was the same book.
(At one point it said to never let actual helicopter pilots fly the helicopter untethered because they will not be familiar with the type and almost certainly roll it over.)
But as far as flying untethered helicopters from scratch, without automatic control, for someone to actually succeed I think they would need to bypass the hovering stage entirely, both on takeoff and landing.
Would it be possible to start by pulling max takeoff power and jam in left pedal while still on the ground? Then very quickly on the way up try to stop the yaw before you got too disoriented. At that point you are in a climb and could have time to figure out the basics of flying. Then finish off with a fast run-on landing onto a runway. ....It could work...I bet the workload would be high.
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 515
Likes: 0
From: Denver, CO and the GOM
Originally Posted by WHK4
Would it be possible to start by pulling max takeoff power and jam in left pedal while still on the ground? Then very quickly on the way up try to stop the yaw before you got too disoriented. At that point you are in a climb and could have time to figure out the basics of flying. Then finish off with a fast run-on landing onto a runway. ....It could work...I bet the workload would be high.