The 'walkaround'
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: UK
Posts: 244
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The 'walkaround'
It seems to be apparent from certain posts here on pprune, that some airlines' flightcrew opt not to carry out a walkaround, and concerns are subsequently always raised about this.
As I am sure there is more than 1 airline 'involved', I would prefer to concentrate on whether folk here on pprune consider this a serious danger, or simply a matter of choice-rather than naming any names.
Do you consider a walkaround inspection of the aircraft:
1) Essential
2) More precautionary, than essential
3) Matter of choice, with little direct impact on safety?
Thanks in advance for any responses.
As I am sure there is more than 1 airline 'involved', I would prefer to concentrate on whether folk here on pprune consider this a serious danger, or simply a matter of choice-rather than naming any names.
Do you consider a walkaround inspection of the aircraft:
1) Essential
2) More precautionary, than essential
3) Matter of choice, with little direct impact on safety?
Thanks in advance for any responses.
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Minneapolis, MN,USA.
Posts: 147
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Essential............ If you want know whats broken, you look in the logbook. If you want to know what might be broken - you look at the aircraft. I cannot imagine anybody except perhaps a military pilot "scrambling", who wouldn't want to ensure its safe to fly before flying it. I've found enough stuff on maintenance walkrounds to know that there's stuff out there for somebody to find and fix before aviating.
ECON cruise, LR cruise...
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: MIRSI hold - give or take...
Age: 52
Posts: 568
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Essential!
Some pre-flight inspection items get worse over time if not performed - and suddenly you have AOG and waste $$$ at an alarming rate.
Some companies have adopted a policy of 1 warning over safety related items - next time you're out! Just gave a guy his first & final warning the other day - over lack of proper pre-flight.
So - somebody will learn to take it seriously
- one way or the other.
Brgds,
Empty
Some pre-flight inspection items get worse over time if not performed - and suddenly you have AOG and waste $$$ at an alarming rate.
Some companies have adopted a policy of 1 warning over safety related items - next time you're out! Just gave a guy his first & final warning the other day - over lack of proper pre-flight.
So - somebody will learn to take it seriously
- one way or the other.Brgds,
Empty
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Who can say?
Posts: 1,700
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If any captain did not, or did not have his F/O carry out a walk-round and a subsequent problem came to light, he is on a very sticky wicket indeed.
Sorry, but it is Airmanship.
If anyone neglects it, thinking "Oh, it'll be ok - it got us here, didn't it?" then I hope they'll tell me before I ever fly with them, because I never, ever will.
On turnaround, I've notived a boot ripped to shreds that had happened during the previous sector. Even when the aircraft has just had a check from an engineer, I still walk round. That way, I've noticed oil filler flaps left open by them...
Neglecting a walkround is lazy, is p!ss-poor airmanship, and, as far as I am concerned, is grounds for dismissal, being gross negligence of duty.
Sorry, but it is Airmanship.
If anyone neglects it, thinking "Oh, it'll be ok - it got us here, didn't it?" then I hope they'll tell me before I ever fly with them, because I never, ever will.
On turnaround, I've notived a boot ripped to shreds that had happened during the previous sector. Even when the aircraft has just had a check from an engineer, I still walk round. That way, I've noticed oil filler flaps left open by them...
Neglecting a walkround is lazy, is p!ss-poor airmanship, and, as far as I am concerned, is grounds for dismissal, being gross negligence of duty.
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: Tenerife, sometimes?
Age: 58
Posts: 56
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Essential, of course!
And I perform it myself everyother flight.
Besides one thing I like is to "caress" the airplane when I do it.
If you do not like what you flight them work in other profession!
And I perform it myself everyother flight.
Besides one thing I like is to "caress" the airplane when I do it.
If you do not like what you flight them work in other profession!
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Near Stalyvegas
Age: 78
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
walkround
At the risk of putting the feline amongst the avians,
In 32 years of Tower and Runway Control duties and umpteen Fam flights, I have only witnessed ONE , count 'em one walk round, and that was with a friend of mine on the ground at Malaga
[I know that I can't see everything from the tower (MAN/EGCC) but I can see quite a lot
we aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
In 32 years of Tower and Runway Control duties and umpteen Fam flights, I have only witnessed ONE , count 'em one walk round, and that was with a friend of mine on the ground at Malaga
[I know that I can't see everything from the tower (MAN/EGCC) but I can see quite a lot
we aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 1,178
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
tinyrice
Even a 'scrambling' mil pilot does a walkround. It is done at the start of the duty and the aircraft is effectively quarantined.
chiglet
I just cannot believe that.
BTW I agree with the above comments................a pre-flight walkround is essential .............. and there ain't no slot on the planet more important.
Even a 'scrambling' mil pilot does a walkround. It is done at the start of the duty and the aircraft is effectively quarantined.
chiglet
I just cannot believe that.
BTW I agree with the above comments................a pre-flight walkround is essential .............. and there ain't no slot on the planet more important.
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Minneapolis, MN,USA.
Posts: 147
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Flaps One. Not having been in the military (found this big yellow streak up my back on the physical), I always wondered how they did that. Chiglet - you're having a giraffe - right?? Good one................
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: EGKK
Age: 42
Posts: 599
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sorry but this thread has me somewhat perplexed. It was my understanding that a pre-flight external inspection by the pilot in command (or the effoh on his/her behalf) was a legal requirement prior to every flight? It seems perhaps I was wrong... 
Whilst I can only claim 200 hours total flying in nothing bigger than a Seneca (yet!), I have never not done a thorough walkaround prior to every single flight. Whether it is pouring down or 110 degrees outside (and I've been in both), it's my life up there.
One would think an airline pilot would appreciate that his/her decision on airworthiness protects hundreds of lives, how can such a judgement be made from the comfort of the flightdeck? Seriously?
Whilst I can only claim 200 hours total flying in nothing bigger than a Seneca (yet!), I have never not done a thorough walkaround prior to every single flight. Whether it is pouring down or 110 degrees outside (and I've been in both), it's my life up there.
One would think an airline pilot would appreciate that his/her decision on airworthiness protects hundreds of lives, how can such a judgement be made from the comfort of the flightdeck? Seriously?
I can't comprehend a pilot not doing a walkround. It's not only company policy, but a legal requirement.
Always did a walkround in mil flying too - no matter how pressed for time we may have been.
Chiglet - I'm not criticizing your comment, but are you completely sure of your facts....if so tell me. That way I can avoid flying with f******
Always did a walkround in mil flying too - no matter how pressed for time we may have been.
Chiglet - I'm not criticizing your comment, but are you completely sure of your facts....if so tell me. That way I can avoid flying with f******
Last edited by Jetdriver; 16th May 2002 at 00:54.
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Near Stalyvegas
Age: 78
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
walkround
I have flown in both Civil and Military a/c, from Chipmonks to B747-400s.
During my time at RAF Kuching [Borneo] in the mid '60s, on muliple stop/start Whirlwnd, Belvedere, Single and Twin Pioneer missions there were no repeat NO intermediate walkrounds.
In light twin ops [multi legs] with a charter company, no walkrounds
I have sat on the FD duing turnaround [in the J/S] and no one has asked me to move, other than go to the loo.
BTW at RAF Woodvale, the Chippies didn't have a walkround after multi cadet trips, and sometimes not even after refuelling.
Now defunct, Air Europe Malta-Brum-Manch. The only time a FD crew left his seat was to help the CSD close the door, in MINUS 6C at Brum before the Manch leg
Same Airline on the ground at Corfu stayed on FD
Ambassador Ditto
As to the others, don't ask I've got amnesia.
we aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
ps When I'm next in the tower at Manch, I will definitely make a point of [really] looking out of the window
During my time at RAF Kuching [Borneo] in the mid '60s, on muliple stop/start Whirlwnd, Belvedere, Single and Twin Pioneer missions there were no repeat NO intermediate walkrounds.
In light twin ops [multi legs] with a charter company, no walkrounds
I have sat on the FD duing turnaround [in the J/S] and no one has asked me to move, other than go to the loo.
BTW at RAF Woodvale, the Chippies didn't have a walkround after multi cadet trips, and sometimes not even after refuelling.
Now defunct, Air Europe Malta-Brum-Manch. The only time a FD crew left his seat was to help the CSD close the door, in MINUS 6C
at Brum before the Manch legSame Airline on the ground at Corfu stayed on FD
Ambassador Ditto
As to the others, don't ask I've got amnesia.
we aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
ps When I'm next in the tower at Manch, I will definitely make a point of [really] looking out of the window
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Hants, UK
Posts: 1,064
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Remember the report on the Potomac bridge crash in Washington? A passenger looking out from the terminal noted that the aircraft pushed back and started engines with NO sign of any footprints in the snow around the aircraft to suggest a walkround had taken place. The aircraft, contaminated with snow on the wings and in the engine nacelles, subsequently crashed into the Potomac river after failing to get airborne from National.
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Near Stalyvegas
Age: 78
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
WALKROUND
Thanx eye
A "Walkround" as has been stated, is mandatory.
I have passed my "observations" and have been "Disbelieved".
In my [Personal] experience, a few examples.
On the first flight of the day, I have very little knowledge of the inspections of these aeroplanes. BUT, if has been suggested, A "Walkround" is Mandatory [ or even "adviseable"] after every flight, I have to differ.
EGs
Non UK airline (Fam Flt)
Arr, pax off, clean, replenish, pax [inc me] board, push and taxi,
No "observed" walkround. Land at intermediate, pax etc..FD crew engaged in conversation with self, no walkround.
Return leg...Exactly the same.
UK airlines..Late arr [a/c change], so no idea af walkround. Arr "Europe" late, Quick turnround.....
Ditto internal UK on "more than one" turboprop
DC10 Alicante, A300 Palma, Ba11 Malaga,B757 Las Palmas...
I "could" go on, but I think that I have made my point.
we [really do] aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
A "Walkround" as has been stated, is mandatory.
I have passed my "observations" and have been "Disbelieved".
In my [Personal] experience, a few examples.
On the first flight of the day, I have very little knowledge of the inspections of these aeroplanes. BUT, if has been suggested, A "Walkround" is Mandatory [ or even "adviseable"] after every flight, I have to differ.
EGs
Non UK airline (Fam Flt)
Arr, pax off, clean, replenish, pax [inc me] board, push and taxi,
No "observed" walkround. Land at intermediate, pax etc..FD crew engaged in conversation with self, no walkround.
Return leg...Exactly the same.
UK airlines..Late arr [a/c change], so no idea af walkround. Arr "Europe" late, Quick turnround.....
Ditto internal UK on "more than one" turboprop
DC10 Alicante, A300 Palma, Ba11 Malaga,B757 Las Palmas...
I "could" go on, but I think that I have made my point.
we [really do] aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: by the river
Posts: 431
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Walkaround
At the risk of possible wrath from many fronts, was it not at MAN that a Crossair captain was killed by ground traffic while doing a 'company manditory' walkaround ?
Should pilots really be put at such risk ?
However sick and sad for those directly and indirectly involved in that case, the answer has to be - YES - its part of the most basic of basics, and part of the job.
As SLF it is difficult to know if a walkaround has taken place or not - but if I knew for certain that a walkaround had NOT taken place, I don't care how many slots you miss, my bags are coming off and I'm not on board.
Should pilots really be put at such risk ?
However sick and sad for those directly and indirectly involved in that case, the answer has to be - YES - its part of the most basic of basics, and part of the job.
As SLF it is difficult to know if a walkaround has taken place or not - but if I knew for certain that a walkaround had NOT taken place, I don't care how many slots you miss, my bags are coming off and I'm not on board.
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 136
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pre Flight Inspection
Essential & Mandatory
I've never known of a pre flight not being done, ever.
On three crew acft as well as the Stoker doing a walk around
Capt or F/O also carried out an inspection - even when OAT was minus fifteen C.
I've never known of a pre flight not being done, ever.
On three crew acft as well as the Stoker doing a walk around
Capt or F/O also carried out an inspection - even when OAT was minus fifteen C.
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Who can say?
Posts: 1,700
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The regulations, of course, do not say WHO has to do the walkround. You need to note, chiglet, that it does not have to be the flightcrew. It could well be a ground engineer who signs for it. You may not see him (on fam flights). You may not even notice him (from the tower) among all the other people milling around an aircraft on turnround.
I have to say, though, in support of chiglet, that I have many times observed aircraft from a well-known low-cost airline whose turnrounds are so tight that on taxy they set off GATSO cameras arrive at the gate. I have watched them from a good vantage point and on many, many occasions there is no walk-round performed.
I stress that this is one airline only that I have observed. No other.
I have to say, though, in support of chiglet, that I have many times observed aircraft from a well-known low-cost airline whose turnrounds are so tight that on taxy they set off GATSO cameras arrive at the gate. I have watched them from a good vantage point and on many, many occasions there is no walk-round performed.
I stress that this is one airline only that I have observed. No other.
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: Sunrise Senior Living
Posts: 1,338
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Essential!
Once you're up in the ether, there are certain things about which you can do NOTHING. Eg Gear pins left in, oil filler caps left open, tyres in bad nick etc.
I also bet that the unfortunate crew of the BMI A321 that had a tailscrape on landing at Dub in difficult conditions wished they had done a w/r when they found that they couldn't pressurise on the way back to Lhr. In fairness, by their own rules, they were not compelled to do a w/r; this was delegated to an engineer, but, guess what, he got distracted!
It's no good sitting up at FL350 wondering if all's ok outside when you should have checked!
Cheers
mcdhu
Once you're up in the ether, there are certain things about which you can do NOTHING. Eg Gear pins left in, oil filler caps left open, tyres in bad nick etc.
I also bet that the unfortunate crew of the BMI A321 that had a tailscrape on landing at Dub in difficult conditions wished they had done a w/r when they found that they couldn't pressurise on the way back to Lhr. In fairness, by their own rules, they were not compelled to do a w/r; this was delegated to an engineer, but, guess what, he got distracted!
It's no good sitting up at FL350 wondering if all's ok outside when you should have checked!
Cheers
mcdhu
In the year I have been line flying I have found only two things on walkarounds. One was a sticky starter valve that kept the number 1 engine turning and the other was a quite large bird strike on the Starboard LED's in BCN which we had cleaned off.
Not much.
But not insignificant. Over the next 30 odd years - based on the last 1 - I rationally expect to find something very significant.
Which airline is it that does not do walkarounds?
WWW
Not much.
But not insignificant. Over the next 30 odd years - based on the last 1 - I rationally expect to find something very significant.
Which airline is it that does not do walkarounds?
WWW
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Near Stalyvegas
Age: 78
Posts: 2,022
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
walkround [or not]
I hear what everybody has said, but I have experienced turnrounds where the only visitor to the FD was the CSD No engineers report, just xx boarded and ready to go. Is this normal?
we aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy
No engineers report, just xx boarded and ready to go. Is this normal?we aim to please, it keeps the cleaners happy