PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Professional Pilot Training (includes ground studies) (https://www.pprune.org/professional-pilot-training-includes-ground-studies-14/)
-   -   The never-ending 'Modular vs. Integrated' debate - merged ad nauseam (https://www.pprune.org/professional-pilot-training-includes-ground-studies/218620-never-ending-modular-vs-integrated-debate-merged-ad-nauseam.html)

Prophead 5th November 2008 11:15

Sorry, i read your post wrong. I also used the wrong smily :ugh::uhoh::\:{:oh::\

Frankly Mr Shankly 5th November 2008 12:24

Absolutely Clanger, we can but try. Taxi for Mr S......

:)

Afraz 23rd December 2008 09:01

Thomson Prefers Modular Students?
 
I have heard from someone who is currently looking for a FO job that Thomson actually prefer modular students. Can anyone comment on the accuracy of this statement?

Thanks!

Flying Squid 23rd December 2008 16:42

Sounds like you are still fishing for clues as to which method is best........Afraz PLEASE give this a rest......... Integrated Vs Modular is a debate that has been around since the dark ages and is unlikely to be solved anytime soon. We all have our reasons for the way in which we choose to train.

Decide what is best for you not everyone else!

Happy Xmas

FS:ok:

GIZZAJOB 23rd December 2008 17:17

Mr Squid , having been a casual observer of Afraz's postings over the last month I do not see any hint that he will be giving up asking the same questions over and over again relentlessly until we all give up . Having spoken to the airlines themselves at the Flyer exhibition he obviously disbelieves what he was told .
Afraz just enrol on a bloody course and give us all a break . If you havent worked out by now that it doesnt matter where you train or under which guise then you are never going to so go and join the Army or something or the navy , oooh or the RAF maybe you could start another thread about which will get you into the lhs seat of a jet quicker

ali1986 23rd December 2008 18:09

Afraz

GO MODULAR!

:ok:

There you go i made the decision for you.

And just out of interest guys, How long did it take everyone to decide which path they were gonna go down days, weeks, months?

Flying Squid 23rd December 2008 18:23

Mr Job....very well said :D

Took me about a few weeks to research it properly and all of 30 seconds to make the final decision once I had weighed up the pro's and con's of both. Mod all the way.

Airflight69 23rd December 2008 19:20

I`m starting modular next year. For me there`s no rush since no matter what way i go looks like i won`t be getting a job as a pilot in the next 4 years. So i`ll take my time, take the exams when i`m ready and hopefully, by the time i get the fATPL, things will look brighter.
I have one question though: for the hr building i was thinking to buy a share on a small a/c then sell it once i have the necessary hrs on the logbook, seem way cheaper than paying £100+/hr renting an a/c. What do you guys think? Is it actually cheaper or is not worth the hassle?

EGCC4284 24th December 2008 15:22

Link for Afraz

http://www.pprune.org/3821823-post640.html

I don’t think Thomson have any preference. It’s still the same blue licence book at the end of the day. I was lucky, but you have to make your own luck in this world.

You do whatever is right for yourself. Modular saves you £1000’s.

Did my PPL in August 1999

Finished modular training in Oct 2005

18 months to get a job at the age of 39 with 440 hours

Best of luck guys.

Rob

GIZZAJOB 24th December 2008 15:27

Wait fooooor it !

G CEXO 25th December 2008 20:04

Afraz, you really need to take your finger out and research both routes thoroughly and come up with a decision yourself.

G-XO

aimskyhigh88 24th January 2009 01:57

How would you do it? - opinions
 
hey guys, I've done a bit of reading around this forum. I just wanted to get peoples opinions on the best path to becoming a commercial pilot. Disregarding financial situations what do you think the most valuable training would be? I've read alot about these cadetships in particular the Etihad one, are these good options if your lucky enough to be chosen?

Basically I just want to get peoples opinions of "in a perfect world" what path would they choose?

Cheers

Frankly Mr Shankly 24th January 2009 11:19

Wahay, it's back! Oh dear god nooooooooooooooooooooo...........

JohnRayner 24th January 2009 12:32

Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated! No! Modular! No! Integrated!


sorry. :O


Although to answer the question. "In a perfect world", the path I would choose would be integrated.

But in my perfect world, I'd have 100k of cash in hand (no loans or remortgages!) to spend on my training.

I'd also have 2 years free of any commitments whatsoever, no mortgage to service for example.

In my perfect world the FTO would be just round the corner an all the training would take place there, so I could still e.g. see the wife.

And (most importantly!) In a perfect world the end of my training would merge nearly seamlessly with my first job in the RHS.

I can't fulfill any of the above, so I'm going modular, taking my time, paying as I go, keeping working, paying the bills, and trying to keep an eye out for when the jobs might happen. Boring but sensible, as more than one of my ex girlfriends have probably thought. :ok:

JR

p.s. The right way to train is the way that's right for you. twee, but true. Gather all the info you can, and make your choice. This place is a wealth of info. Have a trawl!

p.p.s. Read bits of the "Downturn" thread, and "Where are all the jobs?" to get some idea of the difficulties facing the industry right now

moona 24th January 2009 21:50

So which is best Integrated or Modular?


:O sorry couldn't resist

bajadj 24th January 2009 23:44

Modugrated!

JohnRayner 25th January 2009 09:52

Excellent! The third way!

:ok:

MickeyH 16th March 2009 20:14

Sorry to revive this thread...

Assuming I choose to go Modular, would it be wise to train at one of the big 4 FTOs, or would training at my local flying school be just as acceptable to an airline?

How important is it to do all the training with one provider, or does it not matter, as long as the quality of your flying is sufficient?

redsnail 16th March 2009 21:46

Train at an FBO who YOU are happy with. What may suits you may not suit another. Find one with good instructor to student ratio. Good access to the aircraft and various facilities like ILS, NDB & VORs.

Take the time out to visit various FBO/Training centres. If you can, make sure you have some idea about what each stage of the training should take. (I think you may be able to get that from LASORs)

In the end, the license is exactly the same. There is no difference nowadays.

Make sure who ever does your IR is very thorough. That's the "real" test so to speak.

maxdrypower 16th March 2009 21:59

see your pms matey


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:33.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.