PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   Icao Language Proficiency Check (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/473079-icao-language-proficiency-check.html)

P'tit Prince 1st January 2012 22:32

Icao Language Proficiency Check
 
Does anyone know where I can take an informal evaluaton for English language proficiency at level 6 (any where in UK).

S-Works 2nd January 2012 09:08

Are you a native English speaker?

A and C 2nd January 2012 17:50

Any EASA TRE should be able to issue one of these.

S-Works 2nd January 2012 17:57

Not necessarily. It depends on a number of factors, including whether you're a native English speaker and whether your state of licence issue places specific requirements for the grant of a Level 6. Hence the reason I asked the question.

Many NAAs require non native English speakers to undergo a formal language assessment. The UK CAS were pragmatic enough to allow native English speakers to be assessed by an examiner in the course of a skill test.

Edit: damn iPad spelling.

Jan Olieslagers 2nd January 2012 18:09

Mind you the original question is about an

informal evaluaton
(sic!) which might well indicate the poster is after a rough assessment of her/his chances for a level 6. Seeing (s)he left 2 typos in place even after a PM, that might be a wise idea.

achimha 2nd January 2012 18:53

These guys from the UK offer level 6 testing in Germany and elsewhere: Cockpit Voices.

They offered me a quick chat on the phone to determine whether level 6 is a realistic option.

This ICAO language stuff makes me want to cry. I had a document from the FAA declaring that I was "English proficient" but the German CAA did not consider the FAA to be competent in this regard and required me to pass the test with a German examiner whose English was ... rather basic.

dublinpilot 2nd January 2012 19:04


Many NAAs require non native English speakers to undergo a formal language assessment.
And some require native English speakers to undergo formal testing too.

patowalker 2nd January 2012 19:11


Seeing (s)he left 2 typo's in place even after a PM, that might be a wise idea.
What does the apostrophe stand for in "typo's"? :)

WestWind1950 2nd January 2012 19:13

@achimha... Cockpit Voices is at the moment no longer acredited to do Level 6, so I hear.

The FAA " English proficient" is only Level 4! Being proficient does not mean you are good enough for level 6. Besides, the remark on your FAA is not dated, which is required by ICAO, since level 4 is only good for 3-4 years (depending on country and/or IFR). Oh, and the German LBA does not accept tests done in other countries anyway, not even ones done in England, since the examiners are unknown to them.

Jan Olieslagers 2nd January 2012 19:21

You beat me there, duckling! I stand corrected, and so does my writing.

patowalker 2nd January 2012 19:22


The FAA " English proficient" is only Level 4!
"There even are places where English completely
disappears. In America, they haven't used it for years!"

Prof. HH

XLC 3rd January 2012 06:02

This english proficiency requirement is an odd one. Take for example UK JAA PP and a Thai PPL licence.
- In Thailand: you need an English proficiency evaluation to fly outside Thailand on a HS-registered plane. You do not need one if you fly within Thai airspace on such a licence.
- UK licence: it states that the language proficiency is English. (Obviously so I would say as all the training and tests/exams are in English anyway). But does such a licence holder need an extra exam to fly outside UK's airspace, like in Thailand?

achimha 3rd January 2012 06:30

Your UK PPL should contain a statement about English language proficiency ICAO level 6, dated XXX. Otherwise there could be trouble when flying outside of the UK.

Without this entry, Germans aren't even allowed to fly to Austria although the only official language there is German. So don't be surprised if they ground you in Ireland and confiscate your plane :)

The ICAO language test is one of the most stupid things I've seen lately. At least in Germany, it was very hard to find someone that was accredited to do the exam and pretty much impossible to get to more than level 4 without having to travel hundreds of kilometers.

When you fly to France and want to land at an aerodrome where there is no tower or outside business hours, usually the official unicom language is French. Legally, one would have to get a ICAO language proficiency entry for French as well.

Aphrican 3rd January 2012 06:53

[Grammar pedant hat on]

It is customary to insert an apostrophe into abbreviated words.

A "typo's" is an abbreviation of "typographical errors", the apostrophe has been used correctly.

[/Grammar pedant hat off]

flyingfemme 3rd January 2012 06:57


The FAA " English proficient" is only Level 4! Being proficient does not mean you are good enough for level 6. Besides, the remark on your FAA is not dated, which is required by ICAO, since level 4 is only good for 3-4 years
The FAA actually check for Level 4 or better, they just don't discriminate; if you pass, you pass. Recurrent checks are done (implicitly) every time you do a biannual flight check, instrument check, checkride or medical - all instructors, examiners and FMEs are required to inform the FAA if they consider your English proficiency is not good enough for level 4. Does that happen in practice? I don't know.......

S-Works 3rd January 2012 06:58


Your UK PPL should contain a statement about English language proficiency ICAO level 6, dated XXX. Otherwise there could be trouble when flying outside of the UK.
It should, but it does not. They just state English proficient. The UK CAA will provide a letter stating your level if requested. I doubt a native English speaker is going to be in much trouble flying outside the UK.

WestWind1950 3rd January 2012 09:35

@achima... The English exams allows you to do radio communication in English only. Since the primary aviation language IS English, the testing in English has priority.

You actually are not allowed to do radio communication in French unless you have a French level 4 (if it's being tested at all). Soon there will be the requirement for German level 4 within Germany for airfields that only communicate in German (listed in the AIP on the field charts)

And that regulation always existed. If a pilot could not communicate in German and an airfield only had German listed, then that pilot could not fly there.


The ICAO language test is one of the most stupid things I've seen lately. At least in Germany, it was very hard to find someone that was accredited to do the exam and pretty much impossible to get to more than level 4 without having to travel hundreds of kilometers.
I wouldn't call it stupid... ICAO set it up for a reason; and you can't have examiners for level 6 unless they themselves are good enough, and are professional language instructors or similar.

Some countries take it more serious then others. I heard that some German microlights were grounded in Denmark because they didn't have their English level 4 since there they are considered SEP's. And I also heard that soon after inforcement, the French had a fun time checking all incoming British pilots to see if they had their English level! :} Sorry, I can't confirm any of those "rumors".... just like the rumor that all of Alitalia's pilot got the level 6 without an exam. :uhoh:

mad_jock 3rd January 2012 10:25


the French had a fun time checking all incoming British pilots to see if they had their English level!
The bastards did as well. I was on the recieving end of that :mad: with a license with less than a year to run and no level indicated on it. The frog saying that if there was no level indicated it meant that it was level 4 and as the license was 4.5 years old I was out of date. Of course it was the weekend and they were quite happy to throw me in Jail until the CAA opened up again.

S-Works 3rd January 2012 10:55

To be fair, MJ, you are not a native English speaker so deserve what you get..... :p:p:p:p

dublinpilot 3rd January 2012 11:30


When you fly to France and want to land at an aerodrome where there is no tower or outside business hours, usually the official unicom language is French. Legally, one would have to get a ICAO language proficiency entry for French as well.
Can you point out a reference for this?

I can understand why it would make sense, but I've never seen any regulation with required it.

Indeed it would make French airfields in accessable to many foreign pilots even if they were fluent French speakers, simply because there is no facility to add French languange proficiency to their licence.

Imagine a Norweign pilot asking the Norweign CAA for a French Languange Proficiency test so that they could add it to their licence. It's very unlikely that they would have developed such a test, or have such an examiner.

Nobody other then the Norweign CAA can add any privlidges to a Norweign licence other than the Norweign CAA. Hence such a pilot could never visit such a French airfield.

I don't believe that there is any languange requirements in ICAO either other than needing either the local language or English.

Indeed many of these airfields can be used non-radio, making such a requirement simply silly.


All times are GMT. The time now is 18:10.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.