As I said before 27/09, you and I will never understand the weird way they do things over there.
|
Many of us over here wish we were over there.
|
A pretty common occurrence where I fly. |
Ontrack
As I said before 27/09, you and I will never understand the weird way they do things over there. |
Are you two NZ folks even reading the posts? For everyone saying you can't do something, there are several people pointing out that it is nonsense.
|
The point people don't seem to get, why is a mystery, is that closure and openness have nothing to do with facilities. It's to do with what the owner of the field has decided. Thus a major airport with facilities to cope with airliners might be closed to all traffic for some reason and a farm strip with no facilities at all might open to all comers.
It then behoves us as pilots to find out about and respect the wishes of the owner, apart from some legal implications in some cases, it's just good manners:ugh: Licensing is an entirely different matter and the need for a licensed aerodrome is covered by the aircraft operator's activities. Most activities including training, involving a light aircraft do not require a licensed aerodrome, certain commercial activities would need such an aerodrome, but this forum is about private flying. |
stevelup
Are you two NZ folks even reading the posts? For everyone saying you can't do something, there are several people pointing out that it is nonsense. NO. A "closed airfield" in the uk means whatever the operator wants it to. It is common for an airfield to be closed - no fuel, no food, no maintenance, no office to pay landing fee The point people don't seem to get, why is a mystery, is that closure and openness have nothing to do with facilities. It's to do with what the owner of the field has decided. |
Clearly the are some cultural differences in this discussion.
In this part of the world airports don't just close at the whim of the operator. There would have to be a compelling reason for any registered or certified airport not to be available, and I would expect to see that reason stated in a NOTAM. For example, I remember Rockhampton airport in Queensland was once closed for a couple of days because most of the runway was under floodwaters. Sure, runways are sometimes closed at short notice because of disabled aircraft (e.g. wheels-up landing). Generally, however, airports are open all day every day (and all night if lighting is available, and it usually is). Also, with very few exceptions, prior permission is not required. And why should it be? Airports are part of the national infrastructure and are there to be used. Obviously you need permission to use a private farm strip, except perhaps in the case of a forced landing. |
Airports are part of the national infrastructure In Europe, especially the smaller fields tend to be privately owned and privately operated. Which, as has been pointed out ad nauseum, leaves a lot of liberty to the owner/operator. |
I do find it a bit strange that some people based outside of the UK just can't accept that in the UK, the 'rules' are different.
Airfields in the UK tend for the most part to be privately owned and those owners can dictate whether or not they want people to land there. Sometimes their hands are tied by local planning restrictions, often brought about by the local population who view an airfield as an annoyance - not an asset to the community. Different countries different rules and laws and ways of life. Just over the water from here, everyone drives on the opposite side of the road - surely that is just plain wrong? |
I am just wondering how many UK grass strips can actually take any form of wheeled transport at this time of year... (hint... It's Wet.)
Isle of Wight Airport Sandown - EGHN - Home |
Compton Abbas (EGHA) is a grass strip and still accepts traffic :)
I guess it depends on how bad the "wet" has been. As for Sandown, I have been there a few times over last year, and they have put in a new ditch and drainage and have done a lot of work on the field. |
Compton Abbas has the advantage that the water can really only go way from the airfield, unfortunately not the case for most grass strips.:hmm:
|
smarthawke
I do find it a bit strange that some people based outside of the UK just can't accept that in the UK, the 'rules' are different. Airfields in the UK tend for the most part to be privately owned and those owners can dictate whether or not they want people to land there. Sometimes their hands are tied by local planning restrictions, often brought about by the local population who view an airfield as an annoyance - not an asset to the community. Different countries different rules and laws and ways of life. Just over the water from here, everyone drives on the opposite side of the road - surely that is just plain wrong? It would seem your rules are the same as here in the regard that over here use of any private airfield (whether it be a farm paddock or a sealed strip with full facilities) requires permission from the owner. Public airfields are just that, and are freely available for all to use. Some on here seem to infer a private airfield is closed when in fact all that is needed is the owners permission to use that strip. This was the point of confusion. |
Gosh...
Public airfields are just that, and are freely available for all to use. I have personally closed a public airfield, by phoning flight service, identifying myself as a firefighter, and instructing a notam be issued closing the airfield due to a fatal accident. Then I parked a fire truck in the middle of the runway, for the benefit of those who don't check notams. That airfield was then closed - no negotiation. The airfield "authority" did not yet know that I had closed the airfield, but it was closed. Indeed, he never found out that I closed the airfield, as he was the fatality. If a pilot had landed there during the closed time, I would have had that pilot violated. Some on here seem to infer a private airfield is closed when in fact all that is needed is the owners permission to use that strip. This was the point of confusion. It would be presumptuous to assume that you can land wherever you like (trespass) without assuring the "open" [to you] status of the airfield. Sometimes people get away with presumptuous, but it's still presumptuous, it's not "open". My 2 cents worth, as a private airfield owner, and formally, an employee of a public airfield operator. |
Just to put in my two pennorth FWIW. I might be totally off the ball here but I think in places like the US most airfields are owned by the municipality? They are public places, like a bus station. In the UK most airfields are owned by private individuals, and I don't mean that they own an airport but the strip is actually on their land. Indeed you are literally landing in their back yard in a lot of cases. They have the strip for their own use and they let other people use it because they are nice sort of people. Like if you have a big drive you might let the neighbour use it.
|
in places like the US most airfields are owned by the municipality? They are public places, like a bus station. Any competent authority can close the municipal airport (or the bus station). This would include the operator, the police, the fire department, and Transport Canada. For example, near me, CYOO, Oshawa, Ontario. From the Canadian Flight Supplement, in part, (my bold) OSHAWA ON CYOO REF N43 55 22 W78 53 42 Adj N 11°W UTC-5(4) Elev 459 ́ VTA A5000 F-21 LO6 T2 HI5 CAP OPR Muni 905-576-8146 Cert 1130-0330Z‡ O/T PPR The airport is public, and open from 1130 to 0330 UTC. The competent authority (the Airport Manager - Stephen ( I know him well)) can close the airport, and does every night. So when it is not open, it is closed. But, with prior permission you could land there. Only an air ambulance, or police aircraft will easily get that permission. That permitted aircraft would have permission to land, but the airport will still be closed to everyone else. Meigs field, where I used to fly as a destination from time to time, was also closed. Meigs Field - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia To be sure there was no misunderstanding, they dug up the runway one night, and the remaining aircraft had to be trucked out. No one liked it, and the authority who closed it was not regarded as competent, but it was closed. "Closed" is an absolute term, not subject to misunderstanding. Operation only by exemption, or opening. |
OK, lets try another angle. If an airfields hours of operation are say 9 am to 5 pm local, is it closed outside these hours, or open with no services? :E
Rod1 |
That's not another angle, Rod, that is twisting of words. You can forever play on the shades of meaning between "operational", "available", "accessible" &c &c ; it makes no change to the simple facts, as hard to accept/digest as they seem to be to some people.
|
Location: Midlands Posts: 2,261 OK, lets try another angle. If an airfields hours of operation are say 9 am to 5 pm local, is it closed outside these hours, or open with no services? Rod1 |
All times are GMT. The time now is 06:59. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.