PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   Uk to Spain vfr (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/495866-uk-spain-vfr.html)

aerofoil1 19th Sep 2012 07:48

Uk to Spain vfr
 
Good morning all fellow aviators
Right I'm planning on going to Spain in either a c152 or pa28 haven't decided yet although the latter might be more beneficial in terms of space and comfort.
Currently don't have a 737 type rating yet but I'm working on it!
Plus not many airfields hire those do they!
But on a serious note
Does this routing look do able.
I haven't yet got the charts so I've not looked at the airspace in detail
Here is the routing
Egbm-egjj for fuel then
Egjj-lfbd overnight there and re fuel
Lfbd-leso again more fuel
Leso-lemu stay there a couple of nights

Sounds pretty straight forward but with our knowing the airspace restrictions not 100%
would it be advisable to avoid the Pyrenees
Also what maps would you recommend ? Jepersens?
Finally in terms of checking the weather enroute which website is useful
Thanks again

aerofoil1 19th Sep 2012 08:00

Delete the thread ?

BackPacker 19th Sep 2012 08:04

Delete at least one of the two threads you created with the same subject. As there is no useful content in neither at this stage, your pick wihch to delete. But if you delete this one, non-content responses like mine and airpolices will be deleted as well, leaving you with a clean thread to discuss your (lack of) planning.

(And related to the original question, if you can afford such a trip you can also afford a subscription to Skydemon. Draw your route, see what airspace you hit, circumnavigate, THEN come back to us for suggestions. We're not here to do basic planning for you - you learned that in your PPL training.)

aerofoil1 19th Sep 2012 08:08

I have deleted the duplicate thread which was posted in error
I thought this was a forum where other pilots could get advice I'm not planning on doing the trip this year
Jees next time I won't bother asking
Incidentally I'm well aware of the need for flight planning just wanted advice and thoughts
Cheer up!

BackPacker 19th Sep 2012 08:19


Incidentally I'm well aware of the need for flight planning just wanted advice and thoughts

I'm not planning on doing the trip this year
Aerofoil1, you realize we're just here too to share some wisdom, have a few informed discussions, learn something from others, right? We're not paid here to answer your questions or do basic research for you. And we occasionally are in a grumpy mood which is not of your making, but might influence the way we post here. (As I am today...:{)

Your question is extremely vague. On the one hand you're babbling about a 737, then about a C172 or PA28, you mention a few airfields but have clearly not spent any time investigating the route between them. You don't give any hint on what sort of experience you have in crossing significant mountain ranges for instance. You don't seem to have done any investigation with regards to weather websites (loads of info on those already on here.)

This means that the type of posts you solicit are probably very long-winded, detailed ones, which might take up to an hour to compose. And if your plan is just a whim, not going to happen this year and possibly never, do you honestly expect us to spend that hour for you?

There's loads of people who are perfectly willing to help you a lot, with very detailed answers. But not on a whim like this, when you have not even done the most basic research.

aerofoil1 19th Sep 2012 08:36

I was merely trying to inject some light hearted humour in the post
As I've never flown overseas only via low cost airlines I am just after experiences of others who have flown a similar route
Yes the post is vague granted but not retarded
Now if I had posted a question like
"How do you fly a plane" then yes shoot me down!
Obviously before the trip happens I will have done my homework and obtained the necessary flight planning
The post is purely aimed at drawing on other peoples experiences

BackPacker 19th Sep 2012 08:49


The post is purely aimed at drawing on other peoples experiences
http://www.pprune.org/private-flying...ion-spain.html
http://www.pprune.org/private-flying...g-channel.html
http://www.pprune.org/private-flying...-mallorca.html
http://www.pprune.org/private-flying...s-customs.html

Just from typing "Spain" in the search box. I have not tried any of the other obvious keywords from your post.

srayne 19th Sep 2012 09:13


Here is the routing
Egbm-egjj for fuel then
Egjj-lfbd overnight there and re fuel
Lfbd-leso again more fuel
Leso-lemu stay there a couple of nights

Sounds pretty straight forward but with our knowing the airspace restrictions not 100%
would it be advisable to avoid the Pyrenees
Also what maps would you recommend ? Jepersens?
Finally in terms of checking the weather enroute which website is useful
Hi,

I've just done a very similar trip in a PA28 - very easy. Our route was
Cambridge -> La Rochelle -> San Sebastian -> Murcia (San Javier).

Beware that LEMU (Muchamiel) has no fuel thus will require an additional stop in Alicante which is expensive. This is why we chose Murcia. Fuel availability in the South of France was also a problem (August) so double check the French AIS and NOTAMs.

Crossing the Pyrenees from San Sebastian to Pamplona VOR is no problem VFR as long as you can get the 5000ft altitude on the day.

Coming back we routed Murcia - > Barcelona Reus (fuel Stop only) -> Carcassonne -> Annecy -> Reims Prunay -> Cambridge. This route allows you to cross the mountains at low level around the coast.

Maps we took were the Jepp half mil for Spain and the Carte Bossy one mil VFR for France. This together with SkyDemon was more than adequate (beware that SkyDemon Spanish charts do not show much VFR sector and route info yet - although this is being worked on). We used Skydemon to load and print out the AIP plates for all the airfields we needed.

For TAFs and METARs we used SkyDemon.

Fuel in Spain was about £2.20/L (incl VAT) and in France about £1.80/L.

Landing Fees from €15-€30 and parking was very cheap.

Here's a good guide for Muchamiel if you're still going there. Here are the Spanish charges for AENA airports and you can find the Spain AIP here.

Pilotage 19th Sep 2012 09:40

You might do worse than ask around the microlight community.

The 2012 World Microlight Championships were held in Spain, and so far as I know all of the British team flew there and back. Being microlights they'd have had to be day-VFR all the way, and their performance will have been similar to the aircraft you're thinking of.

All the teams names are at Latest News and most of them should be easy to track down as a fair number run flying schools.

P

aerofoil1 19th Sep 2012 10:01

Thanks Callum and yes the hours will come in handy

davrus 19th Sep 2012 12:27

Wow i am left gob smacked

Not posted on here for many years and after seeing the first few replys i dont think i will ever both.

I did however think this was a place to ask question and share experiences but obviously that does not seem the case.

Hats off to the posters that did help with the original question.

If i could answer ir give advise aerofoil1 then i would but unfortunatly havnt done the said flight but good luck and enjoy.

As for the misurable ones why comment if it is not of any use to the original question.

Sorry to rock the boat but this forum will soon be as bad as face book.

Rant over.

Pace 19th Sep 2012 12:46

As the others have stated go Via San Sebastian. The Beauty of that route is you can do it all low level as far as San Sebastian and there are numerous alternative airfields for you to dive in en route.
I have routed IFR via San Sebastian in a Seneca five twin on my way to Malaga numerous times but then did the trip in a Mooney very low level following the beaches all the way down.
The Mooney was a far more exciting experience at a few of hundred feet following the coast and you would have to be a complete idiot to
Get lost !

Pace

Whiskey Bravo 19th Sep 2012 14:03

Hello - we did a similar trip in the summer, ending in Portugal, in an Arrow. France is a doddle and you can either do it low level, or get up to FL65 and follow the Class E 'low level' routes. We did EGHH - LFRS (stop overnight), LFRS - A25 - BMC - B19 - ENSAC - MAGEC - LESO. This was all at FL85, which keeps you well clear of all the low level military activity and the French controllers (who are excllent) will pass you seamlessly from one sector to the next and get you cleared through all the Class D (at least in our experience). The approach into LESO is fabulous!

Another option is to route as high/low as you like down the West coast of France, however beware of the very large danger areas. Our inital plan was favouring routing through these, firstly for the most direct routing and secondly for the coastal scenery. On the way down we were unable to get a crossing, although some will tell you that you can simply route through at your own risk. We were given very positive instructions from ATC to change track and had the inland route ready to go in case this happened. We had checked the activity before departing Nantes and were even told they were cold... On the return, we telephoned Brest Info before departure, checked status, if we could get a crossing, who to call etc. and had no problem coming this way, but i was on a weekend. Brest Info very helpful - can't find their number right now, but I recall it wasn't too difficult to find.

You might want to check out handling etc at Bordeaux. My research suggested they were a bit more LHR like than other French regional airfields. Nantes were a pleasure and not very expensive.

Feel free to PM me and I'll share what I can.

aerofoil1 19th Sep 2012 17:36

srayne
thanks for all that info very informative

dublinpilot 19th Sep 2012 18:39

Bordeaux do indeed see themselves as a large commerical airport.

When I went in 2005, it was compulsory handling at €60. I'm sure it's more now.

All we got for he €60 by the way was an annoying handler who drove over immediately after landing to offer us a lift to his office in the mini bus. When told we'd need about 20 minutes before we were ready he left and came back after 5 minutes and then another 5 minutes. So it was somewhat annoying. In the end we told him we'd be happy to walk the 50 meters to his office and see him inside ;) They also look our payment for the landing charges and under duress, organised the aircraft to be refulled.

I'm suggest you look at La Rochelle which breaks your journey into two relatively equal halves rather than the lobsided split that Bordeaux gives you.

I'm not sure what you're flying and what your range is, but if it was me, I'd go straight to France, perhaps Breast. By doing so you can clear customs early and are free to land whereever you want after that. ie you no longer need to land at a customs airport.

If your range is good enough for 350nm, then you could go straight to LESO without the need to stop in between.

By the way, PocketFMS does have all the VFR sectors in Spain (has had now for nearly nine years ;) ). It too can handle all your flight planning across Europe on such a trip, and works on your iPhone, iPad, Android, Windows, WinCE.

dp

Pace 19th Sep 2012 19:03

WB

I went from La Rochelle all the way to San Sebastian a few hundred meters out to sea following the beaches at a few hundred feet with no problems with Danger areas and in ATC communication all the way!

It was CAVOK with clear skies and excellent visibility! Changing to Biarritz I was horrified to hear them giving RVR with unforecast fog something you have to be aware of in that area with the cold Atlantic.
I was then a few hundred feet above solid cloud with San Sebastian still in the clear (just) popping over the fog banks San Sebastian runway appeared in one clear patch over the airport which fogged in 20 minutes later.

Pace

stickandrudderman 19th Sep 2012 19:12

Airpolice and Backpacker, I think you should apologise.
A naive question by the OP? Perhaps.
An arrogant and bullying response from you two? Definately.
Just because you're on an anonymous forum is no excuse for a lack of courtesy.
Have you never asked a dumb question in your life?:ugh::ugh::ugh:

peterh337 19th Sep 2012 19:38

I have some Spanish and French VFR trips on my website. They are quite detailed and were written to assist people doing long trips.

San Seb no longer has Customs so cannot be flown to/from the UK directly (a 24 carat stupid decision but so many airports are not run for aviation purposes).

Those RAs off the west coast of France tend to be inactive at weekends, but a smarter procedure for VFR is to always plan two routes: one which is assured, and one which you actually want to fly. Then make the selection once airborne and when you can get French ATC to advise on the activity of e.g. R31A1 or whatever.

Obviously watch the French nuclear power station areas. Notams and current charts are a must for foreign flying. In the UK you can be sloppy but if you do that abroad you will one day get caught with your trousers down. The French especially have bizzarely arrogant ways of dealing with this stuff.

Sadly I am also one of those who does occassionally say that posters need to ask well formed questions if they want people to type up long detailed answers. This issue appears on every internet forum and is not getting any better as the years go by, mainly IMHO due to the proliferation of smartphones which have brought out a lot of "low effort content creation", but their owners are still somehow expecting others to spent time on typing up good replies. It just ain't going to happen, and that is why when you do a but of google research on almost any topic you dig out hundreds of web forum discussion hits pointing to long threads packed with banal one-liner posts and you have to spend hours wading through all this... and most of them are dead ends. Whether you like it or not, human nature is what it is, and this is why the quality of online discussion is declining - everywhere, not just the aviation forums.

Whiskey Bravo 19th Sep 2012 19:41

Pace,

Sounds like a great trip and that was basically the plan, although not quite at 200ft... As I said, ATC were very insistent that we didn't route through the danger areas, but were then very accomodating getting us around to be fair. Big lesson was speaking to Brest on the telephone who gave us all the detail we needed for the return and that was the way we routed back from Burgos.

Perhaps we should have been a little more insistent, but on our first trip beyond the Channel Islands or Wales we weren't quite ready to start an international incident without being absolutley sure we were in the right.

Second using La Rochelle or Nantes to split up the trip. If the seat cushions are of 1978 vintage 2 ish hr legs are about enough!

Pace 19th Sep 2012 20:00


we weren't quite ready to start an international incident without being absolutley sure we were in the right.
I probably do start international incidents in my wake :E (only joking) It was a while back and without checking the charts I do not remember that many restrictions close into the shoreline remembering the DAs were further out to sea!

Pace


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:11.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.