PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   Prior Permission Required (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/441228-prior-permission-required.html)

The Dead Side 30th Jan 2011 21:55

Prior Permission Required
 
Whenever I've flown VFR cross country, I've always rang ahead in advance to be greeted with a brief of any unlikely approach procedures and the latest weather and conditions.

I was flying today, tuning into local frequencies just to keep a listen out for their circuits etc., whereupon G-XXXX requests PPR in the circuit to land.

Is it common to fly and just land at an airfield without PPR? I realise most airfields will publish such a need to ask, however I'm wondering how many ask before takeoff, if at all.

Russell Gulch 30th Jan 2011 22:05

It's easier to beg forgiveness than to ask permission.

Genghis the Engineer 30th Jan 2011 22:11

Quite a few airfields are happy for it to be done on RT, but arguably once you're in the circuit, you've really left it a little late. Sounds like somebody was making some political point or other.

G

The Flying Chicken 30th Jan 2011 22:13

Depends where you're going and who you know.
With the instructor hat on, always request PPR for every airfield, or at least, try to get PPR - Gives the student an idea of what to expect.
With my "jolly" hat on, I know a number of airfields that'll take me with no issues at all with or without a call on the radio. But then, I do know who operates the airfield/strips and normally places I wouldn't take most students.

Katamarino 31st Jan 2011 07:42

PPR always makes me laugh. It's like having to phone the supermarket each time you go shopping to get permission to park in their car park.

Jan Olieslagers 31st Jan 2011 07:47

Always wondered what the "prior" refers to. Prior to take-off? To joining the circuit?

For those thinking it ridiculous: the one time I had NOT called before take-off, I found the place rented out for some commercial event and the runway cluttered with booths and people. Of course I had a plan B, there was never a real problem, but I had no plan C so I was on the lucky side.

Edit: over here, many aerodromes explicitly require "PPR by telephone" - check Recreatief Vliegveld Grimbergen - EBGB - Grimbergen Airfield for just one example - and since we're supposed to NOT use our mobiles while airborne there's few options left.

IO540 31st Jan 2011 08:02


PPR always makes me laugh. It's like having to phone the supermarket each time you go shopping to get permission to park in their car park.
Yes, and about as meaningful in practice in the case of large airfields.

PNR/Customs is more meaningful: the policeman is not normally based there. Of course, they could see the incoming flight plans, which is how UK Designated Customs airport Customs decide whether to turn up or not, but most are not that smart :)

cats_five 31st Jan 2011 08:20

But for airfields operating under the 28-day rule or other restrictions it's vital that they know who is coming and going so they don't exceed it - or rather you don't accidentally exceed it for them.

englishal 31st Jan 2011 08:23

Any airfield that doesn't request "PPR by phone" I don't bother calling before and just turn up and ask to land. That way if we decide to go elsewhere, no big deal. There are lots of airfields around that don't require PPR by phone (Examples: Old Sarum, Compton Abbas, Dunkerswell, Bembridge, Shoreham etc....) and if you do phone them they just say...rightyo see ya later.

It has onluy caught me out once, on a flight to Bembridge a few weeks ago and we'd missed the Notam of being closed :O:} Never mind, we just went elsewhere. Might be worthwhile if you are travelling a long distance, beyond bladder diverting range at any rate !

172driver 31st Jan 2011 08:36


PPR always makes me laugh. It's like having to phone the supermarket each time you go shopping to get permission to park in their car park
Quite. In any case, it's largely a UK thing (other then the customs/immigration PNR, but then again, that also pertains mostly to/from the UK, at least in Europe).

IO540 31st Jan 2011 09:09


But for airfields operating under the 28-day rule or other restrictions it's vital that they know who is coming and going so they don't exceed it - or rather you don't accidentally exceed it for them.
I suppose the owner of such a private facility, trying hard to stay below the NIMBY radar, needs to make a decision on whether to publicise it at all. If I had a strip operating like that I would not publish it in any directory for the 10 years it needs to run. I would just invite mates of mine to drop in so I can build up the movements log, for the subsequent approval.

You can't just park in somebody else's drive, so you can't just drop into a strip which you see from the air.

A lot of southern European airports are PPR, Schengen or not. Just look at Greece. Of course there are loads that aren't but it's a pity to throw away the utility of those that are on the basis that one doesn't need to fly there.

I almost never fly to any airport - other than some big H24 ones which I know are not PPR - unless I can contact it beforehand, or the person I am meeting has done so. In the UK it's just a simple phone call.

WestWind1950 31st Jan 2011 09:25

It is not largely a UK thing, there are many so-called "special airfields" in Germany with PPR and most/all can be asked via radio, but you may get refused.

The reasons are many, for example: the field might have few parking positions and thus they won't let you land if those are already filled; or repair work (or event, as mentioned above... ppr fields don't usually need to NOTAM) is going on; landing conditions are poor (=flooded or snow), and so on.

It's always sensible to call in advance, but if you leave yourself an alternative, there is usually no problem to call in via radio and ask, unless, of course, a prior phone call is specifically requested.

Miroku 31st Jan 2011 09:29

Well I for one always phone ahead. That way I can find out the weather, which runway is in use and anything else which could be useful.

NigelOnDraft 31st Jan 2011 09:40

PPR actually covers a multitude of sins... you didn't see/check/missed the NOTAM re the Air Display - they've got no fuel today - they're closed today because someone is sick etc.

I try to PPR except for airfields I know well. After all, the land is usually private property of some form or other, and it is only a common courtesy.

As above, if people "encourage" others that PPR when requested should be disregarded, some will not know here to draw the line e.g. private strips.


so they don't exceed it - or rather you don't accidentally exceed it for them. If I had a strip operating like that I would not publish it in any directory for the 10 years it needs to run. I would just invite mates of mine to drop in so I can build up the movements log, for the subsequent approval.
Just to be clear:
  1. To get the "approval" via CLU will require you to exceed the 28day "limit" for each of the 10 (consecutive) years
  2. I am not 100% sure you then "need" a subsequent approval - that requires notifying the authorities with all sorts of implications including rates :(
  3. If you do then go for PP the "restrictions" will probably be more onerous than before you ever told anybody
NoD

DX Wombat 31st Jan 2011 10:02

:uhoh:

It's easier to beg forgiveness than to ask permission.
Don't try that at Duxford. There is often a lot going on at Duxford and the staff also like to know that you have had a full briefing before you set off. If you don't ask BEFORE you set off the only way you will land there is in a dire emergency. Having said all that, it's a great place to visit with two well maintained runways and other facilities and all the staff I have met have been really friendly and helpful. :ok:

Deeply Concerned 31st Jan 2011 11:50

Some years ago I did so part time instructing at a small grass airfield that welcomed visitors on PPR only. The idea was to gain some idea of the visitors experience before commiting, effectivly a screening process. It's amazing how many PPLs who learned at a large airfield have serious trouble with 600m of wet grass. Every year there would be an aircraft in the hedge.

There are other hazards with grass airfields in winter. Nose wheel aircraft on water logged ground isn't a good idea if you don't know in advance. If PPR is asked there's a reason, please comply.

Katamarino 31st Jan 2011 12:02

I agree that PPR is valid in some situations; such as a private strip with operating limitations. However, it seems to be applied with a ridiculously broad brush; most of the places I have called for PPR have just said "yes, no problem", and when asked if there is anything in particular I need to know, they say no! Then why are you asking for PPR at all, at a large, well equipped, airfield?

I know the wonderful USA is often pointed to as an example, but I have flown to hundreds of airfields over there, and have only encountered one, single airfield, where PP was R. Apart from a love of bureaucracy and rules, I see nothing that rules the majority of Europe's PPR airfields out as particularly different...

sammypilot 31st Jan 2011 13:41

It is common sense to telephone ahead. Firstly there may be a Notam you have missed (see above posting.) Secondly you get an update on the weather. In the U.K. as we all know a matter of a few miles or unusual local conditions can cause huge variations. Recently we were going to go to Garston Farm. Brize and Lyneham were both giving CAVOK but a check with the field's owner produced the response that they were 300 metres in fog caused by the fields elevation. There may also be a special briefing that you need. Finally knowing the runway in use gives you a chance to plan your approach by looking up the Plate.

englishal 31st Jan 2011 15:51

Of course the runway can change during your flight and then you'd be screwed eh?

Fine for 'small strips' or first time, but is there really any need to phone an "international airport" if you want to drop in there? As the americans would say on the phone if you called them "Eh? It's an airport, of course you can land here ???!?!?!" :D

DBo 31st Jan 2011 16:02

PPR
 
A little while ago in CHIRP there was a whine by somebody who hadn't phoned for PPR and found on arrival that the airfield was closed for 30 minutes during the day for an aerobatic display. Being a pilot he was outraged by their actions...

If I'm going for a bimble to somewhere I know and I either have alternate destinations or don't mind just flying back then I may not phone first*. If I really want to land there, or I need to get fuel then I'll ring before I take off.

Dave


* only applies to airfields - I always phone strips.


All times are GMT. The time now is 14:39.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.