PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Private Flying (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying-63/)
-   -   90 bank turn (Merged) (https://www.pprune.org/private-flying/206171-90-bank-turn-merged.html)

muck-savage 13th Jan 2006 10:51

90 degree turn
 
Hi,

Does a 90 degree turn exist......What happens to the forces in a turn after 75 degrees.....


Thanks
Mucky

Farmer 1 13th Jan 2006 11:24

Re: 90 degree turn
 
I suspect you mean bank, Mucky, not turn.

Plenty of 90 degree turns.

High Wing Drifter 13th Jan 2006 12:01

Re: 90 degree turn
 
Hmm. Not sure I understabd the question but I'll take a stab at: The Attitude Indicator will show an underbank and a pitch up.

FlyingForFun 13th Jan 2006 12:18

Re: 90 degree turn
 
Muck,

I think what you are asking is if it's possible to turn with 90 degrees angle of bank?

If that's the case you might consider asking the question in the Private Flying forums, since this is an aerobatic move and there are plenty of people in there who fly aerobatics and would be able to answer your question. As I understand it, though, the lift from the wings would be entirely horizontal, and therefore not counteract the weight at all. However, the fuselage of the aircraft will actually generate a small amount of lift - in some aircraft, enough to counteract the weight. Since up/down with reference to the ground now corresponds to left/right with reference to the pilot, it is the rudder which is used to control the angle of attack. I'm not an expert, though.

FFF
---------------

muck-savage 13th Jan 2006 12:36

Re: 90 degree turn
 
Cheers.... Sorry I badly phrased the question..

I ment If you bank 90 degrees in a turn trying to keep constant alt and speed what will happen + where will forces act

muck-savage 13th Jan 2006 12:38

90 bank turn (Merged)
 
If you bank 90 degrees in a turn trying to keep constant alt and speed what will happen + where will forces act

Croqueteer 13th Jan 2006 14:00

Re: 90 bank turn
 
:eek: Down laddie, Down.

Confabulous 13th Jan 2006 14:19

Re: 90 bank turn
 
Way, way down... there being no horizontal lift component to keep you at the same altitude. If you're thinking of how aerobatic aircraft do it, it's combination of fuselage lift, thrust and a lot of top rudder. Since only aerobatic aircraft are cleared for that kind of asymmetric tail loads, stay away from that flight regime - you'd probably be safer doing a barrel roll!

Andy_R 13th Jan 2006 16:10

Re: 90 bank turn
 
By trying to maintain constant altitude, you will be pulling mighty hard on the yoke/stick and will stall, with the natural (and fairly dramatic in that configuration) consequences of that.

Keygrip 13th Jan 2006 16:47

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
Muck - Pprune rules of engagement:

1 subject = 1 thread, on ONE forum.

paulo 13th Jan 2006 18:55

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
It should be possible with a sufficiently powerful aircraft, given that knife edge "level flight" is easily doable in, say an, Extra 300. Absolutely no chance in anything less.

There's one stunning video clip I've seen where Jurgis Kairys does a low pass, knife edge. The video is taken, 50ft or so above ground, from a grandstand at racetrack in Japan. He passes *below* the camera position. :eek:

Forward airspeed is very low in these scenarios, as the aircraft is partly 'helicoptering' (aka 'prop hanging'), rather than flying on the fuselage & rudder alone.

BEagle 13th Jan 2006 19:13

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
When I flew the Buccaneer, we used to fly 'head-down' toss-bombing manoeuvres dual in the Hunter T8b with a safety pilot although they would be used for real in the Bucc. If I recall correctly, we flew straight and level at around 1000 ft and 450 KIAS, then pulled up at about 3 g until reaching some specific height. The rolled to 120 deg bank, pulled round and rolled out on reciprocal heading at 500 ft above entry height.

Quite disorientating, but simple enough once you got the hang of them.

djpil 13th Jan 2006 19:44

Re: 90 degree turn
 

Originally Posted by FlyingForFun
Muck,
As I understand it, though, the lift from the wings would be entirely horizontal, and therefore not counteract the weight at all. However, the fuselage of the aircraft will actually generate a small amount of lift - in some aircraft, enough to counteract the weight. Since up/down with reference to the ground now corresponds to left/right with reference to the pilot, it is the rudder which is used to control the angle of attack.---------------

Yep, easy in a Pitts S-1.

Keygrip 13th Jan 2006 19:45

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
BEagle....and the relevance of that to this thread...is...?

BEagle 13th Jan 2006 19:54

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
....obviously lost on you.

The world does not stop at a mere 75 deg AoB.

eharding 13th Jan 2006 20:04

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 

Originally Posted by Keygrip
BEagle....and the relevance of that to this thread...is...?

Who cares - I still want a go in a Buccaneer!

The Pitts can maintain a knife-edge straight & level, never tried to
actually *turn* in a knife-edge.

foxmoth 13th Jan 2006 20:04

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 

The world does not stop at a mere 75 deg AoB.

Yes, but hardly a level manouver:E

Paris Dakar 13th Jan 2006 20:06

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
There was link on PPRuNe yonks ago to a video clip of a large mil aircraft which obtained almost that angle of bank - with such catostrophic (and fatal) results.

The aircraft (N American?) possibly a B52 was at a display when the accident happened - a graphic illustration which clearly showed what happens when all lift is lost.

DubTrub 13th Jan 2006 20:07

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 
Well modded, Keygrip


Originally Posted by Croq
Down laddie, Down.

Not quite, if in knife edge, power is able to overcome the quite significant high drag. Otherwise, correct.


..and yes, it was a B52

paulo 13th Jan 2006 23:17

Re: 90 bank turn (Merged)
 

Originally Posted by eharding
Who cares - I still want a go in a Buccaneer!
The Pitts can maintain a knife-edge straight & level, never tried to
actually *turn* in a knife-edge.

Damn you!, and your perfectly neutral elevator control. :ok:

[edit: changed aileron to elevator)


All times are GMT. The time now is 21:43.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.