Engine Roughness/Loss of Power
Thread Starter
Engine Roughness/Loss of Power
This thread is meant to compliment the one on the use of Carb Heat.
In flying training engine problems are usually presented as binary. Engine runs engine doesn't run. However the engine malfunctions that the average PPL is much more likely to actually encounter is a rough running engine and/or a loss of some engine power. What to do about this hardly ever seems to be covered in flight training.
I recently helped redo the emergency checklist for a local flight school and I addressed this issue in the non memory recall section. The intent is a "check" for the pilot use if he/she encounters an engine problem. It goes as follows
Engine Roughness/Reduction in Engine Power
-Carb heat.........................................Full On for at least 30 sec
-Engine gauges...................................Check
(Note if severe carb ice exists engine will initially run very rough until ice has cleared)
If problem persists
-Carb heat........................................Cold
-Mixture ...........................................Full rich then lean to max RPM
If problem persists
- Mags............................................Select right and left mag individually
(Note if engine roughness is more pronounced on one mag select the other mag or both, whichever gives smoothest operation)
----------------Land at nearest suitable airport------------------------
If problem persists
- Fuel selector.................................Left for 2 mins
If problem persists............................Right for 2 mins
---------------Land at nearest suitable airport-------------------------
In addition to to this I have emphasized the importance monitoring the engine instruments in flight. Instructors now periodically and without warning cover the oil temp/press gauges and make sure the students know where the needle is actually pointing. (In the green is not a good enough answer ).
Internal mechanical failures resulting in a total engine failure are the least likely cause of an engine failure but they do happen. The good news is there will almost always be some warning. Any internal misalignment or failure will almost always result in metal rubbing. This will cause a rapid rise in oil temperature with the oil temp gauge pegging at its maximum value. A dramatic drop in oil pressure will quickly follow. Any engine showing these signs should be presumed to be in danger of imminent total failure and appropriate actions to land ASAP should be taken. The only caveat is an open circuit in the oil temp wiring will cause the oil temp needle to peg at the highest temp. However in this case the oil pressure will be normal so it is likely just the gauge. However a landing at the nearest suitable airport would be prudent
In flying training engine problems are usually presented as binary. Engine runs engine doesn't run. However the engine malfunctions that the average PPL is much more likely to actually encounter is a rough running engine and/or a loss of some engine power. What to do about this hardly ever seems to be covered in flight training.
I recently helped redo the emergency checklist for a local flight school and I addressed this issue in the non memory recall section. The intent is a "check" for the pilot use if he/she encounters an engine problem. It goes as follows
Engine Roughness/Reduction in Engine Power
-Carb heat.........................................Full On for at least 30 sec
-Engine gauges...................................Check
(Note if severe carb ice exists engine will initially run very rough until ice has cleared)
If problem persists
-Carb heat........................................Cold
-Mixture ...........................................Full rich then lean to max RPM
If problem persists
- Mags............................................Select right and left mag individually
(Note if engine roughness is more pronounced on one mag select the other mag or both, whichever gives smoothest operation)
----------------Land at nearest suitable airport------------------------
If problem persists
- Fuel selector.................................Left for 2 mins
If problem persists............................Right for 2 mins
---------------Land at nearest suitable airport-------------------------
In addition to to this I have emphasized the importance monitoring the engine instruments in flight. Instructors now periodically and without warning cover the oil temp/press gauges and make sure the students know where the needle is actually pointing. (In the green is not a good enough answer ).
Internal mechanical failures resulting in a total engine failure are the least likely cause of an engine failure but they do happen. The good news is there will almost always be some warning. Any internal misalignment or failure will almost always result in metal rubbing. This will cause a rapid rise in oil temperature with the oil temp gauge pegging at its maximum value. A dramatic drop in oil pressure will quickly follow. Any engine showing these signs should be presumed to be in danger of imminent total failure and appropriate actions to land ASAP should be taken. The only caveat is an open circuit in the oil temp wiring will cause the oil temp needle to peg at the highest temp. However in this case the oil pressure will be normal so it is likely just the gauge. However a landing at the nearest suitable airport would be prudent
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 2,460
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Of course the other reason for engine roughness might be the use of fine wire (iridium) spark plugs made by Champion which have contained defective resistors for many years - see the thread I started here a few weeks ago
On your last para, this is why I have two oil temp gauges and two oil pressure gauges. Getting a 2nd oil temp gauge installed is usually trivial; mine was done via an extra probe on the EDM700. Getting a 2nd oil pressure gauge installed is usually not trivial (on a G-reg) but is unquestionably a Minor Alteration on an N-reg if done right, and UMA make some nice compact (1.25") TSOd transducers and instruments for that.
I see proon has modified the rules under which it marks posts as edited. Previously one had ~ 1 minute to do edits; now it is zero.
On your last para, this is why I have two oil temp gauges and two oil pressure gauges. Getting a 2nd oil temp gauge installed is usually trivial; mine was done via an extra probe on the EDM700. Getting a 2nd oil pressure gauge installed is usually not trivial (on a G-reg) but is unquestionably a Minor Alteration on an N-reg if done right, and UMA make some nice compact (1.25") TSOd transducers and instruments for that.
I see proon has modified the rules under which it marks posts as edited. Previously one had ~ 1 minute to do edits; now it is zero.
Last edited by peterh337; 16th May 2012 at 06:19.
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Stuttgart, Germany
Posts: 265
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
That "in this case the oil pressure will be normal so it is likely just the gauge" case seems to be a standard thing that PPL students learn. I'm not convinced it's a smart thing to teach students. How likely is it and what is the chance of the pilot drawing the wrong conclusions because he remembers that the oil temperature gauge is very likely to fail?
Another case of rough running engine that most pilots are probably not aware of is mixture too rich. In hot and high conditions, you can often kill the engine by setting the mixture too rich. From my experience, students learn that in case of engine roughness, the mixture should be enriched.
Another case of rough running engine that most pilots are probably not aware of is mixture too rich. In hot and high conditions, you can often kill the engine by setting the mixture too rich. From my experience, students learn that in case of engine roughness, the mixture should be enriched.
Join Date: Dec 2011
Posts: 2,460
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I don't think that - if your only engine instruments are oil temp and pressure - normal readings on those are a good guide to a good engine, because in a Lyco the oil pump is a constant volume (gear) pump which feeds a spring loaded pressure regulator valve which will maintain a constant-ish pressure over a fair oil temp range, and the oil temp itself will take a long time to rise, if at all, if there is a localised mechanical problem such a bearing about to seize.
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Amsterdam
Posts: 4,598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Another addition to your checklist, BPF, might be the minimum RPM number at which flight is sustainable.
If RPM is higher than, approximately, 1700 RPM (assuming fixed pitch here), you can fly to the nearest airport (at approximately Vbg/Vy). If it's lower than that number, you cannot sustain flight and will have to prepare for an off-airport landing. But you might have a little engine power to control your descent.
Another thing is uncontrollable/runaway RPM, for instance due to a stuck or broken throttle linkage. Fly to the overhead of the nearest airfield, cut the engine with mixture and/or ignition and make a glide landing. To contain the RPM/speed in case of a runaway, initiate a climb or use steep turns. A runaway RPM can also be contained with very aggressive leaning. Yes, the engine will run rough, but you will be able to keep it below redline.
If RPM is higher than, approximately, 1700 RPM (assuming fixed pitch here), you can fly to the nearest airport (at approximately Vbg/Vy). If it's lower than that number, you cannot sustain flight and will have to prepare for an off-airport landing. But you might have a little engine power to control your descent.
Another thing is uncontrollable/runaway RPM, for instance due to a stuck or broken throttle linkage. Fly to the overhead of the nearest airfield, cut the engine with mixture and/or ignition and make a glide landing. To contain the RPM/speed in case of a runaway, initiate a climb or use steep turns. A runaway RPM can also be contained with very aggressive leaning. Yes, the engine will run rough, but you will be able to keep it below redline.
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Los Angeles, USA
Age: 52
Posts: 1,631
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Magnetos can wreak havoc in the BOTH config, if one starts misbehaving. Can fire completely randomly. So, it can be better to run on one than use the false redundancy/safety blanket of both.
I've found that my oil temp meters either work or they don't. Abnormal readings are not the norm.
I've found that my oil temp meters either work or they don't. Abnormal readings are not the norm.
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: SoCal
Posts: 1,929
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Abnormal readings are not the norm.
Sorry Adam, couldn't resist.....
Last edited by 172driver; 16th May 2012 at 10:06.
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: South-East, United Kingdom
Posts: 248
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I have a related question. I was flying my Piper Archer 181 at 11,000ft and was levelled off, in clear air above clouds, with full RPM and sufficient leaninig. When I applied the carb heat, the engine began to run roughly. I left the carb heat on, thinking there might be a bit of icing. Once the carb heat was turned off, the engine was fine. Applying the carb heat again straightaway, the engine ran rough again. At the time the engine was near the end of its 2000 hour lifecycle and later was shown to have lost about 10% of its power over it's life. I was also pretty much near the service ceiling.
Was the roughness, due to the thinner air, possibly compounded by by the heat applied from the exhaust manifold? I wasnt overly concerned. We had to get a new engine later on anyhow, but havent since been up that high, so I dont know if my experience was 'normal' for the type of plane / height.
Was the roughness, due to the thinner air, possibly compounded by by the heat applied from the exhaust manifold? I wasnt overly concerned. We had to get a new engine later on anyhow, but havent since been up that high, so I dont know if my experience was 'normal' for the type of plane / height.
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Amsterdam
Posts: 4,598
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My thoughts too. Did you adjust the mixture after applying carb heat? That might have solved the rough running.
Other than that - what was the OAT at FL110? If it's extremely cold, applying carb heat might actually bring the carb temps within the icing range. Although there will probably not enough moisture in the air at those OATs to actually cause icing.
Other than that - what was the OAT at FL110? If it's extremely cold, applying carb heat might actually bring the carb temps within the icing range. Although there will probably not enough moisture in the air at those OATs to actually cause icing.
Engine running rough?
Fix it FAST!
F - fuel, change tanks or change mixture setting, or both.
A- air, carb heat or alternate air in case of engine with CS prop
S- spark, check magneto's L/R leave on L or R if condition simprove
T- technical, mechanical failure, throttle cable, mixture cable, oil on cowling or windscreen.. > divert or precautionary landing.
Fix it FAST!
F - fuel, change tanks or change mixture setting, or both.
A- air, carb heat or alternate air in case of engine with CS prop
S- spark, check magneto's L/R leave on L or R if condition simprove
T- technical, mechanical failure, throttle cable, mixture cable, oil on cowling or windscreen.. > divert or precautionary landing.
Thread Starter
That "in this case the oil pressure will be normal so it is likely just the gauge" case seems to be a standard thing that PPL students learn. I'm not convinced it's a smart thing to teach students. How likely is it and what is the chance of the pilot drawing the wrong conclusions because he remembers that the oil temperature gauge is very likely to fail?
Another case of rough running engine that most pilots are probably not aware of is mixture too rich. In hot and high conditions, you can often kill the engine by setting the mixture too rich. From my experience, students learn that in case of engine roughness, the mixture should be enriched.
Another case of rough running engine that most pilots are probably not aware of is mixture too rich. In hot and high conditions, you can often kill the engine by setting the mixture too rich. From my experience, students learn that in case of engine roughness, the mixture should be enriched.
This does beg the question of what is "normal" oil pressure and temperature. Another area that usually isn't addressed in flight training. Oil temp and oil pressure effect each other.
I you have just started your engine on a cold morning it would be normal to have the oil pressure every high, probably close to the upper redline limit with the oil temp at the bottom of the gauge. As the oil warms up the oil pressure will slowly reduce to a more normal mid gauge (ie 75 ish PSI) indication. However if you restart the engine after a short break on a 30 C day, you will should a very high oil temp and the oil pressure will probably be in the yellow arc at low RPMs. Therefore a low oil temp at start up on a cold day with low oil pressure or a very low oil temp after a short shut down on a hot day should be of concern.
I agree with your comment about the mixture which is why it is addressed in my checklist. Since the problem could be too lean a mixture as well as too rich a mixture it is best to start with full rich and then lean to maximum RPM.
Thread Starter
Engine running rough?
Fix it FAST!
F - fuel, change tanks or change mixture setting, or both.
A- air, carb heat or alternate air in case of engine with CS prop
S- spark, check magneto's L/R leave on L or R if condition simprove
T- technical, mechanical failure, throttle cable, mixture cable, oil on cowling or windscreen.. > divert or precautionary landing.
Fix it FAST!
F - fuel, change tanks or change mixture setting, or both.
A- air, carb heat or alternate air in case of engine with CS prop
S- spark, check magneto's L/R leave on L or R if condition simprove
T- technical, mechanical failure, throttle cable, mixture cable, oil on cowling or windscreen.. > divert or precautionary landing.
The first thing that you need to do with a rough running engine is apply full carb heat.
Thread Starter
I don't think that - if your only engine instruments are oil temp and pressure - normal readings on those are a good guide to a good engine, because in a Lyco the oil pump is a constant volume (gear) pump which feeds a spring loaded pressure regulator valve which will maintain a constant-ish pressure over a fair oil temp range, and the oil temp itself will take a long time to rise, if at all, if there is a localised mechanical problem such a bearing about to seize.
Last edited by Big Pistons Forever; 16th May 2012 at 14:43.
Thread Starter
Another addition to your checklist, BPF, might be the minimum RPM number at which flight is sustainable.
If RPM is higher than, approximately, 1700 RPM (assuming fixed pitch here), you can fly to the nearest airport (at approximately Vbg/Vy). If it's lower than that number, you cannot sustain flight and will have to prepare for an off-airport landing. But you might have a little engine power to control your descent.
If RPM is higher than, approximately, 1700 RPM (assuming fixed pitch here), you can fly to the nearest airport (at approximately Vbg/Vy). If it's lower than that number, you cannot sustain flight and will have to prepare for an off-airport landing. But you might have a little engine power to control your descent.
Last edited by Big Pistons Forever; 16th May 2012 at 14:29.
Thread Starter
I once had a mag suffer an internal failure which massively advanced the spark. The engine instantly lost a lot of power and was extremely rough. As soon as I deselected the bad mag the engine ran normally so I diverted to the nearest airport and landed.
I personally do not agree with this check.
The first thing that you need to do with a rough running engine is apply full carb heat.
The first thing that you need to do with a rough running engine is apply full carb heat.
If overly mixture was the culprit for the engine running rough selecting carb heat could cause it too stop.
But let's stop the discussion here, the point being that you need some sort of check/procedure memorized for these events.
FAST, AFeST, BUMP, BUMPFICH, GUMP, GUMPS, it's all trying to achieve the same thing.............memory items.
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: South-East, United Kingdom
Posts: 248
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My thoughts too. Did you adjust the mixture after applying carb heat? That might have solved the rough running
Other than that - what was the OAT at FL110? If it's extremely cold, applying carb heat might actually bring the carb temps within the icing range. Although there will probably not enough moisture in the air at those OATs to actually cause icing.
Join Date: May 2005
Location: UK
Age: 76
Posts: 224
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
'If the oil pressure is normal there is essentially no way you can have an above redline oil temp.'
I afraid that there is a way. I took off on a very hot summer day and climbed to 2000'. As I levelled off I noticed that the oil temperature was rapidly approaching red. I returned to the airfield and we found that the carb heat cable had frayed and stuck carb heat at about half. This was not noticable from the knob which was fully in.
I afraid that there is a way. I took off on a very hot summer day and climbed to 2000'. As I levelled off I noticed that the oil temperature was rapidly approaching red. I returned to the airfield and we found that the carb heat cable had frayed and stuck carb heat at about half. This was not noticable from the knob which was fully in.
Thread Starter
'If the oil pressure is normal there is essentially no way you can have an above redline oil temp.'
I afraid that there is a way. I took off on a very hot summer day and climbed to 2000'. As I levelled off I noticed that the oil temperature was rapidly approaching red. I returned to the airfield and we found that the carb heat cable had frayed and stuck carb heat at about half. This was not noticable from the knob which was fully in.
I afraid that there is a way. I took off on a very hot summer day and climbed to 2000'. As I levelled off I noticed that the oil temperature was rapidly approaching red. I returned to the airfield and we found that the carb heat cable had frayed and stuck carb heat at about half. This was not noticable from the knob which was fully in.