AEROplane???
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Massachusetts Bay Colony
Age: 57
Posts: 476
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
AEROplane???
Having just been chastised by Stiknruda for my colonial spelling of the aeronautical sort, I have a couple of questions to pose to the group at large; to whit:
1. Why is it spelled (not "spelt"!) AEROPLANE?
2. Following whatever logic transpires from 1 above, why is it not spelled AEROCRAFT?
3. Why is it an AERODROME but also an AIRPORT?
4. Who invented the damn things in the first place (Sir Percy missed his chance, unfortunately)
5. Doesn't whoever invented a thing get to call it whatever the hell he wants and spell it that way, too?
I relinquish the floor and await the educated and lively debate to follow...
Pitts2112
1. Why is it spelled (not "spelt"!) AEROPLANE?
2. Following whatever logic transpires from 1 above, why is it not spelled AEROCRAFT?
3. Why is it an AERODROME but also an AIRPORT?
4. Who invented the damn things in the first place (Sir Percy missed his chance, unfortunately)
5. Doesn't whoever invented a thing get to call it whatever the hell he wants and spell it that way, too?
I relinquish the floor and await the educated and lively debate to follow...
Pitts2112
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Kent
Posts: 603
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just so you know what to expect.....
I was also told (a few years ago..!) that it was not a plane, but an AEROplane. It now annoys me when people say plane, and I now say aeroplane all the time.
Will go for answer to number 2, and that's that it's aeorPLANE as the plane is the wing, which is the magic bit of it all.
tKF
I was also told (a few years ago..!) that it was not a plane, but an AEROplane. It now annoys me when people say plane, and I now say aeroplane all the time.
Will go for answer to number 2, and that's that it's aeorPLANE as the plane is the wing, which is the magic bit of it all.
tKF
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Massachusetts Bay Colony
Age: 57
Posts: 476
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sorry, tKF, but it's back to styduying for English A levels for you. Nice try but the argument doesn't hold water! And isn't nearly clever or humorous enough for this forum!
Pitts2112 :-)
Pitts2112 :-)
1. Why is it spelled (not "spelt"!) AEROPLANE?
Because it uses an aerodynamic plane (as in mainplane, or wing) to generate lift.
2. Following whatever logic transpires from 1 above, why is it not spelled AEROCRAFT?
Because it is a craft which travels through the air air - craft!
3. Why is it an AERODROME but also an AIRPORT?
An aerodrome is a place where aeronautics takes place. An airport is a place where people arrive from the air - just like a seaport.
4. Who invented the damn things in the first place (Sir Percy missed his chance, unfortunately)
A moot point, personally I think that M. Bleriot deserves the most credit for coming up with the form of aeroplane that most of us now use.
5. Doesn't whoever invented a thing get to call it whatever the hell he wants and spell it that way, too?
Avion !
Incidentally, the word "airplane" is correct American english but is not equivalent to "aeroplane", it is equivalent to "aircraft". So, a helicopter is an airplane!
G
Because it uses an aerodynamic plane (as in mainplane, or wing) to generate lift.
2. Following whatever logic transpires from 1 above, why is it not spelled AEROCRAFT?
Because it is a craft which travels through the air air - craft!
3. Why is it an AERODROME but also an AIRPORT?
An aerodrome is a place where aeronautics takes place. An airport is a place where people arrive from the air - just like a seaport.
4. Who invented the damn things in the first place (Sir Percy missed his chance, unfortunately)
A moot point, personally I think that M. Bleriot deserves the most credit for coming up with the form of aeroplane that most of us now use.
5. Doesn't whoever invented a thing get to call it whatever the hell he wants and spell it that way, too?
Avion !
Incidentally, the word "airplane" is correct American english but is not equivalent to "aeroplane", it is equivalent to "aircraft". So, a helicopter is an airplane!
G
Guest
Posts: n/a
Genghis Dear chap
I think you'll find that the accepted father of modern aeronautics and someone who informed M Bleriot as to the shape and form of his aeroplane .............was...................is....................... .....
Me!
Sir George Cayley
The air is a navigable ocean that laps at everyones door
Me!
Sir George Cayley
The air is a navigable ocean that laps at everyones door
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: In the UK
Posts: 19
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I believe that the correct term is aircraft, since I had it beaten into me by various QFI's that the term plane, or any derivation thereof was unacceptable since a plane was something that carpenters used
Gnome de PPRuNe
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Too close to Croydon for comfort
Age: 60
Posts: 12,634
Received 300 Likes
on
168 Posts
Plane wrong... plain right, except in woodworking circles...
AEROPLANE please or aircraft... well, as you are a Yank, airplane aint quite so bad as plane...
Bastard - thought that was for metalwork, one lives and learns...
AEROPLANE please or aircraft... well, as you are a Yank, airplane aint quite so bad as plane...
Bastard - thought that was for metalwork, one lives and learns...
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Savannah GA & Portsmouth UK
Posts: 1,784
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I believe the difference is that an airplane is made of aluminum whereas an aeroplane is made of aluminium.
(unless they're made of anything else of course)
(unless they're made of anything else of course)
Ah, now there's a problem in itself. Sir Humphrey Davey, who discovered the process for extracting this wonderful lightweight metal named it ALUMINUM.
The Royal Society, deciding that new elements should end with "ium", renamed it ALUMINIUM.
Our American cousins however, had the courtesy to continue respecting the original British scientist's name for it.
Strange world we live in isn't it!
G
N.B. Whirly, I have a chopper, it is made of steel and hickory and it's used for truncating trees. It has flown on several occasions, but only when the handle gets wet - and once when it came off!
N.B.B. Sir George, would I be right in thinking that your illustrious ancestor used the term "aerial carriage"?
The Royal Society, deciding that new elements should end with "ium", renamed it ALUMINIUM.
Our American cousins however, had the courtesy to continue respecting the original British scientist's name for it.
Strange world we live in isn't it!
G
N.B. Whirly, I have a chopper, it is made of steel and hickory and it's used for truncating trees. It has flown on several occasions, but only when the handle gets wet - and once when it came off!
N.B.B. Sir George, would I be right in thinking that your illustrious ancestor used the term "aerial carriage"?
Guest
Posts: n/a
G the E
That would be "Gentlemans Aerial Carriage" I think you will find.
But then that would lead me on to talking about my footman and his pay claim, which would lead to blood pressure, which would lead to the Leech Doctor.
So I won't go there.
Anyway what do you mean "ancestor?" I'm only just over 150
Sir George Cayley
But then that would lead me on to talking about my footman and his pay claim, which would lead to blood pressure, which would lead to the Leech Doctor.
So I won't go there.
Anyway what do you mean "ancestor?" I'm only just over 150
Sir George Cayley
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Who cares? ;-)
Age: 74
Posts: 676
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
why not rotorcraft?
I think the term "aircraft" is used for ANYTHING that flies around, including balloons, etc. Therefore airplane or aeroplane (either one?) can be used for fixed wing aircraft.
language is a strange thing
Westy
P.S. in German:
aircraft = Luftfahrzeug
airplane = Flugzeug
helicopter = either Hubschrauber, Helikopter or "Drehflügler"
I think the term "aircraft" is used for ANYTHING that flies around, including balloons, etc. Therefore airplane or aeroplane (either one?) can be used for fixed wing aircraft.
language is a strange thing
Westy
P.S. in German:
aircraft = Luftfahrzeug
airplane = Flugzeug
helicopter = either Hubschrauber, Helikopter or "Drehflügler"
Guest
Posts: n/a
The Royal Society, deciding that new elements should end with "ium", renamed it ALUMINIUM.
Lithum
Sodum
Potassum
Magnesum
Titanum
Chromum
(at such a late hour, these are the only metals I can think of)
Oh, also
Berryllum
Tritum
Helum
Potassum
Calcum
Scandum
Vanadum
Gallum
etc
etc...
(OK, so some might be post-USA, but I am neither a chemist nor a historian)