How safe is a SEP aircraft?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: UK
Posts: 158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
How safe is a SEP aircraft?
Hi there,
I was just thinking, how safe is a single engined aircraft such as a cessna or piper in terms of the engine cutting out?
For instance, if you carry out all the necessary checks, carb heat, mixture rich/lean, fuel selector,etc... then what are the chances if any that the engine will just stop? The reason I ask is that I always have this in my mind especially during take-off or flying over populated areas and sometimes water!
I know they get serviced quite frequently but does anyone know of anyone who has been involved in an incident/accident when an engine has stopped mid-flight?
Thanks, and I shall look forward to your replys.
I was just thinking, how safe is a single engined aircraft such as a cessna or piper in terms of the engine cutting out?
For instance, if you carry out all the necessary checks, carb heat, mixture rich/lean, fuel selector,etc... then what are the chances if any that the engine will just stop? The reason I ask is that I always have this in my mind especially during take-off or flying over populated areas and sometimes water!
I know they get serviced quite frequently but does anyone know of anyone who has been involved in an incident/accident when an engine has stopped mid-flight?
Thanks, and I shall look forward to your replys.
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Minnesota
Posts: 139
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is no easy answer to the question, "When will 'my' engine fail?".
I can say, with some authority:
1. Engines always stop for a reason.
2. Eventually all engines will stop.
The big question is: Where is your engine, at any time, between these two points......?
Who said "Nobody lives forever".
W.B.
I can say, with some authority:
1. Engines always stop for a reason.
2. Eventually all engines will stop.
The big question is: Where is your engine, at any time, between these two points......?
Who said "Nobody lives forever".
W.B.
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Earth
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Engines do stop.
When they do it becomes VERY VERY quiet. Almost as if the engine was a large raucous football crowd that suddenly has been told to shut up and watch how you handle the situation.
Sit back and think about it. Full power on take off. All is fine. Glancing across at the ASI keeping near to 70kts. Looking down at the runway and suddenly.............................silence.
A heart stopping silence. Someone in the circuit makes a radio call and it is extra loud without the competition of the engine noise.
For the first time ever you will hear the controls creak as you move them. You can now hear yourself breathing through the mike on the headset. The wind is whistling gently over the airframe. The propellor is like a plank of wood attached to the a/c. You are going down really quite fast.
It doesn't happen often but believe me, when it does, you will have nightmares about it for a long time afterwards.
When they do it becomes VERY VERY quiet. Almost as if the engine was a large raucous football crowd that suddenly has been told to shut up and watch how you handle the situation.
Sit back and think about it. Full power on take off. All is fine. Glancing across at the ASI keeping near to 70kts. Looking down at the runway and suddenly.............................silence.
A heart stopping silence. Someone in the circuit makes a radio call and it is extra loud without the competition of the engine noise.
For the first time ever you will hear the controls creak as you move them. You can now hear yourself breathing through the mike on the headset. The wind is whistling gently over the airframe. The propellor is like a plank of wood attached to the a/c. You are going down really quite fast.
It doesn't happen often but believe me, when it does, you will have nightmares about it for a long time afterwards.
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: EuroGA.org
Posts: 13,787
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You will die eventually, for sure. It's better to have lived an interesting life before one dies (one cannot have an interesting life after one dies because of all the worms). And flying is a good way to make life interesting.
The average time between engine failures is vaguely of the order of 5000 hours, but I am sure that average hides a massive standard deviation - because of the huge range of engines, engine ages, good and bad engine management, and of variable maintenance standards.
It is a good policy to wear a jacket and carry a raft when over water, avoid flying over large amount of terrain (mountains or forests) where there is nowhere to land, avoid flying at night, and avoid flying if the cloudbase is only a few hundred feet above the ground. Do all these things, and one should survive an engine failure.
A lot of people just run out of juice....
The average time between engine failures is vaguely of the order of 5000 hours, but I am sure that average hides a massive standard deviation - because of the huge range of engines, engine ages, good and bad engine management, and of variable maintenance standards.
It is a good policy to wear a jacket and carry a raft when over water, avoid flying over large amount of terrain (mountains or forests) where there is nowhere to land, avoid flying at night, and avoid flying if the cloudbase is only a few hundred feet above the ground. Do all these things, and one should survive an engine failure.
A lot of people just run out of juice....
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: UK,Twighlight Zone
Posts: 0
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
had one in my first 50hrs as a pilot. which means in the 1-5000 ratio I have a few hundred hours before my next one.......
Life is for living...... remember riding a box cart as a kid without brakes or drinking from the hose pipe and not bottled water or sharing a can of drink with a bunch of mates?
Death is a predator you cant outrun so you better just have fun on the way!!
Life is for living...... remember riding a box cart as a kid without brakes or drinking from the hose pipe and not bottled water or sharing a can of drink with a bunch of mates?
Death is a predator you cant outrun so you better just have fun on the way!!
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Essex, UK
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If you fly as if it is always just about to happen, you will walk away from it.
If you fly as if things like that only happen to others, then we will be reading an AAIB report about you and you may well not have walked away.
Any engine, piston or turbine, can suddenly and unexpectedly fail. It could happen in 4999 hours time. It could happen on your next take off.
Fly accordingly.
If you fly as if things like that only happen to others, then we will be reading an AAIB report about you and you may well not have walked away.
Any engine, piston or turbine, can suddenly and unexpectedly fail. It could happen in 4999 hours time. It could happen on your next take off.
Fly accordingly.
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,085
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I do not have statistics conveniently at hand, but I seem to recall that the two most common causes of engine failure are fuel starvation/mismangement, and fuel contamination. Both of those problems are directly within a pilot's control, and can be virtually eliminated by following proper procedures. See generally Norbert Slepyan, Defensive Flying (1986).
Aside from the above, engines can and do experience catastrophic mechanical failures. As most pilots are not qualified mechanics, and taking into account that few (none?) of us are prepared to take the time to remove an aircraft's cowling to do a thorough inspection of the engine compartment before flying, it's largely a matter of hoping that your mechanic did a thorough annual inspection, and trusting to luck. Fortunately, such spontaneous mechanical problems are quite rare.
A pilot who always takes into account the possibility of an engine failure is no more than prudent, and will likely respond better to such an emergency because he or she has anticipated and planned for it. But as some of the other posters have implied, there is no such thing as perfect safety in aviation unless you simply refuse to fly.
Aside from the above, engines can and do experience catastrophic mechanical failures. As most pilots are not qualified mechanics, and taking into account that few (none?) of us are prepared to take the time to remove an aircraft's cowling to do a thorough inspection of the engine compartment before flying, it's largely a matter of hoping that your mechanic did a thorough annual inspection, and trusting to luck. Fortunately, such spontaneous mechanical problems are quite rare.
A pilot who always takes into account the possibility of an engine failure is no more than prudent, and will likely respond better to such an emergency because he or she has anticipated and planned for it. But as some of the other posters have implied, there is no such thing as perfect safety in aviation unless you simply refuse to fly.
Guest
Posts: n/a
P1F:
There is a HUGE chunk of your training that practices for this (even more in chopperopterers).
If you fly enough, it very well might happen. But you should have been trained for it (and after qualifying, practiced for it).
But it is less likely to happen, statistically, than
a) divorce
b) dying in bed
c) dying getting out of bed
d) dying going downstairs for a cuppa.
etc etc
So don't be frightened of it, get the correct training and keep in practice. (Flying that is, not marriage or bed habits).
I'm still waiting for my first engine failure; I am well overdue, but I do practice an awful lot.
[edited to add that I sort of did have one many moons ago...I pulled the fuel knob out instead of the carb heat...but I was within gliding range of the runway, and thought it would be better to land rather than fluff up the correct position of the controls.
And more recently, I had to turn mine off in flight, because oil pressure went to zero. I was overhead a 2-mile long runway at the time, and landed OK, problem was finger trouble on the part of the oil filter replacement maintenance chappie who failed to tighten it up 20 minutes previously...I can tell you, I gave myself a right good slapping.]
There is a HUGE chunk of your training that practices for this (even more in chopperopterers).
If you fly enough, it very well might happen. But you should have been trained for it (and after qualifying, practiced for it).
But it is less likely to happen, statistically, than
a) divorce
b) dying in bed
c) dying getting out of bed
d) dying going downstairs for a cuppa.
etc etc
So don't be frightened of it, get the correct training and keep in practice. (Flying that is, not marriage or bed habits).
I'm still waiting for my first engine failure; I am well overdue, but I do practice an awful lot.
[edited to add that I sort of did have one many moons ago...I pulled the fuel knob out instead of the carb heat...but I was within gliding range of the runway, and thought it would be better to land rather than fluff up the correct position of the controls.
And more recently, I had to turn mine off in flight, because oil pressure went to zero. I was overhead a 2-mile long runway at the time, and landed OK, problem was finger trouble on the part of the oil filter replacement maintenance chappie who failed to tighten it up 20 minutes previously...I can tell you, I gave myself a right good slapping.]
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: EuroGA.org
Posts: 13,787
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
MLS-12D
Here in the UK, it is not even legal for a pilot to remove the cowling on a Transport CofA aircraft. Only the portion of a cowling which has hinges and quick release catches may be legally opened.
I am also not sure that you would see anything that might cause a catastrophic mechanical failure.
In my PPL training I did spot bad / exposed / broken wiring and refused to fly that aircraft (much to the instructor's disgust) but mechanical things are not generally visible.
Here in the UK, it is not even legal for a pilot to remove the cowling on a Transport CofA aircraft. Only the portion of a cowling which has hinges and quick release catches may be legally opened.
I am also not sure that you would see anything that might cause a catastrophic mechanical failure.
In my PPL training I did spot bad / exposed / broken wiring and refused to fly that aircraft (much to the instructor's disgust) but mechanical things are not generally visible.
Join Date: May 2002
Location: cheltenham
Age: 54
Posts: 218
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Agree with IO540
Removing the cowling would not have seen that my con-rod was about to snap on takeoff!
It is something that we should all expect to happen on every flight and treat it accordingly.
Before my engine failure I was far to confident, charging off in all types of weather without really believing the fan would ever go bang! It does give you a reality check and changes the way you fly.
For sometime after I was not really enjoying flying as I used to and have only recently started to relax back in the seat.
After all the most important thing about GA is to ENJOY
Removing the cowling would not have seen that my con-rod was about to snap on takeoff!
It is something that we should all expect to happen on every flight and treat it accordingly.
Before my engine failure I was far to confident, charging off in all types of weather without really believing the fan would ever go bang! It does give you a reality check and changes the way you fly.
For sometime after I was not really enjoying flying as I used to and have only recently started to relax back in the seat.
After all the most important thing about GA is to ENJOY
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: I sell sea shells by the sea shore
Posts: 856
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks CBl... you said
I had a similar "incident" back in the summer. Nobody died and only the aeroplane a bit bent (but easily fixable.. it has been), but I was shaken. Practicising PFLs really does pay off.
I have flown on many occasions since, on the basis that "having fallen off the horse, the best remedy was to get straight back on".
Unfortunately, it's taken a quite a while to actually Enjoy flying again, even though i still felt fairly competent. I've spent lots of time listening to the engine note for the merest quiver, and glancing at the engine instruments.
Not "fun" is it?
Like you I'm only just begining to relax and begin to enjoy being in the sky again... I thought I was alone, so it's good to hear that someone has had a similar experience. Thank you.
rgds BEX
For sometime after I was not really enjoying flying as I used to and have only recently started to relax back in the seat.
I have flown on many occasions since, on the basis that "having fallen off the horse, the best remedy was to get straight back on".
Unfortunately, it's taken a quite a while to actually Enjoy flying again, even though i still felt fairly competent. I've spent lots of time listening to the engine note for the merest quiver, and glancing at the engine instruments.
Not "fun" is it?Like you I'm only just begining to relax and begin to enjoy being in the sky again... I thought I was alone, so it's good to hear that someone has had a similar experience. Thank you.
rgds BEX
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Canada
Posts: 1,085
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am also not sure that you would see anything that might cause a catastrophic mechanical failure.
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Leeds, UK
Posts: 58
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
jeez guys - are you trying to scare the living daylights out of us low hour students?? 
I went solo not so long ago and had there been an engine failure I really don't know that I would have dealt with it OK. 12 hours is not enough time to become competent at such things (especially when most of that time has been spent learning which way is up!!). M akes you wonder why students are allowed solo in 12 hours when maybe it should be more like double that.
It also made me think carefully about the safety of flying GA aircraft out of certain aerodromes. The place I fly from.. if the engine died on the climbout on a particular runway.. I really wouldn't like to guess where you'd put her down. I suspect the answer is in someones back yard.
Safe flying everyone...
I went solo not so long ago and had there been an engine failure I really don't know that I would have dealt with it OK. 12 hours is not enough time to become competent at such things (especially when most of that time has been spent learning which way is up!!). M akes you wonder why students are allowed solo in 12 hours when maybe it should be more like double that.
It also made me think carefully about the safety of flying GA aircraft out of certain aerodromes. The place I fly from.. if the engine died on the climbout on a particular runway.. I really wouldn't like to guess where you'd put her down. I suspect the answer is in someones back yard.
Safe flying everyone...
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Farnham
Posts: 130
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
cblinton...
As someone who flies behind a similar engine (yours was a Continental wasn't it)? I have a few questions.
How old was the engine, both in years and hours? How much oil was it using prior to the failure? Had you noticed any changes between the time you aquired the a/c and the failure? When it failed, could you still see out of the windshield or did you rely on the DV window?
Thanks
GG
As someone who flies behind a similar engine (yours was a Continental wasn't it)? I have a few questions.
How old was the engine, both in years and hours? How much oil was it using prior to the failure? Had you noticed any changes between the time you aquired the a/c and the failure? When it failed, could you still see out of the windshield or did you rely on the DV window?
Thanks
GG
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: Earth
Posts: 1,189
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flyboy
I know you didn't ask the question to me but I will answer it anyway as I am quiet for a moment at work.......
Continental 65
Total time since zero houred was 1422.
1 quart of oil per 7 hours flying was being used.
No change in oils consumption leading up to failure.
The failure was nothing more than just that, a failure. There was no splurges of oil etc. It just stopped.
radarcontrol - don't be put off but at the same time don't expect too much from your engine. They DO stop. I spent many hours reading accident reports when they came through the post and thought "God how awful for the pilot". I felt as though I was on the outside of it and that it wouldn't happen to ME......
I too have spent the last 20 flying hours since the accident listening out for the slightest change in noise from the engine and looking at the guages approximately every 10 seconds.......I wonder when my paranoia will decline.
I know you didn't ask the question to me but I will answer it anyway as I am quiet for a moment at work.......
Continental 65
Total time since zero houred was 1422.
1 quart of oil per 7 hours flying was being used.
No change in oils consumption leading up to failure.
The failure was nothing more than just that, a failure. There was no splurges of oil etc. It just stopped.
radarcontrol - don't be put off but at the same time don't expect too much from your engine. They DO stop. I spent many hours reading accident reports when they came through the post and thought "God how awful for the pilot". I felt as though I was on the outside of it and that it wouldn't happen to ME......
I too have spent the last 20 flying hours since the accident listening out for the slightest change in noise from the engine and looking at the guages approximately every 10 seconds.......I wonder when my paranoia will decline.
Jet Blast Rat
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: Sarfend-on-Sea
Age: 51
Posts: 2,081
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Engines stop. I know a few people who have had engine failures. However there should be very few circumstances in which the people on board cannot survive. If the forced landing looks like turning into a crash, then fly the aircraft as far into the crash as possible, and try to hit the softest, cheapest object in the area at the lowest controllable speed.
Examples: (i) a light twin crashed on approach, having lost both engines due to fuel exhaustion. The approach was over suburban housing, the only landing area people's gardens. (ii) A light single crashed on climbout, due to unknown cause, probably power loss. Under the climbout were some large, flat fields surrounded by soft hedges.
In one accident no-one was seriously injured, in the other all on board received fatal injuries. Why? Well the non-fatal accident was example (i), the fatal example(ii). In the first case the pilot kept the aicraft in a flying condition, even as he hit someone's shed. In the second it appears the aircraft stalled and entered either a spiral descent or a spin.
In both cases an element of luck prevented further deaths, but it is clear that the pilot's handling of the power failure, not the circumstances in which it happened, decided the outcome. If you know what to do in an emergency, and are well-practised, SEPs are very safe.
Examples: (i) a light twin crashed on approach, having lost both engines due to fuel exhaustion. The approach was over suburban housing, the only landing area people's gardens. (ii) A light single crashed on climbout, due to unknown cause, probably power loss. Under the climbout were some large, flat fields surrounded by soft hedges.
In one accident no-one was seriously injured, in the other all on board received fatal injuries. Why? Well the non-fatal accident was example (i), the fatal example(ii). In the first case the pilot kept the aicraft in a flying condition, even as he hit someone's shed. In the second it appears the aircraft stalled and entered either a spiral descent or a spin.
In both cases an element of luck prevented further deaths, but it is clear that the pilot's handling of the power failure, not the circumstances in which it happened, decided the outcome. If you know what to do in an emergency, and are well-practised, SEPs are very safe.