Flight Plans for GA, and do most pilots know how to use them?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Merseyside United Kingdom
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flight Plans for GA, and do most pilots know how to use them?
After a certain 'incident' that happened in work today, it made me wonder do most pilots know how to file a Flight Plan correctly and do most of us know how to use them?
Basically to summarise, we had received a flight plan for some guy who wanted to fly from N.I to the Northwest of England in a flex- winged micro!
The weather on both side of the Sea was fine and the guy had set off as per plan, however with about 40mins left on the aircraft’s ETA the weather this side had deteriorated very badly with strong winds and very heavy rain! (Not forecasted).
With the ETA becoming ever more closer, and the weather worsening we had decided to ring his point of departure and see if the guy had actually left, or turned around due to bad weather.. The A/C had departed and was handed off by the particular ATC unit so using the info from the very detailed routing off the received flight plan 'we' was able to ring around various ATC / RADAR units and try to track the current position of the aircraft. Cutting a long story short the micro was finally tracked down just on the Northwest coast of England and was putting down into a small micro strip due to the worsening weather. Later on the pilot phoned us, after ringing Flight Plans himself, and iformed us of what had happened. Thankfully the pilot of this micro was very switched on and knew what he was doing, before and after landing and all ended well.
However it got me thinking, If the flight plan had not been so detailed with routing etc, would this of been as easy for the ground services to track him down? Also how many of us would of decided to ring someone and let them know they had let down at a particular place (which was not the initial destination, nor the Planned Divert)?
Also, since 99.9% of us have mobile phones these days, would it not be an idea to include this under 'other remarks' when filing a flight plan?
Anyway this particular incident did get me thinking, and i decided to make this post in the hope that it to would get you thinking.. After all that’s what this forum is all about .. Right?
SSC.
Basically to summarise, we had received a flight plan for some guy who wanted to fly from N.I to the Northwest of England in a flex- winged micro!
The weather on both side of the Sea was fine and the guy had set off as per plan, however with about 40mins left on the aircraft’s ETA the weather this side had deteriorated very badly with strong winds and very heavy rain! (Not forecasted).
With the ETA becoming ever more closer, and the weather worsening we had decided to ring his point of departure and see if the guy had actually left, or turned around due to bad weather.. The A/C had departed and was handed off by the particular ATC unit so using the info from the very detailed routing off the received flight plan 'we' was able to ring around various ATC / RADAR units and try to track the current position of the aircraft. Cutting a long story short the micro was finally tracked down just on the Northwest coast of England and was putting down into a small micro strip due to the worsening weather. Later on the pilot phoned us, after ringing Flight Plans himself, and iformed us of what had happened. Thankfully the pilot of this micro was very switched on and knew what he was doing, before and after landing and all ended well.
However it got me thinking, If the flight plan had not been so detailed with routing etc, would this of been as easy for the ground services to track him down? Also how many of us would of decided to ring someone and let them know they had let down at a particular place (which was not the initial destination, nor the Planned Divert)?
Also, since 99.9% of us have mobile phones these days, would it not be an idea to include this under 'other remarks' when filing a flight plan?
Anyway this particular incident did get me thinking, and i decided to make this post in the hope that it to would get you thinking.. After all that’s what this forum is all about .. Right?
SSC.
High Flying Bird
Join Date: Dec 2000
Location: Old Sarum ish
Posts: 2,297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A very good point, SSC. Being fairly new to working in aviation, and not having filed a flight plan as a pilot, I'm only just seeing the tip of the iceberg with the problems flight plans can cause if they're not filled in correctly. I've seen the wrong registration turn up for an aircraft because the pilot's handwriting couldn't be read... I've seen flight plans arrive with us instead of the real destination because someone has typed in the wrong ICAO code... etc etc. Oh, and frequently they are filed late! They're a fantastic safety net when used correctly... DO SO. 
And if your handwriting is less than neat, ask a mate to help.
And if your handwriting is less than neat, ask a mate to help.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Merseyside United Kingdom
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
AerBabe
As you say they can cause problems if not written neatly, but i am pritty sure there must be one out there somewhere where you can type it out and print it off?
SSC
As you say they can cause problems if not written neatly, but i am pritty sure there must be one out there somewhere where you can type it out and print it off?
SSC
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: England
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not filed one myself, so don't claim to be an expert, but here is an electronic form that can be filled in and printed.
<http://www.ais.org.uk/aes/en/image/CA48.pdf>
<http://www.ais.org.uk/aes/en/image/CA48.pdf>
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Who cares? ;-)
Age: 74
Posts: 676
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is there a cell-phone on board?".
How many pilots know about the recent changes to filling out flight plans? At least now in Germany the pilots, not ais, must fill in that complicated address at the top. I only know it because it was one of the subjects at a recent instrutors training seminar I attended.
Westy
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 1,089
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SSC - what a splendid reminder, thank you. In our haste these days we tend to "be brief" and, as you so rightly point out, it is not alway the best policy. I file with Heathrow and have always found them to be extremely helpful on the odd occasions when I have sought advice. Have always included mobile number in remarks.
Yes this is what PPRUNE is best at
Yes this is what PPRUNE is best at
Join Date: Jan 2001
Location: UK
Posts: 1,089
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SSC - I know this has not been posted for long but it seems safety info is not high on people's lists if the number of "hits" let only responses is anything to go by. Someone please tell me I am wrong.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Merseyside United Kingdom
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Workinghard
I know what you are saying however in 24hrs 190 odd people have read it, even if it triggers something in there minds when they next file a plan, then it was worth the effort it took to post!
Thanks for the Comments so far though
I know what you are saying however in 24hrs 190 odd people have read it, even if it triggers something in there minds when they next file a plan, then it was worth the effort it took to post!
Thanks for the Comments so far though
The Original Whirly
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Belper, Derbyshire, UK
Posts: 4,326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
WorkingHard,
You are wrong. At least in my case, and I suspect I'm not unique. I've been away for a week, and I'm only just catching up on life in general, and that includes PPRuNe. It's the height of the holiday season; give people a chance.
Slowsafecruise,
Excellent thread, and a good reminder of what flight plans are for. Something I'd like to add. Once, way back, I filled in a flight plan form, then realised I couldn't get to my planned destination (fog or something; can't remember). I picked another airfield in the same area, and just changed the ICAO designator on my flight plan. I forgot to change the ETA...and the flight was about half an hour longer. Add to that the increased headwind (sod's law of course), and when I arrived they were considering starting to look for me!
Moral of this tale; always check over your flight plan before you file it! In my case, embarrassment and wrist slapping were all that occurred. But the mistake could have been the other way round; I could have been heading for somewhere closer than originally planned, been in trouble, and no-one would have realised until much later.
You are wrong.
At least in my case, and I suspect I'm not unique. I've been away for a week, and I'm only just catching up on life in general, and that includes PPRuNe. It's the height of the holiday season; give people a chance.Slowsafecruise,
Excellent thread, and a good reminder of what flight plans are for. Something I'd like to add. Once, way back, I filled in a flight plan form, then realised I couldn't get to my planned destination (fog or something; can't remember). I picked another airfield in the same area, and just changed the ICAO designator on my flight plan. I forgot to change the ETA...and the flight was about half an hour longer. Add to that the increased headwind (sod's law of course), and when I arrived they were considering starting to look for me!
Moral of this tale; always check over your flight plan before you file it! In my case, embarrassment and wrist slapping were all that occurred. But the mistake could have been the other way round; I could have been heading for somewhere closer than originally planned, been in trouble, and no-one would have realised until much later.
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Merseyside United Kingdom
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whirlybird
Thanks for your kind comments! did you go anywhere nice for your holidays? i wish i was going away! lol
Anyway glad you made your input the only way to learn is from mistakes and i am sure its much better to learn from others!
SSC
Thanks for your kind comments! did you go anywhere nice for your holidays? i wish i was going away! lol
Anyway glad you made your input the only way to learn is from mistakes and i am sure its much better to learn from others!
SSC
Join Date: May 2003
Location: Essex, UK
Posts: 616
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
SSC
I know the pilot well and he is now in northern France, en-route to Portugal with 8 other microlights. Many are not as experienced and your post is a good, timely reminder that we must keep in contact, especially if conditions change. AL was full of praise for people who "were looking out for him".
He was calling Scottish info, but as he was scud running, he couldn't get a response.
If you are going to France from Headcorn, as this group were, Jamie will not file your flight plan without mobile numbers.
Ince to northern France in a day... not bad for a flexwing microlight
bs
I know the pilot well and he is now in northern France, en-route to Portugal with 8 other microlights. Many are not as experienced and your post is a good, timely reminder that we must keep in contact, especially if conditions change. AL was full of praise for people who "were looking out for him".
He was calling Scottish info, but as he was scud running, he couldn't get a response.
If you are going to France from Headcorn, as this group were, Jamie will not file your flight plan without mobile numbers.
Ince to northern France in a day... not bad for a flexwing microlight
bs
Why do it if it's not fun?
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Bournemouth
Posts: 4,779
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Personally, I found the initial post very interesting.....
All the advice I've ever heard (from ATCers posting on these forums, and from ATCers whom I've met face-to-face either socially or when visiting towers/centres) has been that route information on VFR flight plans is ignored. Although putting a detailed route onto a flight plan won't harm anyone, it's generally a wasted effort.
SSC, your post is an example of why that effort is not wasted, and I shall, when I next have reason to file a flight plan, make sure I put as much route information on it as possible, and advise others to do likewise.
FFF
--------------
All the advice I've ever heard (from ATCers posting on these forums, and from ATCers whom I've met face-to-face either socially or when visiting towers/centres) has been that route information on VFR flight plans is ignored. Although putting a detailed route onto a flight plan won't harm anyone, it's generally a wasted effort.
SSC, your post is an example of why that effort is not wasted, and I shall, when I next have reason to file a flight plan, make sure I put as much route information on it as possible, and advise others to do likewise.
FFF
--------------
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Merseyside United Kingdom
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
FlyingforFun
Many thanks for the reply,
I dont know who has told you not to put much detail into your plan, but the way i see it the more the better! Easier to trace you then, should anything go wrong (god forbid).
SSC
Many thanks for the reply,
I dont know who has told you not to put much detail into your plan, but the way i see it the more the better! Easier to trace you then, should anything go wrong (god forbid).
SSC
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Southern England
Posts: 119
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting thread- coupled with our dear friend going through Eastbourne, shows the value of flight planning and flight plans.
On the question of "how many know" I guess the answer is probably ‘only those that need to’. I don’t know the proportion, but allot of people seem to only do VFR local flights or stay on mainland UK, so as they don't need to file them* & would understandably not remember how to do a flight plan. Also, when I was learning to fly, all-be-it in a University Air Squadron, I remember my instructor having to read up on how to complete one, the one time we used one. I wonder if it would be the same for many FI's?
I know this is slightly off topic, but I would love to see the results of a survey of what type of flying people do - i.e. local bumble only local aeros, UK only, international, Work, fun etc. Has this been done before, and if not could we do one on PPPRuNe?
*Before anyone else says it: - unless flying over inhospitable terrain.
PS. On the subject of mobile phones, I'd previously been advised to include the number if so if ATC had a question before the flight they could get to you - I think this thread also shows the post flight value.
PPS.
WestWind1950's post has reminded me of a question I would love an ATC answer from. A number of places, eg Guernsey, ask that a specific address is put in the address section of the Flight plan. Now in the UK I've always been told to leave the address section blank and so have assumed the filing ATSU recognises where these requests are needed and completes them - is always correct?
On the question of "how many know" I guess the answer is probably ‘only those that need to’. I don’t know the proportion, but allot of people seem to only do VFR local flights or stay on mainland UK, so as they don't need to file them* & would understandably not remember how to do a flight plan. Also, when I was learning to fly, all-be-it in a University Air Squadron, I remember my instructor having to read up on how to complete one, the one time we used one. I wonder if it would be the same for many FI's?
I know this is slightly off topic, but I would love to see the results of a survey of what type of flying people do - i.e. local bumble only local aeros, UK only, international, Work, fun etc. Has this been done before, and if not could we do one on PPPRuNe?
*Before anyone else says it: - unless flying over inhospitable terrain.
PS. On the subject of mobile phones, I'd previously been advised to include the number if so if ATC had a question before the flight they could get to you - I think this thread also shows the post flight value.
PPS.
WestWind1950's post has reminded me of a question I would love an ATC answer from. A number of places, eg Guernsey, ask that a specific address is put in the address section of the Flight plan. Now in the UK I've always been told to leave the address section blank and so have assumed the filing ATSU recognises where these requests are needed and completes them - is always correct?
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: London
Posts: 198
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Flight Plans for GA, and do most pilots know how to use them?
The problem seems to be with the details and the questions which don't come up every flight. I am perfectly happy to admit that I don't know the official answers to things like
a) where does a VFR plan get sent to? (some places, the enroute people seem to get it, others not)
b) how long before and after the EOBT can you depart? (1 hour after seems to be OK for VFR, is that right?)
c) how do you delay and adjust plans once filed (get the FBO to do it)
d) is an hour's notice really necessary for a VFR plan or will you get away with shorter notice (seems to vary country to country and place to place)
e) do you need to close a plan (no in UK, yes elsewhere (either by the Tower or direct to AIS)) - and why is UK different?
f) do you need to close a plan terminating in UK if you put somewhere on the continent as alternate?
Anyone?
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Smurph Castle
Age: 45
Posts: 498
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
QUOTE]where does a VFR plan get sent to? (some places, the enroute people seem to get it, others not)[/QUOTE]
I was surprised recently when I phoned UK customs to ask if it would be a problem to return to the UK from France earlier than I had specified (nasty front on the way later...). They said, 'not a problem, we'll keep an closer eye on your flight plan'. I had assumed that smaller GA flight plans were not circulated that widely, but it seems that those in charge of security as well as ATC watch plans that are filed...
I was surprised recently when I phoned UK customs to ask if it would be a problem to return to the UK from France earlier than I had specified (nasty front on the way later...). They said, 'not a problem, we'll keep an closer eye on your flight plan'. I had assumed that smaller GA flight plans were not circulated that widely, but it seems that those in charge of security as well as ATC watch plans that are filed...
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Dublin
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can't please everybody...
Probably not that important, but for VFR flights, should the routing information be written under "Route" or under "Remarks"?
I filed a flight plan in Sabadell, Spain, last weekend and the guy in charge had me change it because I had put the routing info under "Route" (as one would, I guess). He claimed that was only for IFR routings/procedures and insisted I include the route under "Remarks". Filing my flight plan back to Sabadell in Perpignan, France, the lady asked why I had been so silly as to put the Route info under "Remarks"....
special_ig
I filed a flight plan in Sabadell, Spain, last weekend and the guy in charge had me change it because I had put the routing info under "Route" (as one would, I guess). He claimed that was only for IFR routings/procedures and insisted I include the route under "Remarks". Filing my flight plan back to Sabadell in Perpignan, France, the lady asked why I had been so silly as to put the Route info under "Remarks"....
special_ig
Join Date: Oct 1999
Location: Anywhere
Posts: 2,212
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Special
The route section - you were ill advised at Sabadell by someone who'd obviously moved his mouth 3 foot downwards
down&out
Not your problem - whoever addresses the plan should know any additional addressees and include them without any input from yourself (made easier these days by "Colective addressing")
Aim Far
a) Departure, Destination and any mandatory addressed associated airfields. En-Rte airfields don't get them and alternates only get copies if the addressing unit includes them as a separate address
b) Correct. IFR is different 30 minutes either side is acceptable, any different and it has to be changed or delayed. If an IFR plan is not activated within 30 minutes of EOBT then the IFPS computer dumps it and you have to re-file (so DLA's are important in those cases).
c) Delays require a "DLA" message issued by the same agency that filed the plan in the first place, bringing it forward often entails cancelling and then re-filing (if you don't fulfil the answer to (b) above
d) Shorter is fine, but allow at least 30 minutes to get it input into the system for Intl FIR boundary crossing or if the flight wil take place in CAS.
e) Correct. The UK has the concept of the "responsible" party included in the ANO whereby if you don't turn up someone will notify the authorities. No news is good news principle
f) No, as the alternate would not expect to be notified of your arrival at the destination anyway.
Probably not that important, but for VFR flights, should the routing information be written under "Route" or under "Remarks"?
down&out
A number of places, eg Guernsey, ask that a specific address is put in the address section of the Flight plan. Now in the UK I've always been told to leave the address section blank and so have assumed the filing ATSU recognises where these requests are needed and completes them
Aim Far
a) Departure, Destination and any mandatory addressed associated airfields. En-Rte airfields don't get them and alternates only get copies if the addressing unit includes them as a separate address
b) Correct. IFR is different 30 minutes either side is acceptable, any different and it has to be changed or delayed. If an IFR plan is not activated within 30 minutes of EOBT then the IFPS computer dumps it and you have to re-file (so DLA's are important in those cases).
c) Delays require a "DLA" message issued by the same agency that filed the plan in the first place, bringing it forward often entails cancelling and then re-filing (if you don't fulfil the answer to (b) above
d) Shorter is fine, but allow at least 30 minutes to get it input into the system for Intl FIR boundary crossing or if the flight wil take place in CAS.
e) Correct. The UK has the concept of the "responsible" party included in the ANO whereby if you don't turn up someone will notify the authorities. No news is good news principle
f) No, as the alternate would not expect to be notified of your arrival at the destination anyway.