Recommendations for Business Class to SYD via SIN
Thread Starter
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
From: London
Recommendations for Business Class to SYD via SIN
This may may been posted before but I will be flying out to Sydney via Sinapore for a stopover outbound, and back via Hong Kong again for a stopover, will be travelling in April.
Question is an recommendations as to carrier, I normally use BA, and would like to gather some miles etc.. for the trip, and have heard that Cathay provide excellent service.
Thoughts?
Question is an recommendations as to carrier, I normally use BA, and would like to gather some miles etc.. for the trip, and have heard that Cathay provide excellent service.
Thoughts?
Joined: Jan 2008
Posts: 190
Likes: 12
From: Geneva
Well, assuming you want to go LHR-SIN-SYD and return SYD-HKG-LHR without other stops or diversions, your options are pretty limited - especially if you want to stick to oneworld carriers so that you'll get BA miles.
If price is no object, it's pretty hard to beat Singapore Airlines business class on the A380 for LHR-SIN-SYD. But that won't get you back through HKG.
Cathay is certainly pretty good, although some find the new business-class herringbone layout of mini-cabinettes a bit claustrophobic and difficult to get in and out of. I found it weird at first, but it's great for privacy and sleeping. Huge IFE screen, if that's your thing. I'd rate the cabin service above BA, and well ahead of Qantas.
Anyway, given your routing, I think your best bet is BA or Qantas on the way out (QF if you'd like to try the A380), and Cathay on the way back. You should be able to do this all on a BA ticket with codeshare flights on QF and CX, but even if you can't, they are all oneworld carriers and your miles will be credited.
If price is no object, it's pretty hard to beat Singapore Airlines business class on the A380 for LHR-SIN-SYD. But that won't get you back through HKG.
Cathay is certainly pretty good, although some find the new business-class herringbone layout of mini-cabinettes a bit claustrophobic and difficult to get in and out of. I found it weird at first, but it's great for privacy and sleeping. Huge IFE screen, if that's your thing. I'd rate the cabin service above BA, and well ahead of Qantas.
Anyway, given your routing, I think your best bet is BA or Qantas on the way out (QF if you'd like to try the A380), and Cathay on the way back. You should be able to do this all on a BA ticket with codeshare flights on QF and CX, but even if you can't, they are all oneworld carriers and your miles will be credited.
Chief Bottle Washer
Joined: Sep 2000
Aviation Qualifications: ATPL
Posts: 7,260
Likes: 1,438
From: PPRuNe
Far better would be Virgin Atlantic Upper Class. I'd take them over BA First or Business any day, and my last trip that way with Cathay was overwhelmingly unimpressive in Business 
Prof. Airport Engineer
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 726
Likes: 0
From: Australia (mostly)
I'm not a big fan of Cathy business class. I get the impression that they are trying so hard to preserve a hierarchy for their various frequent flyer classes that the normal business class punter gets the short end of the stick. To my surprise, although given your constraints and choices, QF may indeed be the way to go.
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
From: Tsui Wah, Orchard rd branch
And as a counter, I've always been so very impressed by Cathay staff but felt Virgn was a little too cool and quite sloppy in attitude & service.
In the very imprtant longhaul open snackbar comparison, Cathay is superb while Virgin is simply an oatbar, which aint great on a 14hour flight
Have flown Cathay for over 6 years now and on a number of occasions felt the burning need to pen a letter commending cabin crew for a range of small but impressive details they have picked up on.
Not once for Virgin have I done this (let alone BA First & Biz whose CC feel like the certain characters from Carry On films)
Re the beds as a 6'4' I actually find CX longer and easier to sleep in than both VS and BA. Seems to be an extra inch or so which actually makes a difference to me to strech out. Agree on seeming narrow at seating angle but at lying shoulder level is no problem
SQ I havent flown for years as I've never been tempted to move from CX
CX pls contact me for my next upgrade voucher
In the very imprtant longhaul open snackbar comparison, Cathay is superb while Virgin is simply an oatbar, which aint great on a 14hour flight
Have flown Cathay for over 6 years now and on a number of occasions felt the burning need to pen a letter commending cabin crew for a range of small but impressive details they have picked up on.
Not once for Virgin have I done this (let alone BA First & Biz whose CC feel like the certain characters from Carry On films)
Re the beds as a 6'4' I actually find CX longer and easier to sleep in than both VS and BA. Seems to be an extra inch or so which actually makes a difference to me to strech out. Agree on seeming narrow at seating angle but at lying shoulder level is no problem
SQ I havent flown for years as I've never been tempted to move from CX
CX pls contact me for my next upgrade voucher
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 1,103
Likes: 0
From: 45 yards from a tropical beach
Round The World
All Ahead Full
Have you considered a Round The World ticket? Fly outbound via Hong Kong AND Singapore, then from Sydney you could fly via Hawaii and the USA, Mexico or Canada. You must not 'backtrack' and can have quite a few layovers. The cost of the ticket will quite possibly be less than the London - Sydney return. It certainly used to be the case that the best value in ticketing was a Business Class Round The World ticket.
Whatever you choose, have a great voyage.
Have you considered a Round The World ticket? Fly outbound via Hong Kong AND Singapore, then from Sydney you could fly via Hawaii and the USA, Mexico or Canada. You must not 'backtrack' and can have quite a few layovers. The cost of the ticket will quite possibly be less than the London - Sydney return. It certainly used to be the case that the best value in ticketing was a Business Class Round The World ticket.
Whatever you choose, have a great voyage.
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 429
Likes: 0
From: UK
Good idea Neptunus Rex re RTW tickets
oneworld - Fare estimate
Oneworld RTW tickets start from about £4800, though use the planner to help you find the right fare.
oneworld - Fare estimate
Oneworld RTW tickets start from about £4800, though use the planner to help you find the right fare.
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
From: London
Think outside the box.....recapture some old world magic, rejuvinate, relax, chill, see some of the world instead of rushing over it eating crappy food 5 miles up at Mach .85 or thereabouts, crammed into a tin and plastic tube made of 1,000,000 parts that have to keep working and/or fastened to each other for your survival, ,.........what's the rush, anyway?
OK on the cargo boat you wouldn't see Singapore, but is that so important?
Go by Cargo Ship
Or by Liner via Singapore
OK on the cargo boat you wouldn't see Singapore, but is that so important?
Go by Cargo Ship
Or by Liner via Singapore
Last edited by 10DowningSt; 25th February 2010 at 18:47.
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 731
Likes: 0
From: England
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 429
Likes: 0
From: UK
I like your thinking but several weeks at sea with the side of a container for a view doesn't really appeal to most of us
SeeSaw - Watch Around the World in 80 Days online
Thread Starter
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
From: London
Thanks for all the suggestions, especially like the idea on a cruise ship, but as I do have work to do, the boss might not agree on that one!
After speaking to BA, they have offered BA to SIN, with a stopover, and then Quantas onto MEL, then a few flights around Australia, with a return again on Quantas to HKG, and then BA back to London for £3,800 which isn't bad, considering I paid over £500 to do a return to Frankfurt on Wednesday.
Apparently the big saving is to book all the flights at one, as that way the internal flights are at a big saving.
I did look at the round the world option, but it does come out more expensive in the end.
AAF
After speaking to BA, they have offered BA to SIN, with a stopover, and then Quantas onto MEL, then a few flights around Australia, with a return again on Quantas to HKG, and then BA back to London for £3,800 which isn't bad, considering I paid over £500 to do a return to Frankfurt on Wednesday.
Apparently the big saving is to book all the flights at one, as that way the internal flights are at a big saving.
I did look at the round the world option, but it does come out more expensive in the end.
AAF
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 50
Likes: 0
From: London
I like your thinking but several weeks at sea with the side of a container for a view doesn't really appeal to most of us