PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Homebuilt scrap aircraft crashed in WA (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/655417-homebuilt-scrap-aircraft-crashed-wa.html)

Squawk7700 21st Oct 2023 12:26

Homebuilt scrap aircraft crashed in WA
 
Police, paramedics respond after light plane crashes off WA coast (watoday.com.au)Emergency services have rushed to the aid of two people, who were inside a small homemade plane which crashed into the ocean off the coast of Lancelin on Saturday afternoon.

Around 12.25pm West Australian police and St John paramedics responded to reports a fixed wing flying vessel had crashed on a reef near Edwards Island Nature Reserve in Lancelin.



A police spokesman said there were two people on the plane – the pilot and a passenger. Both sustained minor injuries and were assessed by paramedics at the scene.

A Facebook page for Lancelin posted a picture of the plane, named The Mudskipper, and stated it was homemade and “will fly about two metres or so above the water, with a speed up to 120 kilometres per hour.”

“There has been a serious mishap but the flying boat is still afloat. Oh no The Mudskipper has crashed in Lancelin Bay, we believe everyone is OK,” they wrote.


https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....8652e8c5e.jpeg

I guess it was only a matter of time. From memory, they are calling it a boat rather than an aircraft.

treadigraph 21st Oct 2023 15:09

https://x.com/LewisHaskew/status/111...315719681?s=20

Hmm, me Twixxer skills are obviously a bit limited.

Anyway, sorta Caspian Sea Monster.

NZFlyingKiwi 21st Oct 2023 18:25

I usually cringe at the media's reporting of homebuilt (or 'homemade' as they like to say) aircraft but this one probably does fit their expectations more than most by the looks of it.

Squawk7700 21st Oct 2023 20:13


Originally Posted by NZFlyingKiwi (Post 11525390)
I usually cringe at the media's reporting of homebuilt (or 'homemade' as they like to say) aircraft but this one probably does fit their expectations more than most by the looks of it.

Spot on…. and this one was proudly made using scrap components.

Capt Fathom 21st Oct 2023 20:26


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11525220)

I guess it was only a matter of time.

Why do you say that Squawk?

aroa 22nd Oct 2023 00:58

A ‘fixed wing flying vessel’ Mmm.. vessel ..haven’t heard that term before. Doesn’t look too bad for a homebuild WIGE.
A microscopic take on the Caspian Sea Monster , ecranoplane.
I guess rocketing around just above the surface would be easy to dip in a wingtip.
Occupants ok that’s the main thing. Enough flying vessel fatalities of late.

Stationair8 22nd Oct 2023 02:09

Quantas plain in death dive?

Squawk7700 22nd Oct 2023 02:20


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 11525433)
Why do you say that Squawk?

What could possibly go wrong with something like that, just above the water, a salvaged Jabiru motor and no regulatory oversight?

Capt Fathom 22nd Oct 2023 03:01

It’s registered as a boat so there’s your regulatory oversight.
Some interesting videos on youtube re the build and how it works (worked).

Squawk7700 22nd Oct 2023 03:22


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 11525515)
It’s registered as a boat so there’s your regulatory oversight.

Surely you jest :-)

MechEngr 22nd Oct 2023 04:22

Did it crash while flying? Boats hitting reefs is nothing new.

makgeo 22nd Oct 2023 05:43

Saw a video of the incident. Was a loss of AoA and the front plowed into the water. The beauty of these craft is that it wasn't a stall from 100's of feet up and vertical speed wasn't the issue. Plane looked to have come out of it quite well.

Can't post links due to forum rules.

aroa 22nd Oct 2023 07:21

Flying machines registered as a boat. True. Another example of control freaking bureaucratic overreach in Oz.
Since at idle it sits on water ..ergo ..it’s a water borne ‘vessel’ So has to be so registered.
Ditto floatplanes and seaplanes.
In Canada and the US they laugh their heads off at this stupidity.
An aircraft on floats registered as an aircraft is exactly that.. it is not a tinny or speedboat. It’s an Aircraft.
Eff off I say to the idiot agency.

Lead Balloon 22nd Oct 2023 07:50

The Australian CA Act defines an aircraft to mean any machine or craft that can derive support in the atmosphere from the reactions of the air, other than the reactions of the air against the earth’s surface. A wing-in-ground-effect 'thing' - when it's 'moving quickly without touching anything' - is deriving its support from reactions of the air against the earth's surface - either wet or dry.

MechEngr 22nd Oct 2023 07:55

Looks pretty tame to call it a crash, but OK


Squawk7700 22nd Oct 2023 08:07

That video does it no favours, it looks like it was bound to end in disaster due to the speed and proximity to other vessels, waves and the sand.

Cloudee 22nd Oct 2023 08:41


Originally Posted by aroa (Post 11525561)
Flying machines registered as a boat. True. Another example of control freaking bureaucratic overreach in Oz.
Since at idle it sits on water ..ergo ..it’s a water borne ‘vessel’ So has to be so registered.
Ditto floatplanes and seaplanes.
In Canada and the US they laugh their heads off at this stupidity.
An aircraft on floats registered as an aircraft is exactly that.. it is not a tinny or speedboat. It’s an Aircraft.
Eff off I say to the idiot agency.

I’ve only ever seen VH rego on float planes. In what state do you also need boat rego?

thunderbird five 22nd Oct 2023 08:58


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11525518)
Surely you jest :-)

I do jest, and DON'T call me Surely!

Capt Fathom 22nd Oct 2023 11:08


Originally Posted by Cloudee (Post 11525596)
I’ve only ever seen VH rego on float planes. In what state do you also need boat rego?

The ones I flew had a boat rego on the floats and I had to have a boat license. Don’t know what the rules are now but I don’t see boat regos on them anymore.

Aussie Bob 22nd Oct 2023 21:35


The ones I flew had a boat rego on the floats and I had to have a boat license. Don’t know what the rules are now but I don’t see boat regos on them anymore.
Never flown one with boat rego, never been asked for a boat licence. I did however see the "authorities" being told to "piss off; ya got no authority, on the water it's a registered power boat, in the sky it's controlled by the Commonwealth" by a private float operator. He had landed where "they" reckoned he shouldn't. "They" backed down.

I think old mate had a great idea, I am just not that into his testing location. Hope he "flies" it again. Ironically, the Caspian Sea monster featured on "Abandoned Engineering" just last night.


Eff off I say to the idiot agency.
Amen to that aroa, wish more would join us :-)

PiperCameron 23rd Oct 2023 01:16


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 11525660)
The ones I flew had a boat rego on the floats and I had to have a boat license. Don’t know what the rules are now but I don’t see boat regos on them anymore.

Nothing has changed: you are supposed to have a boat rego and a boat license to operate any "watercraft" with an engine in most states of Oz - the eastern ones, anyway - but whether or not you need to show either and what hoops you have to jump through varies from state to state, since each state is responsible for it's own. eg. in Victoria they're issued by Vicroads - the traffic people. Makes sense, don't it?? :rolleyes:

In practice, it seems to be one of those things where, if you're not a weekend fisho or roaring around on a Jetski, because there are so many different bureaucracies involved, so long as you don't screw up nobody's going to bother you either way.

aroa 23rd Oct 2023 23:54

Don’t you love the tv news folk… ocean Emergency !!, Haha. More like a coastal shallows upset. But is a Crash!!

jolihokistix 24th Oct 2023 00:11


Originally Posted by aroa (Post 11526453)
Don’t you love the tv news folk… ocean Emergency !!, Haha. More like a coastal shallows upset. But is a Crash!!

Make that OCEAN EMERGENCY...
(Looks much better now)

megan 24th Oct 2023 01:43

If the public service (oxymoron?) had its way all wheeled aircraft would be required to be registered with the road traffic authority and for pilots to have drivers licenses, I mean they share pavement with cars, trucks, tow motors etc You know it makes sense.

Clare Prop 24th Oct 2023 01:44


Originally Posted by PiperCameron (Post 11525942)

In practice, it seems to be one of those things where, if you're not a weekend fisho or roaring around on a Jetski, because there are so many different bureaucracies involved, so long as you don't screw up nobody's going to bother you either way.

They are unlikely to bother people who do screw up either. Jetskis roaring over dive flags, powerboats mowing down rowers, rights of way and speed limits disregarded; water police are missing in action. Only ever seen them on the water once yelling at kayakers to keep away from the sealions even though it was the sealions who were the ones coming up to have a look at the humans.

PiperCameron 24th Oct 2023 02:02


Originally Posted by Clare Prop (Post 11526481)
They are unlikely to bother people who do screw up either. Jetskis roaring over dive flags, powerboats mowing down rowers, rights of way and speed limits disregarded; water police are missing in action. Only ever seen them on the water once yelling at kayakers to keep away from the sealions even though it was the sealions who were the ones coming up to have a look at the humans.

Down here in Melbourne the Water Police have only one tiny outfit based out of Willliamstown and are often seen to be quite busy on nice weekends either entertaining VIPs in the Admiral's Barge (aka VP01) or chasing jetskis around the St Kilda foreshore in their own suitably-marked Police jetskis (or both at the same time).

I guess they can't be everywhere. To say they're understaffed would be an understatement.

Smelly creatures, them sealions.. :}

Bull at a Gate 24th Oct 2023 05:36

On the Lancelin Facebook page there is a quote from the pilot/skipper who says he has had his skipper’s licence since he was 16 and that he is a commercial airline pilot too. There are a few videos in the comments as well.

Squawk7700 24th Oct 2023 10:38


Originally Posted by PiperCameron (Post 11526487)
Down here in Melbourne the Water Police have only one tiny outfit based out of Willliamstown and are often seen to be quite busy on nice weekends either entertaining VIPs in the Admiral's Barge (aka VP01) or chasing jetskis around the St Kilda foreshore in their own suitably-marked Police jetskis (or both at the same time).

I guess they can't be everywhere. To say they're understaffed would be an understatement.

You obviously haven’t been to their toy shed, they have heaps of equipment. The 40? foot zodiacs from one of the last terrorism funding rounds, the massive thing, the less massive thing, the rigid inflatable things with the dual motors, plus the mobile units complete with Dodge Ram for towing etc, and said jet skis.

But don’t let that get in the way of a good story…

As for whether you are likely to get caught after the 7am-3pm shift is over, well that’s another story.


Capt Fathom 24th Oct 2023 10:47


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11526668)

You obviously haven’t been to their toy shed, they have heaps of equipment. The 40? foot zodiacs from one of the last terrorism funding rounds, the massive thing, the less massive thing, the rigid inflatable things with the dual motors, plus the mobile units complete with Dodge Ram for towing etc, and said jet skis.

But don’t let that get in the way of a good story…

Doesn’t mean they have the personnel to man all that equipment.

Squawk7700 24th Oct 2023 11:57


Originally Posted by Capt Fathom (Post 11526675)
Doesn’t mean they have the personnel to man all that equipment.

They certainly do.

I know a little bit more about that than your average punter ;-)

What they don’t have, is the fuel budget of the Airwing, but they do ok and get a good number of hours on the water overall.

tail wheel 25th Oct 2023 00:08

WIGE craft in Australia require both registration as a marine vessel and registration as an aircraft and the "pilot" must hold a marine drivers license and a pilot license, verified some years ago with the WIGE craft operating in Cairns.

I doubt that Junkyard Dog was compliant.

KRviator 25th Oct 2023 01:11


Originally Posted by tail wheel (Post 11527054)
WIGE craft in Australia require both registration as a marine vessel and registration as an aircraft and the "pilot" must hold a marine drivers license and a pilot license, verified some years ago with the WIGE craft operating in Cairns.

I doubt that Junkyard Dog was compliant.

Not doubting you, but is there a current reference to that requirement? AIUI, there's several 'categories' of aircraft, glider/sailplane/helicopter (powered-lift, I think they call this) and so on, but one thing that stood out when I looked at whether a hovercraft would need a 'pilots' licence was the requirement that any lift generated be exclusive of the reaction of air against the earths surface, ie to be classed as an aircraft (or rocket/glider, etc) per 'the roolz' it had to be able to fly out of ground effect. LB touched on it earlier, but I can't find a definition to 'aircraft' in the current abomination of rules and regulations.

Interesting to note that in NSW, a seaplane - but only while it is on the water - is considered a vessel, per the Marine Safety Act, which also includes "any non-displacement craft" ie a hovercraft (or WIGE vehicle). What's even more interesting to note that, (again, in NSW), my boat, that's locked in my shed, tied down on its' trailer, is still considered to be on a voyage. Because "For the purposes of this Act, a vessel is taken to be proceeding on a voyage from when it gets underway for the voyage until it gets underway for another voyage." RMS obviously employ the same lawyers as CAsA...:ugh:

EDIT: The WA DOT has a nice little page on WIGE(ts), including a decent photo of the boat/plane/vessel
https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....c640e3eeed.jpg

Lead Balloon 25th Oct 2023 01:50

The definition is in the Civil Aviation Act 1988: any machine or craft that can derive support in the atmosphere from the reactions of the air, other than the reactions of the air against the earth’s surface.

Pete Mitchelle 25th Oct 2023 09:04

so, it was a hard landing.

ScareNorth 25th Oct 2023 09:24


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11525511)
What could possibly go wrong with something like that, just above the water, a salvaged Jabiru motor and no regulatory oversight?

The Jabiru engine has 300 hours pulled from a Jabiru upgrading to a Gen 4 engine and the Department of Transport approved the operation over many meetings


Originally Posted by makgeo (Post 11525533)
Saw a video of the incident. Was a loss of AoA and the front plowed into the water. The beauty of these craft is that it wasn't a stall from 100's of feet up and vertical speed wasn't the issue. Plane looked to have come out of it quite well.

Can't post links due to forum rules.

Your exactly right! It suffered a control malfunction losing pitch control in a 20 degree banked turn



Originally Posted by Aussie Bob (Post 11525885)
Never flown one with boat rego, never been asked for a boat licence. I did however see the "authorities" being told to "piss off; ya got no authority, on the water it's a registered power boat, in the sky it's controlled by the Commonwealth" by a private float operator. He had landed where "they" reckoned he shouldn't. "They" backed down.

I think old mate had a great idea, I am just not that into his testing location. Hope he "flies" it again. Ironically, the Caspian Sea monster featured on "Abandoned Engineering" just last night.



Amen to that aroa, wish more would join us :-)

​​​​​​
hey
The craft is not in testing, it was out for a trip around lancelin. It has over 4000km on it

A few interesting comments but what else do you expect on pprune
The vessel was built from purchased material not "scrap" as some seem to think. A control malfunction occured during a 20 degree right hand turn causing loss of pitch control. It held up very well after impacting 200mm deep reef.
The vessel has over 4000km and has flown in several water body's and conditions. The flight at lancelin was a normal flight, not testing. To operate a WIG you only need a skippers ticket. This was approved by the department of transport over several meetings and even after the mishap they have no issue with its operation once repaired.

Mr Mossberg 25th Oct 2023 10:42

Had a mate pulled up by the water police in Port Phillip for speeding, was over near Willy. Mate disagreed with them, when he asked what proof they had they said they got him on a video camera. Went to court to dispute the fine, when the case was laid out, the prosecutor advised the beak that they had the perpetrator on a video camera. Old mate asked the copper when the camera was last calibrated. Beak couldn't help laughing, threw the case out. Was a very entertaining 45 minutes.

Clare Prop 25th Oct 2023 15:09

I was wondering if it was some kind of drone because the DoT picture above seems to be flying without anyone driving it. Then I came across the original picture on this site. Strange photoshop job..
The MudSkipper Wing in Ground Effect (revolutionise.com.au)
https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....4376166ac6.png







MechEngr 25th Oct 2023 18:04

They blurred the pilot for privacy reasons.

tail wheel 25th Oct 2023 19:19

OK, I retract my statement. I saw this WIGE craft in Cairns and could have sworn it had both marine and aviation registration, however this film clip suggests no pilot license required:


I also know CASA Cairns "took an interest" in this craft at the time. It didn't last long, trials only then apparently disappeared?

Squawk7700 25th Oct 2023 20:49

That Cairns one doesn’t seem to fly very high. Looks like a half decent wave would end your dar early.


All times are GMT. The time now is 16:17.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.