PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   The Pacific: General Aviation & Questions (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions-91/)
-   -   Mid - Air @ Caboolture (https://www.pprune.org/pacific-general-aviation-questions/653933-mid-air-caboolture.html)

Fluke 28th Jul 2023 07:39


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11475249)
Is this the airport where you can’t see the aircraft on the other runway due to the trees?

One taking off has hit the one landing (or vice versa) begs the immediate question of WHY… Why are they operating on 2 for intersecting runways?

Because neither knew the other was there !
RIP D&JM

MickG0105 28th Jul 2023 08:16


Originally Posted by Squawk7700 (Post 11475249)
Is this the airport where you can’t see the aircraft on the other runway due to the trees?

Yep, it's a bugger of a set-up.

https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....1d0d761234.jpg


MALT68 28th Jul 2023 08:42

Operational reasons.

Squawk7700 28th Jul 2023 09:05


Originally Posted by MALT68 (Post 11475313)
Operational reasons.

Do you mean financial reasons?

bloodandiron 28th Jul 2023 09:46

Interesting to see the Pawnee seemed to only get a dent in its wing from this. If there was no glider in tow what was the Pawnee doing?

Lead Balloon 28th Jul 2023 09:47

Why is ATSB interested? I thought ATSB has denied responsibility for investigation of these kinds of accidents.

Desert Flower 28th Jul 2023 09:55


Originally Posted by bloodandiron (Post 11475367)
Interesting to see the Pawnee seemed to only get a dent in its wing from this. If there was no glider in tow what was the Pawnee doing?

One would assume that the Pawnee had released a glider & was coming back to land.

DF.

Squawk7700 28th Jul 2023 11:51


Originally Posted by bloodandiron (Post 11475367)
Interesting to see the Pawnee seemed to only get a dent in its wing from this. If there was no glider in tow what was the Pawnee doing?

ATSB stated one was landing and one was taking off.

601 28th Jul 2023 13:13


Is this the airport where you can’t see the aircraft on the other runway due to the trees?
I wonder if this is the only airport on OZ where you cannot see aircraft on another runway

By George 28th Jul 2023 13:37

The pilot of the Jab was a good friend of mine going back fifty years. We flew together at Connair in Darwin in the seventies.Later he went TAA and I went Ansett. He subsequently went to EK and I went to SQ. Stayed in contact all my life. I recently completed his flight review last month. He was the consummate professional pilot to the highest standard I have ever seen. Weight and balance check the works and demonstrated great stick skills. It breaks my heart to hear about this accident to the point I think I will hang up my wings. He was a check pilot on the A380 and built the Jab in his garage. Loved aviation and was a true aviator of the old school. If he can be clobbered what chance do any of us have.
I cannot believe it was a lapse on his part.
Good bye mate I shall never forget you.

KAPAC 28th Jul 2023 13:48

RIP ,
Mid air or fire . The two that wake me up at night .

SWMBO 28th Jul 2023 13:58


Originally Posted by By George (Post 11475497)
The pilot of the Jab was a good friend of mine going back fifty years. We flew together at Connair in Darwin in the seventies.Later he went TAA and I went Ansett. He subsequently went to EK and I went to SQ. Stayed in contact all my life. I recently completed his flight review last month. He was the consummate professional pilot to the highest standard I have ever seen. Weight and balance check the works and demonstrated great stick skills. It breaks my heart to hear about this accident to the point I think I will hang up my wings. He was a check pilot on the A380 and built the Jab in his garage. Loved aviation and was a true aviator of the old school. If he can be clobbered what chance do any of us have.
I cannot believe it was a lapse on his part.
Good bye mate I shall never forget you.

Yes, accurate assessment. David and Jan were the best people. And worse still the other aircraft was piloted by an industry safety professional another example of professional. The fact these two came together is almost impossible, except it did. There is bound to be something more unusual to this. Or maybe not. We probably know each other George, I share your sorrow.

Capn Bloggs 28th Jul 2023 14:46


Originally Posted by 601
I wonder if this is the only airport on OZ where you cannot see aircraft on another runway

No it's not. Kalgoorlie 29/18 is another. More open space near the intersection though.

MALT68 28th Jul 2023 14:58

There are many many airports and airfields in Australia where one runway end cannot be seen by another including major airports such as YMML.
many busy and smaller fields also have runway ends hidden from each other (e.g. Wangaratta, YMUL, YBEV) with usually the most into wind runway used unless the airport ops or a/c requirements dictates otherwise.
some airfields you can’t see one runway end from the other (YLUW).

YCAB has a comprehensive and detailed ops manual. There are no clowns here.
https://www.cabooltureaeroclub.com.a...arch-2023-.pdf

For whatever reason this terrible accident happened to pilots held in high regard.
Here’s hoping that a chain of events can be elucidated with lessons learned.
I know it does not bring the deceased back but hopefully prevents other such accidents.
I am saddened by what has happened.

markis10 28th Jul 2023 15:39


Originally Posted by SWMBO (Post 11475516)
Yes, accurate assessment. David and Jan were the best people. And worse still the other aircraft was piloted by an industry safety professional another example of professional. The fact these two came together is almost impossible, except it did. There is bound to be something more unusual to this. Or maybe not. We probably know each other George, I share your sorrow.

It doesn’t take much for bad luck to come into play, crossing runways, high wing vs low wing, maybe a missed call. Very sad news and deepest sympathy to all who have been involved in this tragic event.

Dora-9 28th Jul 2023 18:47

Hoosten and Triathlon - do you even operate out of YCAB? I've been there for 25 years and I've never had any concerns about the professionalism of the glider operation there - so, without respect, pull your heads in.

George - my condolences at loosing friends.


It doesn’t take much for bad luck to come into play,
One possible factor here is the amount of radio traffic on 125.85; possibly either or both aircraft missed vital calls? This frequency serves two busy airfields (Caboolture and Caloundra) plus it's used for aircraft operating in the Bribie Island training area as well as those transiting out across Morten Bay. Plus you do get clowns with lousy radio discipline; not listening out before transmitting or making incredibly long-winded speeches when a few words would suffice.

Matt48 28th Jul 2023 20:33

The Pawnee was landing.

Squawk7700 28th Jul 2023 21:31


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 11475535)
No it's not. Kalgoorlie 29/18 is another. More open space near the intersection though.

I think he was being sarcastic, so I didn’t respond.

triathlon 28th Jul 2023 21:33


Originally Posted by Dora-9 (Post 11475648)
Hoosten and Triathlon - do you even operate out of YCAB? I've been there for 25 years and I've never had any concerns about the professionalism of the glider operation there - so, without respect, pull your heads in.

George - my condolences at loosing friends.



One possible factor here is the amount of radio traffic on 125.85; possibly either or both aircraft missed vital calls? This frequency serves two busy airfields (Caboolture and Caloundra) plus it's used for aircraft operating in the Bribie Island training area as well as those transiting out across Morten Bay. Plus you do get clowns with lousy radio discipline; not listening out before transmitting or making incredibly long-winded speeches when a few words would suffice.

the landing aircraft has the right of way
. FACT ! …
The aircraft taking off must give way .
FACT !….
With all due respect , how dare you tell me to pull my head in . Who do you think you are , some sort of Sky god ?

markis10 28th Jul 2023 21:36


Originally Posted by Matt48 (Post 11475689)
The Pawnee was landing.

I believe on 24, while the Jab was possibly departing 29 under the wing of the Pawnee most likely on approach, conversely it’s possible the wing of the Jab obscured the view of the approach to 24. Use of 24 is discouraged owing to the hospital upwind, the gliders and Pawnee often use it as that’s where the hanger is at the western end. Info for the benefit of those not familiar with Caboolture

As for glider ops, as an ex Camden rated ATC it is my opinion they add to the safety of operations by forcing circuit traffic to be more mindful of scenarios and possibilities where not all traffic has options when things go pear shaped.


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:27.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.